Chemical potential differentials in the QCD phase diagram from heavy-ion isobar collisions

Joaquin Grefa, Chun Yue Tsang, Rajesh Kumar, Veronica Dexheimer, Claudia Ratti, Zhangbu Xu · 2026

Read Chemical potential differentials in the QCD phase diagram from heavy-ion isobar collisions by Joaquin Grefa, Chun Yue Tsang, Rajesh Kumar, Veronica Dexheimer, Claudia Ratti, Zhangbu Xu (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-21232.txt.

Introduction

Joaquin Grefa and five co-authors read the chemical makeup of matter made in colliding nuclei. Their 2026 paper studies chemical potential gaps in the QCD phase diagram. Temperature and chemical potentials describe QCD matter under extreme heat. The potentials cover baryon number, charge, and strangeness. Gaps between them probe conserved-charge correlations. They also reveal the system's response across the phase diagram.

The team extracts these values from STAR isobar collisions. Ruthenium and zirconium nuclei, with the same mass, were collided. A Bayesian thermal analysis of hadron yields does the extraction. It cuts systematic errors by a wide margin, the authors report. Results are compared with lattice-QCD and Chiral Mean Field predictions. Such checks test our picture of matter at trillion-degree heat.

Catalog record

CREATORJoaquin Grefa, Chun Yue Tsang, Rajesh Kumar, Veronica Dexheimer, Claudia Ratti, Zhangbu Xu
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE31 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-21232

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Chemical potential differentials in the QCD phase diagram from heavy-ion isobar collisions Joaquin Grefa, Chun Yue Tsang, Rajesh Kumar, Veronica Dexheimer, Claudia Ratti, Zhangbu Xu Abstract Temperature and baryon, charge, and strangeness chemical potentials characterize QCD matter under extreme conditions. Differences between these chemical potentials and their ratios probe conserved-charge correlations and the system’s response in the multidimensional QCD phase diagram. We extract these quantities from STAR Ru+Ru and Zr+Zr isobar collisions using a Bayesian thermal analysis of hadron yields, which substantially reduces systematic uncertainties, and compare them with Taylor-expanded lattice-QCD and Chiral Mean Field model predictions. Isobar collisions thus emerge as a precision probe of four-dimensional QCD thermodynamics. I Introduction Understanding strongly interacting matter under extreme conditions is a central goal of nuclear physics Achenbach et al. 2024 . At high energies, Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) predicts a transition from hadronic matter to a deconfined quark–gluon plasma. This transition has been extensively studied through ultra-relativistic heavy-ion collisions at the Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC) and the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). Measurements of identified hadron particle spectra and yields at mid-rapidity provide access to chemical freeze-out conditions, which can be extracted via thermal model analyses Adams et al. 2005 ; Andronic et al. 2018 . In this work, we perform a Bayesian analysis of hadron yields using the statistical model THERMUS Wheaton and Cleymans 2009 . The resulting posterior distributions provide both the marginal probability densities for and the correlations among the chemical‑freeze‑out temperature T_{\text{Chem}} , the fireball radius R , the set of chemical potentials \mu_{i} , and the strangeness‑suppression factor \gamma_{s} . These joint posteriors map out experimentally constrained trajectories in the QCD phase diagram. The relevant \mu ’s correspond to the conserved quantities of the system: baryon chemical potential ( \mu_{B} ), related to net baryon number ( B ) conservation; electric charge chemical potential ( \mu_{Q} ), related to net electric charge ( Q ) conservation (hereafter “charge”); and strangeness chemical potential ( \mu_{S} ), related to net strangeness ( S ) conservation. While these quantities can be studied independently Adams et al. 2005 ; Andronic et al. 2018 , most model fits to experimental data impose simplifying assumptions, such as \mu_{Q}=0 or a fixed charge fraction Y_{Q}=Q/B at midrapidity equal to the proton to baryon ratio Z/A of the colliding nuclei Adams et al. 2005 ; Adamczyk et al. 2017 ; Andronic et al. 2018 . As a result, the interdependence among the \mu_{i} and their mutual response (expressed as constituent correlations of susceptibilities Fu et al. 2019 ; Pratt and Young 2017 ; Pratt et al. 2018 ; Ding et al. 2025 ; Karsch et al. 2022 ) and through differentials (such as d\mu_{B}/d\mu_{Q} and d\mu_{S}/d\mu_{Q} ) remain largely unexplored in dynamically evolving heavy-ion experiments. Isobar collisions Abdallah et al. 2022 provide particularly interesting systems to access this physics. Ruthenium ( {}^{96}_{44} Ru) and Zirconium ( {}^{96}_{40} Zr) have the same mass number A=96 , but differ in their proton and neutron content, corresponding to Y_{Q}=44/96\approx 0.46 and Y_{Q}=40/96\approx 0.42 , respectively, a difference of \sim 9\% . Studying how nuclear systems respond to such deviations from isospin symmetry ( Y_{Q}=0.5 ) is not only essential for heavy-ion phenomenology, but also for understanding neutron stars, where \beta -equilibrium drives the charge fraction to values as low as Y_{Q}<0.1 Pons et al. 1999 . From the theoretical side, first-principle calculations are limited to specific regions of the QCD phase diagram Kumar et al. 2024a . Lattice-QCD calculations are currently limited to vanishing \mu_{B} (due to the sign problem Nagata 2022 ) and temperatures T\gtrsim 110 MeV. Lattice results can be extended to finite \mu_{B} via Taylor expansions of thermodynamic quantities around \mu_{B}=\mu_{Q}=\mu_{S}=0 , using generalized susceptibilities computed on the lattice Noronha-Hostler et al. 2019 ; Monnai et al. 2019 ; Monnai et al. 2024 . The resulting equation of state, denoted here as BQS Noronha-Hostler et al. 2019 ; Jahan et al. 2025 , provides a controlled way to include the effects of finite \mu_{B} , while incorporating finite \mu_{Q} and \mu_{S} , and being reliable up to \mu_{B}/T\approx 2.5 . This allows experimental constraints of strangeness neutrality (enforced via Y_{S}=S/B=0 ) and fixed Y_{Q} to be imposed, covering the region relevant for the isobar collisions studied in this work (see Figure 1 ). Alternative expansion schemes can extrapolate the equation of state up to \mu_{B}/T=3.5 Borsányi et al. 2021 ; Abuali et al. 2025 . Beyond these regions, uncertainties grow rapidly, and one must turn to a different approach. Figure 1: QCD phase diagram regions reproduced by experiment and covered by the theoretical descriptions discussed in this work. Provided that the appropriate degrees of freedom, interactions, and symmetries are included, effective models can be applied to describe the entire multidimensional QCD phase diagram. We make use of the effective Chiral Mean Field Model with an improved meson description (mCMF), including the baryon octet and decuplet. CMF is a relativistic mean-field effective model that describes baryons as interacting via meson mean fields. It incorporates chiral symmetry restoration and deconfinement to quark matter at high energies, both becoming crossovers for high T /low \mu_{B} . mCMF goes to some extent beyond the mean-field approximation by including interactions for the thermal mesons Kumar et al. 2025 . These interactions are calculated through in-medium masses of pseudoscalar and vector mesons, obtained from the explicit chiral symmetry-breaking and vector interaction terms in the Lagrangian, respectively, prior to applying the mean-field approximation. This extension improves the description of thermodynamics at high T /low \mu_{B} Kumar et al. 2025 , corresponding to the region of the isobar collisions studied in this work ( Figure 1 ), while retaining applicability to the high- \mu_{B} /low- T region relevant for neutron-star matter Kumar et al. 2024b . II Methodology and results II.1 From heavy-ion collisions Previous results Adams et al. 2005 ; Adamczyk et al. 2017 ; Andronic et al. 2018 ; Wheaton and Cleymans 2009 suggest that particle yields in ultra-relativistic heavy-ion collisions can be fitted under the assumption of thermal equilibrium (see Supplemental Material, Section S1 ), with relative yields determined by \mu ’s at T_{\text{Chem}} . However, when Ru+Ru and Zr+Zr systems are analyzed independently, the resulting differences in \mu ’s are consistent with zero due to large uncertainties Stankus 2006 ; Adamczyk et al. 2017 ; Abelev et al. 2013 . To address this issue, Ref. Lewis et al. 2024 proposed a method for measuring net-charge from the particle yield differences ( \Delta Q ) between isobar systems using double ratios. \displaystyle\Delta \displaystyle Q=[(N_{\pi^{+}}+N_{K^{+}}+N_{p})-(N_{\pi^{-}}+N_{K^{-}}+N_{\bar{p}})]_{\text{Ru}} (1) \displaystyle- \displaystyle[(N_{\pi^{+}}+N_{K^{+}}+N_{p})-(N_{\pi^{-}}+N_{K^{-}}+N_{\bar{p}})]_{\text{Zr}}\,, where N_{i} represents mid-rapidity yields of particle species i . Under the assumption that \Delta Q\ll N_{i}\ \forall i\in(\pi,K,p) , a change of variable simplifies \Delta Q to: \Delta Q\approx N_{\pi}(R2_{\pi}-1)+N_{K}(R2_{K}-1)+N_{p}(R2_{p}-1)\,, (2) where R2_{i}=[(N_{i}/N_{\bar{i}})_{\text{Ru}}/(N_{i}/N_{\bar{i}})_{\text{Zr}}] are double ratios, and \bar{i} denotes the corresponding antiparticle. This change of variables significantly reduces systematic uncertainties, as most of them cancel out in the double ratios. Using this approach, the STAR experiment has compared the ratio \left<B\right>/\Delta Q against A/\Delta Z in Ru+Ru and Zr+Zr collisions, where \left<B\right> is the average net-baryon number. In 0-10% most central collisions, \left<B\right>/\Delta Q\times\Delta Z/A=1.84\pm 0.02\text{(stat)}\pm 0.09\text{(syst.)}\pm 0.16 (feed-down), favoring the baryon

Read the complete text