The Third Option: Color Phase Curves to Characterize the Atmospheres of Temperate Rocky Exoplanets
Drake Deming, Andrew Lincowski, Laura Kreidberg, Miles H. Currie, Jean-Michel Desert, Guangwei Fu, Jacob Lustig-Yaeger, Victoria S. Meadows, Ignas Snellen · 2026
Read The Third Option: Color Phase Curves to Characterize the Atmospheres of Temperate Rocky Exoplanets by Drake Deming, Andrew Lincowski, Laura Kreidberg, Miles H. Currie, Jean-Michel Desert, Guangwei Fu, Jacob Lustig-Yaeger, Victoria S. Meadows, Ignas Snellen (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-20966.txt.
Introduction
Kylar Greene, Aurora Ireland, Gordan Krnjaic, and Yuhsin Tsai derive a universal spectrum for a class of cosmic signals. Their 2026 paper concerns B-modes in the cosmic microwave background. Many early universe scenarios predict tensor ripples from causal sources after inflation. These sources act below the horizon and for a bounded time. Their microphysics may differ wildly. Yet their spectra share a universal scaling at small wavenumber.
On super-horizon scales, the tensor power grows as the cube of the wavenumber. That is the signature of white noise at production time. Observers can thus test many theories with one template. The paper gives that template a firm basis. It pairs with data studies that set limits on such sources. Together they narrow how the early universe could have rung.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Drake Deming, Andrew Lincowski, Laura Kreidberg, Miles H. Currie, Jean-Michel Desert, Guangwei Fu, Jacob Lustig-Yaeger, Victoria S. Meadows, Ignas Snellen |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 42 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-20966
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Third Option: Color Phase Curves to Characterize the Atmospheres of Temperate Rocky Exoplanets Drake Deming, Andrew Lincowski, Laura Kreidberg, Miles H. Currie, Jean-Michel Desert, Guangwei Fu, Jacob Lustig-Yaeger, Victoria S. Meadows, Ignas Snellen Abstract Detecting and characterizing the atmospheres of rocky exoplanets has proven to be challenging for JWST. Transit spectroscopy of the TRAPPIST-1 planets has been impacted by the effects of spots and faculae on the host star. Secondary eclipses have detected hot rocks, but evidence for atmospheres has been difficult to obtain. However, there is a third option that we call color phase curves. This method will apply to synchronously rotating non-transiting planets as well as transiting planets. A color phase curve uses photometry at a long-IR wavelength near the peak of the planetary thermal emission (e.g., 21 microns) divided by photometry at a shorter wavelength where the star dominates more strongly (e.g., 12 microns). We avoid wavelengths having potentially strong molecular absorption (e.g., 15 microns) to minimize degeneracies in the color phase curve, and we aim to detect and characterize the planetary atmosphere via its longitudinal heat transfer. The ratio of two wavelengths observed nearly simultaneously is designed to isolate thermal emission from the planet, discriminate against the star, and largely cancel instrumental systematic effects. Moreover, we show that invoking mass-radius relations, and using self-consistent physical models, will permit the longitudinal heat transfer to be measured independent of the orbital inclination. Radial velocity surveys are detecting many new exoplanets, including temperate rocky worlds with Earth-like masses. Most of those planets will not transit, but color phase curves have the potential to detect and characterize their atmospheres. I Introduction Detecting and characterizing the atmospheres of rocky exoplanets is a scientific priority ( 12 ) . This quest has been challenging for JWST. Two observational techniques applied to transiting systems have dominated these attempts: transit and eclipse spectroscopy. Transit spectroscopy of rocky planets has produced only hints of spectral features, and secondary eclipses have been broadly consistent with bare rocky surfaces ( 33 ; 80 ; 77 ; 76 ; 1 ; 48 ; 38 ; 65 ; 55 ; 52 ; 44 ; 34 ; 10 ; 18 ; 21 ; 62 ; 31 ; 22 ; 29 , reviewed by 43 , and 23 ). Moreover, transit spectroscopy is sensitive to interference by the Transit Light Source effect ( 61 ) , notably in the TRAPPIST-1 planets (e.g., 59 ). Thin atmospheres are possibly detected in some cases ( 33 ) , and ultra-hot rocky planets can have atmospheres from magma oceans ( 35 ; 73 ) . Nevertheless, new observational approaches to this problem are needed. In this paper, we develop and advocate a third observational option for temperate rocky planets, that we call color phase curves (hereafter CPC). CPCs are based on a ratio of filter photometry at two different wavelengths observed nearly simultaneously. For temperate planets, an optimal strategy is to choose one wavelength near the peak of a temperate planet’s thermal emission (e.g., 21 \mu m) and another wavelength that is relatively more sensitive to the star (e.g., 12 \mu m). The ratio of fluxes observed at those two wavelengths has great potential to isolate thermal emission from temperate planets, discriminate against the star, and cancel instrumental systematics. To our knowledge, it was 69 who first proposed exploiting the infrared emission of temperate planets at long IR wavelengths, and 25 who emphasized using JWST’s MIRI photometry at 21 \mu m. Our CPC concept expands on those ideas by using the ratio of 21- to 12.8 \mu m, by considering the advantages for stellar contamination (§ III.1 ), and exploring how to infer the day-to-night temperature difference without knowing the orbital inclination (§ VI ). Although JWST’s long wavelength sensitivity and low thermal background are well suited to our proposed CPC method, it has not been attempted in practice. In that respect, JWST is arguably under-utilized for temperate exoplanets in spite of a healthy oversubscription status. Specifically, the MIRI 21 \mu m filter has yet to be used for temperate rocky exoplanets, but modeling predictions ( 42 ; 26 ) have been encouraging. I.1 Organization of This Paper We outline the CPC principle in § II.1 , and we point out that it applies to non-transiting planets as well as transiting planets. § III.1 describes how the long thermal wavelengths allow very effective discrimination against star spots and faculae, and § III.2 describes the effect of stellar flares. § III.3 discusses the potential for mitigation of instrumental systematic effects. § IV and § V simulate a detection of the atmosphere of the archetype temperate non-transiting rocky exoplanet Proxima Centauri b. Beyond the detection, § VI describes how to measure the longitudinal heat redistribution in the atmosphere, in spite of uncertainty in the inclination of the orbit. § VII describes the potential for CPCs to be applied to a larger sample of nearby non-transiting planets. § VIII summarizes our results. II Color Phase Curves (CPC) II.1 Principle of CPC Our goal in this paper is to develop the CPC principle, and illustrate how it applies to a sample of planets, including non-transiting rocky planets. Given that non-transiting planets are more common than transiting ones, it is likely that CPC in practice will be primarily a non-transiting method. CPC relies on the fact that the flux from a temperate exoplanet, relative to its star, will peak at a long IR wavelength. In that respect CPC is similar to the Planetary Infrared Excess method proposed by 69 (also, see 49 and 45 ), but we place more emphasis on the Rayleigh-Jeans regime (§ III.1 ), and we discuss how the magnitude of heat transfer can be determined without knowing the orbital inclination (§ VI ). CPC requires that we know what longitudes on the planet are contributing to our measurements at every observed time. That is easiest to do if we are confident that the planet is synchronously rotating, or at least in a lower order resonance such as 3:2 ( 63 ) . The scientific potential of infrared phase curves for non-transiting planets has long been known ( 66 ; 68 ; 51 ) . 66 pointed out that a phase curve having low amplitude can be interpreted as the consequence of longitudinal heat transport by an atmosphere, whereas a synchronously-rotating rocky planet lacking an atmosphere would be expected to have a phase variation of large amplitude (depending on the orbital inclination). 68 described how the phase curve amplitude varies with wavelength as a consequence of the composition, pressure, and temperature of the atmosphere. 51 investigated how multi-wavelength phase curves can be analyzed to constrain the planet’s radius, albedo, and orbital inclination. 72 discussed how comparing phase curves at different wavelengths can inform us of atmospheric properties. However, to our knowledge there is no discussion in the literature that addresses a phase curve measurement using the ratio of two wavelengths observed nearly simultaneously, especially at the long IR wavelengths we discuss in this paper. We envision detecting and characterizing the atmospheres of temperate rocky planets by inferring their heat transport (or lack of it), following the principle of 66 . Our current formulation of CPC