Encounters Between M33 and Present-Day M31 Satellites Hint at a Previous Group Accretion Journal: ApJ Numpy ( 34 ) , SciPy ( 100 ) , Matplotlib ( 37 ) , IPython ( 76 ) , Jupyter ( 44 ) , Astropy ( 3 ; 77 ; 2 ) , Gala ( 78 )

Ekta Patel, Paul Bennet, Sangmo Tony Sohn, Mark A. Fardal, Roeland P. van der Marel · 2026

Read Encounters Between M33 and Present-Day M31 Satellites Hint at a Previous Group Accretion Journal: ApJ Numpy ( 34 ) , SciPy ( 100 ) , Matplotlib ( 37 ) , IPython ( 76 ) , Jupyter ( 44 ) , Astropy ( 3 ; 77 ; 2 ) , Gala ( 78 ) by Ekta Patel, Paul Bennet, Sangmo Tony Sohn, Mark A. Fardal, Roeland P. van der Marel (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-20837.txt.

Introduction

Ekta Patel and four co-authors ask whether two small galaxies near Andromeda once met its largest satellite. Their 2026 paper studies M33, the Triangulum galaxy. The targets are Pisces, also called LGS 3, and Andromeda XVI. Both are present-day satellites of M31, the Andromeda galaxy. The team checks if their paths once crossed M33.

Theory predicts a handful of satellites should orbit M33. Yet few have been found and confirmed, despite M33's high mass. Close past encounters could help explain where those satellites went. A meeting can strip a small galaxy or fling it away. The study uses such encounters as a clue to a past group accretion. Its results bear on how big galaxies gather their families of dwarfs.

Catalog record

CREATOREkta Patel, Paul Bennet, Sangmo Tony Sohn, Mark A. Fardal, Roeland P. van der Marel
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE55 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-20837

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Encounters Between M33 and Present-Day M31 Satellites Hint at a Previous Group Accretion Journal: ApJ Numpy ( 34 ) , SciPy ( 100 ) , Matplotlib ( 37 ) , IPython ( 76 ) , Jupyter ( 44 ) , Astropy ( 3 ; 77 ; 2 ) , Gala ( 78 ) Ekta Patel, Paul Bennet, Sangmo Tony Sohn, Mark A. Fardal, Roeland P. van der Marel Abstract This work investigates whether two known Andromeda (M31) satellites, Pisces (LGS 3) and Andromeda XVI, have interacted with M33, M31’s most massive satellite. Λ \Lambda CDM predictions imply a handful of satellite galaxies around M33, yet few M33 satellites have been found and confirmed despite its high mass. We use proper motions combined with backward orbit integration in a semi-analytic potential to constrain plausible interaction scenarios for Pisces and And XVI. Both dwarfs are currently M31 satellites, defined as being inside its virial radius. However, our results show that, in our fiducial mass models, 42% (And XVI) and 60% (Pisces) of dwarf orbits support that they were previously satellites of M33 (i.e., once inside its virial radius). Both dwarfs had fly-by encounters with M33 at relative velocities greater than M33’s escape speed within the past 1-2 Gyr. In over 70% of orbits, Pisces and And XVI also had a close approach with each other post-M33 interaction and share an orbital plane, suggesting possible past group accretion. We explore a range of mass combinations for M31 and M33, finding that this primarily regulates the likelihood that the dwarfs were satellites of M33 in the past, while upholding conclusions of recent flybys about M33. These close interactions provide new evidence for past satellite exchange and/or group infall scenarios between M31 and M33. Such interactions also affect comparisons to observational surveys that define satellites primarily by their distance relative to host galaxies. show][email protected] I Introduction In the \Lambda Cold Dark Matter ( \Lambda CDM) paradigm, galaxies assemble hierarchically. As low mass galaxies accrete onto the halos of more massive galaxies, many of the low mass galaxies become satellite galaxies of their massive companion ( 60 ; 29 ; 46 ; 12 ) . Satellite galaxies are predicted to be self-similar in \Lambda CDM, such that massive dwarf galaxies also host a population of satellite galaxies. However, historically, satellites of dwarfs have been hard to find observationally ( 63 ) . Nonetheless, within our Galaxy, there has been recent progress in the number of ultra-faint dwarfs (UFDs), discovered around the LMC ( 6 ; 26 ; 45 , e.g.,) . Subsequent studies have confirmed a dynamical association between these UFDs and the LMC as satellites that entered the halo of the Milky Way (MW) along with the accretion of the LMC ( 28 ; 74 , e.g.,) . Just beyond the Local Group (LG), resolved, low mass dwarf satellites have also been detected around NGC 3109 ( 33 ; 24 ) and NGC 2403 ( 13 ) , two LMC-mass galaxies. Furthermore, a satellite in the process of active disruption around dwarf starburst galaxy NGC 4449 has also been observed ( 54 ) , showcasing the hierarchical nature of galaxies at the dwarf-mass scale. Several more distant surveys are also expanding observational searches to unresolved dwarfs around massive dwarf hosts in the Local Volume ( 23 ; 38 ; 48 ) . M33 is a notable exception to this recent success. The third largest galaxy in the LG has a very small or nonexistent satellite system ( 72 ) , despite being more massive than the LMC, and many of the Local Volume systems successfully searched for dwarf satellites ( 58 ) . Furthermore, recent kinematic studies have shown that M33 is likely on first infall into M31 ( 71 ; 98 ; 73 ; 104 ) and therefore surviving satellites should remain bound to M33 at the present day, contrary to previous work suggesting a recent tidal interaction between M33 and M31 during which M33 satellites may have been stripped ( 57 ; 79 ) . Despite this compelling evidence that M33 too should host a population of low mass dwarfs ( 72 ) , like the LMC, deep surveys of M33’s halo have only explored about 35% of M33’s virial volume ( 57 ; 72 , assuming a virial radius of 161 kpc;) . To date, only three candidate M33 satellite galaxies have been reported: UFD And XXII ( 52 ; 15 ) , UFD Pisces VII/Triangulum III ( 53 ; 16 ) , and ultra-diffuse dwarf Triangulum IV ( 68 ) . Without available distances, proper motions (PMs), and line-of-sight (LOS) velocities ( \rm V_{LOS} ) for each of these dwarfs, it is not yet possible to determine whether these galaxies are dynamically associated with M33. In addition, only And XXII has a reported star formation history ( 86 ) , which shows that it quenched about 4.5 Gyr ago; however, it formed a majority ( \sim 80%) of its stars by about 10 Gyr ago. 16 shows tentative evidence for recent star formation in Pisces VII between 1-2 Gyr ago. This recent star formation could be associated with a possible past interaction with M33; however, as noted in 16 , the possibility that the young stars are blue stragglers remains. Interactions with another galaxy may explain the dynamically heated nature of Tri IV. While the potential perturber of Tri IV is yet unknown, 68 has suggested M33 is a strong candidate. Here we report on new orbital results for Pisces (LGS3) and Andromeda XVI (And XVI), which are presently considered M31 satellite galaxies, but may have previously interacted with M33 based on reconstructed orbital histories. If so, these dwarfs would fill in a key part of the M33 satellite mass function, providing a classical dwarf (Pisces) and a dwarf on the boundary between classical and ultra-faint (And XVI). This possible transfer of satellite galaxies back and forth between M33 and M31, and massive satellites and their hosts more generally, has yet to be explored in detail. It may be indicative of remnants of group infall scenarios. We focus on these particular dwarfs because orbital results from a companion paper ( 9 , hereafter BP25) revealed a compelling possibility of a past interaction between M33 and Pisces, based on backward orbit integrations that explicitly include M33’s gravitational influence. Preliminary analysis of And XVI in the same orbital framework suggests it too experienced a close passage with M33. A more detailed discussion of And XVI’s orbital history within the broader M31 satellite population will be presented in forthcoming work (Sohn et al., in prep.). This paper is organized as follows. In Section II , we briefly discuss the data and methods used to investigate the dynamics of Pisces and And XVI. In Section III , we report orbital parameters for Pisces and And XVI and explore possible evolutionary scenarios. Section IV includes a discussion of the plausibility of group infall versus independent accretion events, the impact on M33’s satellite mass function, and M33’s morphology. Finally, we conclude in Section V . II Data and Methods II.1 Galactocentric Coordinates Table 1: Position and Velocity Vectors Dwarf x y z v_{x} v_{y} v_{z} v_{rad} v_{tan}

Read the complete text