How well is the local Large Scale Structure of the Universe known? CosmicFlows vs. Biteau’s Galaxy Catalog with Cloning
Yifei Li (李宜霏), Glennys R. Farrar · 2026
Read How well is the local Large Scale Structure of the Universe known? CosmicFlows vs. Biteau’s Galaxy Catalog with Cloning by Yifei Li (李宜霏), Glennys R. Farrar (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-20808.txt.
Introduction
Yifei Li and Glennys Farrar ask how well we truly know the matter around us in space. Their 2026 paper concerns the local large scale structure of the universe. That structure is the map of galaxies and dark matter near the Milky Way. Many studies need this map as a baseline. It feeds models of cosmic ray sources and forecasts of dark matter signals.
The authors compare two sources for that map. One is CosmicFlows, a well-known catalog built from galaxy motions. The other is Biteau's galaxy catalog with cloning, a method that fills gaps by copying known structure. The paper weighs how far the two agree. Gaps between them mark where our knowledge of the nearby universe is still soft. The work matters for any study that starts from the local map.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yifei Li (李宜霏), Glennys R. Farrar |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 35 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-20808
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
How well is the local Large Scale Structure of the Universe known? CosmicFlows vs. Biteau’s Galaxy Catalog with Cloning Yifei Li (李宜霏), Glennys R. Farrar Abstract Knowledge of the actual density distribution of matter in the local universe is needed for a variety of purposes – for instance, as a baseline model for ultrahigh energy cosmic ray sources in the continuum limit and for predicting the diffuse Dark Matter annihilation signal. Determining the local mass density and velocity distribution is the aim of the CosmicFlows project. An alternate approach is based on catalogs of galaxies, supplemented with some scheme for filling in for unseen galaxies. Here, we compare the density field proposed by 6 with the quasi-linear density field of CosmicFlows2 ( 13 ) and the mean posterior field of CosmicFlows4 ( 29 ) . We find factor-two level differences in some regions and even greater in regions toward the Galactic center zone of avoidance (ZoA) ( | ℓ | < 30 ∘ , | b | < 20 ∘ |\ell|<30^{\circ},|b|<20^{\circ} ) as filled by Biteau using “cloning”. Within 11 Mpc the density field is well-determined by the Local Volume catalog ( 15 ) (which Biteau directly incorporates) and is to be preferred over the CosmicFlows modeling. At larger distances, ( 6 ) is also to be preferred over CosmicFlows for the direction and integrated mass of non-obscured structures, but the radial distribution of mass in ( 6 ) is less robust due to line-of-sight peculiar velocities. Within the ZoA the “galaxies” of ( 6 ) are entirely fictitious and thus their use is ill-advised except in circumstances where they do not contribute to the observable of interest anyway. Moreover, as evidenced by the South Pole Wall which was discovered by CosmicFlows but is not found in the galaxy catalogs, obscuration can be a problem even outside the ZoA. Unexpectedly, we find that the angular positions of structures in CosmicFlows are sometimes not correctly aligned with their true positions as manifest in the galaxy catalog outside the ZoA. I Introduction Recent works have shown that the direction and magnitude of the dipole anisotropy of ultrahigh energy cosmic rays (UHECRs) can be explained by UHECR sources which trace the Large Scale Structure (LSS) of the matter distribution as given by the CosmicFlows2 density field ( 12 ; 8 ; 5 ) . Interestingly, subsequent work ( 4 ) showed that the dipole magnitude – and not just its direction – is a sensitive probe of the coherent magnetic field of the Galaxy, if the UHECR source distribution within \sim 200 Mpc is known. When both the local baryon density and the Galactic magnetic field (GMF) are sufficiently well determined, the magnitude of the UHECR dipole will enable deviations due to individual sources to be robustly identified 1 1 1 The recent work of 2 explicitly demonstrates the sensitivity to source and GMF models. . We also note a significant literature on the local structure for cosmological applications, an incomplete listing of which includes 16 ; 3 ; 18 ; 30 ; 22 . These and other applications motivate a careful comparison of present models of the local matter distribution. Here, for the first time, we provide a quantitative comparison of the density fields derived by directly using catalogs of galaxies with distance estimates ( 6 ) , versus densities inferred from a combined analysis of the observed galaxies’ redshift-independent positions and peculiar velocities as carried out by the CosmicFlows collaboration ( 27 ; 24 ; 25 ; 26 ) . The strength of the CosmicFlows approach is that it self-consistently exploits the information inherent in the relative motions of galaxies and hence is less sensitive to individual galaxy distance determinations and in principle provides constraints on matter concentrations and voids in directions where galaxies are obscured by dust. On the other hand, the direction of galaxies is perfectly known so where obscuration is not a problem galaxy catalogs give better angular information. Early methods for reconstructing the mass density field from peculiar velocities were developed in the linear regime, starting with the POTENT algorithm ( 7 ) , followed by Bayesian approaches such as the Wiener Filter ( 31 ) and constrained realizations ( 14 ) . These techniques were later extended to the quasi-linear regime to produce the CosmicFlows-2 (CF2) density fields ( 13 ) , which provided data for approximately 8,000 galaxies ( 24 ) . In this work, we utilize the significantly expanded CosmicFlows-4 (CF4) catalog, which increases the sample size to 55,877 galaxies ( 26 ) . For the latest CosmicFlows-4 (CF4) reconstruction, we adopt the mean posterior density field derived by 29 , in preparation. This field was generated using the HAMLET algorithm ( 28 ) , which employs Hamiltonian Monte Carlo sampling to iteratively update initial conditions to match the observed z=0 velocity field. Here, we adopt the mean density fields of the simulations in real space to plot the CF4 maps. Another approach to determining the local matter distribution is to look directly at galaxies as tracers of the matter distribution. For this, having good distance measures that are not distorted by peculiar velocities is critical; these have been provided for a varying fraction of galaxies in catalogs such as the Local Volume sample ( 15 ) , the Extragalactic Distance Database ( 23 ) and the NASA/IPAC extragalactic database - Redshift-Independent Distances ( 21 ) . Additional challenges are that 1) galaxy catalogs are necessarily flux-limited, so that the sampling of structure becomes very sparse at large distances, and 2) dust obscuration in the Galactic plane leads to a “zone of avoidance”, where galaxy surveys are not complete. If the triple challenges of accurate distance determination, the zone of avoidance, and sparse sampling at large distance can be overcome, using the direct information on the mass distribution from observed galaxies should give an inherently better-resolved, higher-fidelity density map. 6 tackled these challenges and produced a semi-empirical mass catalog, designated B21 below. It provides a selected sample of 489,000 galaxies within 350 Mpc. Each galaxy is assigned a mass-upscaling factor, calculated based on its luminosity as inferred from its flux, distance and latitude, using the well-measured luminosity function of galaxies. This procedure should do a good job recovering galaxy clusters at large distances, which typically contain multiple bright galaxies, but misses secondary structures such as filaments composed of less-luminous galaxies. Depending on their scale and the application at hand, such secondary structures may or may not be important. More problematic is how to treat the unseen galaxies in the zone of avoidance where dust obscuration must be taken into account. 6 takes the zone of avoidance to be |b|<20^{\circ} for |\ell|<30^{\circ} and |b|<3^{\circ} for 30^{\circ}<|\ell|<180^{\circ} and addresses obscuration by replacing observed galaxies in this region by “cloning” galaxies above and below the region, following 17 . Specifically, he mirrors galaxies across the ZoA boundary at |b|=b_{\mathrm{ZoA}} : \sin b_{\mathrm{clone}}=\sin b_{\mathrm{ZoA}}-(\sin b-\sin b_{\mathrm{ZoA}}), (1) maintaining the galaxies’ other properties such as distance, mass and luminosity. This ensures continuity in galaxy density at the b=\pm\,b_{\mathrm{ZoA}} boundaries (but not at b=0 or on the sides of the ZoA at \ell=\pm 30^{\circ} ). Unfortunately, as we shall see