Effects of the centrality determination method for the equation of state and nucleonic observables from Au+Au collisions at s N ​ N \sqrt{s_{NN}} = 2.4 GeV

Xiaoqing Yue, Pengcheng Li, Yongjia Wang, Qingfeng Li, Fuhu Liu · 2026

Read Effects of the centrality determination method for the equation of state and nucleonic observables from Au+Au collisions at s N ​ N \sqrt{s_{NN}} = 2.4 GeV by Xiaoqing Yue, Pengcheng Li, Yongjia Wang, Qingfeng Li, Fuhu Liu (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-20491.txt.

Introduction

Xiaoqing Yue and four colleagues quantify how the choice of centrality measure affects studies of gold-gold collisions at moderate energy. Centrality says how head-on a collision was. It is a major source of systematic error in heavy-ion work, above all when probing the nuclear equation of state at high density.

The authors assess several determination methods and trace their effects on final-state observables that are sensitive to that equation. Knowing the size of this error bar is essential: claims about the stiffness of dense nuclear matter stand or fall on it.

Catalog record

CREATORXiaoqing Yue, Pengcheng Li, Yongjia Wang, Qingfeng Li, Fuhu Liu
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE36 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-20491

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Effects of the centrality determination method for the equation of state and nucleonic observables from Au+Au collisions at s N ​ N \sqrt{s_{NN}} = 2.4 GeV Xiaoqing Yue, Pengcheng Li, Yongjia Wang, Qingfeng Li, Fuhu Liu Abstract Centrality determination remains one of the major sources of systematic uncertainty in intermediate-energy heavy-ion collision analyses, especially for probing the nuclear equation of state (EoS) at supra-saturation densities. To quantitatively assess the uncertainties associated with different centrality determination methods and to investigate their effects on final-state EoS-sensitive observables. Within the ultra-relativistic quantum molecular dynamics (UrQMD) model, Au+Au collisions at s N ​ N \sqrt{s_{NN}} =2.4 GeV are performed within a soft and a hard EoS. Event centrality is determined using the multiplicity of all charged particles ( M ch M_{\mathrm{ch}} ) and two impact parameter-based centrality filters, one based on a geometrical interpretation and the other based on the Glauber Monte Carlo (MC) model, denoted as b f b_{f} and b r b_{r} , respectively. It is shown that there exist significant differences between the real impact parameter distributions of event samples selected by M ch M_{\mathrm{ch}} , b f b_{f} , and b r b_{r} , particularly between M ch M_{\mathrm{ch}} and b r b_{r} . When the b f b_{f} is employed, uncertainties associated with centrality selection have a weaker influence on observables than the effects induced by the EoS. In contrast, when the b r b_{r} is used, the influence of centrality-related uncertainties becomes more pronounced than that of the EoS. These results demonstrate that a rigorous and consistent mapping between M ch M_{\mathrm{ch}} and impact parameter is essential to impose quantitative constraints on the high-density nuclear EoS. Furthermore, our study indicates that the geometrical interpretation of centrality remains valid and consistent with dynamical multiplicity selection, whereas the Glauber MC-based centrality determination becomes unreliable at the investigated energy. I Introduction Heavy-ion collisions (HICs) create extreme conditions of high energy and baryon density, under which nuclear matter can be compressed with several times saturation density ( \rho_{0} ), and offer a unique opportunity to investigate the properties of hot and dense nuclear matter Danielewicz:2002pu ; Gyulassy:2004zy ; Fukushima:2010bq ; Andronic:2017pug . High excitation and strong interaction in HICs lead to the production of a large number of particles, while the volume of nuclear matter rapidly expands Frankfurt:1981mk ; Jacobs:2004qv . The analysis of the information of the final-state observed particles can provide key insights into the properties of dense nuclear matter and impose critical constraints on its equation of state (EoS). In HICs, the spacetime structure of the particle emission source and the final state observables are usually closely related to the centrality, which can be quantified by the impact parameter b , defined as the perpendicular distance between the center-of-mass of the projectile and target. In theoretical simulations of HICs, the impact parameter serves as the input quantity. Nevertheless, in the real HIC experiments, the centrality cannot be directly detected and is generally determined by the final sensitive observables which can be detected but with the help of the predictions of a theoretical model, such as the total number of hits ( N_{\text{hit}} ) HADES:2017def ; STAR:2022etb , the number of reconstructed tracks ( N_{\text{trk}} ) Zhang:2017xda ; STAR:2022etb , the multiplicity of all charged particles ( M_{\mathrm{ch}} ) Cavata:1990gk ; Kim:1992zza , and the ratio of total transverse to longitudinal kinetic energy in the center-of-mass system ( ERAT ) FOPI:1996cjz . However, there does not exist a strictly one-to-one relationship between the impact parameter and these observables. In our previous work, it was found that the true impact parameter of events selected with the impact parameter filter always has a certain distribution width, which must have a considerable influence on the collective flow in HICs at beam energies below 0.15A GeV Li:2020lup . Subsequently, we further developed the method to infer the impact parameter by using machine learning and applied it to the analysis of experimental data at Sn+Sn collisions at 0.27A GeV detected by the S \pi RIT Time Projection Chamber Li:2020qqn ; Li:2021plq ; Tsang:2021rku . It should be noticed that obtaining the b values or determining the centrality, especially for more central collisions, from HIC experiments is still challenging Mallick:2021wop . Although intermediate-energy HICs occur only on a time scale of several tens of fm/ c , the production and evaluation of the particles are dominated by the strong interaction, and the understanding of the strong interaction and the properties of nuclear matter remains limited Sorensen:2023zkk . To explore the properties of nuclear matter under a wide range of densities, one common method is to compare the HIC experimental data from terrestrial laboratories with theoretical results from transport model simulations TMEP:2022xjg . The density-dependent nuclear EoS is an essential ingredient of the transport models and has a great effort on particle production and collective behaviour Fuchs:2000kp ; TMEP:2022xjg ; Roca-Maza:2018ujj ; Sorensen:2023zkk . In recent years, the EoS around \rho_{0} has been much better constrained, while the EoS at 2-4 times \rho_{0} has large uncertainties Huth:2021bsp ; Tsang:2023vhh . The relative K^{+} multiplicities per nucleon in Au+Au and C+C collisions observed by the KaoS Collaboration favour a soft EoS Fuchs:2000kp . Nevertheless, by adopting a hard EoS in the Jet AA Microscopic transport model, the first- and second-order collective flow of light nuclei measured by the STAR Collaboration can be qualitatively reproduced STAR:2021ozh . Further, the two-pion interferometry at GeV energies favours a relatively stiff EoS up to 4 \rho_{0} , which then turns into a soft EoS at high densities Li:2022iil . Furthermore, in the recent Ref. Li:2025iqq , it was pointed out that within the Bayesian statistical framework and the isospin-dependent Boltzmann-Uehling-Uhlenbeck transport model, the proton flow excitation function data from FOPI indicate a gradual hardening of EoS as its density and temperature increase in reactions with higher beam energies. In addition, for the neutron star, the larger masses and radii favour a stiff EoS, but the hyperons will soften the EoS and reduce the maximum mass of the neutron star Oertel:2016bki ; Li:2024lmd ; Ye:2024meg . To more accurately constrain the information of EoS in dense nuclear matter by comparing the experimentally measured observables with the results of transport model simulations, the effects of the centrality determination method on the final state observables should be paid much more attention right now. In this work, based on the Ultra-relativistic Quantum Molecular Dynamics (UrQMD) model, the hard-EoS ( K_{0} = 380 MeV) and soft-EoS ( K_{0} = 200 MeV) with momentum dependence (labeled as HM and SM) are used to simulate Au+Au collisions at a typical SIS18 energy \sqrt{s_{NN}} =2.4 GeV (corresponding to the gold beam with a kinetic energy of E_{\rm{beam}} =1.23 A GeV on a fixed target), and the final-state charged-particle multiplicity M_{\mathrm{ch}} and two initial-input impact parameter-based methods are used to select events within a certain centrality. One is given by the definition of geometrical centrality, denoted as b_{f} . Another is taken from Ref. HADES:2017def , which is based on the Glauber Monte Carlo (MC) model, denoted as b_{r} . However, the applicability of the Glauber MC model at low energies, such as 2.4 GeV, is questionable because the model assumes

Read the complete text