From cosmological simulations to binary black hole mergers: The impact of using analytical star formation history models on gravitational-wave source populations
Sasha Levina, Floor Broekgaarden, Lieke van Son, Emanuele Berti, Amedeo Romagnolo, Ruediger Pakmor, Ana Lam · 2026
Read From cosmological simulations to binary black hole mergers: The impact of using analytical star formation history models on gravitational-wave source populations by Sasha Levina, Floor Broekgaarden, Lieke van Son, Emanuele Berti, Amedeo Romagnolo, Ruediger Pakmor, Ana Lam (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-20202.txt.
Introduction
Sasha Levina and six colleagues link cosmic star formation history to the black hole mergers that gravity-wave detectors observe. Mergers of binary black holes offer a window into the lives of massive stars across cosmic time. To read that window, models must know how fast stars formed and how rich in heavy elements the gas was at each era.
The authors test what happens when simple analytical star formation histories stand in for full cosmological simulations. Their question is how much that shortcut shifts the predicted merger population. Getting this right matters for turning detector counts into a history of massive stars.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Sasha Levina, Floor Broekgaarden, Lieke van Son, Emanuele Berti, Amedeo Romagnolo, Ruediger Pakmor, Ana Lam |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 64 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-20202
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
From cosmological simulations to binary black hole mergers: The impact of using analytical star formation history models on gravitational-wave source populations Sasha Levina, Floor Broekgaarden, Lieke van Son, Emanuele Berti, Amedeo Romagnolo, Ruediger Pakmor, Ana Lam Abstract Observations of BBH ( BBH ) mergers provide a unique window into the lives of massive stars across cosmic time. Connecting redshift-dependent merger properties to massive star progenitors requires accurate models of cosmic star formation and chemical enrichment histories. Analytical fits for the metallicity-specific cosmic star formation rate density 𝒮 ( Z , z ) \mathcal{S}(Z,z) are commonly used as proxies for the complex underlying star formation history, yet they remain unconstrained. Using the IllustrisTNG cosmological simulations, we evaluate the accuracy of these analytical 𝒮 ( Z , z ) \mathcal{S}(Z,z) prescriptions and assess how simulation resolution and volume affect the inferred 𝒮 ( Z , z ) \mathcal{S}(Z,z) . By coupling the simulated and analytical 𝒮 ( Z , z ) \mathcal{S}(Z,z) to the population synthesis code COMPAS , we investigate the resulting BBH merger rates and mass distributions. We find that analytical 𝒮 ( Z , z ) \mathcal{S}(Z,z) prescriptions can overestimate BBH merger rates at high redshift ( z ≳ 6 z\gtrsim 6 ) by up to a factor of 10 10 – 10 4 10^{4} , depending on cosmological simulation resolution, and can introduce spurious features in the BBH mass distribution. For example, they can produce an artificial feature near 8 M ⊙ 8\,M_{\odot} in the primary mass distribution at z ≲ 2 z\lesssim 2 , which is absent when using the full simulation-based 𝒮 ( Z , z ) \mathcal{S}(Z,z) , while simultaneously suppressing high-mass features. These discrepancies arise because simple analytical models fail to capture a high-metallicity bump and a more flattened low-metallicity tail in the simulated 𝒮 ( Z , z ) \mathcal{S}(Z,z) metallicity distribution. Our results highlight the importance of accurate star formation histories for modeling BBH populations, demonstrate the limitation of widely used analytical 𝒮 ( Z , z ) \mathcal{S}(Z,z) fits, and underscore the need for careful integration of cosmological simulations, analytical fits, and population synthesis when interpreting gravitational-wave observations. show][email protected] I Introduction The mergers of \Acp BBH, even those occurring nearby, encode information about stellar physics across a large range of redshifts due to the distribution of delay times between their formation and merger ( 30 ; 56 ; 31 ; 23 ) . To disentangle the mixture of delay times and formation channels within an observed GW ( GW ) population and to infer the environments and binary evolutionary processes that produce merging BBH , astrophysical population synthesis models of their formation pathways are essential ( 16 ; 17 ; 55 ) . These models must be combined with assumptions about the cosmic star formation history in order to accurately represent stellar progenitors across cosmic epochs ( 66 ; 21 ; 17 ; 13 , e.g.,) . In modeling rates of metallicity-dependent transients (e.g., BBH mergers), the star formation history is commonly represented using a simple, fitted functional form that combines a star formation rate density \mathcal{S}(z) with some assumption for the metallicity distribution across redshift ( 66 , e.g.,) . The resulting metallicity-dependent star formation rate density \mathcal{S}(Z,z) can vary significantly depending on the model, how it is constructed, and the data used to calibrate its parameters ( 23 ; 20 , see) . Rates of double compact object mergers across redshift may change by an order of magnitude depending on the assumptions made for \mathcal{S}(Z,z) ( 21 ; 66 ; 91 ; 17 ; 109 ) . Testing the effect of different models of \mathcal{S}(Z,z) can help disentangle the effects of metallicity evolution, the SFR ( SFR ), and binary evolution models on the BBH population and provide insight into which components are most critical to model accurately. Three methods are typically used to model the star formation history: (i) analytical prescriptions, (ii) observational distributions, or (iii) cosmological simulations. Analytical prescriptions for \mathcal{S}(z) and the redshift-dependent metallicity distribution ( 49 ; 52 ; 53 ; 66 ; 104 ; 90 ; 13 ; 97 ; 96 ; 106 ; 94 , as employed by e.g.,) are derived from galaxy survey data or empirical scaling relations such as \mathcal{S}(z) , the MZR ( MZR ), and the GSMF ( GSMF ). Observational data can also be directly used to create a distribution of star formation histories without performing an analytical fit ( 21 ; 22 ; 12 ; 96 ) . However, observations become increasingly challenging at high redshifts and low galaxy luminosities, with uncertainties in high-redshift dust extinction, survey sensitivity and sky coverage limits, and discrepancies between star formation histories derived from different observational methods ( 22 ; 44 ; 45 ; 28 ; 54 ) . This makes it more challenging to construct a comprehensive cosmic star formation history. Cosmological simulations offer a third approach by modeling a representative population of galaxies across cosmic history. These simulations track the characteristics of stellar populations and the gas from which they form over redshift ( 116 , for a review, see) . This enables the construction of the complete \mathcal{S}(Z,z) from the SFR and metallicity of galaxies, accounting for every galaxy formed in the simulation box without observational limitations ( 42 ; 15 , e.g.,) . The accuracy of that star formation history is constrained by the model resolution, physical assumptions built into the simulation, and the treatment of unresolved processes via subgrid models ( 77 ; 116 ; 72 ) . Different simulations can deviate particularly at high redshifts, as high redshift galaxy evolution is not directly accounted for in the model calibration. The resulting BBH merger rate can vary significantly with simulation used ( 15 ) . Others use the cosmological simulation \mathcal{S}(Z,z) implicitly by populating BBH (or other transients) into the simulation by associating them with stellar populations in the simulation ( 58 ; 60 ; 59 ; 3 ; 2 ; 62 , e.g.,) . More recently, analytical fits to cosmological simulations have been used to represent \mathcal{S}(Z,z) ( 109 ) , which is computationally simpler for further use with population synthesis than constructing \mathcal{S}(Z,z) from the simulation data. These fits have become widely used ( 110 ; 37 ; 83 ; 88 ; 120 , e.g.) . The main challenge in modeling BBH populations using analytical fits to cosmological simulations is twofold. First, it is unclear whether analytical prescriptions can reliably represent the underlying \mathcal{S}(Z,z) . Second, the impact of simulation resolution and box size on the star formation history, and hence on the predicted BBH population, remains insufficiently understood. Several studies have addressed parts of this problem. 109 tested the goodness of fit of analytical \mathcal{S}(Z,z) models to a single IllustrisTNG simulation and examined how varying \mathcal{S}(Z,z) parameters affects the BBH primary mass distribution. 15 explored how different cosmological simulation suites influence predicted BBH population properties. 96 compared analytical \mathcal{S}(Z,z) prescriptions with observationally derived models when computing the BBH merger rate. With respect to numerical effects, 62 found that variations in box size have a negligible effect on \mathcal{S}(Z,z) and on the resulting BBH properties.