Fueling Volunteer Growth: the case of Wikipedia Administrators CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in HCI

Eli Asikin-Garmager, Yu-Ming Liou, Caroline Myrick, Claudia Lo, Diego Saez-Trumper, Leila Zia · 2026

Read Fueling Volunteer Growth: the case of Wikipedia Administrators CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in HCI by Eli Asikin-Garmager, Yu-Ming Liou, Caroline Myrick, Claudia Lo, Diego Saez-Trumper, Leila Zia (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-20016.txt.

Introduction

Eli Asikin-Garmager and colleagues study the volunteer administrators who keep Wikipedia running. Administrators perform over a million actions a year across the project. This multi-method study analyses adminship in hundreds of Wikipedia language editions since 2018. It reveals a two-sided trend in the administrator population.

Over half of all Wikipedias gained administrators on net. Yet almost two-thirds of the highly active editions face decline. The biggest communities, which need governance most, are losing it. The authors frame their study around fuelling volunteer growth. Understanding where administrators thrive or vanish guides recruitment efforts. The health of Wikipedia's governance is a question for the whole open-knowledge ecosystem. The trend cuts both ways at once. Big sites lose staff while small ones gain. That split is the key find here.

Catalog record

CREATOREli Asikin-Garmager, Yu-Ming Liou, Caroline Myrick, Claudia Lo, Diego Saez-Trumper, Leila Zia
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE93 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-20016

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Fueling Volunteer Growth: the case of Wikipedia Administrators CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in HCI Eli Asikin-Garmager, Yu-Ming Liou, Caroline Myrick, Claudia Lo, Diego Saez-Trumper, Leila Zia Abstract . Wikipedia administrators are vital to the platform’s success, performing over a million administrative actions annually. This multi-method study systematically analyzes adminship across 284 Wikipedia languages since 2018, revealing a critical two-sided trend: while over half of all Wikipedias show a net increase in administrators, almost two-thirds of highly active Wikipedias face decline. Our analysis, drawing from large-scale adminship log analysis, over 3000 surveys, and 12 interviews, reveals this decline is primarily driven by insufficient recruitment, not unusual attrition. We identify key barriers for potential administrators, including limited awareness, ambiguous requirements, a demanding selection process, and low initial interest. Recognizing that current administrators remain highly motivated and engaged, we propose actionable recommendations to strengthen recruitment pipelines and fuel Wikipedia administrator growth, crucial for Wikipedia’s long-term sustainability. 1. Introduction Every second, Wikipedia is edited an average of 5 times, and viewed approximately 6000 times 1 1 1 Numbers are computed based on 12-month total pageviews and total edits to Wikipedia as of 2025-09-11 https://stats.wikimedia.org/#/all-wikipedia-projects . This immense scale, fueled by hundreds of thousands of volunteer editors across over 300 languages, relies not only on volunteer editors who write encyclopedic knowledge but also on a critical group of trusted Wikipedia editors with extended rights: Wikipedia Administrators . Administrators perform a range of activities on Wikipedia including but not limited to deleting and restoring Wikipedia articles, blocking disruptive users, and restricting editing access through page protection mechanisms. Through their work they ensure timely, verifiable encyclopedic knowledge. While readers, editors, and content have been extensively studied ( 53 ; 47 ; 42 ) , the dynamics of these vital extended-rights users remain largely unexplored. This study focuses on administrators due to their indispensable role in maintaining content integrity and community health, and their position as a foundational tier for other extended-rights roles such as Wikipedia stewards (users with complete access to the wiki interface on all Wikimedia projects). Background and objective Despite the critical role of administrators, existing research on Wikipedia has primarily focused on editor and reader motivations ( 62 ; 30 ; 2 ; 28 ; 74 ; 75 ) , with limited understanding of administrators beyond specific studies on English Wikipedia’s Request for Adminship (RFA) process ( 9 ; 10 ) . Critically, these prior works often overlook cross-language administrator trends, the underlying drivers of adminship changes, and the specific barriers faced by potential candidates. Concerns about administrator numbers have also been raised intermittently within the Wikipedia community itself, yet a comprehensive, multi-language investigation has been lacking. This study aims to address these significant gaps by offering a large-scale, multi-method analysis of Wikipedia adminship and administrators, their trends, challenges, and motivations across a diverse set of language editions. Contributions and findings. This study presents the first comprehensive, multi-language investigation into Wikipedia administrator dynamics, leveraging log data from 284 Wikipedias, over 3000 administrator surveys, and 12 semi-structured interviews. Our primary contributions are as follows: • We reveal a critical two-sided trend in administrator numbers: while over half of all Wikipedias show growth or stability since 2018, roughly two-thirds of highly active Wikipedias face decline (Section 5.1 ). • We demonstrate that this decline is primarily driven by insufficient recruitment, rather than unusual attrition, with administrator departure rates remaining largely stable (Section 5.2 ). • We identify key barriers to recruitment, including limited awareness of the role, ambiguous candidacy requirements, a demanding and stressful selection process (RFA), and low initial interest among potential administrators. We also highlight the crucial opportunity of current administrator motivation and engagement, and the pervasive challenge of conflict (Section 5.3 ). • We provide actionable recommendations derived from our findings and community engagement to strengthen administrator recruitment pipelines and foster sustainable volunteer moderation, relevant for both Wikipedia communities and the broader HCI community (Section 6 ). 2. Background In this section we provide background knowledge for this study, and explain key concepts used in this paper. Technical definitions will be covered in Section 4 . 2.1. What Wikipedia administrators do and why it matters Administrators on Wikipedia conduct social, governance, and technical work essential to the healthy operation of their Wikipedia language editions. They are granted extended user rights, enabling them to delete pages, block disruptive users, and restrict editing access via page protection 2 2 2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Protection_policy . These rights are primarily used to combat vandalism, 3 3 3 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Vandalism spam, and other issues that threaten content quality and accuracy, thereby maintaining editorial integrity ( 35 ) . Beyond direct moderation, administrators are deeply involved in the project’s infrastructure and community. They develop and operate third-party tools, such as bots for anti-vandalism efforts ( 52 ) . Socially, they exhibit various leadership behaviors ( 77 ) , form crucial knowledge-sharing networks among themselves ( 26 ) , and, as active and involved users, model normative behavior for other editors ( 48 ) . Furthermore, administrators play a significant role in the creation and discussion of Wikipedia policies ( 8 ) . Membership in the administrator group also qualifies users for other, more-restrictive user roles, in practice leveraging the social capital and trust that adminship confers. These specialized roles are essential for critical, higher-tier work across diverse Wikipedia language editions. Examples include: CheckUsers , 4 4 4 https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/CheckUser_policy who access IP information for anti-vandalism efforts; Oversighters , 5 5 5 https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Oversight_policy capable of hiding sensitive edits and redacting private or libelous information from histories; and Stewards , 6 6 6 https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Stewards responsible for user rights management across all Wikipedias. 2.2. Gaining and losing administrator rights The process of becoming a Wikipedia administrator begins with a nomination of a user, and the presentation of their qualifications to the broader community. This process is generally known as a Request for Adminship (RFA) 7 7 7 The list of documented RFA processes across many Wikipedia languages can be accessed via https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q4048254 , and usually takes place on a public page where community members can ask questions and express support or opposition for a candidate. The duration and specific rules of RFAs vary widely across different language Wikipedias. Outcomes are decided by consensus or voting, with a typical success threshold of around two-thirds support. Some Wikipedia editions grant admin rights indefinitely, while others have term limits requiring re-election. 2.3. Removal of administrative rights Administrators can have their rights removed voluntarily by stepping down or involuntarily through a ‘‘de-sysopping’’ 8 8 8 https://simple.wiktionary.org/wiki/Wiktionary:Desysop_policy process initiated by the community. The procedures for involuntary removal vary widely: some Wikipedia editions hold formal votes requiring evidence of wrongdoing and community support, while others rely on higher-level committees of other community members to deliberate on de-sysopping requests. Many projects also have inactivity rules, where administrators who do not maintain a minimum level of activity can lose their status. In cases of removal, former admins may be allowed to reapply for adminship later, depending on community policies. 3. Related Work While substantial research has explored the social dynamics of Wikipedia editors, investigations specifically focused on its administrators remain limited. This section reviews relevant prior work and highlights the specific gaps in

Read the complete text