Laboratory Tests of Laser Control of Electron Beams for Future Colliders
C. Munting, P. Kicsiny, E. Barbi, N. Gonzalez, S. Gessner, I. Drebot · 2026
Read Laboratory Tests of Laser Control of Electron Beams for Future Colliders by C. Munting, P. Kicsiny, E. Barbi, N. Gonzalez, S. Gessner, I. Drebot (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-19865.txt.
Introduction
C. Munting and five colleagues report lab tests of using lasers to control electron beams. Future colliders like the FCC-ee need bunches of matched intensity. An instability called flip-flop can grow when colliding bunches differ in strength. Laser-driven Compton backscattering has been proposed to trim bunch intensity.
Lasers have also been proposed as indestructible collimators, scraping off stray beam particles without material jaws. The team tests these laser control ideas in the laboratory. Proof at small scale comes before any collider adopts the schemes. Beam control is a quiet bottleneck in collider design. The results inform whether light can do a job now done by matter.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | C. Munting, P. Kicsiny, E. Barbi, N. Gonzalez, S. Gessner, I. Drebot |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 13 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-19865
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Laboratory Tests of Laser Control of Electron Beams for Future Colliders C. Munting, P. Kicsiny, E. Barbi, N. Gonzalez, S. Gessner, I. Drebot Abstract Laser-driven Compton backscattering (CBS) has been proposed as method for controlling the intensity of colliding bunches in the FCC-ee so as to avoid the flip-flop instability caused by intensity asymmetry in colliding bunches. Laser-based collimation has also been proposed as an indestructible collimator for high-intensity electron beams. We have initiated a laboratory-based test program of these concepts with the E344 experiment at FACET-II. In this paper, we describe simulations of laser-beam interactions at FACET-II and the relevant scaling for FCC-ee. We also describe the experimental setup and diagnostics that will be used to make the measurements at FACET-II. 1 Introduction Future colliders aim to maximize their luminosity in order to deliver on ambitious physics goals. In order to maximize luminosity, circular colliders operate with very large beam currents, and linear colliders operate with very small spot sizes. We encounter challenges as we push these machines to their luminosity limits. In the FCC-ee electron-positron collider 9 , which operates at high collision energy with intense beams, the beamstrahlung-induced flip-flop instability can lead to luminosity loss 14 ; 15 ; 13 . The instability is driven by charge asymmetry in the colliding bunches, and can be mitigated by quickly removing charge from the more intense of the two bunches by Compton backscattering 22 ; 7 ; 8 . In linear colliders, such as the ILC 3 and CLIC 2 , a considerable fraction of the beam delivery system (BDS) is devoted to collimating away high-amplitude halo particles. The collimators are physical devices that can be destroyed by the beam if the beam is mis-steered 17 . A laser-based collimation scheme has been proposed that would both reduce the length of the BDS and avoid the problem of collimator destruction 23 . While both the laser control of bunch intensity and laser collimation of halo particles are promising topics, neither have been demonstrated in the lab. We have proposed the E344 experiment at FACET-II 20 which leverages the E320 experimental infrastructure 6 to validate these concepts. 2 Compton Back Scattering During Compton backscattering, a high energy electron collides with a lower energy photon, and scatters the photon to modified energies and momenta 7 . The resulting electron energy after collision should be lower than its initial energy, thus providing a mechanism to remove unwanted electrons from the beam by pushing them outside the machine’s energy acceptance. To predict the number of Compton scattering events for the E320 experiment parameters, we compute the Compton cross section for the beam and laser parameters at FACET-II. The scattering parameter x is defined as x=\dfrac{4E_{b}E_{\gamma}}{m_{e}^{2}c^{4}}\cos^{2}\dfrac{\alpha_{0}}{2}, (1) where E_{b} and E_{\gamma} are the energies of the beam and photons respectively and \alpha_{0} is the crossing angle between the incoming electron beam and laser. For the E320 experiment, E_{b}=10\text{ GeV} , \lambda_{\gamma}=800\,\mathrm{nm} and \alpha_{0}=28.1^{\circ} . The calculated scattering parameter is x=0.223 . The total Compton cross section \sigma_{0}(x) is given by the formula 11 : \displaystyle\sigma_{0}(x) \displaystyle=\dfrac{2\pi r_{e}^{2}}{x}\biggl([1-\dfrac{4}{x}-\dfrac{8}{x^{2}}]\ln(1+x) \displaystyle+\dfrac{1}{2}[1-\dfrac{1}{(1+x)^{2}}]+\dfrac{8}{x}\biggl) \displaystyle=550\text{ mbarn}. The maximum energy lost by scattered electrons is E_{loss}=x(1+x)^{-1}E_{b} . For the 10 GeV electron beam, this amounts to 1.83 GeV. The electron beam and laser pulse do not necessarily have the same size. The luminosity per bunch crossing for different-sized beams is given by 8 ; 12 : \displaystyle\mathcal{L}=\dfrac{N_{e}N_{\gamma}}{2\pi\sqrt{\sigma_{e,x}^{2}+\sigma_{\gamma,x}^{2}+(\sigma_{e,z}+\sigma_{\gamma,z})\tan\frac{\alpha_{0}}{2}}\sqrt{\sigma_{e,y}^{2}+\sigma_{\gamma,y}^{2}}} \displaystyle=5.3\times 10^{23}/\mu m^{2}, where N_{e} and N_{\gamma} are the number of electrons and photons in the beam and laser pulses, respectively, \alpha_{0} is the crossing angle, \sigma_{e,x,y} and \sigma_{\gamma,x,y} are the transverse size of the beam and laser pulses, respectively, and \sigma_{e,z} and \sigma_{\gamma,z} are the longitudinal sizes. Table 1 provides the beam parameters for the proposed experiment. Multiplying the cross section by the luminosity gives the total number of collisions for a single beam-laser interaction, with roughly 0.3% of electrons scattering off a photon or \mathcal{L}\sigma_{0}=3\times 10^{7} events. Species N \sigma_{x} ( \mu m) \sigma_{y} ( \mu m) \sigma_{z} Electron 10^{10} 46 23 20 \mu m Photon 4\times 10^{17} 10 10 55 fs Table 1: Electron and photon beam parameters for the proposed experiment at FACET-II. 3 Modeling in CAIN and XSuite The beam dynamics were modeled through a combination of CAIN and Xsuite. CAIN is a FORTRAN Monte Carlo code that allows for the simulation of high energy photon, electron and positron interactions 21 . Xsuite is a tracking software that was used to model particles through the FACET-II lattice. CAIN was operated through the custom python interface Xcain that allows for streamlined communication between Xsuite and CAIN 4 . We assume that the electron and laser pulses are Gaussian distributions and note that the laser is round and smaller than the ellipsoidal electron beam, as shown in Table 1 . Figure 1: Top: \beta_{x} and \beta_{y} functions for this lattice section. Bottom: part of the final focusing section indicating the laser IP (black) and downstream OTR camera (red, “wdsotr”). We represent the electron beam with 5\times 10^{4} macroparticles. We then initialize the laser element in CAIN, add it to the FACET beamline in Xsuite and track the macroparticles. The particles are initialized just upstream of the laser interaction point (IP) and then interact with the laser before propagating to a downstream optical transition radiation (OTR) screen. The beam betafunctions and a layout of the beamline are shown in Figure 1 . The location z=0 m corresponds to the IP and the red circle labled “wdsotr” is the location of the OTR screen. Figure 2 , shows the x-\delta phase space at the location of the OTR screen. The energy distribution shows deviations of up to \sim 20\% , consistent with the estimate of 18% calculated in Section II. The number of particles with an energy loss greater than than 3\% is about 2\times 10^{7} electrons, which is in good agreement with the predicted calculations and suggests that most Compton scattered electrons will be lost from the beam if they were subject to the FCC dynamic aperture 22 . Figure 2: Energy and horizontal (x) position after interaction with a 100\,\mathrm{m}\,\mathrm{J} laser after propagation through the FACET-II lattice. Energy is represented as a fractional deviation from the reference energy p_{0}c=10\text{ GeV} . 4 Experimental Configuration The beam-laser IP for the E320 experiment is shown in Figure 3 . The bunch intensity control experiment will utilize the E320 experimental setup without modification. The maximum laser pulse energy on target is 0.5 J and the minimum laser pulse length is 55 fs, which yields an intense laser pulse suitable for nonlinear Compton scattering and strong-field QED experiments. The E344 experiment aims to operate in the linear Compton scattering regime, so we require only 0.1 mJ on target and a 100 fs-long laser pulse. The laser pulse energy is controlled by a waveplate and polarizer and the pulse length is controlled by adjusting the grating separation in the laser pulse compressor. The E320 experiment focuses the laser down to the smallest possible size and has demonstrated spots less than 2 \mu m wide. The E344 experiment will use the same off-axis parabola (OAP) focusing elements, but achieve larger spots by adding a defocusing term to