Unique Preference Aggregation in Design and Decision Making
A.R.M. Wolfert · 2026
Read Unique Preference Aggregation in Design and Decision Making by A.R.M. Wolfert (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-19759.txt.
Introduction
A. R. M. Wolfert writes on how group preferences get combined into one choice. Preference aggregation sits at the heart of multi-objective design and group decision-making. It picks the alternative that best fits a shared purpose in complex social and technical settings. Preferences are subjective, tied to context, and express the free choice of the people involved.
The paper argues for aggregation methods that respect the uniqueness of each person's ordering. A method that flattens real differences can pick options nobody truly wants. Design teams and public bodies both lean on such aggregation daily. Getting it right shapes products and policies alike. The work examines what a faithful aggregation should preserve.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | A.R.M. Wolfert |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 51 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-19759
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Unique Preference Aggregation in Design and Decision Making A.R.M. Wolfert Abstract Preference aggregation is a core operation in multi-objective design optimisation and group decision-making, as it determines the best-fit-for-common-purpose alternative within complex socio-technical contexts. Since preferences are intrinsically linked to choice, they are subjective, inherently contextual, and reflect humans’ free will to relatively order their alternatives. Therefore, their aggregation requires a rigorous measurement-theoretic foundation to ensure mathematical validity, interpretability, and uniqueness. Barzilai’s Preference Function Modelling (PFM) theory provides a formal foundation by treating preferences as elements of a one-dimensional affine space, where only differences are meaningful. PFM establishes the principal axioms of unique preference aggregation, providing a rigorous basis on which aggregation can be demonstrated. In this paper, these theoretical conditions are applied to construct a linear preference space with commensurability across multiple criteria, a stable zero-referenced interval scale, and uniqueness up to affine transformation, enabling consistent preference aggregation. It is shown that only linear aggregation—a weighted centroid of z z -scores—is admissible. Analytical arguments and illustrative examples demonstrate that this approach produces a unique aggregated preference ranking. Moreover, this work shows that commonly used aggregation approaches in MCDM—such as weighted arithmetic and geometric means, as well as weighted distance-based optimisation methods—often fail to produce consistent rankings and are therefore unsuitable for pure MCDM. In contrast, the unique preference aggregation presented here clarifies the mathematical limits of valid aggregation and provides a principled, implementable foundation for robust multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA) and multi-objective design optimisation (MODO) in multi-faceted problems. Keywords: Multi-Criteria Decision Making (MCDM); Preference Aggregation; Design and Decision Systems; Multi-criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA); Multi-objective Design Optimization (MODO); Preference Function Modelling (PFM) Article history: Compiled January 26, 2026 Introduction Preference is the decisive quantity in engineering design optimisation and management science for multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM). A preference expresses the relative desirability, value , or utility of a design alternative or decision option A_{i} with respect to a criterion C_{j} . Everything of value is relative. Each alternative or option is intuitively evaluated against one’s conscious lived experience — a relative, subjective, and open-ended human perception arising from all the outer and inner senses. Preference is not a physical property but a subjective construct of the mind. It represents an individual’s choice — free will — within the set of available options, defining the decision space from which selections are made. Free will cannot be absolutely measured, because it is not an object of thought but a reality expressed through human willing; what is possible is ordering and comparison, in which preference emerges as a relative expression of value. Preference is inherently contextual — it reflects the free ordering of alternatives within a given situation. It is therefore individual, relational and situation-dependent. Consequently, preference is ’synonymous’ with choice : a binary relation that induces choice, as one selects the alternative one prefers over another: i.e., A_{1}\succ A_{2} . Without difference, no decision — only difference sets willing into motion. Preference scores or ratings are points whose meaning is inherently relational, as they have no absolute zero. Thus, they are elements of a one-dimensional affine space rather than a ratio or absolute scale (e.g., like time without a fixed origin, a rod without a defined length unit, or a road without kilometre markers — in all cases, only differences and ratios of differences carry meaning). They represent orderings and relative magnitudes of preference differences, but are not physical or absolute measurements. Thus, even a seemingly absolute 0 – 100 scale expressing raw preference ratings for a single criterion remains a one-dimensional affine preference scale ( Barzilai2022 ), whose numerical values are defined only up to an affine transformation. Only ratios of differences between preference values are meaningful. Therefore, the only numerically invariant relation on a preference scale is the k -ratio : k=\frac{p_{a}-p_{b}}{p_{c}-p_{d}} (1) where p_{a},p_{b},p_{c},p_{d} are preference scores forming two differences, whose ratio defines a relative scaling factor. Only affine transformations p_{i}\mapsto ap_{i}+b (i.e., scaling and translation) applied uniformly to all preference scores preserve preference differences. Any other mathematical operation (e.g., absolute values or squaring) applied separately to individual scores is not meaningful, because it alters difference ratios and thus changes the preference meaning. Linearity is a property of a vector space, not of human preferences themselves as such. Preference scores are points in a one-dimensional affine space, where only differences between scores carry meaning. Therefore, a preference difference is not a real distance , and preference aggregation cannot be based on metric distance measures or on the direct aggregation of absolute numbers. This reinforces the contemporary recognition in MCDM research (see e.g., 1 ; 3 ; 8 ) that robust multi-objective design and decision modelling requires close alignment between qualitative problem-structuring and mathematically sound preference measurement theory. This distinction between ordering and measurement has direct consequences for formal design and decision methodologies. Notably, Barzilai’s preference function modelling (PFM) theory ( 9 ) had already provided a formal mathematical foundation for preference-based decision-making by establishing the measurement-theoretic conditions for meaningful preference modelling (for further engagement with preference-based MCDM, the reader is referred to Wolfert2023 ). To address this rigorously, Barzilai defined axioms 1 1 1 These are best interpreted as formal conditions (not axioms in the mathematical sense, which are unprovable and self-evident truths, such as Euclid’s postulates) that any valid preference representation and aggregation must satisfy. governing PFM-consistent preference aggregation, ensuring that preference scales and their combinations remain consistent and mathematically valid ( 12 , 2006). These axioms specify the mathematical structure that preferences must satisfy to be meaningfully combined into a single, consistent, and unique (up to affine transformation) aggregated preference score, thereby establishing the formal conditions under which linear algebra and calculus (e.g. Strang2006 ) can be rigorously applied to preference and other subjective quantities. Within this framework, the alternative with the highest aggregated preference represents the best-fit for common purpose, given the set of alternatives and the decision makers’ criteria with their relative importance.The PFM-consistent conditions for preference representation, expressed as axioms by Barzilai, form the theoretical foundation for pure MCDM. For the purpose of aggregation in this work, the following four PFM-based axioms are outlined below. A unique and consistent decision outcome can be produced if and only if preferences satisfy these axioms: Axiom 1 – Preference Preservation ( \Delta -meaningfulness) Preference information is meaningful only in terms of differences between alternatives on an interval scale. These differences are relative, not absolute: distances as geometric constructs have an absolute zero, which does not exist in subjective preference measurement; zero-preference is always relative. Therefore, valid preference scales are only defined up to affine transformations (affine-invariant) applied uniformly: p_{i}^{\prime}=ap_{i}+b,\qquad a>0,\quad\forall i, (2) which preserve all meaningful preference information . Note: Substituting Equation ( 2 ) into Equation ( 1 ) leaves the k -ratio unchanged, thus preserving relative preference differences between alternatives. Axiom 2 - Comparable Criteria Preferences from different criteria can only be aggregated if they are measured on a common, valid, preference-based interval scale with commensurate units, ensuring that no criterion dominates due to its scale rather than its assigned weight. Thus, aggregation is only valid when preference differences are commensurate —i.e., measured in equivalent units across all criteria—ensuring that equal marginal differences carry equal preference