Coarsened data in small area estimation: a Bayesian two-part model for mapping smoking behaviour
Aldo Gardini, Lorenzo Mori · 2026
Read Coarsened data in small area estimation: a Bayesian two-part model for mapping smoking behaviour by Aldo Gardini, Lorenzo Mori (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-19729.txt.
Introduction
Aldo Gardini and Lorenzo Mori work on a measurement problem in public health. Health surveys sample few people in each small area, so direct estimates for those areas are noisy. Small area estimation borrows strength across areas to sharpen the numbers. The authors apply these methods to mapping smoking behaviour.
Their outcome data come from self-reports, which suffer from coarsening. People round answers and favour certain digits, blurring the true values. Ignoring that blur can bias the maps. The authors build a Bayesian two-part model that handles coarsened data directly. Better local estimates help target anti-smoking programs where they are needed most. The method suits other self-reported health measures too.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Aldo Gardini, Lorenzo Mori |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 65 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-19729
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Coarsened data in small area estimation: a Bayesian two-part model for mapping smoking behaviour Aldo Gardini, Lorenzo Mori Abstract Estimating health indicators for restricted sub-populations is a recurring challenge in epidemiology and public health. When survey data are used, Small Area Estimation (SAE) methods can improve precision by borrowing strength across domains. In many applications, however, outcomes are self-reported and affected by coarsening mechanisms, such as rounding and digit preference, that reduce data resolution and may bias inference. This paper addresses both issues by developing a Bayesian unit-level SAE framework for semi-continuous, coarsened responses. Motivated by the 2019 Italian European Health Interview Survey, we estimate smoking indicators for domains defined by the cross-classification of Italian regions and age groups, capturing both smoking prevalence and intensity. The model adopts a two-part structure: a logistic component for smoking prevalence and a flexible mixture of Lognormal distributions for average cigarette consumption, coupled with an explicit model for coarsening and top-coding. Simulation studies show that ignoring coarsening can yield biased and unstable domain estimates with poor interval coverage, whereas the proposed model improves accuracy and achieves near-nominal coverage. The empirical application provides a detailed picture of smoking patterns across region–age domains, helping to characterize the dynamics of the phenomenon and inform targeted public health policies. Key Words: Digits preference, Heaping, Lognormal mixture model, Self-reported survey data, Unit-level model 1 Introduction A substantial proportion of empirical research in public health is grounded in sample surveys, which routinely collect self-reported information on health behaviors, risk factors, and lifestyle patterns. Although such surveys are an essential source of evidence for population health monitoring, the resulting data are inherently subject to sampling variability and multiple forms of measurement error ( Schenker et al. 2010 ; Ramo et al. 2011 , see, among others,) . Self-reported behavioral outcomes are particularly prone to recall bias, rounding, and systematic digit preference, all of which can distort descriptive analysis and both design- and model-based inference. Furthermore, survey sample sizes are often insufficient to produce reliable estimates for small geographic domains or specific socio-demographic groups, thereby motivating the development and use of statistical techniques capable of “borrowing strength” across areas. This study focuses on tobacco consumption, a leading modifiable risk factor for which reliable and geographically disaggregated measures are essential for monitoring population health. To this end, we use data from the European Health Interview Survey (EHIS), coordinated by Eurostat, focusing on the Italian 2019 component. The key indicators considered in the analysis are computed from the variable “mean number of cigarettes smoked daily” and are potentially affected by data coarsening in self-reports, which reduces the effective resolution of the observed data. In particular, we focus on estimating the proportion of daily smokers, the average daily number of cigarettes smoked among daily smokers, and the proportion of heavy smokers among daily smokers. Furthermore, a key objective of this work is to produce estimates at the regional level and further disaggregated by age group, which exacerbates the problem of limited sample sizes in several domains. Producing reliable regional and age-specific estimates is important for informing targeted public health policies and resource allocation ( Kong and Zhang 2020 ; Flor et al. 2021 ) . From a statistical perspective, it also highlights why standard direct estimators, that is expansion estimators based solely on the sample, may be unreliable for the smoking indicators of interest. In particular, direct estimators treat self-reported daily cigarette consumption as error-free, so systematic coarsening can propagate into biased domain-level quantities such as proportions and conditional means. At the same time, the limited sample sizes inflate sampling variability, making direct estimates unstable even in the absence of measurement error. Taken together, these features suggest that direct estimation alone may be inadequate for the targets of interest. Coarsening, heaping, and digit preference have long been recognized as sources of bias in epidemiology, demography, and survey statistics. These phenomena can be interpreted within a unified conceptual framework of data coarsening, whereby rounding represents the most elementary mechanism through which continuous values are observed only at a reduced resolution, while heaping corresponds to structured forms of coarsening characterized by the concentration of reported values at preferred digits or multiples, possibly with multiple levels of coarseness coexisting within the same dataset ( Heitjan and Rubin 1990 ) . Seminal methodological contributions by Heitjan and Rubin 1991 and Heitjan 1993 ; Heitjan 1994 extend the concept of ignorability from missing data to more general forms of data coarsening and formalize the conditions under which the stochastic coarsening mechanism can be validly ignored. When the coarsening mechanism depends on the value of the response, however, ignorability no longer holds and the coarsening process must be modeled explicitly, a point that is particularly relevant for self-reported outcomes subject to heaping. Building on this framework, subsequent work explicitly models heaping and other non-random coarsening mechanisms, showing that failure to account for such processes can substantially distort parameter estimates and lead to misleading inference ( Zhang and Heitjan 2007 ; Wang and Heitjan 2008 ; Zinn and Würbach 2016 ) . More recent contributions examine the impact of heaping in regression modeling ( Bar and Lillard 2012 ) and propose adjustment strategies, possibly incorporating additional information from validation data ( Ahmad et al. 2024 ) . Empirical studies document substantial heaping in behavioral measurements ( Crawford et al. 2015 ) and demographic counts ( Camarda et al. 2017 ) , while survey-oriented work emphasizes implications for official statistics indices such as the poverty rate ( Drechsler and Kiesl 2016 ) . Despite this extensive literature, most methodological work on coarsened data has focused on individual-level outcomes, whereas the main targets in official statistics and public health monitoring are domain-level indicators. This shift from individual to domain targets is central when interest lies in small geographic areas or specific population subgroups. Small Area Estimation (SAE) provides a natural framework to produce stable domain estimates by borrowing strength across areas through auxiliary information and random effects ( Rao and Molina 2015 ) . While SAE methods are well developed, the integration of explicit coarsening mechanisms within SAE models has received limited attention. We address this gap with a Bayesian unit-level SAE model that embeds an explicit coarsening mechanism, treating reported consumption values as heaped realizations of an underlying latent continuous smoking intensity and estimating the coarsening process jointly with the small area model parameters. This joint formulation propagates coarsening-related uncertainty into the target domain indicators while still exploiting auxiliary information for precision gains. The data structure motivates two additional components, a two-part specification to accommodate the non-negligible mass at zero ( Dreassi et al. 2014 ; Chandra and Chambers 2016 ) , and a mixture of two Lognormal components for the positive part to capture heterogeneity in daily cigarette consumption. This specification also raises a technical issue that is relevant for inference on domain indicators. Because Bayesian models based on a Lognormal likelihood may yield posterior moments that are not finite under commonly used priors ( Gardini et al. 2022 ) , we also derive sufficient conditions, stated in terms of prior assumptions on the variance components, that guarantee the existence of posterior moments for the target indicators. Existing SAE applications to tobacco