Direct Doubly Robust Estimation of Conditional Quantile Contrasts
Josh Givens, Song Liu, Henry W. J. Reeve, Katarzyna Reluga · 2026
Read Direct Doubly Robust Estimation of Conditional Quantile Contrasts by Josh Givens, Song Liu, Henry W. J. Reeve, Katarzyna Reluga (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-19666.txt.
Introduction
Josh Givens, Song Liu, Henry W. J. Reeve, and Katarzyna Reluga work on measuring how treatments affect different people. Averages can hide the fact that a treatment helps some patients and not others. Quantile-based measures look at effects across the outcome range, not just at the mean. A newer summary, the conditional quantile comparator, keeps quantile detail while staying fairly interpretable.
The authors develop a direct doubly robust estimator for these quantile contrasts. Doubly robust methods stay valid if one of two working models is right. Direct estimation targets the contrast itself rather than building it from pieces. Better estimators mean trials can report fairer, more detailed effects. The work serves clinical and policy studies where who benefits matters as much as whether it works.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Josh Givens, Song Liu, Henry W. J. Reeve, Katarzyna Reluga |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 87 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-19666
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Direct Doubly Robust Estimation of Conditional Quantile Contrasts Josh Givens, Song Liu, Henry W. J. Reeve, Katarzyna Reluga Abstract Within heterogeneous treatment effect (HTE) analysis, various estimands have been proposed to capture the effect of a treatment conditional on covariates. Recently, the conditional quantile comparator (CQC) has emerged as a promising estimand, offering quantile-level summaries akin to the conditional quantile treatment effect (CQTE) while preserving some interpretability of the conditional average treatment effect (CATE). It achieves this by summarising the treated response conditional on both the covariates and the untreated response. Despite these desirable properties, the CQC’s current estimation is limited by the need to first estimate the difference in conditional cumulative distribution functions and then invert it. This inversion obscures the CQC estimate, hampering our ability to both model and interpret it. To address this, we propose the first direct estimator of the CQC, allowing for explicit modelling and parameterisation. This explicit parameterisation enables better interpretation of our estimate while also providing a means to constrain and inform the model. We show, both theoretically and empirically, that our estimation error depends directly on the complexity of the CQC itself, improving upon the existing estimation procedure. Furthermore, it retains the desirable double robustness property with respect to nuisance parameter estimation. We further show our method to outperform existing procedures in estimation accuracy across multiple data scenarios while varying sample size and nuisance error. Finally, we apply it to real-world data from an employment scheme, uncovering a reduced range of potential earnings improvement as participant age increases. 1 Introduction As data becomes more and more readily available, the demand for personalised treatments and interventions has increased dramatically. The statistical field addressing this challenge is heterogeneous treatment effect (HTE) analysis in which one aims to learn the effect of a treatment on an outcome or response conditional on key covariates ( 15 , 9 , 28 , 24 ) . A core strategy for the analysis of HTE data is to estimate key estimands that quantify the effectiveness of a treatment given the covariates. The two commonly used estimands are the conditional average treatment effect (CATE) ( 2 , 16 , 33 ) and the conditional quantile treatment effect (CQTE) ( 1 , 3 , 29 ) which represent the difference in the conditional mean and quantile of the response respectively for the two treatments given the covariates. Both approaches have advantages: the CQTE yields more granular treatment-effect summaries and is less sensitive to extreme values ( 10 , 8 ) , while the CATE provides a more interpretable estimand with stronger estimation guarantees ( 18 , 20 , 27 ) . A recently introduced estimand, the conditional quantile comparator (CQC) ( 12 ) , aims to bridge the gap between the CATE and the CQTE. The CQC does this by providing a transport map between the conditional treated and untreated response distributions in a quantile preserving manner. The definition of the CQC more naturally aligns with how treatment effects are discussed as they are often talked about as either improving the response by a fixed amount or scaling the response (e.g. a medicine increased life expectancy by 2 years or by 50%). This scaling can be expressed naturally as a function of response while we would need to transform the input via the conditional cumulative distribution function of the untreated response in order to express it as a function of the associated quantile. Therefore in this case the CQC would be able to directly capture this effect helping better understand the treatment and its efficacy while the CATE and CQTE would likely have much more complex relationship for the CATE and CQTE. As the CQC shares properties with the CQTE it also shares its strengths. Namely it is useful in settings where our distribution is heavily skewed, such as platform use or income, as it allows us to make effective decision on which treatment is better without being heavily affected by a small number of extreme samples ( 10 , 6 ) . In relation to this, it can also help with decision making in cases where we want to evaluate our treatment only for certain response values. For example if we want to evaluate some employment intervention on income for those on lower incomes (see our example in Section 5 .) In summary, this leads to the CQC being able to give information on the relationships between the treated and untreated distributions at all levels similarly to the CQTE, while having a more direct interpretation at the response level. The current estimation method for the CQC, introduced in 12 , involves estimating an intermediate estimand and then inverting this to obtain a CQC estimate. Despite having some strong theoretical guarantees, this framework does not enable direct modelling of the CQC itself. This in turn prevents the use of informative parameterisations and limits our ability to constrain or inform the model structure, such as by enforcing smoothness in nonparametric settings. This approach also hinders interpretability of the estimate as it can only be examined via evaluating it at various samples, a procedure which itself can be computationally costly. In this paper, we provide the first direct estimator of the CQC which addresses these limitations. Crucially, our new approach allows the CQC to be explicitly parameterised. This enables us to enforce assumptions on the CQC via flexible techniques including linear parameterisation, neural networks, kernel bandwidth choice in nonparametric settings, and regularisation. This also enhances interpretability by allowing greater flexibility in model inspection. Finally, because our approach models the CQC directly, the estimation error depends on the complexity of the CQC itself, rather than that of an upstream intermediate function. Meanwhile, it retains the doubly robust property, ensuring accurate estimation of the CQC even when all nuisance parameters are estimated suboptimally. To summarise, in this paper we: • Provide the first direct CQC estimation procedure. • Provide finite sample bounds on this estimation procedure. • Illustrate the robustness of our estimator theoretically, and through numerical experiments. • Show it to empirically outperform existing procedures in terms of estimation accuracy along various axes directly highlighting the advantage given by our explicit parameterisation. • Illustrate its interpretability by applying it to real world problems and analysing the results. 2 Problem Formulation We first introduce the general HTE setting. Let Y,X,A be random variables each representing information about an individual in our treatment setting. Specifically we take Y (on \mathcal{Y}\subseteq\mathbb{R} ) to give their univariate outcome/response; X (on \mathcal{X}\subseteq\mathbb{R}^{d} ) to give their covariates of interest e.g. age, height, etc.; and A (on \{0,1\} ) to give their treatment assignment with 1= Treatment and 0= Control. Our overall aim is to understand the effect of treatment, A , on the response, Y , given the covariates, X . We define Z=(Y,X,A) and let D\coloneqq\left\{Z^{(i)}\right\}_{i=1}^{2n}\equiv\{(Y^{(i)},X^{(i)},A^{(i)})\}_{i=1}^{2n} for n\in\mathbb{N} denote IID copies of Z representing our data sample with i indexing each sample/individual and 2n used for notational convenience. We assume that we are in the potential outcome framework so there exists Y(1),Y(0) representing an individuals response both on and off treatment such that Y\equiv Y(A) . To allow our results to translate back to these potential outcomes we