Competing ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic phases on the frustrated Ising honeycomb lattice

P.F. Dias, F.M. Zimmer, N. G. Fytas, M. Schmidt · 2026

Read Competing ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic phases on the frustrated Ising honeycomb lattice by P.F. Dias, F.M. Zimmer, N. G. Fytas, M. Schmidt (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-19648.txt.

Introduction

P. F. Dias, F. M. Zimmer, N. G. Fytas, and M. Schmidt study a model of magnetism on a honeycomb grid. The Ising model treats each site as a tiny magnet that points up or down. Neighbours influence each other through couplings of different strengths and signs. Here the first and second neighbours favour alignment, while third neighbours favour opposition.

That mix is called frustration, since no arrangement can satisfy every bond at once. Frustrated systems can settle into unusual phases, neither fully ordered nor fully random. The authors investigate which phases win as conditions change on the honeycomb lattice. The honeycomb shape matters in real materials such as graphene-like magnets. Phase diagrams from models like this guide the hunt for new magnetic materials.

Catalog record

CREATORP.F. Dias, F.M. Zimmer, N. G. Fytas, M. Schmidt
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE42 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-19648

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Competing ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic phases on the frustrated Ising honeycomb lattice P.F. Dias, F.M. Zimmer, N. G. Fytas, M. Schmidt Abstract We investigate the frustrated J 1 J_{1} – J 2 J_{2} – J 3 J_{3} Ising model on the honeycomb lattice, featuring first- and second-neighbor ferromagnetic couplings ( J 1 > 0 J_{1}>0 and J 2 > 0 J_{2}>0 ) and third-neighbor antiferromagnetic interactions ( J 3 < 0 J_{3}<0 ). Using the cluster mean-field method, we analyze the phase transitions in the regime 1 / 2 < J 2 / J 1 ≤ 1 1/2<J_{2}/J_{1}\leq 1 , where ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic phases compete. Our results reveal that near the strongly frustrated limit J 3 / J 1 = − 1 J_{3}/J_{1}=-1 , the system exhibits order-by-disorder state selection, tricritical and bicritical behavior, critical endpoints, and two successive phase transitions. The ferromagnetic–paramagnetic transition remains second order across the entire interaction range, whereas the antiferromagnetic–paramagnetic boundary shows a richer behavior, including both first- and second-order transitions as well as tricriticality. Increasing the second-neighbor coupling J 2 / J 1 J_{2}/J_{1} narrows the range of J 3 / J 1 J_{3}/J_{1} where first-order antiferromagnetic–paramagnetic transitions occur; beyond a certain threshold, only second-order order–disorder transitions persist. Consequently, the tricritical point shifts toward J 3 / J 1 ≈ − 1 J_{3}/J_{1}\approx-1 as J 2 / J 1 J_{2}/J_{1} increases, culminating in a bicritical point where the antiferromagnetic, ferromagnetic, and paramagnetic phases meet. I Introduction Low-dimensional magnetic systems have long attracted considerable attention due to their relevance to the fundamental physics of phase transitions and their potential technological applications Zhang et al. 2024 ; Elahi et al. 2022 . Significant progress in this field has been driven by the synthesis and characterization of van der Waals materials, many of which exhibit layered honeycomb-lattice magnetic structures Wang et al. 2022 . Notably, the magnetic long-range order in these compounds has been observed to persist down to the monolayer limit Lee et al. 2016 , which, in light of the Mermin–Wagner theorem Mermin and Wagner 1966 , implies the presence of spin anisotropy. Recent studies of van der Waals magnets such as FePS 3 Lee et al. 2016 , VBr 3 Hovančík et al. 2023 , CrI 3 Huang et al. 2017 , and FePSe 3 Chen et al. 2024 provide compelling evidence of strong Ising anisotropy. Moreover, it has been suggested that competing exchange interactions extending up to third neighbors play a crucial role in determining the magnetic behavior of these systems Wang et al. 2022 ; Chen et al. 2024 ; Wildes et al. 2020 . These experimental findings highlight the importance of magnetic frustration in honeycomb lattices and motivate theoretical investigations of the frustrated honeycomb Ising model. In recent years, considerable theoretical effort has been devoted to understanding the phase transitions in the Ising model on the honeycomb lattice, with particular emphasis on the case involving first- ( J_{1} ) and second-neighbor ( J_{2} ) interactions. When ferromagnetic couplings between first neighbors ( J_{1}>0 ) are considered, the model exhibits a ferromagnetic ground state for g_{2}\equiv J_{2}/J_{1}>-1/4 . Early effective-field-theory studies suggested that thermal fluctuations could induce both first- and second-order phase transitions between the ferromagnetic (FE) and paramagnetic (PM) phases, implying the existence of a tricritical point Bobák et al. 2016 . However, more recent results obtained through cluster mean-field (CMF) calculations Schmidt and Godoy 2021 , correlated cluster mean-field Batista et al. 2025 , partition-function-zero analysis Gessert et al. 2024 , and Monte Carlo simulations Žukovič 2021 ; Gessert et al. 2025 ; Azhari et al. 2025 ; Li et al. 2025 support a scenario in which only second-order FE–PM transitions occur in the J_{1} – J_{2} Ising model. Monte Carlo simulations based on the Wang–Landau algorithm further indicate the emergence of a highly degenerate state for g_{2}<-1/4 Azhari et al. 2025 . It has been proposed that tricriticality may arise at the boundary between this degenerate state and the high-temperature paramagnetic phase Azhari et al. 2025 , although this picture has not been confirmed by more recent Metropolis-based simulations Li et al. 2025 . When third-neighbor interactions ( J_{3} ) are included, the system displays several distinct long-range ordered states depending on the relative strengths of g_{2} and g_{3}\equiv J_{3}/J_{1} . Recent CMF and Monte Carlo studies focusing on the regime g_{2}<1/2 have revealed a range of fluctuation-driven phenomena, including order-by-disorder state selection, anomalous specific-heat behavior, and tricriticality Dias and Schmidt 2023 ; Dias et al. 2024 . Although restricted to specific parameter regimes, these works have provided valuable benchmarks for the theoretical description of honeycomb-lattice materials with strong easy-axis anisotropy. In the present work, we aim to deepen the understanding of the J_{1} – J_{2} – J_{3} Ising model on the honeycomb lattice by exploring the phase transitions that occur for g_{2}>1/2 (with J_{1}>0 )—a parameter range largely overlooked in previous investigations. In this regime, both first- and second-neighbor interactions are ferromagnetic, while antiferromagnetic third-neighbor couplings introduce frustration, giving rise to competition between ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic (AF) phases. Our analysis is carried out within the CMF framework, which has been successfully employed in several recent studies of frustrated magnetic systems Yamamoto et al. 2015 ; Roos and Schmidt 2024 ; Yamamoto et al. 2020 ; Rossato et al. 2023 ; Singhania and Kumar 2020 ; Roos et al. 2024 . In particular, the CMF description of the FE–PM phase transition in the J_{1} – J_{2} Ising model is consistent with the results of recent Monte Carlo simulations Schmidt and Godoy 2021 ; Žukovič 2021 ; Gessert et al. 2025 ; Azhari et al. 2025 ; Li et al. 2025 . Moreover, comparative studies of the CMF method and Monte Carlo simulations for the frustrated honeycomb Ising model with ferromagnetic J_{3} interactions have shown that both approaches yield similar thermodynamic behavior Dias et al. 2024 . These findings confirm that the CMF method captures essential frustration effects and provides reliable estimates of phase boundaries and thermodynamic quantities. In the following, we employ CMF calculations using 6-site and 18-site clusters to characterize the phase transitions in the frustrated honeycomb Ising model near the boundary separating the ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic phases. The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. Section II introduces the model and the CMF method. Section III presents our results along with their discussion. Finally, Section IV summarizes the main conclusions and offers an outlook for future relevant research directions. Figure 1: (a) Schematic representation of the first-, second-, and third-neighbor interactions in the honeycomb lattice. (b) Portion of the ground-state phase diagram in the (g_{2},g_{3}) plane, where g_{2}=J_{2}/J_{1} and g_{3}=J_{3}/J_{1} . Panels (c)–(e) illustrate the magnetic configurations of the ferromagnetic (FE), Néel antiferromagnetic (AF), and zigzag (ZZ) antiferromagnetic phases, respectively. Red and black circles denote spins with opposite orientations. II Model and method The Ising Hamiltonian in the absence of external fields is given by \mathcal{H}=-\sum_{i,j}J_{ij}\sigma_{i}\sigma_{j}, (1) where the sum runs over all spin pairs (i,j) coupled by exchange interactions J_{ij} , and \sigma_{i}=\pm 1 . Here, we consider a honeycomb lattice with first-, second-, and third-neighbor interactions denoted by J_{1} , J_{2} , and J_{3} , respectively [see Fig. 1 (a)]. Depending on the magnitude

Read the complete text