Physical Human-Robot Interaction: A Critical Review of Safety Constraints

Riccardo Zanella, Federico Califano, Stefano Stramigioli · 2026

Read Physical Human-Robot Interaction: A Critical Review of Safety Constraints by Riccardo Zanella, Federico Califano, Stefano Stramigioli (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-19462.txt.

Introduction

Riccardo Zanella, Federico Califano, and Stefano Stramigioli review the safety limits that govern robots that touch people. Physical human robot interaction needs clear, strict safety bounds, and one technical standard, ISO/TS 15066, is widely cited for them. The team asks how those bounds were obtained and what assumptions hold them up.

They clarify how to read the limits and what the hidden assumptions do in practice. A bound is only as good as its small print: change an assumption and the safe force or speed changes. Their review serves engineers who must sign off on robots that share space with workers.

Catalog record

CREATORRiccardo Zanella, Federico Califano, Stefano Stramigioli
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE85 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-19462

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Physical Human-Robot Interaction: A Critical Review of Safety Constraints Riccardo Zanella, Federico Califano, Stefano Stramigioli Abstract This paper aims to provide a clear and rigorous understanding of commonly recognized safety constraints in physical human-robot interaction, i.e. ISO/TS 15066, by examining how they are obtained and which assumptions support them. We clarify the interpretation and practical impact of key simplifying assumptions, show how these modeling choices affect both safety and performance across the system, and indicate specific design parameters that can be adjusted in safety-critical control implementations. Numerical examples are provided to quantify performance degradation induced by common approximations and simplifying design choices. Furthermore, the fundamental role of energy in safety assessment is emphasized, and focused insights are offered on the existing body of work concerning energy-based safety methodologies. † † footnotetext: This research has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon Europe Framework Programme under grant agreement No 101070596 (euROBIN). 1 Introduction Figure 1 : Examples of collaborative robots. From left to right: KUKA LBR iiwa, UR5, Doosan H2017, and ABB YuMi (courtesy of KUKA, Universal Robots, Doosan Robotics, and ABB). Over the past two decades, collaborative robots (cobots) have emerged as a new class of robots designed to work safely alongside humans, often allowing direct physical interaction. By enabling efficient small-batch production and minimizing setup times, these systems lower the barriers to automation and thereby make flexible manufacturing both economically and technically viable, even in low-volume, high-mix production contexts. This is particularly relevant for small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), which have historically lacked the financial and technical resources required to deploy large-scale, dedicated robotic systems. Operational studies indicate that human-robot collaboration can reduce cycle times by up to 50% compared to all-human operations, while idle time decreases by 85% when operators work alongside human-aware robots versus fully human teams [ 49 ] . Unlike traditional industrial robots, which are typically confined to cages or safety enclosures, cobots are engineered for open environments where intentional and unintentional contact with human operators may occur [ 1 , 8 ] . Their designs typically incorporate lightweight structures, rounded edges, and advanced sensor suites to support safety-focused control strategies [ 21 ] . This paradigm shift has been accompanied by growing interest in the broader coexistence of humans and robots and in their mutual exchange of information, encompassed by the notion of Human-Robot Interaction (HRI). HRI includes all forms of mutual influence, from non-collaborative scenarios such as supervision, teleoperation, or social interaction, to direct collaboration. Within this spectrum, a further distinction arises when the interaction involves physical contact, leading to the notion of physical Human-Robot Interaction (pHRI), where the emphasis is on the physical component of the interaction. Accordingly, the forces, energy, and power exchanged at the physical interface are key quantitative metrics for safety assessment, regulatory compliance, and control design. It is worth noting that cases in which the physical component is completely absent are relatively rare: even with careful trajectory planning and contact-avoidance algorithms, uncertainty and unforeseen human motion imply a residual possibility of contact. A primary concern in scenarios involving pHRI is ensuring human safety, even under dynamic and partially unknown environmental conditions. While safety is often treated as a fundamental property, it is an emergent characteristic of the interaction context: it depends not only on the robot’s behavior but also on the environment, the task, and human actions. For instance, should safety be operationally defined as the prevention of physical injury, or more broadly as the avoidance of pain and discomfort? Furthermore, can a system legitimately be classified as safe if there exists a small but nonzero probability of harm? In some cases, defining or assessing safety becomes a philosophical problem. For example, what can a robot do to remain “safe” if a human suddenly runs toward it and collides, even when the robot itself is stationary and behaving correctly? To provide practical guidance, the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) helps to bridge the gap between the abstract concept of safety and its operational implementation by adopting a functional perspective, in which safety is regarded as the capability of a robotic system to operate within limits that ensure risks to humans are reduced to an acceptable level. These limits are typically expressed in terms of forces, velocities, accelerations, energy transfer, or spatial constraints, thereby providing quantifiable and enforceable metrics for safe operation. In 2011, the ISO released the standard ISO 10218-2 [ 25 ] , which established foundational safety requirements for the integration of industrial robots into human work environments. Building on this, the technical specification ISO/TS 15066 [ 26 ] was introduced in 2016 to support practitioners in ensuring safety in HRI. A concrete risk comes from the belief that cobots’ design makes them inherently safe, resulting in inadequate control measures, especially in dynamic and complex industrial settings. To this purpose, in 2025, the ISO 10218-2, was revised to deleverage on the concept of cobots in general: only the application can be designed, verified, and validated as collaborative, rather than the robot [ 27 ] . Besides this conceptual shift, for what concerns the safety aspect, these new specifications reaffirm the core practice introduced in the ISO/TS 15066, which is still the main technical guideline in the field. The technical specification ISO/TS 15066 provides quantitative limits to mitigate the risk of human injury during collaborative operations. It enables the dynamic coexistence of humans and robots in the same workspace by defining the allowable motion characteristics under four different collaborative operation modes. Among these modes, the only one which accounts for physical interaction between the robot and a human is the Power and Force Limiting (PFL) mode, which presents a pre-collision guideline aiming to produce safe pHRI. Despite the concrete recommendations provided by these standards, they contain inherent ambiguities that may lead to inconsistent risk assessments and potential underestimation of hazards [ 29 ] . This highlights a broader concern: while the standards offer quantifiable limits and operational definitions, safety in pHRI remains context-dependent, emergent, and sensitive to specific tasks and environmental conditions. ISO/TS 15066 provides a baseline framework whose application requires careful interpretation, as assumptions embedded in the standard may affect both safety assessments and system performance [ 30 ] , emphasizing the need for context-aware evaluation. A proper understanding is crucial not only to implement safety coherently and minimize risks but also to optimize robot performance. In industrial applications, the objective is to ensure that robotic systems perform their designated tasks with maximal operational efficiency while rigorously preserving human safety. Effective safety strategies, therefore, demand a careful balance between risk mitigation and operational efficiency: a robot should not only avoid unsafe behavior (which, according to the standards, could be trivially achieved by keeping it switched off) but must also perform its assigned tasks effectively. While this consideration applies broadly to all practitioners, it is particularly essential for researchers developing novel control strategies, safety frameworks, or pHRI paradigms, where a deep understanding of task-specific dynamics, robot design, and human variability is required to ensure both safe and efficient operation. In this perspective, the present paper aims to provide a clearer and more rigorous understanding of commonly recognized safety constraints in pHRI, focusing on how they are derived and

Read the complete text