Numerical simulations of black hole-neutron star mergers with equal and near-equal mass ratios

Ivan Markin 1, Mattia Bulla 2,3,4, Tim Dietrich 1,5 · 2026

Read Numerical simulations of black hole-neutron star mergers with equal and near-equal mass ratios by Ivan Markin 1, Mattia Bulla 2,3,4, Tim Dietrich 1,5 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-19405.txt.

Introduction

Ivan Markin and three co-authors simulate mergers of a black hole with a neutron star at near equal mass. A detected event, GW230529, hinted that such pairs can be more symmetric than once thought. Even more symmetric pairs should leave fat disks of debris around the merged object.

Those disks can drive bright light shows, like kilonovae, that telescopes can chase. The team runs numerical simulations for equal and near equal mass ratios to map what happens. Their maps help observers know what light to expect when the next such merger's waves arrive.

Catalog record

CREATORIvan Markin 1, Mattia Bulla 2,3,4, Tim Dietrich 1,5
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE42 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-19405

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Numerical simulations of black hole-neutron star mergers with equal and near-equal mass ratios Ivan Markin 1, Mattia Bulla 2,3,4, Tim Dietrich 1,5 Abstract The detection of GW230529_181500 suggested the existence of more symmetric black hole-neutron star mergers where the black hole mass can be as low as 2.6 times that of the neutron star. Black hole-neutron star binaries with even more symmetric mass ratios are expected to leave behind massive disks capable of driving bright electromagnetic transients like kilonovae. Currently, there is only a limited number of numerical-relativity simulations of black hole-neutron star mergers in this regime, which are vital for accurate gravitational waveform models and analytical fitting formulas for the remnant properties. Insufficient accuracy of these may lead to misclassification of real events and potentially missed opportunities to locate their electromagnetic counterparts. To fill this gap in the parameter space coverage, we perform simulations of black hole-neutron star mergers with mass ratios q ∈ { 1 , 1 / 2 , 1 / 3 } q\in\{1,1/2,1/3\} . We find the gravitational waveform models do not show good agreement with the numerical waveforms, with dephasing at the level of around 1 1 rad at the merger. We find that the masses of the dynamical ejecta and disk are in good agreement with the available fitting formulas. The analytical formulas for the remnant black hole are in excellent agreement for the black hole mass, but are less accurate with the predictions for its spin. Moreover, we analyze the remnant disk structure and dynamics, deriving the rotation law and identifying global trapped g g -mode density oscillations. We distinguish three types of accretion in the postmerger and find modulation of the accretion rate by the global oscillations of the disk. Finally, we model the kilonova emission these systems would produce and find that most of them are potentially detectable by Vera C. Rubin Observatory within four days after merger, and by DECam within two days after merger if located at a distance of 200 Mpc. I Introduction Multiple gravitational-wave (GW) signals from black hole-neutron star (BHNS) mergers have been detected to date: GW200105_162426, GW200115_042309 2 , and GW230529_181500 (hereafter GW230529) 1 . According to stellar evolution models, black holes (BHs) are expected to have a mass of at least 5~M_{\odot} , marking the so-called lower mass gap between the heaviest neutron stars (NSs) and the lightest BHs 96 ; 38 . Therefore, most BHNS binaries formed from astrophysical BHs and NSs of typical mass are expected to have the mass ratio at most q\sim 1/3.5 , where q=m_{2}/m_{1} , and m_{1} , m_{2} are the masses of the primary and secondary objects, respectively. As GW230529 inferred to most likely be a BHNS merger of 3.6~\mathrm{M_{\odot}} BH with a 1.4~\mathrm{M_{\odot}} NS ( q\approx 1/2.6 ) 1 , this hypothesized lower mass gap was found to be populated with BHs. The existence of BHNS systems with comparable component masses may indicate their formation through dynamical interactions in dense star clusters, while the effects of mass segregation there may lead to the production of BHNS systems where both the BH and NS have comparable masses 97 ; 27 ; 127 ; 112 . BHNS systems with mass ratios q\sim 1/2 may also be second-generation systems, i.e., formed as a result of dynamical interaction of an NS with a remnant of an earlier binary neutron star (BNS) merger, whose mass is roughly double that of the initial NS in the binary 56 ; 109 ; 75 . On the other hand, symmetric BHNS systems with larger component masses may form from a binary NS system, where one of the NSs collapses, e.g., due to accretion and, thus, exceeding the maximum mass allowed by their equation of state (EOS) 114 . Alternatively, such BHs might be an aftermath of a premature collapse of an NS 4 ; 35 or white dwarf triggered by a smaller BH, such as a primordial one, if those exist 24 ; 117 ; 50 ; 110 ; 50 ; 106 ; 9 ; 10 . As recently estimated by Ref. 11 , a significant fraction of BHs in the NS-mass range can be produced by premature collapse of main-sequence stars triggered by capture of small primordial BHs. M\Omega_{\mathrm{orb,ini}} e Name CoRe m_{\mathrm{NS}} m_{\mathrm{BH}} q M \mathcal{M}_{c} EOS \mathcal{C}_{\mathrm{NS}} \Lambda_{\mathrm{NS}} \tilde{\Lambda} d \mathrm{[10^{-2}]} \mathrm{[10^{-4}]} DD2_mNS0.8_mBH1.6 BAM:0227 0.8 1.6 1/2 2.4 0.9734 DD2 0.0909 12530 1586 30 2.044 7 DD2_mNS1.2_mBH1.2 BAM:0228 1.2 1.2 1 2.4 1.0447 DD2 0.1347 1633 816 31 1.954 4 DD2_mNS1.2_mBH2.4 BAM:0229 1.2 2.4 1/2 3.6 1.4601 DD2 0.1347 1633 206 45 2.044 7 DD2_mNS1.4_mBH1.4 BAM:0230 1.4 1.4 1 2.8 1.2188 DD2 0.1563 701 350 34 2.132 6 DD2_mNS1.4_mBH2.8 BAM:0231 1.4 2.8 1/2 4.2 1.7034 DD2 0.1563 701 88 50 2.190 3 DD2_mNS2.2_mBH2.2 BAM:0232 2.2 2.2 1 4.4 1.9152 DD2 0.2510 29 14 56 1.995 7 DD2_mNS2.2_mBH4.4 BAM:0233 2.2 4.4 1/2 6.6 2.6768 DD2 0.2510 29 3 81 2.099 1 SLy_mNS1.2_mBH1.2 BAM:0234 1.2 1.2 1 2.4 1.0447 SLy 0.1545 811 405 29 2.145 5 SLy_mNS1.2_mBH2.4 BAM:0235 1.2 2.4 1/2 3.6 1.4601 SLy 0.1545 811 102 43 2.179 4 SLy_mNS1.4_mBH1.4 BAM:0236 1.4 1.4 1 2.8 1.2188 SLy 0.1804 307 153 34 2.129 5 SLy_mNS1.4_mBH2.8 BAM:0237 1.4 2.8 1/2 4.2 1.7034 SLy 0.1804 307 38 50 2.189 4 SLy_mNS1.4_mBH4.2 BAM:0238 1.4 4.2 1/3 5.6 2.0511 SLy 0.1804 307 13 66 2.218 2 Table 1: Binary parameters of the simulated configurations. First column: configuration name. Second column: waveform identifier in CoRe database 32 ; 53 . First column group: Arnowitt–Deser–Misner (ADM) mass of the NS in isolation m_{\mathrm{NS}} , Christodolou mass of the BH m_{\mathrm{BH}} , mass ratio q=m_{\mathrm{NS}}/m_{\mathrm{BH}} , total mass of the binary M , and chirp mass \mathcal{M}_{c} . Second column group: name of the employed EOS, the NS compactness \mathcal{C}_{\mathrm{NS}} , quadrupolar tidal deformability of the NS \Lambda_{\mathrm{NS}} , effective tidal deformability of the binary \tilde{\Lambda} . Third column group: initial binary separation d , mass-scaled initial orbital frequency M\Omega_{\mathrm{orb,ini}} , and residual eccentricity in the initial data e . The GW230529_181500 event has revived interest in simulating BHNS mergers with more symmetric mass ratios using numerical relativity (NR) 43 ; 82 ; 84 , as it enables detailed modeling of compact objects within the fully general-relativistic framework. Moreover, the BHNS systems with symmetric masses, q\approx 1 , tend to have more massive accretion disks 44 , whereas for the cases with a nonspinning BH, the disk mass peaks for systems with q\in[1/2,1] 57 . When the BH has a larger prograde spin, heavier disks are produced, with an extended distribution to more asymmetric mass ratios 85 . On the other hand, the mass of dynamical ejecta peaks at q\sim 1/2 for systems with nonspinning BHs, and extends to more asymmetric mass ratios when the BH has larger prograde spin 68 . The combination of these two facts makes systems with mass ratios between 1/2 and 1 promising sources of electromagnetic counterparts, such as kilonovae and gamma-ray bursts 89 ; 72 ; 64 ; 108 ; 71 ; 86 . One motivation for investigating symmetric BHNS systems in NR is the verification of the accuracy of gravitational waveform models. The number of BHNS NR waveforms available for waveform model calibration

Read the complete text