Appraising the Necklace: A post-common-envelope carbon dwarf inside an apparently carbon-poor planetary nebula
David Jones, Romano L. M. Corradi, Gustavo A. García Pérez, Christophe Morisset, Jorge García-Rojas, Laurence Sabin, Bruce Balick, Jacob Wise, Antonio Mampaso, James Munday, Pablo Rodríguez-Gil, María del Mar Rubio-Díez, Miguel Santander-García, Paulina Sowicka, Alexander Csukai, Todd C. Hillwig, An · 2026
Read Appraising the Necklace: A post-common-envelope carbon dwarf inside an apparently carbon-poor planetary nebula by David Jones, Romano L. M. Corradi, Gustavo A. García Pérez, Christophe Morisset, Jorge García-Rojas, Laurence Sabin, Bruce Balick, Jacob Wise, Antonio Mampaso, James Munday, Pablo Rodríguez-Gil, María del Mar Rubio-Díez, Miguel Santander-García, Paulina Sowicka, Alexander Csukai, Todd C. Hillwig, An (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-19382.txt.
Introduction
David Jones and a large team find a carbon rich dwarf star hiding inside a nebula that looks carbon poor. The Necklace nebula is a two lobed planetary nebula left after a shared envelope phase between two stars. Its central star has been shown to be a dwarf carbon star, rich in carbon by type.
Yet the nebula around it reads as poor in carbon, a flat contradiction at first glance. The team appraises how both facts can hold at once. Cases like this test the story of how paired stars trade material and shed their outer layers.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | David Jones, Romano L. M. Corradi, Gustavo A. García Pérez, Christophe Morisset, Jorge García-Rojas, Laurence Sabin, Bruce Balick, Jacob Wise, Antonio Mampaso, James Munday, Pablo Rodríguez-Gil, María del Mar Rubio-Díez, Miguel Santander-García, Paulina Sowicka, Alexander Csukai, Todd C. Hillwig, An |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 51 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-19382
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Appraising the Necklace: A post-common-envelope carbon dwarf inside an apparently carbon-poor planetary nebula David Jones, Romano L. M. Corradi, Gustavo A. García Pérez, Christophe Morisset, Jorge García-Rojas, Laurence Sabin, Bruce Balick, Jacob Wise, Antonio Mampaso, James Munday, Pablo Rodríguez-Gil, María del Mar Rubio-Díez, Miguel Santander-García, Paulina Sowicka, Alexander Csukai, Todd C. Hillwig, Andrea Henderson de la Fuente, Jacco H. Terwel Abstract Context. The Necklace nebula is a bipolar, post-common-envelope planetary nebula, the central star of which has been shown to have a dwarf carbon star companion. Aims. We aim to understand the origins of the Necklace and its dwarf carbon central star. Methods. We study the carbon abundance of the nebula through far ultraviolet spectroscopy obtained with the Hubble Space Telescope. Furthermore, through simultaneous modelling of multiband light and velocity curves, we attempt to constrain the parameters of the central star system. Results. Puzzlingly, we find that the region of the inner nebula observed with the Hubble Space Telescope is seemingly not carbon-rich, at odds with the dwarf carbon star nature of the companion of the central star. The initial mass of the nebular progenitor was likely very close to the limit to become carbon-rich, perhaps experiencing a very late thermal pulse. The dwarf carbon star companion is found to be significantly inflated with respect to that expected for an isolated main sequence star of the same mass. Conclusions. The properties of the central binary are consistent with the progenitor having become carbon-rich and its companion having accreted a significant amount of that carbon-enriched material. However, it is unclear how this evolutionary hypothesis can be reconciled with the inner nebula potentially being carbon poor. 1 Introduction Dwarf Carbon (dC) stars are main-sequence stars which display molecular absorption bands of C 2 , CN and CH in their spectra, even though they have yet to undergo the necessary nucleosynthesis or experience the third dredge up (TDU) required to have brought carbon-rich material to the stellar surface ( 18 ) . The favoured hypothesis for the origins of such stars is that they have previously accreted carbon-rich material from a more evolved companion or its wind ( 32 ) . However, only a handful have been shown to be in spectroscopic binaries with close white dwarf (WD) companions ( 19 ; 46 ) , where the shortest period of these have almost certainly experienced a common-envelope (CE) phase ( 70 ; 79 ) . The CE phase is perhaps the least well understood phase of binary stellar evolution ( 34 ) , in spite of its critical importance in understanding the formation of almost all close binaries with an evolved component (WD, black hole or neutron star). A CE is formed when runaway Roche lobe overflow in a binary system leads to the engulfment of the companion. Subsequent tidal forces between the orbiting companion and donor’s core lead to the deposition of orbital energy and angular momentum into the envelope, shrinking the orbit and lifting the CE either culminating in a merger or the formation of a close binary and the ejection of the CE ( 62 ) . The binary star systems which survive this process, without merging, are thought to be the close-binary central stars of planetary nebulae (PNe), where the nebula itself comprises the ejected envelope while the central ionising source was once the degenerate core of the pre-CE donor star ( 41 ) . The Necklace nebula (IPHASXJ194359.5+170901, IRAS 19417+1701, PN G054.2 - 03.4; 13 , hereafter C11) is unique among post-CE PNe in that it has been shown to host a dC companion ( 52 ) – making it an invaluable system with which to probe the role of the CE phase in the formation of both PNe and dC stars. The nebula’s prominent ring morphology is thought to be due to strongly flattened deposition of the envelope, presumably in the orbital plane of the central binary ( 33 ) . The fainter, high velocity polar outflows, on the other hand, were found to have a larger kinematical age than the main body of the PN ( 13 ) . Therefore, they have been proposed to be formed by a collimated wind from an accretion disc around the secondary star prior to the CE phase ( 13 ) . Evidence for a similar phase of pre-CE accretion is seen in other post-CE PNe, where the binary companions have been found to be inflated ( 36 ; 35 ) and/or where the polar regions of the nebulae are kinematically older ( 53 ) , however no other post-CE PN has been shown to host a dC central star. In this paper, we present a detailed study of the Necklace in order to exploit its unique nature as a probe of the CE in the formation of highly aspherical PNe ( 6 ; 38 ) as well as the formation of dC stars ( 32 ) . With this goal, we have modelled the light and radial velocity variations of the central binary in order to constrain the stellar and orbital parameters of the system. We also probe the chemical and physical properties of the nebula via space-based narrowband imaging and ultraviolet (UV) spectroscopy. 2 Observations 2.1 Optical spectroscopy Radial velocity measurements of the secondary star of the Necklace nebula were obtained during several nights at the 3.5-m APO telescope at Point Apache Observatory (New Mexico, USA) and at the 4.2-m William Herschel Telescope (WHT) at the Observatorio del Roque de los Muchachos (ORM, La Palma, Spain). At APO, we used the DIS double-arm spectrograph. In the blue, the B1200 grating with a slit width of 1.5” provided a spectral reciprocal dispersion of 0.62 Å per pixel, a resolution of 2 Å, and spectral coverage from 3850 to 5050 Å. In the red arm, grating R1200 provided a dispersion of 0.58 Å pix -1 , a resolution of 1.6 Å, and wavelength coverage from 5650 to 6800 Å. At the WHT, we used the Intermediate-dispersion Spectrograph and Imaging System (ISIS). In the blue arm, grating R600B was used, providing a dispersion of 0.44 Å per pixel, a resolution of 1.6 Å with the adopted slit width of 1 ′′ , and wavelength coverage from 3600 to 5050 Å. In the red arm, grating R316R gave a dispersion of 0.92 Å pix -1 , and a resolution of 3.0 Å from 5500 to 7300 Å. Typical integration times at each telescope were 30 or 40 minutes, which were repeated during the period of visibility of the target in the allocated time. The journal of the spectroscopic measurements is presented in Table 1 . Table 1: Journal of spectroscopic observations. For each night, the integration time and number of exposures obtained are indicated. 1 1 1 Notes. $$\ast$$ $$\ast$$ footnotetext: Lower resolution spectra from 13 . Date Exposures 4.2m WHT 2007-07-17 20 min \times 3 ∗ ∗ footnotemark: ∗ 2010-05-02 40 min 2010-05-30 40 min 2010-06-19 40 min 2010-07-22 40 min 2010-07-26 40 min 2011-05-11 40 min 2011-11-05 40 min \times 2 3.5m APO 2012-06-20 30 min \times 3 2012-06-21 30 min \times 3 2012-06-23 40 min \times 2 2012-06-24 40 min \times 5 2012-06-25 30 min \times 5 2012-07-13 40