Pareto-Front Engineering of Dynamical Sweet Spots in Superconducting Qubits
Zhen Yang, Shan Jin, Yajie Hao, Guangwei Deng, Xiu-Hao Deng, Re-Bing Wu, Xiaoting Wang · 2026
Read Pareto-Front Engineering of Dynamical Sweet Spots in Superconducting Qubits by Zhen Yang, Shan Jin, Yajie Hao, Guangwei Deng, Xiu-Hao Deng, Re-Bing Wu, Xiaoting Wang (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-19209.txt.
Introduction
Zhen Yang and six co-authors tune superconducting qubits to sit at their calmest working points. A qubit run at a dynamical sweet spot shrugs off the low frequency flux noise that scrambles quantum states. How long that calm can last, and what hard limits cap it, stayed open questions.
The team frames the search as a multi objective trade, using a fully parameterized scheme that wiggles the flux in a repeating pattern. Their Pareto front view shows the best swaps between calm and other needs. Longer calm times mean quantum machines that can run deeper computations before errors win.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Zhen Yang, Shan Jin, Yajie Hao, Guangwei Deng, Xiu-Hao Deng, Re-Bing Wu, Xiaoting Wang |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 58 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-19209
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Pareto-Front Engineering of Dynamical Sweet Spots in Superconducting Qubits Preprint: APS/123-QED Zhen Yang, Shan Jin, Yajie Hao, Guangwei Deng, Xiu-Hao Deng, Re-Bing Wu, Xiaoting Wang Abstract Operating superconducting qubits at dynamical sweet spots (DSSs) suppresses decoherence from low-frequency flux noise. A key open question is how long coherence can be extended under this strategy and what fundamental limits constrain it. Here we introduce a fully parameterized, multi-objective periodic-flux modulation framework that simultaneously optimizes energy relaxation ( T 1 T_{1} ) and pure dephasing ( T ϕ T_{\phi} ), thereby quantifying the tradeoff between them. For fluxonium qubits with realistic noise spectra, our method enhances T ϕ T_{\phi} by a factor of 3-5 compared with existing DSS strategies while maintaining T 1 T_{1} in the hundred-microsecond range. We further prove that, although DSSs eliminate first-order sensitivity to low-frequency noise, relaxation rate cannot be reduced arbitrarily close to zero, establishing an upper bound on achievable T 1 T_{1} . At the optimized working points, we identify double-DSS regions that are insensitive to both DC and AC flux, providing robust operating bands for experiments. As applications, we design single- and two-qubit control protocols at these operating points and numerically demonstrate high-fidelity gate operations. These results establish a general and useful framework for Pareto-front engineering of DSSs that substantially improves coherence and gate performance in superconducting qubits. I Introduction Superconducting qubits are among the most advanced platforms for quantum computation, with the transmon qubit being widely studied in both theory and experiment 39 ; 37 ; 61 ; 4 ; 51 ; 27 ; 20 ; 50 ; 17 ; 1 ; 3 ; 63 ; 44 ; 24 ; 5 ; 49 ; 48 . In parallel, the fluxonium qubit has emerged as a promising alternative, offering long coherence times and high anharmonicity 34 ; 43 ; 41 . Nevertheless, preserving quantum coherence remains a central challenge, because qubits inevitably couple to their environments. Extending coherence times and mitigating noise-induced errors are therefore critical goals for both fault-tolerant quantum computing and near-term noisy intermediate-scale quantum processors 56 ; 14 ; 47 ; 55 . In fluxonium devices, dominant decoherence mechanisms include flux noise 64 and dielectric loss 36 . Several strategies have been developed to improve coherence, including operating at static sweet spots 22 ; 26 ; 42 ; 65 ; 52 , applying dynamical decoupling techniques 60 ; 23 ; 10 ; 58 ; 46 , and advancing materials and fabrication techniques 36 ; 62 . More recently, periodic flux modulation has been proposed to combine the advantages of static sweet spots and dynamical decoupling. This approach gives rise to dynamical sweet spots (DSSs), where the first-order sensitivity to low-frequency flux noise is suppressed, thereby improving both energy relaxation time ( T_{1} ) and pure dephasing time ( T_{\phi} ). DSSs have since been explored extensively in both theory and experiment, demonstrating substantial robustness to noise 12 ; 59 ; 21 ; 38 ; 16 ; 7 ; 31 ; 15 ; 19 ; 45 . In transmons, they were introduced via single-tone parametric flux modulation 12 , with two-tone drives later improving gate performance in experiments 59 . In fluxonium, Huang et al. 21 established Floquet-engineered continuous DSS families that support control and readout, with experiments reporting up to a 40-fold increase in coherence at such DSSs 38 . Subsequent studies have further expanded the DSS toolbox: longitudinal readout eliminates the adiabatic ramp in dispersive schemes 16 ; tunable-complex-amplitude modulation 7 and commensurate two-tone modulation 31 further extend the control space and improve coherence times; two-tone modulation provides access to double-DSS operating points, for which analytic formulas on their locations which are useful for parameter selection 6 . Overall, DSSs have evolved from single-tone transmon implementations to Floquet-engineered fluxonium families, expanding control capabilities and boosting robustness. Despite this progress, important limitations remain. At static sweet spots, qubits typically exhibit longer T_{\phi} but shorter T_{1} compared to points far from the sweet spot, reflecting an inherent trade-off between these two figures of merit. A similar competition arises in DSSs: the system parameters that maximize T_{\phi} generally do not coincide with those that maximize T_{1} 7 . Moreover, existing DSS schemes often restrict the modulation to predefined forms, such as single-tone or two-tone drives 21 ; 38 ; 7 ; 16 ; 31 . These constraints naturally raise the question: can coherence times T_{1} and T_{\phi} be optimized simultaneously under general periodic flux control, and what fundamental limits govern their maximum values? To overcome the limitations of existing DSS approaches and to systematically determine both the optimal coherence times and their fundamental limits, we develop a fully parameterized multi-objective periodic-flux modulation framework for fluxonium qubits. This framework generalizes beyond conventional single- and two-tone drives by allowing arbitrary periodic flux modulations, thereby enlarging the search space for waveform design. Within this setting, we perform a multi-objective optimization of T_{1} and T_{\phi} and map out the resulting T_{1} - T_{\phi} Pareto front (PF), which makes the trade-off explicit and identifies optimal operating points. For realistic experimental parameters, the optimal solutions on this PF extend T_{\phi} by factors of 3-5 compared with existing DSS strategies, while maintaining T_{1} in the hundred-microsecond regime. By analyzing the PF, we find that relaxation times T_{1} cannot be increased without bound under any periodic-flux modulation. Finally, the optimized PF also includes “double-DSS” regions that are simultaneously insensitive to both DC and AC flux, providing robust operating bands that are well suited for experiments. As applications, based on typical experimental parameters, we select a representative DSS on the PF to evaluate the impact of noise on gate fidelity in open quantum systems. Numerical results demonstrate a high-fidelity single-qubit X gate with 99.9993% fidelity under a 10 ns evolution, and a \sqrt{i\text{SWAP}} gate achieving 99.995% fidelity within 28 ns. Unless otherwise stated, we focus on fluxonium qubits throughout this work, though similar techniques are also applicable to transmon devices. This paper is organized as follows. Section II introduces the dynamics of fluxonium qubits under general periodic modulation and establishes the connection between tunable parameters and decoherence rates. Section III describes the multi-objective numerical optimization procedure to simultaneously optimize T_{1} and T_{\phi} , and reports the T_{1} - T_{\phi} Pareto front, along with the identification of double-DSS regions. Section IV demonstrates the realization of high-fidelity quantum gates at optimal DSS operating points. II Fluxonium qubits under general Periodic Modulation Under general periodic modulation, the dynamics of fluxonium qubits are well described within the Floquet framework. This formalism allows us to analyze the system-bath interaction and to derive the associated decoherence rates in the presence of low-frequency 1/f flux noise and dielectric loss. II.1 System Hamiltonian The Hamiltonian of the fluxonium system is given by 33 H_{q}(t)=4E_{C}\hat{n}^{2}+\frac{1}{2}E_{L}\left[\hat{\varphi}+\phi_{\mathrm{ext}}(t)\right]^{2}-E_{J}\cos\hat{\varphi}, (1) where E_{C} , E_{L} , and E_{J} denote the capacitive, inductive, and Josephson energies, respectively. \hat{n}=Q/(-2e) represents the Cooper-pair number operator, while \hat{\varphi}=2\pi\Phi/\Phi_{0} is the dimensionless flux operator. Here, \Phi_{0}=h/(2e) is the magnetic flux quantum, where h is Planck’s constant. The charge operator Q and the flux operator \Phi satisfy the canonical commutation relation [\Phi,Q]=i\hbar , which leads to [\hat{n},\hat{\varphi}]=i . In this work, we discuss the most general form of the external periodic flux drive: