Double Fairness Policy Learning: Integrating Action Fairness and Outcome Fairness in Decision-making

Zeyu Bian, Lan Wang, Chengchun Shi, Zhengling Qi · 2026

Read Double Fairness Policy Learning: Integrating Action Fairness and Outcome Fairness in Decision-making by Zeyu Bian, Lan Wang, Chengchun Shi, Zhengling Qi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-19186.txt.

Introduction

Zeyu Bian, Lan Wang, Chengchun Shi, and Zhengling Qi demand two kinds of fairness from decision policies at once. Fairness research mostly studies supervised learning, but policies that act on the world raise their own issues. Since a policy intervenes, it creates two fairness targets that can pull apart.

The first is action fairness: like cases should get like actions. The second is outcome fairness: the downstream results should also be even. Their framework, double fairness policy learning, chases both together. Tools used in hiring, lending, and care need this wider lens before they can claim to be fair.

Catalog record

CREATORZeyu Bian, Lan Wang, Chengchun Shi, Zhengling Qi
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE99 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-19186

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Double Fairness Policy Learning: Integrating Action Fairness and Outcome Fairness in Decision-making Zeyu Bian, Lan Wang, Chengchun Shi, Zhengling Qi Abstract Fairness is a central pillar of trustworthy machine learning, especially in domains where accuracy- or profit-driven optimization is insufficient. While most fairness research focuses on supervised learning, fairness in policy learning remains less explored. Because policy learning is interventional, it induces two distinct fairness targets: action fairness (equitable action assignments) and outcome fairness (equitable downstream consequences). Crucially, equalizing actions does not generally equalize outcomes when groups face different constraints or respond differently to the same action. We propose a novel double fairness learning (DFL) framework that explicitly manages the trade-off among three objectives: action fairness, outcome fairness, and value maximization. We integrate fairness directly into a multi-objective optimization problem for policy learning and employ a lexicographic weighted Tchebyshev method that recovers Pareto solutions beyond convex settings, with theoretical guarantees on the regret bounds. Our framework is flexible and accommodates various commonly used fairness notions. Extensive simulations demonstrate improved performance relative to competing methods. In applications to a motor third-party liability insurance dataset and an entrepreneurship training dataset, DFL substantially improves both action and outcome fairness while incurring only a modest reduction in overall value. Keywords: Fairness; Trustworthiness; Policy Learning; Multi-objective Optimization. 1 Introduction As a core aspect of trustworthiness, fairness has become central to machine learning ( 14 ; 49 ; 17 ; 18 ; 22 ; 47 ; 39 ; 7 ) , motivated by ethical concerns about the societal impacts of algorithmic decision-making. In many domains such as healthcare, insurance, lending, and public programs, algorithmic systems can affect large populations at scale. Purely accuracy- or profit-driven optimization can amplify disparities, imposing disproportionate burdens on vulnerable groups, and exposing organizations to legal and reputational risk. Fairness is therefore not merely a normative ideal. It is an operational requirement for responsible deployment and a critical pillar of ethical AI. Most existing work on algorithmic fairness has focused on supervised learning. In contrast, fairness in policy learning, where the goal is to maximize expected reward or social welfare, has received comparatively limited attention ( 29 ; 39 ; 43 ; 15 ; 45 ) . A key distinction is that policy learning is inherently interventional: a policy selects an action A , and that action alters subsequent outcomes. This leads to two conceptually distinct fairness targets. Action fairness concerns whether the policy treats individuals similarly in its action choices across sensitive groups (e.g., equalized treatment assignments). Outcome fairness instead asks whether the consequences (e.g., the benefits, welfare, or other fairness-relevant outcomes) induced by the policy are equitably distributed across groups. Importantly, equalizing actions does not, by itself, equalize outcomes when groups face different constraints, environments, or downstream responses to the same action. Consistent with this distinction, our analysis of a Belgian motor liability insurance dataset ( 13 ) show that standard policy optimization methods can induce substantial disparities in both action and outcome fairness (Table 1 in Section 6 ). This “action–outcome” gap arises naturally in practice. For instance, a government job training program might admit participants equally (action fair), unequal downstream constraints such as transportation access, caregiving burdens, or financial instability can still prevent some participants from completing the program or benefiting from it to the same extent. This could result in an inequitable final outcome (e.g., different job placement rates) even though the admission decision appears fair. In our analysis of such a training program in Section 6.2 , we found a stark example of this disparity: one demographic group had a nearly 20% lower probability of securing an internship than another. This underscores the importance of outcome-level fairness in decision-making. This work is also motivated by growing concerns about fairness in the insurance industry. Machine learning algorithms are increasingly used to automate risk assessment, pricing, and claims-related decisions, making trustworthy decision rules especially critical. For example, UnitedHealth has used the nH Predict platform ( 38 ) to assess patient risk and forecast outcomes in ways that inform coverage and pricing. While such tools can improve efficiency, they also raise concerns about algorithmic bias and discrimination against vulnerable populations. A recent class-action lawsuit alleges that the nH Predict algorithm was used to unlawfully deny or curtail rehabilitation care for seriously ill and elderly. 1 1 1 See the news report at Healthcare Finance News . The insurance context further illustrates why action fairness alone is it insufficient. In automobile insurance, a typical “action” is to classify a customer as low-risk vs. high-risk, which directly affects premiums. Action fairness focuses on whether similarly situated individuals across groups receive comparable risk labels and charged comparable premiums. However, even under perfect action fairness, two individuals with similar profiles receiving the same label and premium, their realized protection can still differ across groups. For example, claims may be approved at different rates, reimbursed differently, or processed with different delays across groups due to differences in documentation burdens, access to provider networks, or other downstream mechanisms. In such cases, the action is equal, but the policy-induced outcome, the expected net benefit or welfare a customer receives, remains unequal. Outcome fairness is designed to detect and mitigate precisely these disparities. These findings highlight the need to balance the decision maker’s value objectives with fair treatment across different groups. Motivated by these concerns, we propose a novel double fairness policy learning framework that jointly targets (a) action fairness; (b) outcome fairness; and (c) maximization of the overall value function. We refer to this integrated goal as double fairness learning (DFL). The DFL framework raises three central challenges. First, outcome fairness can only be controlled indirectly through the policy’s actions and the environment’s response: unlike action fairness, one cannot directly “intervene” on outcomes, so it is unclear when an outcome-fair (or doubly fair) policy exists at all. Second, the three objectives, action fairness, outcome fairness and value maximization, typically conflict, so it is rare for a single policy to optimize all three simultaneously. Hence, a principled framework is needed to characterize and manage these trade-offs, for which we adopt the concept of Pareto optimality. Third, computing the relevant Pareto fairness set is nontrivial in practice: standard linear scalarization approaches can miss Pareto-optimal solutions when the policy class is non-convex, as is typical for many policy parameterizations ( 33 ) . We address these challenges with a unified methodology and theory. We first provide a systematic analysis of when outcome-fair and doubly fair policies can be achieved, yielding interpretable conditions for feasibility. To manage trade-offs, we cast DFL as a multi-objective optimization problem ( 26 ) and target policies that are Pareto-efficient with respect to the two fairness criteria while achieving high value function. To compute Pareto solutions, we adopt a lexicographic weighted Tchebyshev scalarization strategy ( 37 ) , which can recover Pareto solutions without requiring convexity (see Figure 7 in Appendix). We then develop an estimator that embeds fairness objectives directly into the policy optimization procedure, establish regret bounds that provide rigorous performance guarantees under double fairness constraints. The proposed DFL framework is flexible and accommodates a broad range of fairness notions from the literature, making it applicable across domains where decisions have heterogeneous downstream

Read the complete text