Origin of the nucleon gravitational form factor B N ( t ) B_{N}(t)
Xianghui Cao, Bheemsehan Gurjar, Chandan Mondal, Chen Chen, Yang Li · 2026
Read Origin of the nucleon gravitational form factor B N ( t ) B_{N}(t) by Xianghui Cao, Bheemsehan Gurjar, Chandan Mondal, Chen Chen, Yang Li (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-19141.txt.
Introduction
Xianghui Cao and four co-authors ask why one of the nucleon's gravity related numbers stays so small. Recent simulations and models agree that this form factor stays tiny even when momentum is passed to the nucleon. Its value at zero momentum must vanish, a fact tied to the equivalence principle, but the smallness elsewhere lacks a clear cause.
The team traces the physical origin of that suppression. Form factors encode how a particle's charge, magnetism, and mass are spread inside it. Explaining a stubborn zero like this one sharpens the theory of how quarks and gluons build the mass of everyday matter.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Xianghui Cao, Bheemsehan Gurjar, Chandan Mondal, Chen Chen, Yang Li |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 21 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-19141
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Origin of the nucleon gravitational form factor B N ( t ) B_{N}(t) Preprint: USTC-ICTS/PCFT-26-05 Xianghui Cao, Bheemsehan Gurjar, Chandan Mondal, Chen Chen, Yang Li Abstract Recent lattice QCD simulations and phenomenological models indicate that the nucleon’s gravitational form factor B N ( t ) B_{N}(t) remains remarkably small at finite momentum transfer t t . While B N ( 0 ) = 0 B_{N}(0)=0 is a known consequence of the equivalence principle, the physical origin of its suppression at finite t t has not been fully elucidated. In this work, we demonstrate that the smallness of B N ( t ) B_{N}(t) arises from a fundamental cancellation within the nucleon’s wave functions. Using light-front holographic QCD, we show that B N ( t ) B_{N}(t) is governed by an antisymmetric factor in the longitudinal dynamics that leads to an exact vanishing in the symmetric limit and significant suppression for realistic nucleon structures. Our results suggest that the smallness of B N ( t ) B_{N}(t) is a signature of the nucleon’s dominant S-wave character, providing a formal justification for its frequent omission in practical applications like near-threshold J / ψ J/\psi production. Gravitational form factors (GFFs) characterize the distribution of energy, spin, and pressure within the nucleon. They are defined via the hadron matrix element of the energy-momentum tensor, T^{\mu\nu} Kobzarev:1962wt ; Pagels:1966zza : \langle p^{\prime},\sigma^{\prime}|T^{\mu\nu}(0)|p,\sigma\rangle=\bar{u}_{\sigma^{\prime}}(p^{\prime})\Big[A(t)\gamma^{\{\mu}P^{\nu\}}\\ +B(t)\frac{iP^{\{\mu}\sigma^{\nu\}\rho}q_{\rho}}{2M}+D(t)\frac{q^{\mu}q^{\nu}-g^{\mu\nu}q^{2}}{4M}\Big]u_{\sigma}(p), (1) where P=(p+p^{\prime})/2 , q=p^{\prime}-p , and t=q^{2} , a^{\{\mu}b^{\nu\}}=(a^{\mu}b^{\nu}+a^{\nu}b^{\mu})/2 . Here, A(t) , B(t) , and D(t) represent the three fundamental GFFs of the nucleon. Often, the form factor J(t)=[A(t)+B(t)]/2 is adopted in the literature. Consequently, investigating their properties is essential to unraveling the internal structure of the primary building blocks of matter. While the existing literature focuses predominantly on the GFFs A(t) and D(t) , discussions regarding B(t) remain relatively scarce Teryaev:1999su ; Polyakov:2018zvc ; Burkert:2023wzr . This observable is intimately linked to the nucleon’s spin structure; specifically, B(0) corresponds to the anomalous gravitomagnetic moment (AGM). The equivalence principle (EP) requires that B(0)=0 Teryaev:1999su , a result proven in light-front QCD Brodsky:2000ii and supported by lattice simulations Deka:2013zha ; Hackett:2023rif and model-based computations Cebulla:2007ei ; Goeke:2007fp ; Goeke:2007fq ; Neubelt:2019sou ; Azizi:2019ytx ; Anikin:2019kwi ; Chakrabarti:2020kdc ; Fujita:2022jus ; Nair:2024fit ; Yao:2024ixu ; Nair:2025sfr . The vanishing of B(0) is consistent with the tensor meson dominance in \pi N scattering Renner:1970sbf ; Jones:1971am . Furthermore, recent lattice QCD simulations suggest that the nucleon GFF B_{N}(t) remains consistent with zero even at finite t , within current simulation uncertainties Deka:2013zha ; Hackett:2023rif . Although some dispersion relation analyses based on lattice data suggest a non-vanishing B_{N}(t) as shown in Fig. 1 Cao:2024zlf ; Broniowski:2025ctl ; Cao:2025dkv , the extracted values are sufficiently small that they are often neglected in practical applications, such as predicting near-threshold J/\psi photoproduction Hatta:2018ina ; Mamo:2019mka ; Hatta:2019lxo ; Guo:2021ibg ; Mamo:2021krl ; Duran:2022xag ; Guo:2024wxy ; Guo:2025jiz ; Meziani:2025dwu ; Guo:2025muf . Regardless, the persistent smallness of B_{N}(t) across different scales warrants a formal explanation. Figure 1: The gravitational form factor B_{N}(t) of the nucleon obtained from lattice QCD (dots, Hackett:2023rif ), dispersion relation and VMD analyses based on the lattice data (bands, Cao:2024zlf ; Broniowski:2025ctl ; Cao:2025dkv ), as well as two theoretical models, LFHQCD (solid line, see texts) and DSEs (dot-dash lines, Yao:2024ixu ). One plausible explanation for the smallness of B_{N}(t) is flavor cancellation Teryaev:1998iw . Within the framework of generalized parton distributions (GPDs), the GFF B_{N}(t) is identified as the second Mellin moment of the GPD E(x,\xi,t) : B_{q,g}(t)=\int{\mathrm{d}}x\,xE_{q,g}(x,\xi,t), (2) where x is the longitudinal momentum fraction of the struck parton and \xi is the skewness variable. In the proton, the GPDs E_{u} and E_{d} possess opposite signs. This is evident from their first Mellin moments at the forward limit ( t=0 ), which correspond to the flavor-contributions to the anomalous magnetic moment: \begin{split}\kappa_{u}=\,&\int{\mathrm{d}}xE_{u}(x,0,0)\approx+1.67,\\ \kappa_{d}=\,&\int{\mathrm{d}}xE_{d}(x,0,0)\approx-2.03.\end{split} (3) The numerical values above are representative estimates from the constituent quark model. Unlike the Pauli form factor F_{2}(t) , which is defined by the first Mellin moment of E weighted by the electric charges of the quarks, the GFF B_{N}(t) is weighted by the momentum fraction x . Because E_{u} and E_{d} maintain their opposite signs across the x -distribution, a significant cancellation occurs between the u and d quark contributions. A simple non-relativistic quark model estimate yields: \begin{split}B_{N}(0)\approx B_{u}(0)+B_{d}(0)\approx\,&\frac{2}{3}\kappa_{u}+\frac{1}{3}\kappa_{d}\approx 0.44.\\ \end{split} (4) While this simple estimate suggests a non-vanishing value, the result can be further refined. For instance, the MIT Bag Model predicts a vanishing AGM ( B_{N}(0)=0 ) in the static limit Ji:1997gm . While relativistic corrections generally reintroduce a non-vanishing AGM, it has been shown that B_{N}(t) vanishes in the large- N_{c} limit Neubelt:2019sou . Finally, a complete description must account for the gluon contribution. At t=0 , B_{g}(0) is conjectured to vanish based on an extended EP Teryaev:1998iw ; Teryaev:1999su . The suppression of B_{N}(t) can be further understood through the fundamental symmetries governing graviton interactions. Within the Dyson-Schwinger equations (DSEs) framework, B_{N}(t) is found to be vanishingly small, strictly obeying the constraint B_{N}(0)=0 Yao:2024ixu . This result is primarily driven by the symmetry of the graviton-quark vertex, which is rigorously enforced by Ward-Takahashi identities derived from the EP Brout:1966oea . Complementary insights are provided by holographic QCD, which models hadron-graviton interactions within a 5D warped geometry Polchinski:2001tt ; Abidin:2009hr ; Hatta:2018ina ; Mamo:2019mka ; Fujita:2022jus ; Fujii:2024rqd ; Mamedov:2024tth ; Deng:2025fpq ; Liu:2025vfe ; Nascimento:2025ryr ; Fujii:2025eug ; Nascimento:2025smf ; Liu:2025qja ; Hippelainen:2026izm . In this framework, GFFs are computed via the scattering of a bulk graviton off a nucleon field in Anti-de Sitter (AdS) space. Notably, in models employing minimal gravitational coupling, B_{N}(t) vanishes identically across all momentum transfers Abidin:2009hr . This result is fundamentally rooted in the fact that the minimal interaction vertex in the 5D bulk conserves helicity in the massless limit. Since the form factor B(t) is the gravitational analog of the Pauli form factor F_{2}(t) and specifically corresponds to a helicity-flip transition, the absence of a helicity-flipping mechanism in the minimal coupling scheme leads to its vanishing. Consequently, any non-zero value for B_{N}(t) would require the introduction of non-minimal coupling terms, such as higher-derivative Pauli-type interactions in the 5D action. The empirical observation that B_{N}(t) is nearly zero suggests that the nucleon’s interaction with gravity is dominated by these minimal, helicity-conserving holographic processes. A closely related approach is light-front holographic QCD (LFHQCD), which establishes a mapping between the holographic description in 5D AdS space and light-front QCD deTeramond:2014asa ; Dosch:2015nwa (see Ref. Brodsky:2014yha for a review). Within this framework, the AGM B_{N}(0) vanishes identically for each individual Fock sector, a result fundamentally ensured by the underlying light-front dynamics. The GFF B_{N}(t) at finite t also vanishes in this approach, as directly implied by the holographic correspondence. However, it is important to note that for theories other than QCD, the GFF B(t) is not required to be zero Brodsky:2000ii ; Burkert:2023wzr . By performing a comparative analysis of the light-front wave functions (LFWFs) across different theoretical frameworks, we can gain deeper insight into the specific underlying dynamics that suppress B_{N}(t) for the nucleon. This suggests that the smallness of this observable