An alternative approach to several important systems in classical mechanics: energy factorization
Karlo Lelas, Dario Jukić · 2026
Read An alternative approach to several important systems in classical mechanics: energy factorization by Karlo Lelas, Dario Jukić (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-18957.txt.
Introduction
Karlo Lelas and Dario Jukić solve classic mechanics problems by a fresh route: splitting total energy into factors. They use complex numbers to factor the energy of systems whose potential energy stays positive. From that one start, they reach exact answers for several well known problems.
The list covers the simple harmonic oscillator and a projectile thrown straight up. It also covers motion under a repulsive inverse cube force and a damped oscillator with linear drag. A single energy trick that solves all four gives students and teachers a new lens on old textbook ground.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Karlo Lelas, Dario Jukić |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 30 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-18957
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
An alternative approach to several important systems in classical mechanics: energy factorization Karlo Lelas, Dario Jukić Abstract We show how several important classical problems, with positive definite potential energy, can be solved by starting from the factorization of the total mechanical energy using complex numbers. In particular, we derive in a new way exact analytical solutions for: simple harmonic oscillator, vertical projectile motion, motion under a repulsive inverse cube force, and damped harmonic oscillator (with linear damping). We also show how this approach easily yields an excellent approximation of the energy decay and a new approximate analytical solution in the case of a weakly damped harmonic oscillator. Our derivations are suitable for undergraduate physics teaching as an alternative to solving Newton’s equations of motion. In addition, we comment on the limitations of our approach, but also on the insights it provides and opportunities for further research. I Introduction In typical undergraduate physics textbooks 3 ; 19 ; 8 , even the solution of a simple harmonic oscillator is not derived by solving Newton’s equation of motion, but rather by considering the connection of harmonic oscillations with uniform circular motion. The situation is even worse with a damped harmonic oscillator, for which solutions are typically presented without any derivation 3 ; 19 ; 8 . The reason for this is that Newton’s equation of motion is a second-order differential equation, which is mathematically demanding for first-year undergraduates to solve. Therefore, alternative approaches are needed that lead to exact solutions for these and other interesting systems, using simpler mathematics. The aim of this paper is to offer a new approach to the analysis of the dynamics of several important classical systems, based on physics and mathematics that are well understood by first-year undergraduates. If we consider one-dimensional dynamics (i.e. motion along the x -axis only) of mass m under the influence of conservative forces, the law of conservation of total mechanical energy is given by 19 \frac{mv^{2}}{2}+U(x)=E\,, (1) where v=dx/dt is the velocity. The first term in ( 1 ) is the kinetic energy, and U(x) is the potential energy corresponding to the conservative force F(x)=-dU(x)/dx . For conservative forces, equation ( 1 ) can be derived without knowing the explicit form of functions x(t) and v(t) , i.e. on general grounds, using the work-energy theorem 19 . Here we analyze the dynamics in several important cases with positive-definite potential energy, i.e. with U(x)\geq 0 , and the starting point of our analysis is equation ( 1 ). In that case, we can factor ( 1 ) as \left(\sqrt{\frac{m}{2}}v+i\sqrt{U(x)}\right)\left(\sqrt{\frac{m}{2}}v-i\sqrt{U(x)}\right)=E\,, (2) where i=\sqrt{-1} . The expressions in parentheses are complex conjugates. Therefore, the expression in the first parentheses can be written as \sqrt{\frac{m}{2}}v(t)+i\sqrt{U(x(t))}=\sqrt{E}\,e^{i\phi(t)}\,, (3) and the expression in the second parentheses as \sqrt{\frac{m}{2}}v(t)-i\sqrt{U(x(t))}=\sqrt{E}\,e^{-i\phi(t)}\,, (4) where we emphasized that position and velocity depend on time, and introduced an unknown function \phi(t) , i.e. the time-dependent phase. Since e^{\pm i\phi(t)}=\cos\phi(t)\pm i\sin\phi(t) , by adding equations ( 3 ) and ( 4 ) we easily get v(t)=\sqrt{\frac{2E}{m}}\cos\phi(t)\,, (5) and by subtracting them we get \sqrt{U(x(t))}=\sqrt{E}\sin\phi(t)\,. (6) Equations ( 5 ) and ( 6 ) are the cornerstones of our approach. In what follows, we use them to determine x(t) for several fundamental systems in classical physics. We note here that similar approaches have already been introduced in the context of harmonic oscillators 5 ; 16 ; 17 , but none of them start from factorization of total mechanical energy using basic knowledge of complex numbers. For example, in a recent paper 17 , the starting point is a system of coupled first-order differential equations for position and momentum. The equations are then decoupled by introducing a new function which is a linear combination of position and momentum with complex coefficients. Thus, the process of decoupling the equations led to the introduction of complex numbers. After solving the uncoupled equations for the new function and its complex conjugate, linear combinations of the new function and its complex conjugate were used to obtain solutions for position and momentum as functions of time, and it was subsequently shown that the energy of the simple harmonic oscillator is conserved 17 . Our starting point is more natural and easier to understand. In particular, in the case of a simple harmonic oscillator (or any other conservative system), it is easy to show that energy is conserved, without knowing how position and velocity (momentum) depend on time, and therefore our starting point is equation ( 1 ). The steps from ( 1 ) to the equations ( 5 ) and ( 6 ) are straightforward and easy to understand, since anyone with elementary knowledge of complex numbers knows that a+b , where a\geq 0 and b\geq 0 , can be written as (\sqrt{a}+i\sqrt{b})(\sqrt{a}-i\sqrt{b}) and that complex conjugates have the same modulus but differ in the sign of the phase. II Simple harmonic oscillator In the case of potential energy U(x)=k\,x^{2}/2 , i.e. the case with the force F(x)=-kx , equation ( 6 ) becomes x(t)=\sqrt{\frac{2E}{k}}\sin\phi(t)\,. (7) The first derivative of ( 7 ) with respect to time is \frac{dx(t)}{dt}=\sqrt{\frac{2E}{k}}\left(\frac{d\phi(t)}{dt}\right)\cos\phi(t)\,. (8) The unknown function \phi(t) must be such that ( 8 ) corresponds to the velocity ( 5 ), i.e. if we equate the right hand sides of ( 8 ) and ( 5 ) we get \frac{d\phi(t)}{dt}=\sqrt{\frac{k}{m}}\,. (9) Thus, we get a simple first order differential equation which can be solved using the separation of variables method, i.e. by solving the integral \int_{\phi(0)}^{\phi(t)}d\phi(t^{\prime})=\omega_{0}\int_{0}^{t}dt^{\prime}\,, where we introduced the standard notation \omega_{0}=\sqrt{k/m} . Of course, even without knowing integral calculus, it is easy to argue using only elementary knowledge about the first derivatives that the solution to equation ( 9 ) is \phi(t)=\omega_{0}t+\phi_{0}\,, (10) where \phi_{0}=\phi(0) is the initial phase. Thus, in the case of simple harmonic oscillator the solution is x(t)=\sqrt{\frac{2E}{k}}\sin\left(\omega_{0}t+\phi_{0}\right)\,. (11) The amplitude \sqrt{2E/k} and the initial phase are easily obtained from initial conditions x(0)=x_{0} and v(0)=v_{0} . For example, if the dynamics starts with the initial conditions x_{0}>0 and v_{0}=0 , we have E=kx_{0}^{2}/2 and \phi_{0}=\pi/2 , and ( 11 ) becomes x(t)=x_{0}\cos(\omega_{0}t) . III Homogeneous gravitational potential energy In the case of potential energy U(x)=mgx , where we take x=0 as the reference level, and that the positive direction of the x -axis is upwards, the equation ( 6 ) becomes x(t)=\frac{E}{mg}\sin^{2}\phi(t)\,. (12) We can solve this case even more simply than the harmonic oscillator. Namely, since the associated conservative force is of constant magnitude, i.e. F(x)=-mg , we know that this is a motion with constant acceleration a=-g . Therefore, the instantaneous and average accelerations are equal, i.e. dv(t)/dt=\Delta v/\Delta t=-g , where \Delta v=v(t)-v_{0} , \Delta t=t , and v_{0} is the initial velocity (along the x -axis). Thus, one can easily conclude, using only basic definitions of instantaneous and average accelerations 19 , that the instantaneous velocity is given by v(t)=v_{0}-gt\,. (13) If we equate the right hand sides of ( 5 ) and ( 13 ) we get \cos\phi(t)=\sqrt{\frac{m}{2E}}\left(v_{0}-gt\right)\,. (14) If we use ( 14 ) and identity \sin^{2}\phi(t)=1-\cos^{2}\phi(t) in ( 12 ) we easily get x(t)=\frac{E}{mg}-\frac{1}{2g}\left(v_{0}-gt\right)^{2}\,. (15) If we take, e.g., initial conditions x_{0}=h and v_{0}>0 , i.e. E=mgh+mv_{0}^{2}/2 , ( 15 ) becomes x(t)=h+v_{0}t-\frac{g}{2}t^{2}\,,