Learning the Pareto Space of Multi-Objective Autonomous Driving: A Modular, Data-Driven Approach
Mohammad Elayan, Wissam Kontar ∗ · 2026
Read Learning the Pareto Space of Multi-Objective Autonomous Driving: A Modular, Data-Driven Approach by Mohammad Elayan, Wissam Kontar ∗ (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-18913.txt.
Introduction
Mohammad Elayan and Wissam Kontar learn the trade-offs of self-drive cars straight from real road data. A self-drive car must weigh three aims at once. It must stay safe, it must not waste time, and it must deal well with the cars and folk near it. A gain in one aim can cost in the next. Past work set those weights by hand or by a plan, not by how cars truly drive.
The team score each tick of real drives on all three aims. Those scores chart the space of trades that real drives make. A car can then be set to a point in that space by choice, with eyes open. The chart is built in parts, so each aim's score can be checked on its own. Such a chart could help firms set drive style with care.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Mohammad Elayan, Wissam Kontar ∗ |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 23 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-18913
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Learning the Pareto Space of Multi-Objective Autonomous Driving: A Modular, Data-Driven Approach Mohammad Elayan, Wissam Kontar ∗ Abstract Balancing safety, efficiency, and interaction is fundamental to designing autonomous driving agents and to understanding autonomous vehicle (AV) behavior in real-world operation. This study introduces an empirical learning framework that derives these trade-offs directly from naturalistic trajectory data. A unified objective space represents each AV timestep through composite scores of safety, efficiency, and interaction. Pareto dominance is applied to identify non-dominated states, forming an empirical frontier that defines the attainable region of balanced performance. The proposed framework was demonstrated using the Third Generation Simulation (TGSIM) datasets from Foggy Bottom and I-395. Results showed that only 0.23% of AV driving instances were Pareto-optimal, underscoring the rarity of simultaneous optimization across objectives. Pareto-optimal states showed notably higher mean scores for safety, efficiency, and interaction compared to non-optimal cases, with interaction showing the greatest potential for improvement. This minimally invasive and modular framework, which requires only kinematic and positional data, can be directly applied beyond the scope of this study to derive and visualize multi-objective learning surfaces. Full reproducibility is supported via our open-source codebase on GitHub . I Introduction Automated driving systems are steadily transitioning from experimental deployments to complex, mixed-traffic environments. Yet, the behavioral footprint of these vehicles remains only partially understood. Global research on autonomous driving is increasingly moving toward the development of driving agents that learn and adapt through multi-objective reasoning. These consensus-driven agents aim to balance performance dimensions rather than optimize a single goal, which marks a shift toward socially aware, context-adaptive autonomy. Achieving such balance is central to creating driving agents that integrate smoothly within human-dominated traffic systems. Human drivers continuously navigate competing objectives, such as maintaining safety margins without impeding flow or signaling intent through subtle motion cues. AVs, by contrast, rely on a mix of rule-based and learned control policies that integrate perception, planning, and decision-making. While these systems achieve consistent and safe operation, their design constraints and conservative tuning can limit efficiency or interaction fluidity. As AV deployment expands, understanding this multi-objective balance is essential for defining the attainable space of context-sensitive, high-performance operation, rather than raking AVs by a single score. This study introduces an empirical learning framework that derives multi-objective trade-offs directly from naturalistic trajectory data. Our method was tested on the Third Generation Simulation (TGSIM) data, which capture diverse urban driving contexts and mixed traffic interactions. A unified objective space across safety, efficiency, and interaction represents each AV driving instance as a point within a behavioral landscape, from which the Pareto-optimal frontier is learned using Gaussian Process Regression (GPR). The resulting surface captures the continuous structure of optimal trade-offs while suppressing noise and segmentation artifacts. Learning the Pareto space means identifying behavioral states where improving one objective (safety, efficiency, or interaction) necessarily reduces another. It represents a continuous surface of optimal trade-offs derived from real-world data, forming the basis for learning balanced and adaptive autonomous driving. The framework situates empirical behavior within the broader pursuit of adaptive, learning-based driving agents. Beyond evaluation, it provides a transferable foundation for multi-objective learning and control (Figure 1 . Its modular structure, built on basic positional and kinematic inputs and requiring no specialized instrumentation, can be applied to any trajectory dataset or metric formulation. It connects empirical observation with prescriptive modeling, bridging naturalistic data and the design of consensus-driven autonomous systems. Fig. 1 : Conceptual overview of the overarching framework linking empirical data to learning-based control. II Literature Review AVs display behavior that diverges systematically from that of human-driven vehicles (HDVs). Empirical studies consistently show that AVs maintain wider spatial buffers and higher values of surrogate safety indicators such as time-to-collision (TTC) and post-encroachment time (PET), signaling a cautious, safety-prioritized control logic [ 23 , 37 , 7 ] . Yet, traditional surrogate safety measures (SSMs) like TTC and PET, which were developed around human perceptual and reaction constraints, are not directly transferable to mixed-traffic environments. These metrics overlook the low-latency perception–response loops and rule-based decision layers characteristic of AV systems [ 27 , 35 ] . Consequently, short TTC values may not necessarily imply risk in automated contexts, while PET thresholds can mischaracterize the outcome of negotiated or non-conflict interactions [ 32 ] . Beyond safety, AV operation influences broader traffic dynamics. Controlled experiments and field data reveal that AV-led platoons can suppress oscillations and improve local stability [ 17 , 8 ] . However, under heterogeneous conditions, cautious accelerations and large headways may reduce overall throughput [ 3 , 13 ] . Recent studies also highlight AVs’ lack of visual and social cues compared to HDVs, which can affect pedestrian trust and increase gap acceptance times [ 9 , 14 ] . Recent research trends move toward such integrated evaluation. Composite indicators like SAFR-AV and risk factor scores attempt to encapsulate safety and interaction jointly [ 22 , 32 ] , while Pareto-based modeling in simulation studies has illuminated recurring trade-offs among comfort, efficiency, and safety [ 21 , 20 , 15 ] . Parallel algorithmic literature frames these trade-offs explicitly as multi-objective optimization or reinforcement learning (RL) tasks, enabling agents to negotiate among competing goals via constrained or Pareto-based reward formulations [ 34 , 33 ] . Advances in multi-agent and consensus-oriented RL further demonstrate that cooperative adaptation among AVs can enhance both safety and stability at the network scale [ 30 , 12 ] . Despite advances in AV research, empirical understanding of how these systems manage multi-objective trade-offs in real traffic remains limited. Most prior studies rely on simulations or theoretical control models. This study constructs an empirical Pareto frontier directly from observed trajectories, evaluating AV behavior across safety (via GSSM), interaction, and efficiency. The framework quantifies how real-world driving aligns with optimal balance and provides a basis for benchmarking behavioral consensus and informing next-generation AV decision design. III Dataset Description This study uses two high-resolution trajectory datasets from the Third Generation Simulation (TGSIM) project—Foggy Bottom and I-395, collected by the U.S. Department of Transportation’s Intelligent Transportation Systems Joint Program Office and released in January 2025 [ 28 ] [ 29 ] . The Foggy Bottom dataset captures trajectories at four urban intersections in Washington, D.C. It includes pedestrians, cyclists, scooters, passenger cars, trucks, buses, and SAE Level 3 AVs . AVs completed four consecutive left turns, providing a consistent basis for assessing performance in dense traffic. The I-395 dataset covers a 0.5 km freeway segment in Washington, D.C. It includes a major on-ramp and off-ramp, capturing frequent merges and lane-keeping by passenger cars, trucks, buses, and 21 SAE Level 2 AVs operating exclusively in one lane. Each record includes timestamped positions, lane IDs, dimensions, and kinematics. For both datasets, pixel coordinates were transformed to a meter-scale frame with the origin at the lower-left reference corner. Kinematic variables were smoothed with Gaussian filters to preserve transient events such as braking and turning. All behavioral metrics were derived from the filtered x–y components for consistency. The full preprocessing workflow is publicly available at our GitHub repository . IV Methodology In this section, we present the methodological framework used to analyze AV behavior and construct the Pareto frontier. IV-A Identifying Detected Agents Tesla’s camera-based