Evidence for a Peak at ∼ \sim 0.3 in the Eccentricity Distribution of Typical Super-Jovian Exoplanets numpy ( 28 ) , pandas ( 46 ) , matplotlib ( 31 ) , corner ( 21 ) , scipy ( 66 ) , astropy ( 5 , 3 , 4 ), radvel ( 23 )

Sarah Blunt, Jason Wang, Ruth Murray-Clay, Bruce Macintosh, Ryan A. Rubenzahl, B.J. Fulton · 2026

Read Evidence for a Peak at ∼ \sim 0.3 in the Eccentricity Distribution of Typical Super-Jovian Exoplanets numpy ( 28 ) , pandas ( 46 ) , matplotlib ( 31 ) , corner ( 21 ) , scipy ( 66 ) , astropy ( 5 , 3 , 4 ), radvel ( 23 ) by Sarah Blunt, Jason Wang, Ruth Murray-Clay, Bruce Macintosh, Ryan A. Rubenzahl, B.J. Fulton (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-18877.txt.

Introduction

Sarah Blunt and five colleagues chart how the tilt of the paths of big far worlds spreads. Each such world runs on a path that is more or less stretched, from a round ring to a long loop. The shape of that spread holds clues to how the worlds were born and how they were stirred since. The team use a clean set of finds made by one long hunt that read the wobble of stars.

They fix the counts for the worlds the hunt would miss, so the spread is fair. They work out how oft big worlds show at each mass, span, and path stretch. The counts rise with span for both light and heavy big worlds, out to a wide span. In that fair set they find a bump in path stretch at a set mark for the heaviest worlds.

Catalog record

CREATORSarah Blunt, Jason Wang, Ruth Murray-Clay, Bruce Macintosh, Ryan A. Rubenzahl, B.J. Fulton
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE66 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-18877

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Evidence for a Peak at ∼ \sim 0.3 in the Eccentricity Distribution of Typical Super-Jovian Exoplanets numpy ( 28 ) , pandas ( 46 ) , matplotlib ( 31 ) , corner ( 21 ) , scipy ( 66 ) , astropy ( 5 , 3 , 4 ), radvel ( 23 ) Sarah Blunt, Jason Wang, Ruth Murray-Clay, Bruce Macintosh, Ryan A. Rubenzahl, B.J. Fulton Abstract In this study, we compute completeness-corrected occurrence rates of giant exoplanets as a function of mass, semimajor axis, and eccentricity, using the approximately uniform California Legacy Survey sample of RV-discovered planets published in 58 . We recover the previously-detected rise in occurrence with semimajor axis for both lower- and higher-mass subsets of the population out to ∼ \sim 5 au. When restricting to planets with semimajor axes between 0.1 and 4.5 au (roughly speaking, the “peak” of giant planet occurrence), we find evidence for distinct eccentricity distributions for each of two mass sub-populations. Most strikingly, we observe a peak in the eccentricity distribution of super-Jovian planets (3-20 M J ) at 0.3, which is apparent using two different parameterizations of the eccentricity distribution model. A hierarchical histogram model reveals that ∼ \sim 92% of posterior samples indicate an elevated occurrence rate of super-Jupiters with modest eccentricities (0.2–0.4) compared to lower or higher eccentricities (i.e. evidence for a moderate eccentricity “peak”), and 99% of samples indicate super-Jupiters with modest eccentricities are more common than those with lower eccentricities (i.e. evidence that moderate eccentricities are more common than low eccentricities). We use a truncated Gaussian model fit to pinpoint the location of the super-Jupiter eccentricity peak with more precision, finding a maximum a posterior (MAP) peak location of e = 0.3 e=0.3 . This low but elevated characteristic eccentricity could be the result of dynamically hot histories, perhaps involving a giant impacts phase. All analysis code for this project is publicly available on Zenodo ( https://zenodo.org/records/18089157 (catalog doi 18089157) ) and GitHub: github.com/sblunt/eccentricities . show][email protected] I Introduction The orbits of planets, particularly orbital eccentricities, encode information about their formation and subsequent dynamical histories. Over the past 30 years of exoplanet science, this fact has enabled us to shed light on how planets form and evolve. The overall eccentricity distribution of exoplanets discovered with the radial velocity (RV) method is consistent with a beta distribution peaking at e=0 ( 35 ) . This is generally interpreted as evidence that exoplanets form via core accretion (which produces circular orbits), with the “dynamical tail” out to higher eccentricities resulting from a zoo of potential dynamical processes: planet-planet scattering ( 57 , 10 , 34 , 45 ), secular interactions with outer planets or stellar companions ( 18 , 52 ), excitation due to stellar fly-bys ( 13 ) , and planet-disk interactions ( 56 ) . Overall, in the mid-2010s, all evidence pointed to most planets being on circular orbits; while eccentric planets were known to exist, they were thought to be the exception to the rule. Over the past few years, exoplanet science have begun to study orbital eccentricities in different regimes, pointing to a slightly more complicated story than vanilla core accretion and occasional dynamical excitation. At the low mass extreme, 25 recently showed that for small (0.5-15 R ⊕ ) transiting planets, average eccentricity increases with mass, with 16 M ⊕ objects achieving an average eccentricity of \sim 0.2. At the high mass extreme, 9 identified a broad distribution of eccentricities for imaged brown-dwarf mass objects which resembles that of stellar binaries at similar separations (see, e.g. 32 ) more than that of planets discovered with RVs or imaging. This result was corroborated by 50 and 15 (although the latter point out that the distinctness of the two distributions depends on the mass boundary). The elevated eccentricities of high-mass imaged brown dwarfs was interpreted by 9 as evidence for different formation mechanisms, with planets forming via core accretion and brown dwarfs via dynamically “hotter” process such as gravitational collapse. In this study, we characterize the population-level eccentricity distribution of “typical” giant planets, defined as planets 175-6000 M ⊕ located at the “peak” of giant planet occurrence ( \sim 0.1-4.6 au; 24 ). The eccentricity distribution of this population has historically been difficult to understand; at such separations, transit probabilities are small, and RV discoveries require long baselines (generally at least one orbital period, although not always; see e.g., 8 ). In addition, direct imaging has historically been limited to wider-separation giants (although the advent of interferometric detection is changing this; see 69 and 29 ). Microlensing, which is undeniably useful for determining occurrence rate statistics ( 48 ), is incapable of measuring exoplanet eccentricities. As long-baseline RV surveys ( 58 , 71 ) mature, uniform samples of RV-derived giant planet eccentricities at the peak of occurrence are available for the first time. In this Letter, inspired by trends first identified by 22 , we take advantage of the recent public release of the California Legacy Survey (CLS; 58 ) to derive completeness-corrected occurrence rates as a function of eccentricity, semimajor axis, and mass. 68 recently pointed out, using exoplanet eccentricity measurements downloaded from the NASA Exoplanet Archive, a peak in the eccentricity distribution of super-Jupiter planets similar to the result we ultimately derive here. Our objective in this paper is to evaluate the significance of this peak, taking into account survey sensitivity, Poisson statistics, and other potential statistical biases. We ultimately corroborate their observation of the peak, and ask that future works cite their paper alongside this work when referencing the super-Jupiter eccentricity peak. II Method II.1 Method in Theory: a Hierarchical Histogram Our method expands on a formalism originally developed by 30 and 20 , and recently applied by 24 and 25 (among others). In Appendix A , we present our method in detail. For casual readers, the method can be understood as making a 3-dimensional histogram of planets in (e, a , M). This histogram, however, is special because: 1) it corrects for non-uniform survey sensitivity (“completeness”), 2) it takes into account uncertainties in individual planets’ posteriors on (e, a , M) that make their “bin identity” uncertain, 3) it accounts for counting statistics uncertainties by treating the entire observed sample as a realization of a Poisson distribution, and 4) it marginalizes over the uncertainties in inclination at a population level, allowing us to calculate occurrence rates in (e, a , M), even though RV measurements can only constrain (e, a , M \sin{i} ). II.2 Method in Practice We used the publicly available California Legacy Survey (CLS) sample ( 58 ) planets as an approximately uniform, uninformed long-baseline ( >10 year) sample of FGK stars to search for companions. Section 2 of ( 58 ) describes the sample selection in detail, including observing strategy and stellar sample characteristics. Figure 2 of that paper shows the distribution of RV baselines in the sample. The CLS survey observed 719 stars over a median RV baseline of 21 yrs, each star for a median of 71 observations. Sample selection was performed so as not to bias the survey toward or away from detecting companions (e.g. stellar metallically was purposefully not factored into sample selection, and

Read the complete text