Experimental Demonstration of Commutation Relations Using Intensity Correlations

Hans Dang, Sebastian Luff, Martin Fischer, Markus Sondermann, Mojdeh. S. Najafabadi, Luis L. Sánchez-Soto, Gerd Leuchs · 2026

Read Experimental Demonstration of Commutation Relations Using Intensity Correlations by Hans Dang, Sebastian Luff, Martin Fischer, Markus Sondermann, Mojdeh. S. Najafabadi, Luis L. Sánchez-Soto, Gerd Leuchs (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-18870.txt.

Introduction

Hans Dang and six colleagues show by a lab test a core rule of quantum theory that had not been shown head on till now. The rule sets how two traits of a light field trade: to read one trait shifts the next by a set sum. That rule sits at the root of the famed cap on how sharp both traits can be known at once. Past tests checked the cap, not the rule at its root.

The team read the rule from two kinds of joint count on the light field. Each count is a chart of how oft two reads land as a pair. The two charts, set side by side, give the rule's sum with no room for doubt. A head-on show of such a root rule is a rare gain. It firms the base on which much of light-based quantum work stands.

Catalog record

CREATORHans Dang, Sebastian Luff, Martin Fischer, Markus Sondermann, Mojdeh. S. Najafabadi, Luis L. Sánchez-Soto, Gerd Leuchs
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE24 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-18870

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Experimental Demonstration of Commutation Relations Using Intensity Correlations Hans Dang, Sebastian Luff, Martin Fischer, Markus Sondermann, Mojdeh. S. Najafabadi, Luis L. Sánchez-Soto, Gerd Leuchs Abstract The canonical commutation relation is a cornerstone of quantum theory and underlies the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. Although uncertainty relations have been extensively tested, direct verifications of the underlying commutation relation itself have remained elusive. We report an experimental demonstration of the bosonic commutation relation for optical field operators based on measurements of two distinct intensity correlation functions. From these measurements, we extract the expectation value of the field-operator commutator for both a single-photon state and coherent state. In both cases, the measured values are consistent with unity, in quantitative agreement with quantum theory. Introduction.— Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle, whether framed in terms of indeterminacy Heisenberg 1927 or complementarity Bohr 1928 , is rooted in a fundamental feature of quantum mechanics: the noncommutativity of operators associated with complementary observables. In stark contrast to classical intuition, this principle asserts that certain pairs of physical properties, such as position and momentum or wavelike and particlelike behavior, cannot be simultaneously specified with arbitrary precision in the same experiment. This inherent uncertainty is not a limitation of measurement, but a fundamental property of nature itself. Although the uncertainty principle has been rigorously tested across a wide range of physical systems, direct experimental access to the commutation relations that underpin it remains elusive. This difficulty arises because noncommuting observables do not admit a joint probability distribution, and their product is generally non-Hermitian, precluding straightforward measurement. To date, experimental demonstrations have been largely confined to finite-dimensional qubit systems Hasegawa et al. 1997 ; Wagh et al. 1997 ; Kim et al. 2010 ; Yao et al. 2010 ; Wagner et al. 2021 . In the continuous-variable domain, the canonical commutation relation between position and momentum—or, equivalently, between bosonic creation and annihilation operators—has been explored indirectly via sequential single-photon addition and subtraction from an optical field Zavatta et al. 2004 ; Zavatta et al. 2009 . We address this question from a different perspective by exploiting intensity correlation measurements, a technique pioneered by Hanbury Brown and Twiss (HBT) Brown and Twiss 1956 ; Hanbury Brown and Twiss 1956 and formally grounded in Glauber’s quantum theory of optical coherence Glauber 1963a ; Glauber 1963b ; Glauber 1963c . In a conventional HBT experiment, an optical field is incident on a 50:50 beam splitter, and the two output fields are detected by independent detectors whose signals are subsequently time-correlated. This approach enabled the landmark observation of photon antibunching Kimble et al. 1977 ; Cresser et al. 1982 ; Walls 1979 ; Leuchs 1986 , which is widely regarded as compelling experimental evidence for the particle nature of light Grangier et al. 1986 . The HBT arrangement has become the gold standard for measuring intensity correlation functions, yet it can misleadingly suggest that a beam splitter is essential to demonstrate photon indivisibility. As pointed out by Loudon Loudon 1973 , a much simpler configuration, in which light is incident on a single-photon detector, is in principle sufficient. In such a simple scheme, correlations are extracted from the time-resolved detection record via auto-correlation analysis Wiersig et al. 2009 ; Steudle et al. 2012 . While computationally efficient, this method yields a pronounced peak at zero time delay (as is to be expected for every auto-correlation function) that is absent in cross-detector measurements. In this Letter, we demonstrate that the distinction between cross-correlation and auto-correlation measurements is not merely technical, but reflects a fundamental consequence of the noncommutativity of bosonic field operators. Specifically, HBT cross-correlations probe a normal ordering of field operators that is intrinsically different from the operator ordering accessed in single-detector auto-correlations. By quantitatively comparing these two classes of intensity correlations, we show that the zero-delay auto-correlation peak—commonly regarded as an artifact—constitutes a direct experimental manifestation of the bosonic commutation relation. Moreover, we generalize this approach to establish a framework for determining commutation relations through intensity correlation measurements. Remarkably, our method applies to arbitrary optical fields and operates independently of whether their statistics are classical or quantum, underscoring both its fundamental significance and its broad experimental accessibility. Theoretical background.— We consider the standard HBT setup. Within Glauber photodetection theory Glauber 1963b , the joint probability of detecting a photon at time t in one detector and another photon at time t^{\prime} in the second detector is proportional to w(t,t^{\prime})\propto\langle\hat{E}^{(-)}(t)\hat{E}^{(-)}(t+\tau)\hat{E}^{(+)}(t+\tau)\hat{E}^{(+)}(t)\rangle:=G^{(2)}(t,t^{\prime}) , where \tau=t^{\prime}-t is the time delay, \hat{E}^{(\pm)} are the positive (negative) parts of the fields and the angle brackets indicate ensemble averages evaluated with the use of the density matrix as \langle\hat{O}\rangle=\mathop{\mathrm{Tr}}\nolimits(\hat{\varrho}\hat{O}) for any observable \hat{O} . In what follows, we assume the fields to be ergodic, so that ensemble averages are equivalent to time averages Mandel and Wolf 1995 . This measurement thus yields the second-order correlation function g^{(2)}_{\mathrm{cross}}(\tau)=\frac{\langle\vcentcolon\mathrel{\hat{I}(t)\,\hat{I}(t+\tau)}\vcentcolon\rangle}{\langle\vcentcolon\mathrel{I(t)}\vcentcolon\rangle^{2}}=\frac{\langle\hat{a}^{\dagger}(t)\hat{a}^{\dagger}(t+\tau)\hat{a}(t)\hat{a}(t+\tau)\rangle}{\langle\hat{a}^{\dagger}(t)\hat{a}(t)\rangle^{2}}\,, (1) where \hat{I}(t)=\hat{E}^{(-)}(t)\hat{E}^{(+)}(t) is the intensity operator and \vcentcolon\mathrel{\,}\vcentcolon denotes normal ordering. The subscript “cross” stresses that we cross-correlate the signals measured with two different detectors, including the correlation at zero delay \tau=0 . For stationary fields, this definition is independent of the choice of the absolute detection time t . A key feature of g_{\mathrm{cross}}^{(2)}(\tau) is its independence from optical losses, which makes it particularly robust experimentally. This robustness, however, comes at the expense of reduced sensitivity to absolute photon-number statistics. In addition, the HBT configuration is unaffected by detector dead time. The above discussion applies to energy-detecting measurements, such as photodiodes or click detectors, but not to quadrature-sensitive detection schemes, e.g., homodyne detection Björk et al. 2001 ; Hessmo et al. 2004 ; Shikhali Najafabadi et al. 2024 Most intensity-correlation measurements employ the HBT scheme. One may nevertheless ask why the correlation function is not instead obtained by recording a time series with a single detector and evaluating the correlation numerically Steudle et al. 2012 . We denote the resulting auto-correlation function as g^{(2)}_{\mathrm{auto}} . In contrast to the HBT cross-correlation g^{(2)}_{\mathrm{cross}} , g^{(2)}_{\mathrm{auto}} is not generally independent of losses, a consequence of the nontrivial effect of attenuation on quantum signals. Importantly, however, losses affect only the zero-delay value: for all \tau\neq 0 , the two correlation functions are identical. This property can be of advantage in experiments. Instead of splitting the incoming light using a beam splitter onto two detectors and correlating the resulting two time series, it might be already sufficient to simply send all the light to a single detector with a fast response time, and calculate the auto-correlation function instead. Depending on the delay range of interest, this can significantly reduce the required measurement time. For example, sending N photons into an HBT setup with a beam splitter of reflectivity R and transmissivity 1-R , the expected number of correlations scales as N/R\times N/(1-R)=N^{2}/(R-R^{2}) . In contrast, when the same photons are detected by a single detector and auto-correlated, the number of correlations at \tau\neq 0 scales as N^{2}-N . Hence, the number of data points contributing to g^{(2)}_{\mathrm{cross}}(\tau) scales as \mathcal{O}\left(N^{2}/(R-R^{2})\right) , whereas for g^{(2)}_{\mathrm{auto}}(\tau) it scales as \mathcal{O}(N^{2}) . For the optimal case of a 50:50 beam splitter, this translates to a reduction in the required measurement time by a factor of four. The two approaches differ, however, at

Read the complete text