The Blown Lead Paradox: Conditional Laws for the Running Maximum of Binary Doob Martingales
Jonathan Pipping-Gamón & Abraham J. Wyner Department of Statistics, University of Pennsylvania · 2026
Read The Blown Lead Paradox: Conditional Laws for the Running Maximum of Binary Doob Martingales by Jonathan Pipping-Gamón & Abraham J. Wyner Department of Statistics, University of Pennsylvania (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-18774.txt.
Introduction
Jonathan Pipping-Gamón and Abraham Wyner study a trap in sports talk: the team that had the best shot to win, yet lost, is said to have blown the game. Live win odds now run with each game on air. When a team that once stood at a high mark falls to a loss, the mark is read as proof of a choke. The pair ask what mark a sound set of odds would give by chance to a team that goes on to lose.
That mark has a spread set by the odds them-selves, if the odds are right. A big blown lead may be no more than what chance gives in a fair game. The pair work out that spread for a clean kind of odds path. Their sums give fans a yard stick: past it, a loss may be a choke.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jonathan Pipping-Gamón & Abraham J. Wyner Department of Statistics, University of Pennsylvania |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 37 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-18774
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Blown Lead Paradox: Conditional Laws for the Running Maximum of Binary Doob Martingales Jonathan Pipping-Gamón & Abraham J. Wyner Department of Statistics, University of Pennsylvania Abstract Live win-probability forecasts are now ubiquitous in sports broadcasts, and retrospective commentary often cites the largest win probability attained by a team that ultimately loses as evidence of a “collapse.” Interpreting such extrema requires a reference distribution under correct specification. Modeling the forecast sequence as the Doob martingale of conditional win probabilities for a binary terminal outcome, we derive sharp distributional laws for its path maximum, including the conditional law given an eventual loss. In discrete time, we quantify explicit correction terms (last-step crossings and overshoots); under continuous-path regularity these corrections disappear, yielding exact identities. We further obtain closed-form distributions for two extensions: the maximal win probability attained by the eventual loser in a two-player game and the minimal win probability attained by the eventual winner in an n n -player game. The resulting formulas furnish practical benchmarks for diagnosing sequential forecast calibration. 1 Introduction Modern decision systems routinely display real-time probability forecasts for binary terminal events. A particularly visible example is win probability in sports broadcasts, which reports at each timestep the estimated chance that a designated team ultimately wins. In Super Bowl LVII, for instance, ESPN’s win probability model assigned the Philadelphia Eagles a peak win probability of 78.4\% early in the third quarter ( 2 ) . The Eagles nevertheless lost the game on a last-second field goal. Post hoc commentary often treats such episodes as extraordinary “collapses,” implicitly suggesting that a team losing from a 78.4\% position should be rare. This interpretation is misleading, however. Even under perfect calibration, the distribution of the peak win probability conditional on ultimately losing differs from the naive fixed-time intuition suggested by a single displayed probability. Accordingly, the relevant object is not the forecast at a fixed time, but the path maximum attained by the eventual loser. Without a reference distribution for this conditional maximum under correct probabilistic specification, the evidentiary value of a quoted peak win probability is unclear. We study this phenomenon in its canonical probabilistic form. Let Y\in\{0,1\} be the terminal outcome of interest (e.g., team A wins), revealed at a terminal time N , and let (\mathcal{F}_{k})_{k=0}^{N} be the natural filtration generated by the observable state process up to time k . Define the (ideal) forecast process p_{k}\equiv\mathbb{P}(Y=1\mid\mathcal{F}_{k}),\qquad k=0,1,\dots,N. Then (p_{k}) is a bounded Doob martingale with p_{0}\in(0,1) and p_{N}=Y . The primary path functional we analyze is the path maximum M_{N}\equiv\max_{0\leq k\leq N}p_{k}, with continuous-path analogue M=\sup_{0\leq t\leq 1}p_{t} . We study the terminal running maximum M_{N} (the path maximum over the horizon). We are particularly interested in behavior on the event \{Y=0\} (“eventual loss”). In two-player games, one often reports the eventual loser’s maximal win probability M_{\lambda} , while in n -player settings one may analogously consider the eventual winner’s minimal probability M_{\omega} ; both are natural extremes of coupled Doob martingales induced by conditional winning probabilities. Related Work. Classical martingale theory controls the upper tail of M_{N} (and its continuous-path analogue M ) through maximal inequalities (e.g., Doob’s inequality) and Ville-type bounds for nonnegative (super)martingales, implying that under correct martingale specification large values are not, by themselves, exceptional ( 1 ; 7 ) . What is typically missing in applications is a distributional benchmark, an explicit law for M_{N} and related extremes, especially conditional on the terminal outcome. Under continuous-path regularity, our unconditional law for \sup_{t}p_{t} can be viewed as a special case of Doob’s maximal identity for continuous nonnegative local martingales; see, e.g., 4 and textbook treatments such as 6 . Our main focus is on the conditional law given the terminal outcome and on the multi-player competitive extensions. Our perspective also aligns with the martingale viewpoint in sequential analysis ( 8 ) and with modern “betting martingale” or e-value formulations that provide time-uniform guarantees via nonnegative supermartingales ( 3 ) . Contributions. This paper supplies a distributional benchmark for path extrema of bounded Doob martingales with \{0,1\} -valued terminal outcomes. The main technical contribution is a set of sharp closed-form laws—exact under continuous-path regularity and otherwise accompanied by explicit last-step/overshoot corrections—that sharpen classical Doob/Ville maximal bounds which control only the upper tail. Concretely: • We derive the unconditional law of M_{N} and the conditional law of M_{N} given Y=0 in discrete time, identifying precisely when equalities hold and quantifying the discrete-time correction terms from last-step crossings and overshoots. • We extend these results to the two-player eventual-loser functional M_{\lambda} and to the n -player eventual-winner functional M_{\omega} , yielding closed-form distribution functions that depend only on the initial probabilities. • We show that under continuous-path limits, terminal-step crossings and overshoots vanish and the discrete-time bounds become exact distributional identities. Organization. Section 2 develops the discrete-time theory via optional stopping. Section 3 treats the continuous-path case and derives exact distributional identities. Section 4 illustrates how the resulting reference distributions can be used to interpret and test “collapse” claims in applied settings. Section 5 concludes with limitations and extensions. 2 Discrete-Time Case We first analyze the problem in discrete time. Our starting point is a binary terminal event and its associated conditional probability (win-probability) martingale, whose maximum records how close the process comes to the event over the course of the game or experiment. In this section, we work with an abstract filtered probability space and derive general distributional laws for this maximum, both unconditionally and conditionally on the event not occurring. 2.1 Problem Setup Let (\Omega,\mathcal{F},(\mathcal{F}_{k})_{k=0}^{N},\mathbb{P}) be a filtered probability space, and let Y\in\{0,1\} be \mathcal{F}_{N} -measurable. Define the associated Doob martingale of conditional event probabilities p_{k}\equiv\mathbb{E}[Y\mid\mathcal{F}_{k}],\quad 0\leq k\leq N. Then p_{k}\in[0,1] , with p_{0}=\mathbb{P}(Y=1)\in(0,1), and p_{N}=Y\in\{0,1\} . We define the path maximum of the martingale and, for each fixed x\in[0,1] , the first time the process reaches or exceeds level x : M_{N}\equiv\max_{0\leq k\leq N}p_{k},\qquad\tau_{x}\equiv\inf\{k\geq 0:p_{k}\geq x\}, with the convention \inf\emptyset=\infty and with optional stopping applied at \tau_{x}\wedge N . Our goal in this section is to characterize the distribution of M_{N} and its conditional law given Y=0 under this minimal martingale structure. 2.2 Unconditional Distribution Theorem 1 . The cumulative distribution function of M_{N} satisfies F_{M_{N}}(x)\geq 1-\frac{p_{0}}{x},\quad x\in[p_{0},1), with equality when \mathbb{P}(\tau_{x}=N)=0 and p_{\tau_{x}}=x a.s. on \{\tau_{x}<N\} (e.g. under continuous-path limits). For x<p_{0} , we have F_{M_{N}}(x)=0 . In particular, M_{N} has an atom at x=1 of mass \mathbb{P}(M_{N}=1)=p_{0} . For finite N , the remainder of the law is supported on the discrete set of attainable values of M_{N} in [p_{0},1) . Proof. See Appendix A for the full proof. ∎ 2.3 Conditional Distribution Theorem 2 . The cumulative distribution function of M_{N} conditional on the terminal event Y=0 satisfies F_{M_{N}\mid Y=0}(x)\geq 1-\left(\frac{p_{0}}{1-p_{0}}\right)\cdot\left(\frac{1-x}{x}\right),\quad x\in[p_{0},1), with equality when \mathbb{P}(\tau_{x}=N)=0 and p_{\tau_{x}}=x a.s. on \{\tau_{x}<N\} (e.g. under continuous-path limits). For x<p_{0} , we have F_{M_{N}\mid Y=0}(x)=0 . For finite N , the law is supported on the discrete set of attainable values of M_{N} in [p_{0},1) . Proof. See Appendix A for the full proof. ∎ 3 Continuous-Path Case In the discrete-time setting, we studied the martingale p_{k}=\mathbb{E}[Y\mid\mathcal{F}_{k}], for a binary terminal outcome Y , and derived sharp inequalities for the law of its