Constraint-Aware Discrete-Time PID Gain Optimization for Robotic Joint Control Under Actuator Saturation

Ojasva Mishra, Xiaolong Wu, Min Xu · 2026

Read Constraint-Aware Discrete-Time PID Gain Optimization for Robotic Joint Control Under Actuator Saturation by Ojasva Mishra, Xiaolong Wu, Min Xu (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-18639.txt.

Introduction

Ojasva Mishra, Xiaolong Wu, and Min Xu tune the loops that hold robot joints on track. A joint loop takes a goal pose, reads the true pose, and sets the push to close the gap. Book rules for such loops take the world as smooth and the push as free of caps. Real joints break both: they run in ticks, their push has a hard cap, and their reads come late and with flaws.

The team build a tune path that takes those real facts as its start. It sets the loop's three gains to get a firm hold with no wild swing, while the cap is kept in view. A good tune could keep arms and legs of robots safe and true. It could also cut the hand work of trial and error on each new joint.

Catalog record

CREATOROjasva Mishra, Xiaolong Wu, Min Xu
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE44 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-18639

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Constraint-Aware Discrete-Time PID Gain Optimization for Robotic Joint Control Under Actuator Saturation Ojasva Mishra, Xiaolong Wu, Min Xu Abstract The precise regulation of rotary actuation is fundamental in autonomous robotics, yet practical PID loops deviate from continuous-time theory due to discrete-time execution, actuator saturation, and small delays and measurement imperfections. We present an implementation-aware analysis and tuning workflow for saturated discrete-time joint control. We (i) derive PI stability regions under Euler and exact zero-order-hold (ZOH) discretizations using the Jury criterion, (ii) evaluate a discrete back-calculation anti-windup realization under saturation-dominant regimes, and (iii) propose a hybrid-certified Bayesian optimization workflow that screens analytically unstable candidates and behaviorally unsafe transients while optimizing a robust IAE objective with soft penalties on overshoot and saturation duty. Baseline sweeps ( τ = 1.0 \tau=1.0 s, Δ ​ t = 0.01 \Delta t=0.01 s, u ∈ [ − 10 , 10 ] u\in[-10,10] ) quantify rise/settle trends for P/PI/PID. Under a randomized model family emulating uncertainty, delay, noise, quantization, and tighter saturation, robustness-oriented tuning improves median IAE from 0.843 0.843 to 0.430 0.430 while keeping median overshoot below 2 % 2\% . In simulation-only tuning, the certification screen rejects 11.6 % 11.6\% of randomly sampled gains within bounds before full robust evaluation, improving sample efficiency without hardware experiments. Keywords: PID control, discrete-time implementation, actuator saturation, integral windup, anti-windup, robustness, Jury stability, Bayesian optimization, robotic joints 1 Introduction The precise regulation of rotary actuation constitutes a fundamental challenge in the engineering of autonomous robotic systems, ranging from industrial manipulators to self-guided electric vehicle charging mechanisms. In these cyber-physical domains, the fidelity of motion control determines the operational success of the system. The Proportional-Integral-Derivative (PID) controller remains the preeminent standard in feedback control systems due to its versatile structure and proven capacity to ensure asymptotic stability. Despite the ubiquity of PID control, the translation of continuous-time control theory into physical application is frequently complicated by hardware constraints. Theoretical models often assume infinite control authority and continuous signal processing; however, practical robotic joints operate within strict voltage/torque limits and utilize digital processors that execute control laws in discrete time steps. When a controller demands an input that exceeds the physical capabilities of the actuator, the system enters a regime of saturation, introducing non-linearities that can degrade performance or induce instability. In addition, real embedded loops exhibit non-idealities such as computation delay, sensor noise, and encoder quantization that interact with discretization and saturation. This research presents a systematic characterization of a first-order Linear Time-Invariant (LTI) robotic joint under discrete PID control. Unlike generalized derivations found in introductory literature, this study isolates the specific impact of control gains ( K_{p},\ K_{i},\ \text{and}\ K_{d} ) within the context of a magnitude-constrained system and then extends the analysis toward robust, implementation-aware tuning in simulation. Contributions While the baseline gain sweeps are intended to be interpretable, the paper is strengthened by three contributions that directly target robotics implementation gaps: 1. Closed-form PI stability regions in discrete time. For a first-order joint model, we derive explicit gain- and sampling-dependent stability constraints for PI control using the Jury criterion under both forward-Euler and exact ZOH discretizations, enabling “safe” gain selection before simulation. 2. Saturation-dominant evaluation with anti-windup. We include a discrete back-calculation anti-windup update and demonstrate how it changes recovery dynamics when saturation is frequent (a regime not captured by small-step, low-demand baselines). 3. Robust constraint-aware gain selection. We propose a robustness-oriented Bayesian gain-selection workflow that optimizes IAE while enforcing stability and soft constraints on overshoot and saturation duty across a randomized family of joint models (delay, noise, quantization, and parameter uncertainty). 2 Motivation 2.1 Problem formulation While the Proportional-Integral-Derivative (PID) controller is the theoretic standard for asymptotic stability in linear time-invariant (LTI) systems, its implementation in robotic actuation is frequently compromised by physical nonlinearities—specifically actuator saturation and discretization artifacts. Theoretical derivations often assume continuous-time signal processing and infinite control authority. However, practical autonomous joints operate within strict voltage limits ( u_{\min},u_{\max} ) and utilize digital processors that execute control laws in discrete time steps ( \Delta t ). The discrepancy between continuous-time theory and discrete-time implementation creates a performance gap. When a high-gain controller demands an input exceeding the actuator’s physical capacity ( |u(t)|>u_{\mathrm{sat}} ), the system enters a regime of saturation. This introduces windup phenomena and nonlinear transient behaviors that degrade tracking fidelity, represented by the Integral of Absolute Error (IAE) and settling time. Furthermore, the use of first-order forward Euler discretization in low-latency embedded loops introduces numerical approximations that deviate from ideal analytical predictions [ 3 , 2 ] . 2.2 Research objectives The primary objective of this study is to systematically characterize the dynamic response of a first-order LTI robotic joint under magnitude-constrained discrete PID control and to extend the analysis toward robust practice without requiring hardware access. Specifically, this research aims to: 1. Quantify discretization sensitivity: analyze the deviation between theoretical continuous-time predictions and discrete-time implementations using Forward Euler integration with limited sampling resolution ( \Delta t=0.01\,\text{s} ). 2. Characterize saturation nonlinearities: evaluate the impact of control effort clamping ( u_{k}\in[-10,10] ) on integral windup and rise-time performance during step responses, including saturation-dominant tasks. 3. Derive constraint-aware tuning heuristics: establish tuning guidelines for K_{p},K_{i},K_{d} that minimize IAE while enforcing stability and bounded overshoot under model variations (delay, noise, parameter uncertainty). Table 1 lists the key symbols used throughout this paper. Table 1: Key symbols used throughout this paper with the equation number of introduction marked. Symbol Description y(t),\,y_{k} Joint output (position) in continuous and discrete time; plant output in ( 1 )–( 3 ). u(t),\,u_{k} Control effort; proportional/PI/PID laws in ( 4 )–( 6 ). r Reference (desired joint position), unit step used throughout baseline experiments. e_{k} Tracking error, e_{k}=r-y_{k} , defined after ( 3 ). \tau Plant time constant in the first-order model ( 1 ). K Plant static gain in ( 1 ). \Delta t Sampling interval (control period) in ( 3 ). K_{p},\,K_{i},\,K_{d} Proportional, integral, and derivative gains in ( 4 )–( 6 ). I_{k} Discrete integral state and back-calculation update in ( 8 ). u_{\min},\,u_{\max} Actuator saturation bounds used in the clamp ( 7 ). \%OS Percent overshoot metric in ( 9 ). t_{r},\,t_{s} Rise time and settling time in ( 10 ) and ( 11 ). e_{ss} Terminal steady-state error estimate in ( 12 ). \mathrm{IAE} Integral of absolute error in ( 13 ). z Discrete-time closed-loop pole for P control in ( 14 ). a,\,b Exact ZOH discrete-time coefficients in ( 23 ). K_{aw} Anti-windup (back-calculation) gain in ( 8 ). J Robust BO objective in ( 21 ). \lambda_{os},\,\lambda_{sat},\,\lambda_{u} BO penalty weights in ( 21 ). 3 Related work This paper connects three threads that frequently appear in robotics actuation but are often studied in isolation: (i) digital PID implementation effects (sampling and discretization), (ii) saturation and anti-windup behavior in voltage/torque-limited joints, and (iii) data-efficient gain selection under uncertainty when direct hardware iteration is impractical. 3.1 Digital PID in robotics and sampled-data effects PID remains a workhorse in robotics because it is simple, interpretable, and effective across a wide range of actuation plants. Recent reviews and sampled-data surveys emphasize that real closed-loop behavior depends strongly on implementation details that are frequently abstracted away in continuous-time

Read the complete text