Physics-Informed Uncertainty Enables Reliable AI-driven Design
Tingkai Xue, Chinchun Ooi, Yang Jiang, Luu Trung Pham Duong, Pao-Hsiung Chiu, Weijiang Zhao, Nagarajan Raghavan, My Ha Dao · 2026
Read Physics-Informed Uncertainty Enables Reliable AI-driven Design by Tingkai Xue, Chinchun Ooi, Yang Jiang, Luu Trung Pham Duong, Pao-Hsiung Chiu, Weijiang Zhao, Nagarajan Raghavan, My Ha Dao (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-18638.txt.
Introduction
Tingkai Xue and seven colleagues add doubt counts to the smart design of parts that pick which waves may pass. Such parts, used in chips and in light tools, let some tones through and block the rest. Past smart design was fast but blind to its own doubt. In zones with few past facts, its guesses could be far off, and the search would chase a false peak.
Their plan tracks doubt as it designs, and it steers the search away from zones where doubt is high. Physics rules guide the doubt count, so it stays true to how waves act. A search that knows its doubt should land on parts that work in the lab, not just on screen. That gain counts for parts that are dear to make and test.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Tingkai Xue, Chinchun Ooi, Yang Jiang, Luu Trung Pham Duong, Pao-Hsiung Chiu, Weijiang Zhao, Nagarajan Raghavan, My Ha Dao |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 57 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-18638
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Physics-Informed Uncertainty Enables Reliable AI-driven Design Tingkai Xue, Chinchun Ooi, Yang Jiang, Luu Trung Pham Duong, Pao-Hsiung Chiu, Weijiang Zhao, Nagarajan Raghavan, My Ha Dao Abstract Inverse design is a central goal in much of science and engineering, including frequency-selective surfaces (FSS) that are critical to microelectronics for telecommunications and optical metamaterials. Traditional surrogate-assisted optimization methods using deep learning can accelerate the design process but do not usually incorporate uncertainty quantification, leading to poorer optimization performance due to erroneous predictions in data-sparse regions. Here, we introduce and validate a fundamentally different paradigm of Physics-Informed Uncertainty, where the degree to which a model’s prediction violates fundamental physical laws serves as a computationally-cheap and effective proxy for predictive uncertainty. By integrating physics-informed uncertainty into a multi-fidelity uncertainty-aware optimization workflow to design complex frequency-selective surfaces within the 20 - 30 GHz range, we increase the success rate of finding performant solutions from less than 10% to over 50%, while simultaneously reducing computational cost by an order of magnitude compared to the sole use of a high-fidelity solver. These results highlight the necessity of incorporating uncertainty quantification in machine-learning-driven inverse design for high-dimensional problems, and establish physics-informed uncertainty as a viable alternative to quantifying uncertainty in surrogate models for physical systems, thereby setting the stage for autonomous scientific discovery systems that can efficiently and robustly explore and evaluate candidate designs. 1 Introduction Inverse design is a ubiquitous problem statement spanning multiple disciplines in science and engineering from drug discovery and materials science to electrical engineering [ 29 , 20 , 31 ] . Historically, progress has been driven by a combination of expert intuition and iterative, costly physical prototyping, a process that inherently limits the scope of exploration and hinders the discovery of novel, non-intuitive solutions. The rise of computational science offered a paradigm shift, enabling virtual testing that is more resource-efficient than physical fabrication. However, the computational cost of these models still render exhaustive search in vast, high-dimensional design spaces intractable. To overcome this bottleneck, data-driven surrogate models, particularly deep neural networks, have emerged as a powerful solution, capable of predicting performance in milliseconds and dramatically accelerating the design optimization process [ 21 , 24 , 8 ] . Crucially, these data-driven models are inherently unreliable when extrapolating. Lacking any grounding in physical principles, they can produce confidently incorrect predictions in data-sparse regions of the design space, which engenders significant brittleness when incorporated in optimization algorithms for inverse design [ 2 , 19 ] . In being guided by these surrogates, one can be deceptively led into false minima during the automated design optimization process, i.e. regions that appear optimal to the model but are actually poor-performing. The conventional approach to mitigate this risk is through statistical uncertainty quantification. Bayesian methods and certain forms of statistical learning algorithms (e.g. Gaussian processes) are prized for their ability to provide estimates of uncertainty in their predicted output. Similarly, Bayesian neural networks have been proposed as a way to incorporate probabilistic estimation or uncertainty in deep learning models, while Deep Ensembles are another simple yet effective alternative [ 16 , 26 , 28 ] . Specific to design optimization, uncertainty estimates are a key component of any strategy to balance the classic ‘exploration-exploitation’ trade-off. Uncertainty estimates can guide the algorithm to ‘explore’ novel regions where the model is least confident, while the model’s predictions guide it to ‘exploit’ known regions of high performance [ 30 , 12 ] . While effective, these methods can be computationally burdensome and, more fundamentally, do not leverage the rich, underlying physical laws that govern the system. Here, we introduce and validate a fundamentally different paradigm: Physics-Informed Uncertainty. Simply, a surrogate model’s credibility can be directly, cheaply, and effectively assessed by quantifying the degree to which its predictions violate fundamental physical laws. By evaluating a model’s compliance with principles like continuity in electromagnetic field or conservation of energy, we can generate a powerful, low-cost proxy for predictive uncertainty. This approach is not only computationally efficient but also versatile, allowing it to be integrated with any pre-trained surrogate model to guide optimization. To rigorously test this principle, we apply it to the inverse design of frequency-selective surfaces (FSS), an especially challenging problem due to its extremely high-dimensional design space ( \approx 10^{97} possibilities), and great practical importance in telecommunications and optics as a fundamental building block of metasurfaces [ 18 ] . An illustrative schematic of this physics-informed uncertainty metric and its potential utility in robust uncertainty-aware multi-fidelity design optimization is in Fig 1 . Figure 1: Illustration of how a single-fidelity surrogate-assisted optimization workflow may lead to erroneous designs as the design deviates from its’ training distribution whereas an uncertainty-aware multi-fidelity workflow efficiently utilizes high-fidelity evaluations in balancing ‘exploration’ and ‘exploitation’ for robust design optimization. The novel aspect of this work is the validation of physics-based rules as an effective uncertainty metric in this real-world problem of metasurface design. We demonstrate that a standard surrogate-assisted particle swarm optimization workflow catastrophically fails, achieving a success rate of less than 10%. In contrast, a multi-fidelity uncertainty-aware framework, guided by the physics-informed uncertainty, is able to more robustly find performant solutions at \approx 5x the rate, even while maintaining a 10-fold reduction in computational cost relative to the sole use of high-fidelity numerical solvers. While there is some prior literature on the use of machine learning for the design of frequency selective surfaces, we note that this is the first work, to our knowledge, to both demonstrate the potential drawbacks, especially in such high-dimensional spaces whereby no practical dataset is anticipated to ever be fully comprehensive, and to incorporate ideas of uncertainty into the design optimization workflow [ 1 , 5 , 6 ] . More broadly, the ability to estimate uncertainty using physical principles introduces a promising direction for domain experts to encode prior knowledge as constraints or indicators of model reliability, establishing a generalizable strategy for reliable and efficient AI-driven scientific discovery. 2 Methods 2.1 Description of frequency selective surface Frequency-selective surfaces are a fundamental component of many complex electronic devices, including in advanced telecommunications [ 14 , 3 ] . For this work, we focus on the performance of devices in the 20 - 30 GHz range, which is crucial to 5G and sub-6G communication systems. Crucially, this is currently the most challenging frequency range that is manufacturable. Current fabrication technologies limit the design space to simple shapes for frequencies much higher than this range, while the dimensionality of the problem for frequencies in the MHz and below range is much lower and can be well-studied by conventional approaches. For this frequency range, a typical meta-atom (basic building block in the fabrication of a frequency-selective surface) is defined on a 5.4\times 5.4mm^{2} planar area. While the meta-atom design can theoretically be any free-form composition of free-space and a metallic conductor, it is common to utilize a pixel-based discretization to parameterize the entire design space, which determines the dimensionality of the design problem. In pursuit of high-performance designs, cells with more complex patterns are increasingly desired, but this inadvertently increases the design space. The fundamental choice of number of pixels needs to balance the ability to produce sufficiently complex designs while satisfying