Automated Landmark Detection for assessing hip conditions: A Cross-Modality Validation of MRI versus X-ray

Roberto Di Via, Vito Paolo Pastore, Francesca Odone, Siôn Glyn-Jones, Irina Voiculescu · 2026

Read Automated Landmark Detection for assessing hip conditions: A Cross-Modality Validation of MRI versus X-ray by Roberto Di Via, Vito Paolo Pastore, Francesca Odone, Siôn Glyn-Jones, Irina Voiculescu (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-18555.txt.

Introduction

Roberto Di Via and four colleagues teach a tool to find key points on hip scans in two kinds of image. Care for a hip fault rests in part on angles staff read off X-ray shots. Those angles flag a fault where the hip ball and its socket clash. But the full size and span of the clash need a three-dim view, which a deep scan can give.

A tool that finds the same points in both kinds of shot would let staff blend the two views. The X-ray gives the quick angles. The deep scan gives the span. The team test if their marks hold up when the kind of shot swaps. A firm cross test could cut hand work and make hip calls more even across clinics. It could also help plan cuts with both views in hand.

Catalog record

CREATORRoberto Di Via, Vito Paolo Pastore, Francesca Odone, Siôn Glyn-Jones, Irina Voiculescu
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE20 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-18555

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Automated Landmark Detection for assessing hip conditions: A Cross-Modality Validation of MRI versus X-ray Roberto Di Via, Vito Paolo Pastore, Francesca Odone, Siôn Glyn-Jones, Irina Voiculescu Abstract Many clinical screening decisions are based on angle measurements. In particular, FemoroAcetabular Impingement (FAI) screening relies on angles traditionally measured on X-rays. However, assessing the height and span of the impingement area requires also a 3D view through an MRI scan. The two modalities inform the surgeon on different aspects of the condition. In this work, we conduct a matched-cohort validation study (89 patients, paired MRI/X-ray) using standard heatmap regression architectures to assess cross-modality clinical equivalence. Seen that landmark detection has been proven effective on X-rays, we show that MRI also achieves equivalent localisation and diagnostic accuracy for cam-type impingement. Our method demonstrates clinical feasibility for FAI assessment in coronal views of 3D MRI volumes, opening the possibility for volumetric analysis through placing further landmarks. These results support integrating automated FAI assessment into routine MRI workflows. Code is released at https://github.com/Malga-Vision/Landmarks-Hip-Conditions . 1 Introduction Femoroacetabular impingement (FAI) is a pathomechanical hip disorder affecting 20–25% of the population, characterised by abnormal contact between the femoral head–neck junction and acetabular rim during motion [ 16 ] . Early identification is critical, as untreated FAI accelerates degenerative cartilage loss and predisposes to premature osteoarthritis [ 12 ] . FAI is the main cause of hip replacement. However, it is hard to diagnose at its early stages. Imaging is essential for early detection and treatment. Clinical assessment relies on two geometric parameters (Fig. 1 ): the \alpha -angle, quantifying femoral head asphericity (cam morphology), and the lateral centre-edge (LCE) angle, measuring acetabular coverage (pincer morphology). Pathological thresholds are typically \alpha{>}65^{\circ} and LCE {>}40^{\circ} [ 6 , 17 ] . Figure 1: FAI assessment from paired T1 MRI (top) and X-ray (bottom). The \alpha -angle and LCE angle quantify femoral head asphericity and acetabular coverage, respectively. Our study confirms that automated landmark detection achieves equivalent accuracy across modalities, confirming the feasibility of MRI landmark detection. Current clinical practice relies on anteroposterior (AP) pelvic X-rays, which have fundamental limitations from tissue density being projected into a single view plane. The foot-to-hip alignment and pelvic tilt can affect the plane in which the relevant angles are being measured, leading to a variability of up to 15^{\circ} [ 8 ] , sufficient to misclassify borderline cases. In this work, we investigate whether geometric FAI metrics can be reliably extracted from MRI alone. Whilst foot-to-hip misalignment can still be present in the coronal view, there are methods for correcting the misalignment, and measuring the angle in the correct plane. The first step towards this important 3D analysis is precisely showing that landmarks can be detected automatically in MRI slices. Deep learning-based landmark detection have been used in diverse medical imaging tasks [ 2 , 13 , 11 ] , with recent work demonstrating the feasibility of an automated FAI assessment from X-rays [ 9 ] . However, no prior work has validated automated FAI assessment on MRI or directly compared cross-modality performance on matched cohorts. MRI offers intrinsic advantages over X-ray, because the alignment of the hip can be corrected post-scan, and the true 3D nature of the impingement area can be assessed independently, either across multiple slices separately or, ideally, through a single volumetric assessment. Contributions. (1) We present the first cross-modality validation of automated hip landmark detection between X-ray and MRI. Standard heatmap regression models achieve equivalent performance on T1-weighted MRI (2.98 MRI vs. 3.02 mm X-ray mean error, 87.5% diagnostic accuracy) on a matched patient cohort. This establishes coronal MRI as a successful modality for automated FAI assessment; (2) By extending measurements conventionally taken from X-rays to the corresponding slice in 3D MRI volumes, we enable seamless integration into clinical workflows; (3) We thereby establish a validated 2D foundation for future volumetric extensions towards full 3D geometric analysis and prediction. 2 Method 2.1 Problem Formulation We formulate FAI angle computation as a landmark detection problem. For each hip, we localise four annotated anatomical keypoints: femoral head centre (FHC), neck-axis point (NA) along the femoral neck centreline, lateral acetabular edge (LAE), and lateral cam point (LCP) where the femoral head deviates from sphericity (see Fig. 2 ). The \alpha -angle is computed as the angle between the femoral neck axis (FHC \rightarrow NA) and the cam deformity vector (FHC \rightarrow LCP). Due to the LCP being hard to pinpoint – even by clinicians – \alpha is notoriously difficult to calculate. The easier LCE angle is calculated as the angle between the vertical axis and the acetabular coverage vector (FHC \rightarrow LAE), quantifying lateral acetabular overhang. Angles are visualised in Fig 1 . 2.2 Heatmap Regression Architecture Following established practice in medical landmark detection [ 15 , 5 ] , we adopt a heatmap regression formulation. For each landmark k\in\{1,\ldots,4\} , we generate a ground-truth Gaussian heatmap H_{k}{\in}\mathbb{R}^{h\times w} , centred at the annotated location (x_{k},y_{k}) as H_{k}(i,j)=\exp\!\left(-\frac{(i-y_{k})^{2}+(j-x_{k})^{2}}{2\sigma^{2}}\right) , with \sigma{=}5 empirically providing the best trade-off between localisation precision and training stability. Encoder–decoder networks are trained to predict heatmaps \hat{H}_{k} from input images I{\in}\mathbb{R}^{512\times 512} by minimizing the negative log-likelihood (NLL) over the four landmarks [ 10 ] . At inference, landmark coordinates are extracted as the spatial argmax of each predicted heatmap. For robustness, we employ test-time augmentation (TTA) by averaging heatmap predictions across different augmented views per test image, applying the stochastic transformations described in Sec. 3.1 . 3 Experiments 3.1 Dataset and Training Setup We use a paired dataset of 89 patients who underwent AP pelvic X-ray and multiple hip MRI for FAI evaluation, collected at Oxford University as part of the FAIT trial [ 3 ] . This pathological cohort includes subjects with clinical and imaging evidence of FAI but without significant osteoarthritis or hip dysplasia. Data were acquired using the same protocol, across multiple UK sites, with some patients contributing multiple time points. Since acquiring such a rich dataset, with multiple imaging modalities, longitudinally for the same patient is logistically and clinically challenging, the resulting paired dataset remains relatively small. For MRI, we only used T1-weighted coronal acquisitions consisting of 20 slices with 3.3 mm spacing. All images are resized/padded to 512{\times}512 and min–max normalised to [0,1] . All annotations are standardised to the middle slice (index 10), identified through pilot analysis of 20 subjects as the mid-acetabular coronal plane where all four landmarks (FHC, NA, LAE, LCP) are concurrently visible with maximal clarity. Future work will investigate automatic slice selection to eliminate manual standardisation. Example paired X-ray and MRI images with annotated landmarks are shown in Fig. 2 . During training, stochastic augmentations include affine transforms (scale 0.95 – 1.05 , translation \pm 5\% , rotation \pm 10^{\circ} , shear \pm 5^{\circ} ) and intensity jitter (brightness/contrast \pm 15 – 20\% , gamma 0.85 – 1.15 ). The training:validation:test datasplit is 65{:}10{:}25 balanced across \alpha -angle distributions given by Kolmogorov–Smirnov testing. This yields 105:17:40 images (57:8:24 patients). We train a UNet++ with a ResNet18 encoder (ImageNet-initialised) independently on the MRI and X-ray datasets. Optimisation uses AdamW (learning rate 1{\times}10^{-4} , weight decay 1{\times}10^{-5} ). Training uses the NLL loss with an ExponentialLR scheduler ( \gamma=0.95

Read the complete text