Rethinking AI in the age of climate collapse: Ethics, power, and responsibility

Julio Vega · 2026

Read Rethinking AI in the age of climate collapse: Ethics, power, and responsibility by Julio Vega (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-18462.txt.

Introduction

Julio Vega asks what we owe the Earth as we build and use more AI. Smart tools can help track ice loss, watch woods and seas, and trim waste in power grids. Yet the tools them-selves burn power, need rare parts, and can shift who holds sway in a town or a land.

Vega pulls those two sides into one frame. He weighs the gains of AI for the fight on climate change next to its harms. He also asks who gets to choose how the tools are used, and who pays when they go wrong. The piece calls for rules and norms that keep the gains while they curb the harms. It is a plea for care and for shared say in how these tools grow.

Catalog record

CREATORJulio Vega
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE15 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-18462

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Rethinking AI in the age of climate collapse: Ethics, power, and responsibility Julio Vega Abstract Abstract The climate crisis requires responses that integrate scientific, ethical, social, and technological perspectives. Artificial intelligence (AI) has emerged as a powerful tool in climate modelling, environmental monitoring, and energy optimisation, yet its growing use also raises critical environmental, ethical, legal, and social questions. This contribution examines the ambivalent role of AI in the ecological crisis, addressing both its promises and its risks. On the one hand, AI supports improvements in climate forecasting, renewable energy management, and real-time detection of environmental degradation. On the other hand, the energy demands of data centres, resource-intensive hardware production, algorithmic bias, corporate concentration of power, and technocratic decision-making reveal contradictions that challenge its sustainability. The discussion explores these issues through interdisciplinary lenses, including environmental ethics, philosophy of technology, and legal governance, and concludes with recommendations for socially just, ecologically responsible, and democratically accountable uses of AI. Rather than assuming AI as an inherently sustainable solution, this analysis argues that its contribution to climate action depends fundamentally on the values, institutions, and power structures that shape its development. Keywords: Artificial intelligence; Climate crisis; Environmental ethics; Sustainability; Algorithmic governance; Environmental justice; Philosophy of technology; Green AI; Regulation 1 Introduction The climate crisis stands as one of the greatest challenges of the twenty-first century. Its complexity demands responses that integrate scientific, ethical, social, and technological forms of knowledge. In this context, artificial intelligence (AI) emerges as a tool capable of transforming the ways in which we analyse, predict, and address the impacts of climate change. Yet far from providing a simple solution, this technology activates ethical, environmental, and social debates that require critical and interdisciplinary reflection. This study offers an analytical and deliberately reflective examination of the role of AI in the contemporary ecological crisis. The discussion spans philosophical, ethical, legal, and social questions, aiming to problematise the growing dependence on algorithmic systems in environmental governance. Although AI has been promoted as a driver of efficiency and sustainability, it also raises risks related to intensifying energy consumption, reproducing inequality, and consolidating technocratic approaches to environmental management. From a philosophical perspective, we must ask how AI reshapes our relationship with nature: does it function as a means toward more sustainable models, or does it perpetuate an instrumental view of the natural world? Ethically, the delegation of sensitive decisions to opaque systems requires examining transparency and fairness. Legally, the absence of robust regulatory frameworks opens the door to uncontrolled uses; and socially, AI’s uneven development generates tensions concerning who benefits and who bears the costs of its deployment. The paper is structured into eight sections. It begins with an overview of AI’s role in climate mitigation and adaptation, followed by an analysis of its direct environmental impacts. The discussion then addresses the ethical and philosophical dilemmas associated with AI deployment, examines the regulatory frameworks required to govern these technologies, and considers the social implications arising from their use. The concluding section synthesises the findings and provides recommendations for fostering AI practices that support sustainability, environmental justice, and equitable governance. 2 AI as a Tool in the Fight Against Climate Change Artificial intelligence has become a key component of the digital transformation of various sectors, including the environmental sphere. Its capacity to process large volumes of data and generate predictions from complex patterns has expanded our understanding of climate change and strengthened mitigation and adaptation strategies. Its contributions include improvements to climate modelling, energy optimisation, and real-time environmental monitoring. In the scientific domain, these technologies have enabled advances in simulating atmospheric and oceanic behaviour using machine learning techniques and deep neural networks. These tools, used by bodies such as the IPCC, facilitate the production of more precise and dynamic future scenarios. At the same time, automated analysis of satellite imagery enables the detection of deforestation, fires, or changes in land cover, allowing rapid responses and improving environmental enforcement. AI has also become relevant in energy management, optimising the production, distribution, and consumption of renewable energy [ 2 , 3 ] . Intelligent systems can anticipate demand, adjust electrical grids, and support the integration of solar and wind energy. Such advances are often celebrated as part of a more efficient transition away from fossil fuels. However, this optimistic picture must be tempered by a critical perspective. The development and application of such technologies is concentrated largely in the Global North, reproducing structural inequalities and generating significant disparities in technical capacity. Simultaneously, AI may be used as a tool for greenwashing , offering superficial solutions that conceal the lack of deeper changes in production models. The transformative potential of AI will ultimately depend on the principles guiding its implementation. For AI to meaningfully contribute to sustainability, it must be oriented by ethical criteria and principles of environmental justice, avoiding unequal distribution of benefits and preventing reinforcement of extractive ecological dynamics [ 4 ] . 3 Environmental Impact of AI Despite its potential contributions, AI generates significant environmental impacts that require rigorous scrutiny. Many algorithmic solutions rely on infrastructures that demand large amounts of energy and natural resources, potentially exacerbating the very ecological crisis they aim to mitigate. This paradox invites a critical assessment of the sustainability of the technological ecosystem itself. One major issue is the high energy consumption of data centres that host training and processing infrastructures. The development of advanced deep learning models requires intensive computational capacity, translating into substantial electricity use. Some estimates suggest that training a single large language model can produce more than 280 tonnes of CO 2 , a figure comparable to the lifetime emissions of multiple cars. In addition, water use for cooling servers poses a serious concern, especially in regions already suffering hydrological stress. Locating technological infrastructure in vulnerable areas can exacerbate socio-environmental tensions, affecting ecosystems and local communities. Environmental impacts also extend to the hardware involved. Producing chips, servers, and intelligent devices requires extracting rare earth minerals and heavy metals, activities often associated with pollution, biodiversity loss, and labour rights violations. The lifecycle of this equipment also poses challenges concerning electronic waste management and planned obsolescence. These tensions reveal a deep ethical contradiction: can a technology be considered sustainable if its development contributes to environmental degradation? Philosophically, this paradox echoes critiques of the instrumental rationality guiding much of modern technological development. In response, initiatives such as Green AI promote energy efficiency, renewable energy use, and algorithms that demand fewer resources [ 1 ] . Although promising, these proposals remain marginal relative to the rapid growth of the technological sector. Their effectiveness will depend on regulatory frameworks that incentivise responsible practices and limit excessive resource use. 4 Ethical Issues in the Application of AI to Environmental Governance The use of AI in environmental management raises far-reaching ethical dilemmas. As decisions are increasingly delegated to algorithmic systems, questions arise regarding responsibility, transparency, justice, and democratic control. These are not merely technical issues but central elements in evaluating the legitimacy of such technologies. The opacity of many deep learning models is a primary challenge. These “black boxes” make it difficult to understand the rationale behind decisions that may affect entire ecosystems or communities. Lack of explainability can undermine basic principles of

Read the complete text