Brauer-Siegel theorem for families of number fields over almost S n S_{n} fields

Anup B. Dixit · 2026

Read Brauer-Siegel theorem for families of number fields over almost S n S_{n} fields by Anup B. Dixit (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-18408.txt.

Introduction

Anup Dixit works on a deep guess about how number fields grow. Number fields are sets built by adding roots of whole number rules to the plain ratios. Two counts rule each field: one counts its ideal groups, and one sets the size of its unit grid. An old guess says how the pair of counts should grow as fields get large.

All past proofs shrink the task, by group tricks, to a known hard case for square fields. Dixit takes on fields whose group is close to the full set of swaps of their roots. That near-full case is the hard core of the guess. A proof here would push the guess close to a full proof for all fields. The work thus marks a key step in a long hunt in pure maths.

Catalog record

CREATORAnup B. Dixit
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE35 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-18408

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Brauer-Siegel theorem for families of number fields over almost S n S_{n} fields Anup B. Dixit Abstract . The classical Brauer-Siegel conjecture describes the asymptotic behavior of the product of the class number and the regulator in families of number fields. All known cases of the conjecture rely on reducing the problem, via group-theoretic methods, to Siegel’s theorem for quadratic fields over ℚ \mathbb{Q} or over a fixed base field. In this paper, we establish a new form of descent for the Brauer–Siegel conjecture. We show that if the conjecture holds for a family of almost S n S_{n} -fields, it necessarily holds for all quadratic extensions over that family, under mild conditions. This result may be viewed as an analogue of Siegel’s theorem in which the base field is allowed to vary. In addition, we also establish the generalized Brauer-Siegel conjecture as formulated by Tsfasman-Vlăduţ for asymptotically good towers of number fields over a family of almost S n S_{n} -fields. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification 11M41, 11R42 1. Introduction Let K/\mathbb{Q} be a number field. Denote by n_{K}=[K:\mathbb{Q}] its degree, by d_{K}:=|disc(K/\mathbb{Q})| its absolute discriminant, by h_{K} its class number, by R_{K} its regulator and by \widetilde{K} its Galois closure over \mathbb{Q} . A classical problem in number theory, dating back to Gauss, is to understand how h_{K} varies on varying K . If one uses analytic methods, it is more feasible to study the distribution of h_{K}R_{K} , which appears in the class number formula. Writing \rho_{K} for the residue of the Dedekind zeta-function \zeta_{K}(s) at s=1 , the class number formula states that \rho_{K}=\frac{2^{r_{1}}(2\pi)^{r_{2}}h_{K}R_{K}}{\mu_{K}\,\log\sqrt{d_{K}}}, where r_{1} and r_{2} are the number of real and complex embeddings of K respectively and \mu_{K} denote the number of roots of unity in K . Consequently, the asymptotic behaviour of h_{K}R_{K} in a family is governed by that of \rho_{K} , which is amenable to analytic techniques. In the case of a family of quadratic fields K_{i}/\mathbb{Q} , Siegel [ 8 ] proved that (1) \lim_{i\to\infty}\frac{\log h_{K_{i}}R_{K_{i}}}{\log\sqrt{d_{K_{i}}}}=1. Thus, \log h_{K}R_{K} grows asymptotically like \log\sqrt{d_{K}} over a family of quadratic fields. In particular, there are only finitely many quadratic fields with bounded h_{K}R_{K} , even though it is conjectured that h_{K}=1 for infinitely many real quadratic fields. This is famously known as the class number one problem. In the rest of the article, following the notation in [ 10 ] , we denote g_{K}:=\log\sqrt{d_{K}} . Siegel’s theorem was extended by Brauer in [ 1 ] , who showed that for any family of number fields \{K_{i}\} with K_{i}/\mathbb{Q} Galois for all i , if d_{K_{i}}^{1/n_{K_{i}}}\to\infty , then ( 1 ) holds. This was further extended to families of almost normal fields by Stark [ 9 ] and Zykin [ 12 ] . Here, we call a number field L almost normal if there is a tower \mathbb{Q}=L_{1}\subsetneq L_{2}\subsetneq\cdots\subsetneq L_{t}=L, such that L_{i+1}/L_{i} is Galois for all i . For families of number fields K with solvable Galois closure, ( 1 ) was proved by the author in [ 3 ] building on the work of V. K. Murty [ 7 ] . More recently Wong [ 11 ] proved ( 1 ) for suitable combinations of the above conditions. In all the above cases, a crucial input is the existence of a zero-free region for \zeta_{K}(s) in a neighbourhood of s=1 . More precisely, Stark [ 9 ] showed that if K/\mathbb{Q} is a number field for which \zeta_{K}(s) has a real zero \beta satisfying 1-\frac{1}{4f(n_{K})\log d_{K}}\leq\beta<1, then there exists a quadratic subfield N\subset K such that \zeta_{N}(\beta)=0 . This reduction to quadratic case is the key mechanism underlying existing proofs. Stark further showed that one may take f(n_{K})=1 when K/\mathbb{Q} is Galois, and f(n_{K})=4 when K/\mathbb{Q} is almost normal. For number fields whose Galois closure over \mathbb{Q} is solvable, V. K. Murty [ 7 ] showed that one can take f(n_{K})=cn_{K}^{e(n_{K})}\delta(n_{K}), where e(n_{K})=\max_{p^{a}\|n_{K}}a and \delta(n_{K})\ll n_{K}^{4} is an explicitly described function. These estimates are sufficiently strong to permit a reduction of such families to that of quadratic fields, where Siegel’s theorem is applicable. For a general extension K/\mathbb{Q} , however, the only unconditional bound due to Stark [ 9 ] allows one to take f(n_{K})=n_{K}! , and grows too rapidly to yield ( 1 ). However, under the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis, \zeta_{K}(s) has no zeros in the region 1/2<\Re(s)<1 and hence we expect ( 1 ) to hold in general. This leads to the Brauer-Siegel conjecture, which we refer to as (BS) and state below. Conjecture 1.1 (BS) . Let \{K_{i}\} be a family of number fields satisfying d_{K_{i}}^{1/n_{K_{i}}}\to\infty . Then, \lim_{i\to\infty}\frac{\log h_{K_{i}}R_{K_{i}}}{g_{K_{i}}}=1. Applying the class number formula, this is equivalent to \lim_{i\to\infty}\frac{\log\rho_{K_{i}}}{g_{K_{i}}}=0, where \rho_{K_{i}} denotes the residue of \zeta_{K}(s) at s=1 . Recent years have seen substantial interest in various aspects of this conjecture, such as its effective versions, see for instance [ 2 ] . In this work, we focus on establishing a reduction-type result in this setting. More precisely, in all the cases where Conjecture 1.1 is currently known, Siegel’s theorem for quadratic fields plays an indispensable role. This leads to the question of whether the Brauer-Siegel property is preserved under quadratic extensions of number fields. Problem 1.2 . Let \{L_{i}\} be a family of number fields for which (BS) holds. For any \{N_{i}\} with [N_{i}:L_{i}]=2 , does (BS) hold for \{N_{i}\} ? This problem may be viewed as a natural extension of Siegel’s theorem, in which the base field is no longer fixed. It is also closely related to Stark’s conjecture asserting that there are only finitely many CM -fields with bounded class number. In this paper, we answer this question in the affirmative when L_{i} ’s are almost S_{n} number fields. Definition 1.3 . Let L/\mathbb{Q} be a number field such that there exists an S_{n} -field K/\mathbb{Q} , satisfying K\subset L\subset\widetilde{K} and Gal(\widetilde{K}/L)\cong S_{m} for some m\leq n-1 . Then, we say that L is an almost S_{n} -field. \mathbb{Q} K L \widetilde{K} S_{n} S_{n-1} S_{m} Figure 1. For instance all S_{n} -fields are almost S_{n} -fields with m=n-1 and this notion captures a much larger family of number fields. Theorem 1.4 . Let \{L_{i}\} be a family of almost S_{n_{i}} -fields. Let N_{i}/L_{i} be quadratic extensions satisfying N_{i}\cap\widetilde{L_{i}}=L_{i} and (2) \frac{\log d_{N_{i}}}{\log d_{L_{i}}}\to\infty. If Conjecture 1.1 (BS) holds for the family \{L_{i}\} , then it also holds for the family \{N_{i}\} . Remark. One may be tempted to extend the above result to families of almost normal fields over almost S_{n} -fields. Indeed, by Stark’s result (see Theorem 2.1 ), it is possible to reduce the problem to a family of quadratic extensions over \{L_{i}\} . Unfortunately, condition ( 2 ) is an obstruction here and prevents this generalization. However, this is not an issue in the modern formulation of the Brauer-Siegel theorem for asymptotically good families introduced by Tsfasman and Vlăduţ in [ 10 ] . We discuss this below. For a number field K/\mathbb{Q} and a prime power q , denote by N_{q}(K) the number of ideals in \mathcal{O}_{K} with norm q . For a family of number fields \mathcal{K}=\{K_{i}\} , we say that \mathcal{K} is asymptotically exact if the following limits

Read the complete text