Joint constraint on the propagation origin of the cosmic-ray spectral knee from energy spectrum and anisotropy observations

Hua Yue, Lin Nie †, Yiqing Guo, Hongbo Hu · 2026

Read Joint constraint on the propagation origin of the cosmic-ray spectral knee from energy spectrum and anisotropy observations by Hua Yue, Lin Nie †, Yiqing Guo, Hongbo Hu (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-17851.txt.

Introduction

Hua Yue, Lin Nie, Yiqing Guo, and Hongbo Hu revisit a long-standing puzzle in cosmic ray physics. Their 2026 preprint is about the knee, a bend in the cosmic ray energy spectrum. No one yet knows for sure what makes the bend. Guesses point to how the rays are sped up, how they hit other matter, or how they spread through the Galaxy.

New data give the team fresh leverage. The LHAASO observatory has measured the proton spectrum with fine care, along with total and composition spectra and the rays' direction spread. By testing models against all of these at once, the authors narrow where the knee's cause can sit. Joint use of spectrum and direction is the key move.

Catalog record

CREATORHua Yue, Lin Nie †, Yiqing Guo, Hongbo Hu
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE40 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-17851

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Joint constraint on the propagation origin of the cosmic-ray spectral knee from energy spectrum and anisotropy observations Hua Yue, Lin Nie †, Yiqing Guo, Hongbo Hu Abstract The origin mechanism of the cosmic-ray knee region remains an unresolved mystery, with acceleration, interaction, and propagation models drawing significant attention. The latest experimental observations of the PeV total spectrum, composition energy spectrum, and anisotropy—particularly the precise measurements of the proton spectrum by the LHAASO experiment—have provided crucial breakthroughs in uncovering its origin. Based on the latest LHAASO measurements of the proton energy spectrum, combined with cosmic-ray spectral and anisotropy data, this study proposes that the spectral index variation in the knee region arises from changes in the propagation coefficient. By introducing a knee position ℛ knee \rm\mathcal{R}_{knee} and an index variation δ knee \rm\delta_{knee} , we construct a rigidity-dependent double-power-law diffusion model to reproduce the knee-region spectral structure. Through modifications to the diffusion coefficient, we successfully replicate the observed knee-region spectral structure in the LHAASO proton spectrum and calculate the corresponding anisotropy. Under current data and model dependencies, a joint analysis of the energy spectrum and anisotropy does not support the propagation origin model of the cosmic-ray knee at a 95% confidence level. We hope that future LHAASO experiments will provide precise measurements of the energy spectra and anisotropies of various nuclei in the knee region, thereby offering a definitive test of the propagation model as the origin mechanism of the knee-region spectral structure. I Introduction One of the most significant structures in the cosmic-ray (CR) energy spectrum is the so-called knee, a steepening feature around a few PeV, reminiscent of a human knee. While the overall spectrum from GeV to \rm\sim 50~EeV follows an approximate power-law behavior, precise measurements have revealed a series of fine structures. These include a spectral hardening near a rigidity of \rm\sim 200~GV ( 88 ; 87 ; 27 ; 20 ; 98 ; 24 ; 26 ; 18 ; 19 ) , softening of the proton and helium spectra at \rm\sim 14~TeV ( 98 ; 41 ; 42 ; 36 ) and \rm\sim 34~TeV ( 28 ) respectively, the knee at \rm\sim 3~PeV ( 70 ) , a second knee near 400 PeV ( 80 ; 46 ; 73 ; 60 ; 13 ) , the ankle at \rm\sim 5~EeV ( 13 ; 16 ; 17 ; 3 ) , and the GZK suppression above several tens of EeV ( 63 ; 100 ; 13 ) . Among these, the knee is particularly important, characterized by a change in spectral index from -2.7 to -3.1, and is widely considered to mark the transition between Galactic and extragalactic cosmic rays (EGCRs). Since its discovery in 1958, the knee has been a central focus in cosmic-ray physics, prompting extensive theoretical modeling efforts to explain its origin. Current explanations for the knee fall into three main categories: source acceleration limits, propagation effects, and interaction scenarios. In the acceleration-limited models, the knee arises due to the maximum energy that cosmic-ray sources (e.g., supernova remnants) can provide ( 94 ) , which scales linearly with charge number Z , implying a rigidity-dependent cutoff. Propagation-based models attribute the knee to changes in the diffusion properties of cosmic rays as they traverse the Galaxy, such as variations in the diffusion coefficient or escape time ( 45 ; 96 ; 72 ; 89 ; 84 ; 91 ; 50 ; 51 ; 49 ) , also resulting in a rigidity-dependent feature. Alternatively, interaction-based models suggest that the knee is caused by interactions between cosmic rays and background particles (e.g., photons or neutrinos) ( 69 ; 48 ; 56 ) , or by new physics beyond the Standard Model in the Earth’s atmosphere ( 83 ; 82 ) . These processes would result in a mass-number A -dependent knee structure. Distinguishing among these scenarios requires determining whether the knee is primarily Z- , R- , or A -dependent ( 67 ) . If the knee depends on A , interaction-based origins are favored. However, a rigidity-dependent knee could result from either acceleration or propagation, making further discrimination challenging. Recent experiments have begun probing this dependence with improved precision. In recent years, high-resolution measurements of the CR spectrum and anisotropy have offered new insights. The LHAASO experiment has precisely measured the all-particle spectrum in the \rm 0.3–30~PeV range, clearly resolving the spectral break at the knee ( 52 ) . Furthermore, LHAASO has reported high-precision measurements of the proton spectrum between 0.1 and 10 PeV, revealing the proton knee structure in detail ( 97 ) . IceTop has extended the proton spectrum above 10 PeV, while KASCADE and KASCADE-Grande have provided composition-sensitive measurements. KASCADE identified the knee as primarily due to a steepening of light components, though inconsistencies remain between different hadronic interaction models (e.g., QGSJet vs. SIBYLL) ( 68 ; 57 ; 38 ) . KASCADE-Grande, using the QGSJET-II-02 model ( 86 ; 85 ) , further identified a knee in the iron spectrum at \rm\sim 80~PeV ( 40 ) , suggesting the existence of a heavy-component knee. If the knee arises from propagation effects, a sharp increase in anisotropy amplitude is expected near the knee energy. Recent anisotropy measurements by AS \gamma ( 31 ; 33 ; 32 ) , KASCADE-Grande ( 54 ) , IceCube/IceTop ( 9 ; 8 ; 5 ; 6 ; 10 ) and the Pierre Auger Observatory (AUGER) ( 15 ) have provided critical data. AUGER, in particular, has measured the anisotropy from tens of PeV to tens of EeV. Its results show a dip structure in anisotropy amplitude near \rm\sim 1~EeV and a phase shift from Galactic to extragalactic directions ( 55 ; 1 ; 2 ) . Above \rm\sim 10~EeV , cosmic rays appear to be of extragalactic origin. Since both spectral features and anisotropies are shaped by the diffusion process, a combined analysis of these observables is essential for identifying the origin of the knee. If the knee arises from propagation effects, a correlation with anisotropy features is expected, whereas an acceleration-driven knee may not exhibit such behavior. In this work, we investigate the propagation origin of the cosmic-ray knee by jointly analyzing spectral and anisotropy data. The paper is organized as follows: Section II describes the methodology; Section III presents the results; Section IV provides a summary and discussion. II Model and method Cosmic rays originate from particle acceleration processes in extreme astrophysical environments, such as supernova remnants, rapidly rotating pulsars, intense stellar winds from massive stars, and energetic microquasar jets ( 74 ; 99 ; 101 ) . These high-energy astrophysical objects accelerate charged particles to nearly the speed of light through mechanisms like shock acceleration and magnetic reconnection, before ejecting them into the vast interstellar medium. These particles then undergo diffusion through the Galactic magnetic field for millions of years, continuously interacting with interstellar matter and modifying their spectral properties. The propagation of cosmic rays is precisely described by the following equation ( 93 ) : \displaystyle\frac{\partial\psi(\vec{r},p,t)}{\partial t}= \displaystyle q(\vec{r},p,t)+\vec{\nabla}\cdot\left(D\vec{\nabla}\psi-\vec{V}\psi\right) (1) \displaystyle+\frac{\partial}{\partial p}p^{2}D_{p}\frac{\partial}{\partial p}\frac{1}{p^{2}}\psi-\frac{\partial}{\partial p}\left[\dot{p}\psi-\frac{p}{3}(\vec{\nabla}\cdot\vec{V})\psi\right] \displaystyle-\frac{1}{\tau_{f}}\psi-\frac{1}{\tau_{r}}\psi. Here, \psi(\vec{r},p,t) represents the density of cosmic rays with momentum p at position \vec{r} , and q(\vec{r},p,t) denotes the source term. D is the spatial diffusion coefficient,

Read the complete text