From Thermodynamic Criticality to Geometric Criticality: A Linear Kernel Map from Matter Susceptibilities to Black–Hole Shadows

Jingxu Wu, Jie Shi and Chenjia Li, Yuwei Yin · 2026

Read From Thermodynamic Criticality to Geometric Criticality: A Linear Kernel Map from Matter Susceptibilities to Black–Hole Shadows by Jingxu Wu, Jie Shi and Chenjia Li, Yuwei Yin (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-17613.txt.

Introduction

Jingxu Wu, Jie Shi, Chenjia Li, and Yuwei Yin link matter traits to black hole images. They build an explicit linear map for that link. Inputs are compact, conserved changes to the stress-energy tensor. The map gives the metric response in static, spherical spacetimes. From there it yields geometric observables. Key outputs are the shadow radius and photon-sphere frequency.

Those outputs are what horizon-scale imaging measures. A direct map lets teams test matter ideas against photos. It skips long nonlinear solves for small changes. Black hole imaging is now a data-rich field. Fast links from matter to image sharpen its tests. The work serves both gravity theory and observation.

Catalog record

CREATORJingxu Wu, Jie Shi and Chenjia Li, Yuwei Yin
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE36 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-17613

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

From Thermodynamic Criticality to Geometric Criticality: A Linear Kernel Map from Matter Susceptibilities to Black–Hole Shadows Jingxu Wu, Jie Shi and Chenjia Li, Yuwei Yin Abstract We construct an explicit linear map from compact, conserved thermodynamic/effective-medium perturbations of the stress–energy tensor to the metric response in static, spherically symmetric spacetimes, and from there to geometric observables of direct relevance to horizon-scale imaging: the shadow radius and photon-sphere frequency. The response is expressed through L 1 L^{1} -bounded kernels written in a piecewise “local + tail” form, which makes transparent the separation between near-photon-sphere sensitivity and far-zone contributions (including AdS tails). Under mild assumptions on the matter susceptibilities near a critical point, dominated convergence transfers the thermodynamic exponent to the geometric susceptibility, γ sh = γ th \gamma_{\rm sh}=\gamma_{\rm th} , with controlled analytic corrections. We further provide AdS far-zone bounds with explicit outside-support constants depending only on background geometric data at the photon sphere and shell geometry. A reproducible numerical pipeline with convergence diagnostics is presented and benchmarked. I Introduction Black holes offer a laboratory where gravitation, statistical mechanics, wave optics, and precision radio imaging meet. The black hole chemistry program promotes the cosmological constant to a pressure and the mass to an enthalpy, yielding bona fide equations of state with critical points and response functions KubiznakMannReview2016 ; KubiznakMann2012 ; KastorRayTraschen2009 ; Dolan2011 ; GunasekaranKubiznakMann2012 ; AltamiranoKubiznakMannSherkatghanad2013 ; WeiLiu2013 ; CveticGibbonsKubiznakPope2011 ; FrassinoMannRudolphSalsi2014 ; HawkingPage1983 ; DolanKastorMannTraschen2013 . In parallel, horizon-scale very long baseline interferometry has rendered the black-hole shadow a quantitative observable; the Event Horizon Telescope and its extensions constrain ring diameter, asymmetry, and temporal variability in M87* and Sgr A* FalckeMeliaAgol2000 ; EHT2019I ; EHT2019VI ; EHT2022SgrA ; EHT2021M87Dynamics ; EventHorizon2024ArrayUpgrades . Against this backdrop, a unifying question arises: can thermodynamic criticality be translated into geometric criticality of observables such as the shadow radius and photon-sphere frequencies, and if so, through what map and with which exponents and error controls? The geometric theory of photon surfaces and shadows has a long lineage Synge1966 ; Bardeen1973 ; Luminet1979 . Modern analyses illuminate the structure of light rings, higher-order photon rings, and interferometric signatures HiokiMaeda2009 ; JohannsenPsaltis2010 ; GrallaHolzWald2019 ; JohnsonLupsasca2020 ; PerlickTsupko2022PhysRep ; OkabayashiYaguchi2023 ; Vagnozzi2023 . The eikonal correspondence between photon-sphere properties and quasinormal modes (QNMs) Cardoso2009PRD ; BertiCardosoStarinets2009 ; StefanovYazadjiev2010 ; Konoplya2020ShadowReview provides a dynamical channel that ties ring geometry to ringdown spectroscopy. Very recently, Kobialko and Gal’tsov developed a systematic perturbation theory for confining surfaces and shadows in static, spherically symmetric spacetimes, expanding the shadow radius to second order around a reference background and identifying the precise metric combinations that control r_{\rm ph} and R_{\rm sh} KobialkoGaltsov2024 ; KobialkoGaltsov2025PRD . These results sharpen how geometric observables respond to weak deformations of the metric. On the thermodynamic side, extended-phase-space analyses reveal rich phase structures and susceptibilities—from van der Waals–like transitions to reentrant phenomena and superfluid analogues—in asymptotically AdS, higher-derivative, or matter-coupled sectors GunasekaranKubiznakMann2012 ; AltamiranoKubiznakMannSherkatghanad2013 ; WeiLiu2013 ; HennigarMannKubiznak2017 ; DeBoer2011 ; Feng2018 ; FrassinoMannRudolphSalsi2014 . The emphasis on response functions near criticality naturally invites a bridge from thermodynamic susceptibilities to imaging observables—yet most shadow studies deform the metric directly, whereas most thermodynamic studies track state variables without an explicit optical map. This paper builds a direct, first-principles thermodynamic-to-optical dictionary . Working in areal-radius gauge for static, spherically symmetric spacetimes, we linearize Einstein’s equations about a vacuum background (asymptotically flat or AdS) and source them with compact, conserved perturbations of the stress–energy tensor that encode either a matter shell or an effective medium consistent with an equation of state. The linearized equations reduce to first-order quadratures for the mass function and redshift potential; fixing the time gauge at infinity yields an explicit integral representation \delta f(r)=\int[\mathcal{K}_{\rho}(r,\bar{r})\Delta\rho(\bar{r})+\mathcal{K}_{p}(r,\bar{r})\Delta p_{r}(\bar{r})]\,d\bar{r} , with kernels written in a piecewise local + tail form. Evaluating at the background photon sphere r_{0} gives a single linear functional for the shadow shift, \delta R_{\rm sh}=\frac{R_{0}}{2}\left[\frac{\delta f(r_{0})}{f_{0}(r_{0})}-\frac{r_{0}\,\delta f^{\prime}(r_{0})}{f_{0}^{\prime}(r_{0})}\right], which cleanly separates near-surface sensitivity from far-zone contributions. The same kernels govern the frequency channel via \Omega_{\rm ph}=R_{\rm sh}^{-1} , producing an internal amplitude ratio |d\Omega_{\rm ph}/d\lambda|/|\chi_{\rm sh}|=R_{0}^{-2} that is independent of microscopic details and can be checked against QNM systematics Cardoso2009PRD ; BertiCardosoStarinets2009 ; Konoplya2020ShadowReview . Two structural facts make the map both universal and practical. The kernels are L^{1} -bounded and the sources have compact support that is independent of the control parameter, so dominated convergence transfers thermodynamic scaling laws to geometry with norm control: if the matter (or effective-medium) susceptibility diverges as |\epsilon|^{-\gamma_{\rm th}} near a critical point, then the geometric susceptibility \chi_{\rm sh}=dR_{\rm sh}/d\lambda inherits the same exponent, \gamma_{\rm sh}=\gamma_{\rm th} , up to analytic corrections whose propagation we make explicit. Moreover, in asymptotically AdS backgrounds the tail integrals enjoy an extra suppression \propto L^{2}/r_{0}^{3} , leading to quantitative outside–support bounds with explicit constants C_{1},C_{2},C_{3} that depend only on background data at r_{0} and shell geometry [a,b] . These properties strengthen far-zone diagnostics beyond the asymptotically flat case and tighten error budgets for numerical pipelines and, prospectively, for EHT-class observations EHT2019I ; EHT2019VI ; EHT2022SgrA ; Psaltis2020PNAS ; Kocherlakota2021 . The approach is deliberately minimal: no symmetry beyond static spherical symmetry; a linear regime enforced by conservation; and a direct geodesic link to observables. This avoids gauge pitfalls and supplies robust far-zone checks familiar from perturbation theory Chandrasekhar ; PoissonToolkit ; VisserBook . It also complements the recent geometric perturbation framework of Kobialko and Gal’tsov KobialkoGaltsov2024 ; KobialkoGaltsov2025PRD : rather than assuming abstract metric deformations, we embed them into a conserved source sector and push thermodynamic critical laws through explicitly computed kernels to the optical side. The outcome is a transparent route to amplitude-level predictions and exponent transfer that can be confronted with simulations and observations Mizuno2018GRMHD ; PerlickTsupko2022PhysRep ; JohnsonLupsasca2020 ; GrallaHolzWald2019 and extended to broader model spaces—including higher-derivative gravity, effective media with anisotropy, and charged or regular black holes Feng2018 ; DeBoer2011 ; AmarillaEiroa2012 ; AyonBeatoGarcia2000 ; GuoGao2020 . II Thermodynamic-to-Metric Map We begin with the areal–radius gauge, adopting signature (-,+,+,+) and units 8\pi G=c=1 . In this gauge the most general static, spherically symmetric metric can be written as \displaystyle ds^{2} \displaystyle=-f(r;\lambda)\,dt^{2}+h(r;\lambda)\,dr^{2}+r^{2}d\Omega^{2}, (1) \displaystyle f \displaystyle=e^{2\Phi}A,\qquad h=A^{-1},\qquad A(r;\lambda)=1-\frac{2\,m(r;\lambda)}{r}-\frac{\Lambda r^{2}}{3}. This parametrization cleanly separates the two metric degrees of freedom most directly tied to matter: the mass function m(r) and the redshift potential \Phi(r) . We linearize about the vacuum background m_{0}(r)=M,\qquad\Phi_{0}(r)=0,\qquad A_{0}(r)=1-\frac{2M}{r}-\frac{\Lambda r^{2}}{3}, (2) so that departures from vacuum are carried entirely by the perturbations (\delta m,\delta\Phi) . Physically motivated sources are localized in a compact, C^{\infty} shell [a,b]\subset(2M,\infty) , ensuring smooth matching to the vacuum geometry outside the shell and eliminating distributional artifacts at the interfaces. The perturbed stress–energy takes the diagonal form \Delta T^{\mu}{}_{\nu}=\mathrm{diag}\!\big(-\Delta\rho,\ \Delta p_{r},\ \Delta p_{t},\ \Delta p_{t}\big),\qquad\mathrm{supp}\,\Delta T\subset[a,b], (3) with an equation of state (or effective–medium closure) that relates (\Delta p_{r},\Delta p_{t}) to (\Delta\rho,\lambda) Chandrasekhar ; PoissonToolkit ; VisserBook ; KubiznakMann2012 . On the static background the conservation law \nabla_{\mu}T^{\mu}{}_{\nu}=0 reduces to a first–order ODE for the radial pressure, \frac{d\,\Delta p_{r}}{dr}+\big(\Delta\rho+\Delta p_{r}\big)\,\Phi_{0}^{\prime}(r)+\frac{2}{r}\big(\Delta p_{r}-\Delta p_{t}\big)=0,\qquad\Phi_{0}^{\prime}(r)=\frac{M-\frac{\Lambda r^{3}}{3}}{r^{2}A_{0}(r)}. (4) Given \Delta\rho and the anisotropy \Delta\Pi:=\Delta p_{t}-\Delta p_{r} , this ODE determines \Delta p_{r} uniquely once we impose the physically natural two–point conditions \Delta p_{r}(a)=\Delta p_{r}(b)=0, (5) which guarantee C^{1}

Read the complete text