Intelligence Requires Grounding But Not Embodiment

Marcus Ma, Shrikanth Narayanan · 2026

Read Intelligence Requires Grounding But Not Embodiment by Marcus Ma, Shrikanth Narayanan (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-17588.txt.

Introduction

Marcus Ma and Shrikanth Narayanan argue that intelligence needs grounding, not embodiment. Recent language model gains revived an old debate. Must a mind have a body to be intelligent? The authors define intelligence by four properties. They list motivation, predictive ability, and understanding among them. Grounding links symbols to the world they mean.

Embodiment entails grounding, they argue, but grounding can arise without a body. That split reshapes what builders must give AI systems. It shifts focus from robot bodies to world linkage. The debate guides research funds and design choices. A clear stance helps labs test claims about machine minds. The paper stakes that stance with care.

Catalog record

CREATORMarcus Ma, Shrikanth Narayanan
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE26 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-17588

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Intelligence Requires Grounding But Not Embodiment Marcus Ma, Shrikanth Narayanan Abstract Recent advances in LLMs have reignited scientific debate over whether embodiment is necessary for intelligence. We present the argument that intelligence requires grounding, a phenomenon entailed by embodiment, but not embodiment itself. We define intelligence as the possession of four properties—motivation, predictive ability, understanding of causality, and learning from experience—and argue that each can be achieved by a non-embodied, grounded agent. We use this to conclude that grounding, not embodiment, is necessary for intelligence. We then present a thought experiment of an intelligent LLM agent in a digital environment and address potential counterarguments. 1 Introduction The relationship between agentic intelligence and embodiment heavily divides the field of artificial intelligence into two broad camps of computational functionalism and embodied cognition. Functionalists believe intelligence is complex information processing independent of substrates and referents, with roots dating to the physical symbol system hypothesis 33 . Recent advances in LLMs seemingly support this hypothesis based on LLMs’ emergent reasoning abilities 53 and impressive zero-shot performance 6 . Proponents of embodied cognition argue intelligent agents must interact with the real world. They argue embodiment is necessary to prescribe meaning to symbols that otherwise lack them, a distinction known as the “Symbol Grounding Problem” 19 . From this viewpoint, intelligence requires coexistence with the dynamics of real-world interaction 5 and comprehension of the rules of physics 50 ; 1 . Recently, a minority view reconciling both positions has emerged. This middle ground argues that virtual embodiment, where agents interact in well-defined physics simulations to build their own world models, can produce intelligent agents 25 . 3 similarly argue language comprehension requires grounded multimodal embodiment but this embodiment can be virtual. We clarify and extend this position: while embodiment, both virtual and physical, is sufficient for intelligence, it is not strictly necessary for it. The critical requirement is grounding : the mechanism by which to prescribe externally consistent meaning to symbols. When combined with interaction, grounding provides an environment capable of producing intelligent agents. 2 Definitions • An agent is an entity with the ability to sense and interact continuously in an environment through a perception-action loop. Critically, agents need not be embodied. A digital agent operates over data and information algorithmically rather than in the physical world. It receives input signals and produces output signals which then influence future input signals. • Grounding is the mechanism for which arbitrary symbols gain meaning 19 through the assignment of consistent, causal values to symbols based on referents existing in a reality external to the symbols themselves. Grounding ties the rules and constraints of the external environment to the symbols that aim to represent it and is how language and all symbolic systems gain meaning 3 ; 2 . • Embodiment refers to spatial presence in the physical world. While an implementation of a computational agent requires substrate hardware such as computers, the agent itself is substrate-independent, as its behaviors are not tied to its physical representation but rather its internal logic. In this work, we refer to non-embodied environments as digital. • A consensus definition of intelligence is widely debated 26 . We opt to define intelligence extensionally, i.e., by defining a superset of traits demonstrative of intelligence such that possession of every trait constitutes intelligence. In Appendix A , we examine five established definitions of intelligence and define intelligence broadly as the possession of four characteristics: motivation, signal prediction, the ability to understand causality, and learning from experience. 2.1 Distinguishing Intelligence from Human Intelligence It is easy to over-define what constitutes intelligence based on bias towards the human experience. Human intelligence covers affect, consciousness, and an ability to create new goals autonomously; however, these are human properties rather than intelligent properties. An uncaring computer algorithm that only does as instructed could be intelligent as long as it achieves its goals effectively. 3 Outline of the Core Argument We posit any agent with motivation, predictive power, understanding of causality, and experiential learning is intelligent. We claim none of these capabilities explicitly require embodiment but do require grounding. We thus conclude embodiment is not necessary for intelligence, but grounding is. We demonstrate how grounding alone is sufficient for a digital agent to possess each property: • § 4 : Motivation requires knowledge of a desired future state and a current state. A pure symbolic manipulation system has no mechanism to assign values to states; value must be derived from grounding to referents in the agent’s environment. • § 5 : Grounding is not required for predictive power. LLMs have demonstrated the ability of an entirely self-supervised computational model to predict the complex signal of human language with incredible accuracy. • § 6 : Understanding of causality naturally arises from the ability to predict, perceive, and interact as the agent learns which of its actions result in changes in the environment. This interaction must take place in a grounded environment with consistent rules and constraints, but this environment need not be embodied. • § 7 : Learning from experience has two requirements: the ability to assign values to environment states and utilization of past experience to understand how to act to yield higher value states. For the first, we reuse our argument for motivation: value assignment relies on pre-established knowledge from an external grounding source. For the second, we reference decades of reinforcement learning research demonstrating that computational agents can autonomously find optimal behavior policies through unsupervised interaction in well-defined environments. We conclude that because none of these properties explicitly requires embodiment, and possession of these four properties constitutes intelligence, embodiment is not necessary for intelligence. 4 Intelligence Requires Sufficient Motivation A core component of intelligence is the ability to accomplish goals; motivation is the driving force that sets goals and measures progress on them. Goal-driven action requires additional information beyond just symbol manipulation, as it requires a relative ordering of patterns of perception as “good” or “bad” with regards to a given goal. A purely predictive model treats all symbols as elements of a set with no relative ordering between elements; it only understands the correlations and patterns between symbols. This information must be grounded to referents that set the implicit or explicit values of specific perceptions, with motivation as the directive to move towards higher value states. 4.1 On Intelligence and Biological Motivation There are several prominent theories that view intelligence as a prerequisite for life and intelligence as rooted deeply into the motivation for survival. Somatic marker theory posits that rationality (and thus intelligence) necessitates physical and biological regulation via homeostasis 10 . Autopoiesis, a theory describing the nature of living systems as a collection of self-replicating and growing components 29 , similarly sees “living as a process [and] a process of cognition” 27 . This could easily lead one to assume that embodiment in the form of an living organism is necessary for intelligence. However, we cannot assume being an embodied organism is required for intelligence just because all existing intelligent agents are embodied organisms. At its core, survival (i.e., maintaining one’s homeostatic state) is just a difficult and long-spanning goal in the constantly changing and novel environment of the physical world. The physical world

Read the complete text