Are Quantum Voting Protocols Practical? DOI: XXXXXXX.XXXXXXX ISBN: 978-1-4503-XXXX-X/2018/06
Nitin Jha, Abhishek Parakh · 2026
Read Are Quantum Voting Protocols Practical? DOI: XXXXXXX.XXXXXXX ISBN: 978-1-4503-XXXX-X/2018/06 by Nitin Jha, Abhishek Parakh (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-17514.txt.
Introduction
Nitin Jha and Abhishek Parakh survey if quantum voting can work in practice. Quantum voting aims for ballot secrecy with public proof of the tally. Its shield rests on physics, not just hard math. Superposition, no-cloning, and entanglement are the core tools. The authors weigh those promises against real-world needs.
Elections demand scale, ease of use, and trust by non-experts. A scheme can be sound in theory and fail at the polls. The survey maps that gap in plain terms. It helps officials judge claims from quantum vendors. It also shows researchers which flaws to fix first. Ballot trust is too key to rest on lab demos.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Nitin Jha, Abhishek Parakh |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 26 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-17514
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Are Quantum Voting Protocols Practical? DOI: XXXXXXX.XXXXXXX ISBN: 978-1-4503-XXXX-X/2018/06 Nitin Jha, Abhishek Parakh Abstract . Quantum voting protocols aim to offer ballot secrecy and publicly verifiable tallies using physical guarantees from quantum mechanics, rather than relying solely on computational hardness. This article surveys whether such quantum voting protocols are practical. We begin by outlining core mathematical ideas such as the superposition principle, the no-cloning theorem, and quantum entanglement. We then define a common system and threat model, identifying key actors, trust assumptions, and security goals. Representative protocol families are reviewed, including entanglement-based schemes with central tallying, self-tallying designs that enable public verification, and authority-minimized approaches that certify untrusted devices through observable correlations. Finally, we evaluate implementation challenges, including loss, noise, device imperfections, scalability, and coercion resistance, and discuss realistic near-term deployment scenarios for small-scale elections. 1. Introduction Like Delphi’s oracle, elections must be beyond reproach. Election protocols, whether electronic or paper ballots, must satisfy two competing security guarantees - maintain the secrecy of ballots, and provide publicly verifiable results. Classical cryptography-based solutions solve this by using end-to-end encryption, scrambling mechanisms called mixed-nets, public bulletin boards, and zero-knowledge proofs. Some of these systems have even seen deployments at smaller scales ( Centrone et al. 2022 ; Kumar and Pathak 2022 ) , mostly in Europe, while the most popular deployment today remains the electronic voting machines with voter-verified paper trails (VVPT) ( Ansari et al. 2008 ; Hughes and Maqsood 2022 ) . The security of classical cryptographic algorithms that support electronic voting protocols relies on the mathematical complexity, and therefore, long-term storage of election data and audit trails can be an issue since an attacker who cannot break today’s encryption can still capture traffic and decrypt it later. While the adoption of post-quantum cryptography (resistant to quantum attacks) offers some promises, it still relies on unproven hardness assumptions ( Mmaduekwe and Mmaduekwe 2024 ) . Quantum voting claims to provide an alternative solution to secure electronic voting based on the fundamental principles of quantum mechanics. For example, the no-cloning principle prevents copying of unknown states, allowing any tampering to be detected. Entanglement allows parties to share correlations that reveal collective properties while hiding individual contributions, helping prevent deanonymisation of individual inputs. Consequently, a quantum voting protocol can be designed so that each voter encodes a choice into a local operation (such as quantum bit rotation) on part of a shared quantum resource, while only joint measurements or public post-processing reveal the overall tally. Probing any single piece of quantum information should not leak meaningful information, and tampering attempts are revealed as noise or as inconsistent correlations. A typical electronic voting protocol consists of the following parties and rules: (1) Voters: each voter holds a credential and applies a local operation (and, in some variants, publishes a small classical share), (2) A registrar (eligibility authority) issues one credential per eligible voter and publishes revocation or eligibility lists. It is trusted for the correctness of issuance, but need not be trusted for tally privacy. (3) A quantum source prepares and distributes ballot states or multipartite entanglement. In authority-minimized designs, the source can be untrusted and certified via publicly verifiable test rounds. (4) A collector (central-tally variants only) performs a joint measurement and posts outcomes with audit data. Privacy should not rely on trusting the collector, while correctness is enforced by evidence on a public bulletin board (append-only, publicly readable), and (5) Public verifiers or auditors recompute checks from the posted evidence. Finally, the minimal trust profile is defined in the following way. Classical communication channels must be authenticated to prevent tampering or impersonation. The registrar is trusted only for issuing one credential per voter and preventing double voting, but not for ballot privacy. Thus, a voting pilot is a limited, real-world trial of the protocol, not a system role. The idea is not to develop one universal quantum voting mechanism but rather a family of these protocols depending on different trade-offs in trust, hardware, and usability. Early work treated voting as a special case of privacy-preserving multiparty computation performed with entangled quantum states. However, later proposals developed self-tallying elections, where anyone can compute the result from public data without relying on a designated vote counter. Some newer designs even try to remove trusted middlemen (the collector or the counter). They use a shared quantum state made by an untrusted source. If the measurement results show the expected pattern, we know things were done correctly even without a designated authority. Another, more practical, approach avoids storing qubits as today’s quantum memories have limited capacities. It uses optical signals that are prepared, sent, and measured immediately, which lowers the difficulty of building smaller prototypes on short links. The use of quantum mechanics principles to achieve secure voting prototypes comes with its own challenges. The theoretical security guarantees are often hard to implement, as physical devices are imperfect: light signals fade and pick up noise in the channel, and parts like detectors or modulators can leak clues through side channels, for example, small timing delays, power spikes, optical reflections, radio noise, or logging artifacts that line up with a voter’s action. By calibration, we mean keeping all sites lined up so the source, modulators, interferometers, and detectors operate within set ranges: clocks stay in sync, optical phase and polarization stay stable, power levels and detector thresholds stay within bounds. Apart from this, theoretical security cannot guarantee societal goals. Coercion resistance, for example, means a voter cannot prove their vote to the adversary to avoid compliance by a voter to the adversary’s demands ( Juels et al. 2005 ) . Therefore, it’s important to clarify where quantum properties can strengthen privacy and verifiability, where they cannot, and how those insights fit into broader election practices. This article focuses on the properties of voting principles: privacy and anonymity, eligibility and one-person-one-vote, fairness, public verifiability, and receipt-freeness with coercion resistance. Quantum protocols achieve these to different degrees and under strict assumptions. In the near term, realistic use often means small networks on short and well-controlled links, where self-tallying and memory-free optical designs use available hardware. City or national elections would require reliable multipartite entanglement or repeater-assisted links, which are open questions for many active research studies. We provide a brief survey of different classes of quantum voting protocols, the advantages of using them, and their practicality of deployment. The article is structured as follows: Sec 2 goes over the basic quantum mechanics principles that are central to the security guarantees of any quantum algorithm, and it also covers the basic theory and elements associated with quantum voting schemes. Sec 3 specifies the system architecture and threat model, including roles, trust assumptions, and security goals. Sec. 4 surveys representative voting protocols, grouped into entanglement-based, self-tallying, authority-minimized, and memory-free optical designs. Sec. 7 analyzes advantages and limitations, with attention to scalability, device imperfections, and coercion resistance. Sec. 6 evaluates practicality and near-term deployment patterns, and outlines integration with classical infrastructure for pilots on short, well-controlled links. It also summarizes open problems and engineering challenges. Sec 8 concludes the work and the several topics covered across the article. 2. Quantum Basics for Voting Before jumping into the details of quantum voting