Flux-ratio anomalies in cusp quasars reveal dark matter beyond CDM

Siyuan Hou, Shucheng Xiang, Yue-Lin Sming Tsai, Daneng Yang, Yiping Shu, Nan Li, Jiang Dong, Zizhao He, Guoliang Li, Yizhong Fan · 2026

Read Flux-ratio anomalies in cusp quasars reveal dark matter beyond CDM by Siyuan Hou, Shucheng Xiang, Yue-Lin Sming Tsai, Daneng Yang, Yiping Shu, Nan Li, Jiang Dong, Zizhao He, Guoliang Li, Yizhong Fan (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-16818.txt.

Introduction

Siyuan Hou and a team of nine co-authors use bent quasar light to test dark matter. Gravity from a galaxy can split a quasar's light into shots. In cusp sets, three shots sit close in a line. Their glow rates should match a set pattern. When they don't, small clumps of stuff may be at fault. Their 2026 preprint checks such off marks in the largest clean set yet.

That set holds seventeen cusp lens sets. The team pits the marks against three dark tales. Cold, self-touching, and fuzzy dark stuff each face the test. Fake lens sims show which tale fits the marks. Such tests can rule out whole dark tales at once.

Catalog record

CREATORSiyuan Hou, Shucheng Xiang, Yue-Lin Sming Tsai, Daneng Yang, Yiping Shu, Nan Li, Jiang Dong, Zizhao He, Guoliang Li, Yizhong Fan
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE78 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-16818

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Flux-ratio anomalies in cusp quasars reveal dark matter beyond CDM Siyuan Hou, Shucheng Xiang, Yue-Lin Sming Tsai, Daneng Yang, Yiping Shu, Nan Li, Jiang Dong, Zizhao He, Guoliang Li, Yizhong Fan Abstract Strongly lensed quasars in cusp configurations provide a uniquely sensitive probe of small-scale dark matter structure. Using the largest microlensing-free flux ratios for 17 quadruply imaged cusps, we combine these with extensive Monte Carlo simulations of mock lens realizations under cold dark matter (CDM), self-interacting dark matter (SIDM), and fuzzy dark matter (FDM) scenarios. Building on this, we propose a region (minor-axis and narrow major-axis cusp lenses) where flux-ratio anomalies persist even under globally parameterized models (”macromodels”) with multipole freedom (capturing disk, asymmetric, or merger-driven structures). Within this region, J1042+1641 is > 3 ​ σ >3\sigma incompatible with both CDM and SIDM. Our results yield a Bayes factor exceeding 100 100 , providing very strong evidence for FDM over even the most optimistic CDM and SIDM scenarios. As only 11 cusp lenses lie within this region, extending to larger samples will be essential for assessing its statistical generality and for decisively confirming these findings with future microlensing-free flux ratio data. keywords Strongly lensed quasars, Cusp configurations, Flux ratio anomalies, Dark matter microphysics, Fuzzy dark matter The fundamental nature of dark matter is one of the most important and long-standing questions in physics and cosmology. The cold dark matter (CDM) framework has achieved remarkable success on large scales, reproducing the cosmic web and the anisotropies of the cosmic microwave background with high fidelity 96 ; 3 . On galactic and sub-galactic scales, however, several challenges persist. Inner halo profiles and the diversity of dwarf-galaxy rotation curves both deviate from simple CDM expectations 67 ; 77 , and discrepancies in small-scale clustering remain under active debate 108 . Independent evidence from strong lensing also point to low-mass subhalos, where analyses of perturbed Einstein arcs tend to favor perturbers with unusually high concentrations 66 ; 20 ; 59 . Moreover, observations reveal an apparent excess of galaxy–galaxy strong-lensing events in clusters 64 ; 98 . These challenges motivate dark matter scenarios beyond CDM, among which self-interacting dark matter (SIDM) and fuzzy dark matter (FDM) have emerged as compelling alternatives. Strong-lensing magnification and flux-ratio measurements can probe subhalos down to \sim 10^{6}~M_{\odot} 70 ; 73 ; 82 ; 101 , precisely the regime where CDM, SIDM, and FDM make distinct small-scale predictions. They therefore offer a uniquely powerful route to testing the nature of dark matter. The cusp relation provides a stringent test of the smoothness of the lensing mass distribution 87 ; 29 . When a source lies close to a cusp of the caustic in an otherwise smooth lens potential, three highly magnified images form near the critical curve. When the source approaches a cusp of the caustic, the signed magnifications of the three merging images nearly cancel, yielding the theoretical expectation R_{\rm cusp}\approx|\mu_{A}+\mu_{B}+\mu_{C}|/(|\mu_{A}|+|\mu_{B}|+|\mu_{C}|)\approx 0 . Here \mu_{A} , \mu_{B} , and \mu_{C} denote the signed magnifications of the three images that merge as the source approaches the cusp. Since the images form extremely close to the critical curve, R_{\rm cusp} becomes highly sensitive to perturbations in the lens potential 62 ; 65 , and this sensitivity grows as the opening angle \phi decreases, thereby strengthening its response to small-scale dark matter structure. In practice, R_{\rm cusp} is an observational, macromodel-independent statistical quantity constructed directly from image positions and flux ratios, while the opening angle \phi provides a continuous geometric descriptor of the configuration. Various dark matter scenarios invoke different mechanisms to violate the cusp relation. In the CDM picture, subhalos and halos along the line of sight perturb the lensing potential and can drive departures from the ideal cusp relation 102 . However, the associated convergence fluctuations remain modest, making it difficult for CDM substructure alone to account for the most extreme anomalies 104 ; 31 . SIDM offers a promising framework for addressing these anomalies by producing a population of dense, core-collapsed subhalos 33 . In SIDM, elastic scattering between dark matter particles drives gravothermal evolution 94 ; 100 ; 2 ; 38 . Halos first develop central cores and subsequently undergo gravothermal collapse, producing compact high-density subhalos that generate pronounced flux-ratio anomalies and violations of the cusp relation. Velocity-dependent cross sections can nevertheless drive collapse in systems as low as 10^{6}~M_{\odot} 106 , even for cross sections small enough to remain consistent with dwarf galaxies 108 . By contrast, FDM suppresses bound substructure and instead introduces wave-induced density fluctuations that perturb the lens mapping 40 ; 52 ; 85 . Alfred et al. 5 used high-precision radio observations to interpret the anomalies in HS 0810+2554, demonstrating that interference-induced fluctuations from FDM can significantly perturb the image plane even in the absence of traditional subhalos. Deviations from the cusp relation have long been used to probe small-scale dark matter structure, but their constraining power among different opening angle configurations has not been systematically quantified. Higher-order multipoles in the lens galaxy, arising from stellar discs, mergers, and boxy or disky morphologies 21 ; 46 ; 42 ; 13 , can generate magnification perturbations that mimic signals otherwise attributed to dark matter substructure 91 . However, their dependence on lens geometry remains poorly characterized, and the extent to which they are degenerate with the microphysical predictions of CDM, SIDM, and FDM has not been assessed in a statistical framework. Previous analyses 61 have generally relied on flux ratios affected by stellar microlensing and have been limited by small sample sizes with narrow opening angle coverage, reducing their ability to distinguish between dark matter scenarios. In this work, we use the latest microlensing-free flux ratios for 17 quadruply imaged cusp lenses (see Extended Data Table. 1 for details), drawn from the GO-2046 JWST program 72 ; 45 ; 44 ; 30 along with radio and HST narrow-line measurements. Combining these data with extensive Monte Carlo simulations of mock lens realizations, we first construct a baseline set of lensing mock data based on singular isothermal ellipsoid (SIE) with external shear models 107 ; 18 , as well as SIE with external shear and higher-order multipoles models 76 ; 81 . The distributions of the macromodel parameters are chosen to be consistent with the observed lens sample. We explicitly compare the mock and observed distributions of the lens and source redshifts, the Einstein radius, the external shear, and the axis ratio (see Extended Data Fig. 5 for details). We then superimpose substructure perturbations based on CDM, SIDM, and FDM scenarios using pyHalo 1 1 1 https://github.com/dangilman/pyHalo 32 on the smooth lens potentials. Using our JAX -accelerated GPU implementation 2 2 2 https://github.com/jax-ml/jax of the PICS lensing framework 58 ; 9 , we generate 10^{8} cusp configurations for Bayesian model comparison. This large ensemble allows us to identify the regions in the R_{\rm cusp} – \phi plane where higher-order multipole perturbations dominate, and to assess how the behavior of several dark matter benchmark scenarios differs (see Methods for details). Substructure perturbations in CDM, SIDM, and FDM scenarios Figure 1: Top panels: Effective convergence perturbations ( \kappa_{\mathrm{eff,sub}} ; see Eq. ( 14 )) induced by substructure in a representative lens with significant m=3/4 multipoles, characterized

Read the complete text