Torsion Obstruction for Conclusive Posets
Bekir DANIŞ, İsmail Alperen ÖĞÜT · 2026
Read Torsion Obstruction for Conclusive Posets by Bekir DANIŞ, İsmail Alperen ÖĞÜT (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-16730.txt.
Introduction
Bekir Daniş and İsmail Alperen Öğüt settle a math guess with a firm no. The guess claimed that all posets have a trait called conclusiveness. A poset is a set with a part-way rank rule. Their 2026 preprint gives a case that breaks the guess. The case leans on twist traits and a famed flat shape.
The authors also sort which small posets hold the trait. They link the trait to the life of outer derivations. Such maps track how a rank rule can shift. Plain cases that break broad guesses are gold in math. They keep the field from years of false trails.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Bekir DANIŞ, İsmail Alperen ÖĞÜT |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 20 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-16730
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Torsion Obstruction for Conclusive Posets Bekir DANIŞ, İsmail Alperen ÖĞÜT Abstract We give a counterexample to a conjecture made by Cigler, Jerman and Wojciechowski stating that all posets are conclusive. We also provide combinatorial characterizations for conclusiveness of finite posets and the existence of outer derivations. 2010 Mathematics Subject Classification: Primary 06A11, Secondary 06A07. Keywords: conclusive poset, derivation, minimal finite model, real projective plane, torsion. 1 Introduction Let P be a finite poset, I(P,k) its incidence algebra over some commutative ring k . A classical result states that the cohomology group H^{n}(I(P,k)) vanishes for all degrees ( n\geq 1 ) if P does not contain any crown subposets ( [ 7 ] , [ 9 ] ). This is an obstruction for the non-vanishing of the cohomology that is independent of the ring k . In a recent paper by Cigler, Jerman and Wojciechowski ( [ 5 ] , Conjecture 3.1 ), it was conjectured that the non-vanishing of the first cohomology, assuming k is non-trivial, is a property that is independent of k (the precise statement is different, we shall explain why it is equivalent). This independence is named as being conclusive . The authors verify the conjecture for posets with at most 10 elements ( [ 5 , Corollary 6.7 ] ). The main purpose of this paper is to provide a counterexample to this conjecture. If a poset admits torsion in its first homology group, then the vanishing of its first cohomology depends on whether k possesses the respective torsion, thus a counterexample to the conjecture can be obtained. In fact, the minimal finite model of \mathbb{R}P^{2} (see Figure 2 ), admits 2 -torsion in homology. Moreover, in [ 1 ] , through computer verification, it was proven by Adamazsek that the smallest poset whose homology admits torsion has 13 elements, which increases the above bound to 12 . A more conceptual proof which avoids the reliance on calculations is given by Cianci and Ottina in [ 4 ] . Although the topological machinery is very powerful, we believe that a purely combinatorial approach is necessary to develop better insight as to why the conjecture fails. For this reason, we give a combinatorial proof of the following theorem that does not rely on topological facts regarding \mathbb{R}P^{2} . Theorem 1.1 . The minimal finite model of \mathbb{R}P^{2} is inconclusive. We also investigate certain conditions that guarantee a poset to be conclusive which avoid homological calculations. We provide a characterization for the existence of outer derivations in terms of the number of edges, vertices and the k -rank of a particular matrix. Hence, a poset is conclusive if and only if this rank does not depend on k . We also provide a generalization for the above classical result regarding exclusion of a crown being an obstruction for the existence of outer derivations. Another condition for conclusiveness arises from the machinery developed in [ 4 ] which provides a combinatorial way of deciding whether the homology of the poset admits torsion. The results assume posets to not include any beat points, that is, they must be minimal finite spaces . As shown in [ 3 ] , the number of elements these posets have must be at least twice of their height. We combine these two combinatorial results to obtain a characterization of conclusiveness in terms of basic invariants of posets. 2 Preliminaries and Homological Tools Let us briefly recall the terminology used in [ 5 ] . Let R be a relation on a finite set S (seen as a subset of S\times S ), k a commutative ring. A function f:R\rightarrow k is called transitive if for every (x,y),(y,z)\in R one has f(x,z)=f(x,y)+f(y,z). Moreover, f is called potential if there exists a function \varphi:S\rightarrow k such that for every (x,y)\in R , one has f(x,y)=\varphi(y)-\varphi(x). Let P be a finite poset on S . Clearly P can be seen as a relation on S . The quadruple (S,P,k,f) is called a transitive system (the original definition only requires k to be an Abelian group, so the whole ring structure is not necessary). If f is a potential function, then it is said that the system can be completed . The poset P is called soluble if for every G and f , the system (S,P,G,f) can be completed and is called defective if there exists an f such that for every nontrivial G , the system (S,P,G,f) can not be completed. Moreover P is called conclusive if it is defective or soluble. In [ 5 ] , authors conjectured that every poset on a finite set is conclusive (Conjecture 3.1 ). There exists a one to one correspondence between transitive functions on a poset and derivations of its incidence algebra (the codomain of the transitive function is the commutative ring over which we consider the incidence algebra). The same correspondence induces a one to one correspondence between the potential functions and the inner derivations (See [ 10 , Section 7] for a compherensive discussion). Hence, being soluble means every derivation of the poset over any commutative ring is inner, whereas being defective is equivalent with the poset admitting outer derivations over every non-trivial commutative ring. One can see that being conclusive is thus equivalent with the fact that the existence of outer derivations is a property that is independent of the commutative ring. Posets where there exists an element that is comparable with every other element do not admit any outer derivation, thus are conclusive ( [ 5 , Theorem 1.7 ] , [ 10 , Theorem 7.1.9 ] ). An algebraic approach that provide a way to obtain soluble posets via several operations including sum and cartesian product of posets is given in [ 6 ] , which provide another way of obtaining classes of conclusive posets. Recall that I(P,k) denotes the incidence algebra of the poset P over a commutative ring k . From the above discussion, the solubility of P is equivalent with the vanishing HH^{1}(I(P,k))=0 of the first Hochschild cohomology group for every k whereas P being defective can be formulated as HH^{1}(I(P,k))\not=0 for every non-trivial commutative ring k . This point of view enables the utilization of topological machinery. Write \Delta(P) denote the order complex of P . The following provides a complete characterization for the notion of conclusiveness. Theorem 2.1 . Let P be a poset on a finite set. Then P is conclusive if and only if H_{1}(\Delta(P),\mathbb{Z}) is torsion free. Proof. Let k be any commutative ring. We have HH^{1}(I(P,k))\cong H^{1}(\Delta(P),k) . The Universal Coefficient Theorem yields H^{1}(\Delta(P),k)\cong\mathrm{Hom}(H_{1}(\Delta(P),\mathbb{Z}),k). First assume that P is conclusive. Since P is finite, H_{1}(\Delta(P),\mathbb{Z}) is finitely generated, so there exists a prime p where the homology does not contain any p -torsion. Suppose that for some integer n\geq 2 it contains n -torsion. Then H^{1}(\Delta(P),\mathbb{Z}_{p})=0 whereas H^{1}(\Delta(P),\mathbb{Z}_{n})\not=0 , contradicting the conclusivity of P . Now suppose the converse, that is, H_{1}(\Delta(P),\mathbb{Z})\cong\mathbb{Z}^{r} for some r\geq 0 . The fact that \mathrm{Hom}(\mathbb{Z}^{r},k)\cong k^{r} for any commutative ring k yields the result. ∎ 3 Conditions for Solubility In this section, we will provide the graph theoretical characterizations for the existence of outer derivations. Let P be