Reducing TLS loss in tantalum CPW resonators using titanium sacrificial layers
Zachary Degnan, Chun-Ching Chiu, Yi-Hsun Chen, David Sommers, Leonid Abdurakhimov, Lihuang Zhu, Arkady Fedorov, Peter Jacobson · 2026
Read Reducing TLS loss in tantalum CPW resonators using titanium sacrificial layers by Zachary Degnan, Chun-Ching Chiu, Yi-Hsun Chen, David Sommers, Leonid Abdurakhimov, Lihuang Zhu, Arkady Fedorov, Peter Jacobson (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-16369.txt.
Introduction
Zachary Degnan and coauthors cut loss in tantalum wave guides with a thin guard film. Their 2026 preprint deals with two level flaws that sap wave energy. The guides are built on high pure silicon bases. A thin film of titanium is laid on the tantalum first. The film is just two units thick in atom scale terms.
That thin film acts as a loss sink for the flaw states. Tests show a large cut in loss from the film. Low loss guides hold waves for more time in quantum gear. More time means more steps can run in one act. The work gives a plain recipe for low loss guides.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Zachary Degnan, Chun-Ching Chiu, Yi-Hsun Chen, David Sommers, Leonid Abdurakhimov, Lihuang Zhu, Arkady Fedorov, Peter Jacobson |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 24 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-16369
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Reducing TLS loss in tantalum CPW resonators using titanium sacrificial layers Preprint: AIP/123-QED Zachary Degnan, Chun-Ching Chiu, Yi-Hsun Chen, David Sommers, Leonid Abdurakhimov, Lihuang Zhu, Arkady Fedorov, Peter Jacobson Abstract We demonstrate a substantial reduction in two-level system loss in tantalum coplanar waveguide resonators fabricated on high-resistivity silicon substrates through the use of an ultrathin titanium sacrificial layer. A 2 Å titanium film, deposited atop pre-sputtered α \alpha -tantalum, acts as a solid-state oxygen getter that chemically modifies the native Ta oxide at the metal–air interface. After device fabrication, the titanium layer is removed using buffered oxide etchant, leaving behind a chemically reduced Ta oxide surface. Subsequent high-vacuum annealing further suppresses two-level system loss. Resonators treated with this process exhibit internal quality factors Q i Q_{i} exceeding an average of 1.5 million in the single-photon regime across ten devices—over three times higher than otherwise identical devices lacking the titanium layer. These results highlight the critical role of interfacial oxide chemistry in superconducting loss and reinforce atomic-scale surface engineering as an effective approach to improving coherence in tantalum-based quantum circuits. The method is compatible with existing fabrication workflows applicable to tantalum films, offering a practical route to further extending T 1 T_{1} lifetimes in superconducting qubits. Reducing loss and decoherence in superconducting circuits through materials engineering is a direct and scalable approach to enhancing qubit coherence, compared to alternative circuit-level approaches such as participation ratio optimisation. 38 ; 5 ; 22 ; 15 By targeting the microscopic origins of decoherence 25 ; 15 —particularly dielectric loss from two-level systems (TLS) at device interfaces 41 ; 8 ; 23 —this strategy enables intrinsic improvements to T_{1} and T_{2} without requiring changes to qubit architecture. Crucially, materials-based methods have the advantage of being readily compatible with existing device layouts and fabrication workflows, making them broadly accessible. The adoption of tantalum (Ta) as a superconducting material has led to major advances in the coherence times of superconducting quantum processors and internal quality factors of superconducting resonators, 12 ; 39 ; 27 ; 32 ; 14 ; 28 including recent demonstrations of 2D transmon qubits with energy relaxation times ( T_{1} ) exceeding 1.6 milliseconds. 4 This improvement is widely attributed to the chemically stable and high-quality native oxide formed on Ta, which plays a key role in suppressing dielectric loss from TLS. 8 ; 27 This confers a distinct advantage over other superconductors such as niobium (Nb), whose native oxide is comparatively lossy. 37 ; 3 However, despite the reduced intrinsic losses of Ta oxides, Ta-on-silicon superconducting resonators and qubits remain limited by TLS losses originating from surface oxides—particularly at the metal–air (MA) interface—underscoring the need for a more precise understanding and control of interfacial oxide chemistry and structure. 4 ; 20 Amorphous Ta pentoxide (a-Ta 2 O 5 )—the primary native oxide phase—grows spontaneously upon air exposure, owing to the highly negative formation energy of Ta 2 O 5 . 16 Although thinner than native oxides on other superconductors, such as NbO x , the Ta oxide still contributes significantly to decoherence through TLS dipoles associated with its amorphous structure. 8 Figure 1: (a) Schematic of CPW fabrication with a sacrificial Ti layer. Native Ta oxide was removed by Ar + ion beam milling, followed by in situ deposition of a 2 Å Ti layer. Circuit patterning was performed using positive-tone optical lithography and CF 4 -based reactive ion etching. Post-fabrication treatments consisted of buffered oxide etching (BOE) and annealing. (b) Surface atomic concentrations from XPS survey scans at stages marked in (a). The Ti layer is retained during lithography and etching, then removed by long-BOE prior to annealing. While oxides can be readily removed through techniques such as chemical or physical etching, their spontaneous regrowth is unavoidable during fabrication and device packaging. This has motivated studies on capping and passivation layers—such as gold, gold-palladium, magnesium oxide and organic self-assembled monolayers—deposited atop superconducting films to prevent or minimise oxide regrowth. 6 ; 1 ; 43 These methods are generally successful in reducing oxide regrowth and improving surface metallicity, however the resulting reductions in TLS loss are modest at best, and in some cases increased due to the added interface complexity on the measured devices. In parallel to capping- or passivation-layers, sacrificial layers offer an approach to modify the underlying film surface without remaining in-place during device operation, typically being removed by selective etching at the end of device fabrication. Materials such as yttrium (Y) 40 and titanium (Ti) 17 have been employed as sacrificial layers—up to 10 nm in thickness—in high-mobility graphene devices to improve cleanliness, simplify large-scale fabrication, and reduce device-to-device variability. Deposited prior to critical fabrication steps and subsequently removed, the sacrificial layer serves to getter oxides and contaminants, and protect the active surface from residue accumulation. Here, we demonstrate a surface engineering approach that enhances the quality factor of superconducting coplanar waveguide (CPW) resonators by modifying the Ta oxide through the application of an ultrathin Ti sacrificial layer, significantly reducing TLS loss at the MA interface and reducing device variability. Fabricating devices with such a sacrificial Ti layer, along with post-fabrication buffered oxide etching (BOE) and high temperature annealing, we observe up to a four-fold increase in the internal Q-factor ( Q_{i} ) of Ta-on-Si CPW resonators compared to otherwise identical devices without the Ti layer. These resonators reach values above 2 million at single photon occupancy, and above 10 million at higher photon numbers. Unlike traditional capping layers, which remain on the device and can complicate fabrication or introduce additional interfaces, 3 ; 6 ; 43 our method uses an ultrathin Ti film as a temporary, removable, and reactive surface modifier. Deposited on a Ta film, the Ti layer acts as a solid-state oxygen getter, preferentially reacting with ambient or residual oxygen to modify the formation dynamics of the native Ta oxide. This alters the interfacial chemistry, leading to a thinner, less defective Ta oxide with reduced TLS density, and therefore a lower MA loss tangent \tan\delta^{\text{ TLS}}_{\text{ MA}} . Furthermore, the Ti layer has a dual-use of acting as a kinetic barrier to (re)oxidation, protecting the underlying Ta during lithographic fabrication steps. From the phase diagram of the Ta-Ti system, it can be seen that alloys are unable to form below 882 ∘ C, 26 preventing detrimental inter-diffusion of the layers during annealing steps during fabrication. After lithography, the Ti is subsequently removed using buffered oxide etchant (BOE), eliminating it from the final device while retaining the favourable oxide modification. The process offers a clean and scalable route to improving dielectric interfaces and is highly compatible with standard thin-film deposition and microfabrication techniques, enabling rapid adoption by groups seeking to reduce surface losses in superconducting quantum circuits. Figure 2: (a) Schematic of the fabricated circuit with five \lambda/4 resonators side-coupled to a transmission line. The resonator CPW has a 5 µm gap and 9 µm width. (b) Complex S_{21} data (points) and circle fit (line) over a 100 kHz span around the centre frequency f_{c} . The scattering data traces a circle in the complex plane (left) and produces a Lorentzian dip in amplitude (right) 31 . Figure 3: Internal quality factor measurements for bare Ta reference samples,