The detectability of bars at high redshift: a case study using Euclid-like mock observations of TNG50 simulated galaxies 2025 The detectability of bars at high redshift: a case study using Euclid-like mock observations of TNG50 simulated galaxies – References
Gustavo F. Gonçalves, Rubens E. G. Machado, R. R. Valença, E. Athanassoula, Karín Menéndez-Delmestre, Thiago Bueno-Dalpiaz · 2026
Read The detectability of bars at high redshift: a case study using Euclid-like mock observations of TNG50 simulated galaxies 2025 The detectability of bars at high redshift: a case study using Euclid-like mock observations of TNG50 simulated galaxies – References by Gustavo F. Gonçalves, Rubens E. G. Machado, R. R. Valença, E. Athanassoula, Karín Menéndez-Delmestre, Thiago Bueno-Dalpiaz (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-16335.txt.
Introduction
Gustavo Gonçalves and coauthors test if bars in young star systems can be seen in fake views. Their 2026 preprint deals with barred star systems through time. Euclid views show bars fall from near space to a past shift of one. The TNG50 sim says bars should stay more oft than that. A clash of this kind may stem from view bias, not true counts.
The team makes fake Euclid like views of TNG50 systems. They then test how oft bars can be seen in those views. Miss rates at high shift would ease the clash much. The case study shows how to fair test sims next to views. It guards teams from false clash claims.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Gustavo F. Gonçalves, Rubens E. G. Machado, R. R. Valença, E. Athanassoula, Karín Menéndez-Delmestre, Thiago Bueno-Dalpiaz |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 64 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-16335
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The detectability of bars at high redshift: a case study using Euclid-like mock observations of TNG50 simulated galaxies 2025 The detectability of bars at high redshift: a case study using Euclid-like mock observations of TNG50 simulated galaxies – References Gustavo F. Gonçalves, Rubens E. G. Machado, R. R. Valença, E. Athanassoula, Karín Menéndez-Delmestre, Thiago Bueno-Dalpiaz Abstract Modern surveys such as Euclid report a decline in the fraction of barred galaxies from the local Universe to z ∼ 1 z\sim 1 , whereas the TNG50 simulation predicts higher bar fractions, in tension with observations. This discrepancy may be due to observational biases in bar detectability when comparing simulations with observations. We present a proof-of-concept study quantifying how Euclid-like observational conditions affect bar detectability in TNG50. We analysed the entire galaxy sample at z = 0.5 z=0.5 and highlight one borderline case with a bar length of 2.1 kpc and strength A 2 = 0.4 A_{2}=0.4 . Synthetic images were produced with Monte Carlo radiative transfer and realistic post-processing, and analysed with ellipse fitting and Fourier decomposition, as well as the recently constructed Zoobot analysis. Results were compared to idealised, noise-free stellar mass maps. In the illustrative case the bar is clearly detected in the mass map and remains visible in the Euclid VIS I E I_{\rm E} filter, where Zoobot also classifies it as barred, but becomes undetectable in Y E Y_{\rm E} and in the VIS–NISP RGB composite, with all methods failing outside VIS. Extending to the full z = 0.5 z=0.5 sample, Zoobot recovers only 31/141 galaxies, while A 2 A_{2} and ellipse fitting perform better (80/141 and 67/141) but still miss many short or weak bars. When non-detections are counted as unbarred, the bar fraction of 44 per cent falls to 12–33 per cent depending on method. These results demonstrate the strong impact of observational effects on bar detectability and motivate bar-fraction estimates which incorporate realistic instrumental conditions across redshift in cosmological simulations. 1 Introduction Stellar bars are common features in spiral galaxies in the local Universe, playing a key role in the secular evolution of galaxies. The observed bar fraction is known to evolve with redshift, reflecting both the intrinsic evolution of bars over cosmic time and the increasing observational challenges in detecting them at higher distances. Progress in this field relies on the combined use of large observational surveys and cosmological simulations, which together provide complementary insights into the mechanisms governing bar formation and evolution. Understanding how the bar fraction evolves with redshift is essential for constraining models of galaxy formation and secular evolution. This is closely linked to the dynamical influence of bars on different galactic components, including the disk, bulge, and halo, primarily through angular momentum redistribution ( 4 ) . Quantifying the observed bar fraction as a function of redshift is a delicate question in its own right, due to the different selection criteria that lead to considerable spread among different observational results. Additionally, comparisons between observations and simulations are even more fraught with uncertainty. Even at low redshift, the exact value of the local bar fraction depends on the classification methodology, instrumental characteristics and sample selection criteria—particularly regarding the inclusion or exclusion of weak bars. For all these reasons, the local bar fraction can range from 25 to as much as 70 per cent ( 7 ; 1 ; 39 ; 12 ; 16 ; 19 , e.g.) . Nevertheless, it is found observationally that the fraction of bars decreases with increasing redshift ( 52 ; 40 , e.g.) . Systematic differences also arise from the visual classification methodology itself. Studies based on Galaxy Zoo volunteer classifications typically report lower local bar fractions ( 39 , around 30 per cent;) , whereas visual classifications conducted by professional astronomers often yield significantly higher values, frequently exceeding 60 per cent ( 20 , e.g.) . This discrepancy is commonly associated with differences in the interpretation and classification of weak bars by citizen science volunteers compared to professional astronomers. Several observational and methodological factors have been reported in the literature as key challenges for reliably identifying bars in galaxies. Spatial resolution is a critical limitation, especially at high redshifts, where small-scale features become harder to resolve ( 42 ) . The choice of wavelength and filter also plays an important role ( 41 ) , as bars are more easily detected in near-infrared bands, which better trace the old stellar population and are less affected by dust obscuration ( 20 ) . Bar size are also important factors affecting detectability. Short bars are intrinsically more difficult to identify and characterize, especially at higher redshifts where their typical angular size becomes smaller and increasingly comparable to the instrumental resolution ( 53 ) . Thus, many short bars may fall below the angular resolution limit of the instrument. If the population of such short bars is appreciable at high redshifts, this would significantly impact the interpretation of the bar fraction evolution. Different approaches have been employed to identify bars in galaxies, each with its own strengths and limitations. Traditional visual classification has a long history in extragalactic astronomy, dating back to early works such as 15 and, more recently, large citizen science projects like Galaxy Zoo ( 29 ; 54 , e.g.) . Quantitative methods based on two-dimensional photometric decomposition are also widely used, relying on tools such as IMFIT ( 18 ) , BUDDA ( 14 ) , and GALFIT ( 44 ) to separate the contributions of bulge, disk, and bar components. Other techniques include isophotal ellipse fitting ( 34 ) , which identifies bar features through characteristic radial variations in ellipticity and position angle, and Fourier decomposition, where the strength of the m=2 mode ( A_{2} ) is often used as a quantitative bar indicator ( 9 ; 16 , e.g.) . More recently, unsupervised machine learning techniques have also been explored as alternative methods for bar identification in large datasets, as we will discuss in the context of the first Euclid data release Q1 ( 24 ) and its initial bar fraction analysis. The Euclid Space Telescope Q1 represents a major advance in our ability to study galaxy morphology from local galaxies at z=0.1 to intermediate-redshift galaxies at around z=1.0 , thanks to its wide-area coverage and unprecedented spatial resolution in the optical and near-infrared. The first public data release ( 24 , Q1;) has already enabled the measurement of the bar fraction in a sample roughly an order of magnitude larger than previous studies covering a similar redshift range, such as those based on the Hubble Space Telescope within the Galaxy Zoo framework ( 40 ) . In this context, the use of unsupervised machine learning models has become essential to efficiently classify the vast number of galaxies expected from future Euclid observations. A example is the Zoobot model ( 57 ) , which was trained on volunteer classifications from the Galaxy Zoo project, based on Euclid galaxy images. During the volunteer classification phase, participants viewed both RGB composites—generated from the VIS and NISP filter channels—and single-channel VIS images, the latter providing higher spatial resolution ( 26 ) . These human-labeled datasets were then used to train the Zoobot, enabling automated classification