Cyclic sunspot activity during the first millennium CE as reconstructed from radiocarbon

I. Usoskin ,, S.K. Solanki, N.A. Krivova, T. Chatzistergos · 2026

Read Cyclic sunspot activity during the first millennium CE as reconstructed from radiocarbon by I. Usoskin ,, S.K. Solanki, N.A. Krivova, T. Chatzistergos (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-16203.txt.

Introduction

Usoskin and coauthors rebuild sun spot cycles of the first thou years CE. Their 2026 preprint uses carbon based proxy data for past sun acts. Direct views of sun acts start in the year 1610. Past that, teams turn to trace data kept in wood and ice. New carbon tests are now fine to pick out the known sun cycle of near eleven years.

The team uses that fine grain to rebuild cycles far back. Clear cycles show the sun kept its beat in that era. They also show how strong each past beat was. That past helps test sun models over long spans. It links earth trace data to sun acts of old.

Catalog record

CREATORI. Usoskin ,, S.K. Solanki, N.A. Krivova, T. Chatzistergos
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE24 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-16203

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Cyclic sunspot activity during the first millennium CE as reconstructed from radiocarbon I. Usoskin ,, S.K. Solanki, N.A. Krivova, T. Chatzistergos Abstract Context. Solar activity, dominated by the 11-year cyclic evolution, has been observed directly since 1610 CE. Before that, indirect cosmogenic proxy data are used to reconstruct it over millennia. Recently, the precision of radiocarbon Δ 14 \Delta^{14} C measurements has improved sufficiently to allow reconstructing cyclic solar activity over millennia. Aims. We present the first detailed reconstruction of solar activity, represented here by annual sunspot numbers, during the first millennium, 1 – 969, CE. Methods. The reconstruction of sunspot numbers from Δ 14 \Delta^{14} C was performed using a physics-based method which involves several steps: using the modern carbon-cycle box model, the 14 C production rate, corrected for the contemporary geomagnetic shielding, was computed from the measured concentrations; The open solar magnetic flux was computed using a model of the heliospheric cosmic-ray modulation; Sunspot numbers were calculated by inverting a model of the evolution of the Sun’s magnetic field. The Markov Chain Monte Carlo approach was used to directly account for different sources of uncertainty. Results. Annual sunspot numbers were reconstructed for the first millennium CE. This period includes one extreme solar event occurring in 774 CE and one Grand solar minimum of 650 – 730 CE. We could identify 91 solar cycles, of which 26 were well-defined, while 24, and 41 were reasonably and poorly defined, respectively. The mean cycle length was 10.6 years, but the lengths of individual cycles vary between 8 and 15 years. The existence of empirical Waldmeier’s relations remains inconclusive with this dataset. No significant periodicities were found beyond the 11-year cycle. Conclusions. This work fills the gap in the solar cycle statistics between the previously reconstructed first millennium BCE and the second millennium CE, providing vital constraints for the solar dynamo and irradiance models. A consistent 3-millennium-long reconstruction of sunspot numbers, based on a composite multi-proxy cosmogenic record, is pending. 1 Introduction The Sun is a variable star, whose variability is an important driver of the terrestrial environment ( 11 ; 13 , e.g.,) , but also serves as a laboratory for testing solar/stellar dynamo theory ( 6 ; 18 , e.g.,) . Solar magnetic activity is dominated by quasi-periodicity with roughly an 11-year time scale ( 14 ) , called the Schwabe cycle. The Schwabe cycle is strongly modulated by secular variability, ranging from the periods of very low solar activity, known as Grand minima ( 9 ; 29 , the most recent being the Maunder minimum between 1645 – 1715 – ) , to periods of very high solar activity, called Grand maxima, such as in the second half of the 20th century ( 34 ; 26 ) . However, the statistical properties of solar Grand minima and maxima are poorly constrained by direct sunspot observations. Several empirical rules describe solar cycle characteristics, such as Waldmeier’s rule ( 38 ) , which relates the strength of a solar cycle to the length of its rising phase. These relations were inferred from direct instrumental observations of sunspots over the last four centuries, covering only 25 reasonably resolved cycles and a dozen additional, more poorly constrained ones ( 7 ) . Consequently, the statistical significance of such empirical relations remains limited. In particular, the question of whether solar cycles operate as a phase-locked clock or rather as a sequence of independent dynamo pulses has remained open ( 40 ) . Indirect proxies in the form of cosmogenic isotopes, mostly 14 C measured in tree rings and 10 Be in ice cores, made it possible to reconstruct solar activity on the multi-millennial timescale over the Holocene ( 26 ; 37 ; 27 ; 1 ; 41 , e.g.,) . However, this method, while reliably reconstructing long-term variability, could not resolve individual solar cycles due to the insufficient temporal resolution of isotope measurements ( 35 , e.g.,) . For example, although several dozen Grand minima and maxima were found during the Holocene ( 32 ; 16 ) , the behaviour of very low solar activity was known only for the Maunder minimum ( 36 , e.g.,) . A major breakthrough in the quality of 14 C measurements was made recently, thanks to the development of accelerator mass spectrometry, which made it possible to reconstruct individual solar cycles from annual tree-ring data ( 15 , see a review by) . The first of this kind was a precision set of annual 14 C measurements covering the last millennium ( 3 ) . A careful analysis of this dataset allowed us to reconstruct 85 individual sunspot cycles for the period 970 – 1900 CE ( 33 ) . A similar precision dataset for the first millennium BCE ( 4 ) led to a reconstruction of 93 solar cycles for that period ( 28 ) . These results provided important constraints on solar dynamo theory ( 2 , e.g.,) . Very recently, the millennium-long gap between the previously measured annual-resolution datasets has been bridged by a high-resolution 14 C dataset covering the first millennium CE ( 39 ) . By applying the methodology developed by us earlier ( 33 ; 28 ) to this new dataset, we reconstruct individual sunspot cycles for the period 1 – 970 CE and present the results of their statistical analysis. 2 Data Several datasets have been used in this work, as described below. Our main data set is the series of the relative concentration of radiocarbon 14 C, measured at an annual resolution in European oak trees for the period 1 – 969 CE ( 39 ) . It is shown in Figure 1 a along with the 1\sigma error bars provided, which are of the order of 1.6 ‰. For intervals with multiple measurement points, a weighted average was used to obtain annual values and their uncertainties. The dataset includes several short gaps (data in the years 475, 573, 804, 805, 809, 928, 929, 944, and 945 CE were missing), which were linearly interpolated, and an enhanced error bar of \sigma =5 ‰ was assigned to the interpolated datapoints. Figure 1 : Sequential steps of the annual solar activity reconstructions for the first millennium CE. Panel a) Raw \Delta^{14} C data ( 39 ) . The red arrow indicates the signature of the extreme solar particle event (ESPE) of 774 CE. Panel b) 14 C production rate Q^{*} corrected for the geomagnetic shielding and ESPE effects. Panel c) Open solar flux F_{\rm o} . Panel d) Sunspot number. Black curves, grey shading and red curves depict the annual values, 1 \sigma (68% confidence interval) uncertainties, and 22-year smoothed data, respectively. Since the reconstruction of solar activity from cosmogenic isotopes involves correction for the geomagnetic shielding, we considered six recent archeo/paleo-magnetic models covering the period of interest, in the form of the virtual dipole moment (VDM) as shown in Figure 2 . As seen, the geomagnetic field was stable and strong (VDM in the range (9 – 11) \cdot 10 22 A m 2 bounded by the AK and K08 curves. Figure 2 : Recent reconstructions of the geomagnetic virtual dipole moment VDM for the first millennium CE. The models are:

Read the complete text