Constraining Nuclear Molecular Gas Content with High-resolution CO Imaging of GOALS Galaxies
James Agostino, Anne M. Medling, Loreto Barcos-Muñoz, Vivian U, Mynor Rodríguez Vásquez, George C. Privon, Claudia Cicone, Lee Armus, Jorge Moreno, Claudio Ricci, Yiqing Song, Christopher C. Hayward, Katherine Alatalo, David B. Sanders · 2026
Read Constraining Nuclear Molecular Gas Content with High-resolution CO Imaging of GOALS Galaxies by James Agostino, Anne M. Medling, Loreto Barcos-Muñoz, Vivian U, Mynor Rodríguez Vásquez, George C. Privon, Claudia Cicone, Lee Armus, Jorge Moreno, Claudio Ricci, Yiqing Song, Christopher C. Hayward, Katherine Alatalo, David B. Sanders (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-16057.txt.
Introduction
James Agostino and a large team weigh the gas near the hearts of two merging star systems. Their 2026 preprint uses sharp CO views of the GOALS set. The two rich mergers hold much mass in their first tens of parsecs. If all that mass were a black hole, it would look too big. That clash with known black hole to host links drives the study.
The team weighs the cool gas from the CO light. Gas mass can then be split from black hole mass in the core. A clean split tests if the black holes are in truth too big. It also shows how much fuel sits near the core. The work aids the study of mergers and their core growth.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | James Agostino, Anne M. Medling, Loreto Barcos-Muñoz, Vivian U, Mynor Rodríguez Vásquez, George C. Privon, Claudia Cicone, Lee Armus, Jorge Moreno, Claudio Ricci, Yiqing Song, Christopher C. Hayward, Katherine Alatalo, David B. Sanders |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 51 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-16057
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Constraining Nuclear Molecular Gas Content with High-resolution CO Imaging of GOALS Galaxies James Agostino, Anne M. Medling, Loreto Barcos-Muñoz, Vivian U, Mynor Rodríguez Vásquez, George C. Privon, Claudia Cicone, Lee Armus, Jorge Moreno, Claudio Ricci, Yiqing Song, Christopher C. Hayward, Katherine Alatalo, David B. Sanders Abstract We present measurements of the cool molecular gas mass around the nuclei of two gas-rich mergers, III Zw 035 and IRAS F01364 − - 1042, whose enclosed masses (M enc ) within the central 40-80 pc would be overmassive if attributed entirely to the supermassive black hole mass (SMBH) and compared to SMBH-galaxy scaling relations. Our gas mass measurements are derived from Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) Band 6 long-baseline observations of CO(J=2-1) and 230 GHz continuum emission at 14-20 pc resolution, which probes below the resolving limit of the previous black hole mass measurements. Subtracting molecular gas mass from these enclosed masses is not enough to reconcile with BH-galaxy relationships, but independently measuring M enc using the cold CO(2-1) gas does shift the black holes down to their expected values. Still, these ALMA data reveal respective molecular gas masses of ∼ \sim 3 × \times 10 7 to ∼ \sim 6 × \times 10 8 M ⊙ within 70 pc of these black holes, which could challenge some black hole accretion models that assume nuclear gas like this has no angular momentum. I Introduction Every massive galaxy in our universe is thought to host a supermassive black hole (SMBH) in its center. These SMBHs typically contain masses millions or billions times the mass of our Sun. Their gravitational sphere of influence is tiny (of order \sim 1-100 pc, the radius of which can be defined as r SOI \approx GM BH / \sigma^{2}_{*} ; see 111 ) when compared to the typical kpc to hundreds of kpc scale sizes of galaxies. Despite this, a number of galaxy-wide properties correlate with the mass of the central SMBH. These are the so-called black hole mass (M BH ) scaling relations, where SMBH mass scales with host galaxy properties like bulge luminosity ( 59 ; 51 ; 66 ; 68 ), stellar mass ( 90 ; 65 ; 61 ; 69 ; 46 ; 10 ; 24 ), and bulge velocity dispersion ( 42 ; 74 ; 96 ; 45 ; 9 ; 68 ). The mechanism driving these relations is not well understood and the search for a physically-motivated picture for the co-evolution is an active area of research (see 62 and 48 for reviews and 11 for a recent study on local galaxies). One of the major uncertainties in placing galaxies on the SMBH-galaxy scaling relations is a precise measurement of the M BH . Even with very-long-baseline interferometry, the region near the event horizon can only be directly “observed” around the nearest, most massive SMBHs ( 39 ). Depending on the target and data available, multiple approaches can be taken to measure SMBH mass. Some of these methods include reverberation mapping ( 25 ; 55 ; 103 ; 19 ), Schwarzschild modeling ( 86 ; 40 ; 63 ; 60 ; 30 ; 42 ; 101 ; 106 ), direct measurements of stellar orbits ( 44 ; 43 ), dynamical modeling of stars and gas in circumnuclear disks ( > 1 pc) ( 20 ; 8 ; 70 ; 99 ; 72 ), and empirically-calibrated proxies (e.g. 104 ; 77 ; 12 ; 97 ). In this paper, we refer to a parent sample of nine SMBH masses within gas rich mergers derived via gas and stellar kinematics in 73 . These enclosed mass (M enc , mass under r = 77 mas from the SMBH) measurements use data from Keck/OSIRIS adaptive optics (AO) and target galaxies from the Great Observatory All-sky LIRG Survey (GOALS, 2 ). In the K-band, these data use the CO (2-0) and (3-1) bandheads to trace kinematics of young stars along with emission from Br \gamma and H 2 . LIRGs (luminous infrared galaxies) emit an excess of light in the infrared ( 84 , L IR > 10 11 L ⊙ by definition;) powered by vigorous activity from either star formation or AGN, or both. Based on the dynamical (M enc ) measurements in 73 , individual galaxies like III Zw 035 and IRAS F01364 - 1042 are significantly offset (by between \sim 0.5 - 2.5 dex) from the canonical black hole mass scaling relations: supermassive black hole mass (M BH ) vs. stellar velocity dispersion ( \sigma_{\star} ), total stellar mass (M ⋆ ), and bulge luminosity (L H,bulge ). Non-LIRG spiral galaxies do not typically lie above scaling relations ( 33 ; 34 ), and whether most LIRGs do remains in question. Overmassive black holes present a challenge to the canonical understanding of gas-rich mergers, which predicts that these black holes will grow more in an upcoming quasar phase — placing them in even greater conflict with scaling relations ( 75 ; 53 ; 52 ). The results from 73 were surprising but came with a caveat: the resolution of the Keck/OSIRIS+AO data does not probe all the way down to the expected SMBH r {}_{\mathrm{SOI}}\approx 10 pc (or less; value estimated for IRAS F01364 - 1042 based on \sigma_{\star} found in 73 and equation 3 of 62 ). Those dynamically-derived SMBH mass measurements in 73 are a M enc within the highest achievable resolution by OSIRIS at a 35 mas plate scale, 77 mas (a Nyquist sampling rate of 2.2; see 71 ), meaning they could include significant extended stellar and gaseous mass. This paper is focused on quantifying exactly how much molecular gas mass exists within that limit, then completing an independent M enc measurement for comparison. 71 performed a pilot study focused on measuring molecular gas mass in one of these galaxies that host double nuclei, NGC 6240. Using Atacama Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) Band 6 CO(J=2-1) and continuum data to measure molecular gas mass, they found that in the northern nucleus, the black hole shifts down to scaling relations after the gas mass correction, as up to 89% of the previously measured enclosed mass could be attributed to gas rather than the black hole. In contrast, the dynamical mass of the southern nucleus consists of up to only 11% gas mass, leaving it above scaling relations. The following work estimates the amount of molecular gas mass in two other gas-rich, merging LIRGs with the purpose of understanding whether or not these galaxies host overmassive black holes. Such confirmation would be further evidence for an accretion paradigm in which the SMBH grows before the global galaxy properties in scaling relations, which is contrary to the timeline of accretion in typical systems ( 54 ; 22 ; 1 ). In this Paper we determine whether the amount of gas present within the resolving limit of the original dynamical mass measurements accounts for the observed disagreement with scaling relations. We then measure an independent M enc using the CO(2-1) kinematics. This paper is structured as follows. Section II details the CO(2-1) measurements obtained from the ALMA and how the imaging process of these measurements was conducted. Section IV explains how we calculated molecular gas mass