Dancing in Chains: Strategic Persuasion in Academic Rebuttal via Theory of Mind
Zhitao He, Zongwei Lyu, Yi R. (May) FungHong Kong University of Science and Technology [email protected], [email protected] · 2026
Read Dancing in Chains: Strategic Persuasion in Academic Rebuttal via Theory of Mind by Zhitao He, Zongwei Lyu, Yi R. (May) FungHong Kong University of Science and Technology [email protected], [email protected] (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-15715.txt.
Introduction
Zhitao He, Zongwei Lyu, and Yi R. Fung study academic rebuttal as a persuasion game in a 2026 arXiv paper. AI now helps at many stages of research. Rebuttal, the reply to reviewers, remains underexplored. It is not a plain technical debate. Authors must persuade under severe information asymmetry. They do not know exactly what each reviewer thinks or values.
The title frames their approach: strategic persuasion via theory of mind. Theory of mind means modeling the other side's beliefs. A good rebuttal guesses what worries a reviewer and answers that. The paper's title, Dancing in Chains, hints at the constraints authors feel. For researchers, rebuttal skill can decide a paper's fate. A formal account of that skill could help both humans and AI assistants.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Zhitao He, Zongwei Lyu, Yi R. (May) FungHong Kong University of Science and Technology [email protected], [email protected] |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 90 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-15715
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Dancing in Chains: Strategic Persuasion in Academic Rebuttal via Theory of Mind Zhitao He, Zongwei Lyu, Yi R. (May) FungHong Kong University of Science and Technology [email protected], [email protected] Abstract Although artificial intelligence (AI) has become deeply integrated into various stages of the research workflow and achieved remarkable advancements, academic rebuttal remains a significant and underexplored challenge. This is because rebuttal is a complex process of strategic communication under severe information asymmetry rather than a simple technical debate. Consequently, current approaches struggle as they largely imitate surface-level linguistics, missing the essential element of perspective-taking required for effective persuasion. In this paper, we introduce RebuttalAgent , the first framework to ground academic rebuttal in Theory of Mind (ToM), operationalized through a ToM-Strategy-Response (TSR) pipeline that models reviewer mental state, formulates persuasion strategy, and generates strategy-grounded response. To train our agent, we construct RebuttalBench , a large-scale dataset synthesized via a novel critique-and-refine approach. Our training process consists of two stages, beginning with a supervised fine-tuning phase to equip the agent with ToM-based analysis and strategic planning capabilities, followed by a reinforcement learning phase leveraging the self-reward mechanism for scalable self-improvement. For reliable and efficient automated evaluation, we further develop Rebuttal-RM , a specialized evaluator trained on over 100K samples of multi-source rebuttal data, which achieves scoring consistency with human preferences surpassing powerful judge GPT-4.1. Extensive experiments show RebuttalAgent significantly outperforms the base model by an average of 18.3% on automated metrics, while also outperforming advanced proprietary models across both automated and human evaluations. Disclaimer: the generated rebuttal content is for reference only to inspire authors and assist in drafting. It is not intended to replace the author’s own critical analysis and response. 1 1 1 Our code and models: https://github.com/Zhitao-He/RebuttalAgent $\dagger$ $\dagger$ footnotetext: Equal contribution 1 Introduction Large language models (LLMs) are profoundly reshaping the entire research workflow ( 38 ; 40 ; 5 ) , from acting as a powerful tool for auxiliary tasks such as literature summarization ( 11 ; 30 ) and data visualization ( 56 ; 60 ) , to serving as a collaborative partner in core tasks such as hypothesis formulation ( 53 ; 41 ; 23 ) and experimental design ( 54 ; 25 ) , and even functioning as an autonomous author of complete scientific papers that successfully pass human peer review ( 58 ; 49 ) . While LLMs have become an indispensable collaborator in most stages of research, its role in the critical phase of academic rebuttal remains underexplored. From a game-theoretic perspective, the academic rebuttal process is not a simple technical debate but rather a classic Dynamic Game of Incomplete Information ( 1 ; 12 ; 42 ) . In this process, authors must persuade reviewers under severe information asymmetry , whereby they are unaware of the reviewers’ knowledge base, intrinsic biases, or the cascading effects of their responses. Current approaches for addressing this challenge, which primarily rely on Supervised Fine-tuning (SFT) on review datasets ( 67 ) , suffer from the fundamental limitations of direct imitation. These models excel at mimicking surface-level linguistic patterns, resulting in responses that are superficially polite but often formulaic and lack strategic depth. This failure stems from their inability to perform the strategic, perspective-taking reasoning demanded by the game-theoretic structure of rebuttal. In practice, a successful rebuttal transcends superficial politeness and is, at its core, an exercise in strategic reasoning ( 18 ; 43 ; 36 ) . This requires a complex analysis of trade-offs, such as when to concede, when to stand firm, when to provide new evidence, or when to reframe the narrative. Successfully navigating these trade-offs depends on the ability to perceive the mind of the other, a capacity known in cognitive science as Theory of Mind (ToM) ( 57 ; 33 ; 14 ) . ToM involves modeling the internal states of others, such as their beliefs, intentions, and differing perspectives, to understand and predict their actions. Grounded in this mental model, an author can then model a reviewer’s specific internal state, such as their knowledge background, potential biases, and core concerns, to strategically allocate the limited response space, distinguishing between core critiques that warrant direct rebuttal and minor points that can be tactfully reframed. In this paper, we propose RebuttalAgent , the first model to integrate Theory of Mind into academic rebuttal. RebuttalAgent employs a novel three-stage generation framework we term ToM-Strategy-Response (TSR) , which decomposes the complex task of rebuttal into a coherent series of reasoning and generation steps. Specifically, the initial Theory-of-Mind (T) stage comprises a hierarchical analysis to discern macro-level reviewer intent while deconstructing the micro-level attributes of each comment. This analysis constructs a multi-dimensional reviewer profile designed to inform both global strategy and local tactics. Subsequently, the Strategy (S) stage utilizes this profile to formulate an actionable plan for the target comment, which aligns the response strategy with both the macro- and micro-level critiques from the reviewer. The process concludes with the Response (R) stage, which achieves context-aware synthesis by integrating the reviewer profile, the plan, and pre-retrieved evidential chunks from the original manuscript, thereby generating a persuasive response. To train RebuttalAgent with these complex reasoning capabilities, we construct RebuttalBench , a large-scale synthetic dataset of over 70K high-quality samples. This dataset is created via a critique-and-refine pipeline using multiple powerful teacher models, with each sample containing a complete TSR chain. Our training process begins with Supervised Fine-tuning to instill the agent with foundational rebuttal capabilities, and then advances the agent’s ToM-based analysis and sophisticated strategic policies via Reinforcement Learning (RL), which is optimized by a novel self-reward mechanism that enables scalable self-improvement without requiring a separate, external reward model during training. For reliable and efficient automated evaluation, we further develop a specialized evaluator called the Rebuttal-Reward Model ( Rebuttal-RM ). Built upon Qwen3-8B, this model is trained on a diverse, multi-source dataset of over 100K samples, which achieves high scoring consistency with human preferences, significantly surpassing the powerful judge GPT-4.1. In summary, our main contributions are as follows: • We introduce RebuttalAgent , the first framework to leverage Theory of Mind (ToM) for academic rebuttal. Our agent employs a novel ToM-Strategy-Response (TSR) pipeline. By explicitly modeling the reviewer’s perspective, identifying key concerns, and suggesting grounded responses with adaptive strategic reasoning, our agent aims to help authors communicate more clearly and effectively and move beyond formulaic responses. • We construct RebuttalBench , a large-scale dataset of over 70K high-quality samples created via our critique-and-refine pipeline, with each sample containing a ToM-strategy-response chain. Building on the foundational ToM-based reasoning and rebuttal capabilities through SFT, we further optimize the analysis and strategic policies of agent using RL with our Self-reward mechanism, enabling scalable policy refinement without external reward model. • To conduct reliable and efficient evaluation, we develop Rebuttal-RM , a specialized evaluator that achieved high scoring consistency with human experts. Extensive experiments show RebuttalAgent outperforms the base model by an average of 18.3%, and shows performance comparable to advanced proprietary across both automated and human evaluation. 2 Task Formulation In this section, we define the task of academic rebuttal. The core objective is to generate a convincing response to the target comment. Formally, the input of this task