Computational Representations of Character Significance in Novels
Haaris Mian, Melanie Subbiah, Sharon Marcus, Nora Shaalan, Kathleen McKeown · 2026
Read Computational Representations of Character Significance in Novels by Haaris Mian, Melanie Subbiah, Sharon Marcus, Nora Shaalan, Kathleen McKeown (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-15508.txt.
Introduction
Haaris Mian and four co-authors rethink how to measure a character's weight in a novel in a 2026 arXiv paper. Most models score characters by their presence in scenes. They count actions, named mentions, and lines of dialogue. That lens favors the character who shows up most. The main character wins by default under such counts.
The authors argue that presence alone misses much of what makes a character matter. A figure can shape a plot while rarely on stage. Their work builds computational representations of character significance that go further. The abstract frames the flaw more than the fix, so details rest in the full text. For digital humanities, the stakes are clear. Better measures of significance mean better maps of how stories work.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Haaris Mian, Melanie Subbiah, Sharon Marcus, Nora Shaalan, Kathleen McKeown |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 62 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-15508
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Computational Representations of Character Significance in Novels Haaris Mian, Melanie Subbiah, Sharon Marcus, Nora Shaalan, Kathleen McKeown Abstract Characters in novels have typically been modeled based on their presence in scenes in narrative—considering aspects like their actions, named mentions, and dialogue. This conception of character places significant emphasis on the main character who is present in the most scenes. In this work, we instead adopt a framing developed from a new literary theory proposing a six-component structural model of character. This model enables a comprehensive approach to character that accounts for the narrator / character distinction and includes a component neglected by prior methods, discussion by other characters. We compare general-purpose LLMs with task-specific transformers for operationalizing this model of character on major 19th-century British realist novels. Our methods yield both component-level and graph representations of character discussion. We then demonstrate that these representations allow us to approach literary questions at scale from a new computational lens. Specifically, we explore Woloch’s classic “the one vs the many" theory of character centrality and the gendered dynamics of character discussion. 1 Introduction When reading a novel, we typically come away with a sense of who the main character is, but even novels with singular lead protagonists have many other significant characters. Traditional literary theory classifies characters as major and minor 15 ; 40 , but many characters blur this distinction. For a given character, we aim to quantify how much “space" the character occupies in the story, thereby quantifying their significance. A substantial portion of computational work on character has focused on social networks extracted from the text through character co-occurrence 2 or dialogue exchange 12 . While these analyses are useful, they construct character significance almost exclusively through interaction: a character takes up space through co-occurrence or dialogue with others. This idea is somewhat contradictory to Woloch’s prominent literary theory of "the one vs. the many" 40 . Woloch argues that narratives are “structured around the relationship between one central individual who dominates the story and a host of subordinate figures who jostle for, and within, the limited space that remains." This frames character prominence as a zero-sum game; other characters must be suppressed to elevate the central figure 35 . We collaborate with researchers in English and Comparative Literature who have developed a six-component model of individual character significance in novels. These components bring into focus how characters take up space beyond physical presence in scenes. For example, interiority is a component measuring the expression of the character’s voiced and unvoiced thoughts and feelings. There is also a component measuring mentions of a character in dialogue from other characters ( discussion by other characters ), which foregrounds other characters’ interest in them. We use this component-based definition to develop computational representations of character significance. In addition, we leverage the discussion by other characters component to develop a new type of social graph. We explore how discussion by other characters forms a directed “discussion" graph, which can bring a new view to character centrality in novels. We use this representation to answer literary analytic questions about the gendered aspects of character discussion. We also compare count-based measures of character significance with network-based measures and highlight how varying definitions of taking up narrative “space" lead to differing rankings of prominence in the narrative. The core contributions of our work are: • Framing character representations with a six-component model of character, developed in literary theory 21 and releasing an accompanying dataset of expert-annotated component scores. • Developing and releasing a pipeline that can accurately label these components across 19th-century novels 1 1 1 Data and code available at github.com/haarisamian/tagging-gutenberg . and create character representations, including component-based frequency counts and a new network representation. • Using these representations to perform a corpus-level analysis addressing questions in literary theory around how characters are centered in novels. 2 Related Work 29 comprehensively categorize the use of NL techniques for literary theory; our work fits most closely within the category of agents , foregrounding the centrality of characters. Recently, 39 investigate how well LLMs understand literary texts by prompting them to retrieve quotations from a novel. They find that while large, closed source models do well overall, all models struggle with difficult scenarios. Their work clearly shows that further modeling work is required if LLMs are to perform well on literary analysis tasks. Our work, like 39 , examines whether LLMs can be used to successfully carry out this analysis. Unsurprisingly, given the importance of characters in literary theory, other research focuses solely on detection of characters and their attributes 5 ; 33 ; 30 . Work by 2 assesses cascading, pipelined methods for identifying characters, demonstrating the need for better coreference approaches. They find that traditional pipelined methods outperform LLMs in terms of recall. Other work 38 focuses on grounding characters to their narrative locations and uses these results to analyze literary hypotheses (e.g., showing that protagonists are more mobile than minor characters). This line of work has yielded a valuable resource for identifying characters in the form of a corpus of character coreference annotations 3 . Additionally, there is a substantial body of work extracting and analyzing character networks from literary texts. 19 provide a survey of character network extraction and analysis methods. Foundational work by 27 introduced network analysis as a tool for literary criticism, using manually annotated networks to analyze narrative structure in Hamlet. Subsequent work has automated network construction through co-occurrence ( 10 ) and dialogue detection ( 13 ; 12 ) , enabling analysis at larger scales ( 18 ) . A key finding is that character networks often exhibit small-world and scale-free properties ( 20 ) , a phenomenon common to both literary and other natural social networks. Centrality measures have been used to identify protagonists and analyze character prominence ( 9 ; 23 ; 1 ) . Our work extends this research by grounding network analysis in a component-based theory of character, more specifically the relational “discussion" component we propose in Section 3, which offers a new line of analysis not covered by prior co-occurrence or dialogue approaches. While 37 investigate information propogation in social networks and their gendered dynamics, no principled investigation has been done of the propagation of information specifically focusing on the discussion of other characters and the gendered dynamics of such discussion as we present here. 3 Narrative Components of Character Pride and Prejudice Jane Eyre N A C I DC DN N A C I DC DN Avg. per chapter 52.3 29.9 23.1 32.9 60.3 7.7 67.1 143.5 79.9 110.2 88.7 22.1 Avg. per character 58.0 33.1 25.6 36.5 66.9 8.5 15.2 32.5 18.1 24.9 20.1 5.0 Total 3192 1823 1409 2006 3679 467 2548 5453 3038 4186 3371 839 Table 1: Component score summary statistics across the two hand-counted novels in our corpus. Our team includes literary researchers, who have developed an original model of character significance. In the past, scholars of character have focused on: 1) Character types (e.g. hero, helper, antagonist) or social roles (e.g., artist, teacher, banker) 32 , 2) Character prominence (e.g., major vs. minor 40 , flat vs. round 15 ; 14 , and 3) Realism 6 .