Vibe Coding Kills Open Source

Miklós Koren, Gábor Békés, Julian Hinz, Aaron Lohmann · 2026

Read Vibe Coding Kills Open Source by Miklós Koren, Gábor Békés, Julian Hinz, Aaron Lohmann (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-15494.txt.

Introduction

Miklós Koren, Gábor Békés, Julian Hinz, and Aaron Lohmann study how AI coding changes open source in a 2026 arXiv paper. Generative AI is reshaping how software gets made and used. In vibe coding, an AI agent builds software for the user. It picks and assembles open-source parts on its own. Users often never read the docs or talk to maintainers.

That shift can weaken the feedback loop open source relies on. Fewer bug reports and less contact mean less support for maintainers. The authors study the equilibrium effects on the whole ecosystem. Their title states the worry bluntly: vibe coding kills open source. The paper tests that claim with economic reasoning. Funders and maintainers alike have a stake in the answer.

Catalog record

CREATORMiklós Koren, Gábor Békés, Julian Hinz, Aaron Lohmann
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE70 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-15494

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Vibe Coding Kills Open Source Thanks: We thank Gergely Orosz, Eduardo Arino de la Rubia and Kevin Xu for helpful comments. This project was funded by the European Research Council (ERC Advanced Grant agreement number 101097789). The views expressed in this research are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official view of the European Union or the European Research Council. Project no. 144193 has been implemented with the support provided by the Ministry of Culture and Innovation of Hungary from the National Research, Development and Innovation Fund, financed under the KKP_22 funding scheme. Békés thanks NRDIF for financial support under OTKA Project #147121 . Miklós Koren, Gábor Békés, Julian Hinz, Aaron Lohmann Abstract Generative AI is changing how software is produced and used. In vibe coding, an AI agent builds software by selecting and assembling open-source software (OSS), often without users directly reading documentation, reporting bugs, or otherwise engaging with maintainers. We study the equilibrium effects of vibe coding on the OSS ecosystem. We develop a model with endogenous entry and heterogeneous project quality in which OSS is a scalable input into producing more software. Users choose whether to use OSS directly or through vibe coding. Vibe coding raises productivity by lowering the cost of using and building on existing code, but it also weakens the user engagement through which many maintainers earn returns. When OSS is monetized only through direct user engagement, greater adoption of vibe coding lowers entry and sharing, reduces the availability and quality of OSS, and reduces welfare despite higher productivity. Sustaining OSS at its current scale under widespread vibe coding requires major changes in how maintainers are paid. JEL Codes: O33, L86, D85 Keywords: Open Source Software, Artificial Intelligence, Network Externalities, Nested Logit, Software Economics 1 Introduction Generative AI is reshaping software development. AI coding assistants such as Claude Code, Cursor, and Lovable let users translate intent into working applications with little or no manual coding. This AI-mediated mode of building software is often called “vibe coding.” Vibe coding reduces the cost of producing software, but it also changes how users interact with the software ecosystem. Traditionally, a developer selects packages, reads documentation, and interacts with maintainers and other users. Under vibe coding, an AI agent can select, compose, and modify packages end-to-end, and the human developer may not know which upstream components were used. This shift raises a general equilibrium question about the sustainability of open source software (OSS). OSS is a nonrival input into producing more software, and it generates large social value relative to its direct production cost ( Hoffmann et al. 2024 ) . Yet many OSS projects rely on visibility and engagement from direct users—documentation visits, bug reports, public Q&A, and reputation—to sustain maintenance and capture private returns ( Lerner and Tirole 2002 ; Jones 2020 ) . If AI mediation substitutes for direct interaction, then the technology that makes software easier to use may simultaneously erode the engagement-based channel that funds and motivates its supply. We ask whether the productivity gains from vibe coding outweigh the loss of appropriable demand once developer entry and selection respond. We build a tractable model of the OSS ecosystem in the spirit of monopolistic competition with endogenous variety ( Krugman 1980 ) and heterogeneous-project selection ( Melitz 2003 ) . Developers incur an up-front development cost before project quality is realized, draw project quality from a Pareto distribution, and then decide whether to release the project as OSS by paying a fixed sharing cost. Users value variety and choose among available packages under a discrete-choice demand system. In addition, after selecting a package, users choose whether to interact with it directly or through an AI agent. This nested choice captures that vibe coding is a usage technology that affects both user utility and the degree of engagement that maintainers can monetize. Vibe coding affects the OSS ecosystem through two channels. The first is a productivity channel: by reducing the effective cost of using a given package, AI raises user utility and lowers the cost of producing new software that builds on existing components. Even before state-of-the-art vibe coding tools, field experiments documented sizable productivity gains from AI coding assistance ( Peng et al. 2023 ; Cui et al. 2025 ) . The second is a demand-diversion channel: when users rely on AI agents rather than direct interaction, maintainers capture less engagement and therefore less private return per unit of usage. These channels interact because entry and sharing are endogenous. Better usage technology raises the value of the ecosystem as an intermediate input and would tend to increase entry. But a contraction in monetizable engagement shrinks the effective market for OSS maintainers and discourages sharing and entry. Since “customer demand motivates the supply of energy that drives software ecosystems” ( Jones 2020 ) , a technology that alters how demand is expressed can reshape supply even if total usage rises. Our main result is that under traditional OSS business models, where maintainers primarily monetize direct user engagement (higher visibility leading to paid opportunities or other forms of appreciation), higher adoption of vibe coding reduces OSS provision and lowers welfare. In the long-run equilibrium, mediated usage erodes the revenue base that sustains OSS, raises the quality threshold for sharing, and reduces the mass of shared packages. Variety shrinks and the average quality of shared OSS falls, so user utility can decline despite better AI. The decline can be rapid because the same magnification mechanism that amplifies positive shocks to software demand also amplifies negative shocks to monetizable engagement. In other words, feedback loops that once accelerated growth now accelerate contraction. The key intuition behind the negative channel is that when mediated adoption is responsive to AI capability, direct engagement can fall faster than development costs decline. Utility falls because entry decisions generate a business-stealing externality: when a new package enters, it attracts users away from existing packages, but the entrant does not internalize that this diversion reduces the engagement-based returns that other maintainers rely on. The strength of this diversion depends on how responsive users are to improvements in AI capability: when AI tools get better, how quickly do users switch away from direct interaction? The rapid diffusion of AI coding assistants suggests high responsiveness; in the policy section, we discuss how to quantify it using adoption and usage data ( Demirer et al. 2025 ) . We also analyze two extensions. First, we consider a benchmark in which vibe coding is used only by professional software developers and does not directly mediate final-user consumption. In this case, the demand-diversion channel is absent: AI lowers development costs without eroding engagement-based monetization. The equilibrium features higher entry and higher average quality of shared OSS. This benchmark helps interpret short-run dynamics in which AI is primarily a developer productivity tool, while vendors increasingly target non-developer users as well ( Anthropic 2026 ) . Second, we allow for alternative monetization arrangements and ask what is the lowest per-user monetization that sustain OSS entry at its current level. This can be lower than the current level, because the increase in productivity partly offsets the loss of developer reward. But, under plausible parameters, per-user monetization must

Read the complete text