Flocking by stopping – a novel mechanism of emergent order in collective movement
Yogesh Kumar KC, Arshed Nabeel, Srikanth Iyer, Vishwesha Guttal · 2026
Read Flocking by stopping – a novel mechanism of emergent order in collective movement by Yogesh Kumar KC, Arshed Nabeel, Srikanth Iyer, Vishwesha Guttal (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-15362.txt.
Introduction
Yogesh Kumar KC, Arshed Nabeel, Srikanth Iyer, and Vishwesha Guttal find order in a flock whose members copy by stopping. Their 2026 arXiv paper deals with collective movement, seen across nature. Local rules between neighbors can yield coherent global motion.
Classic models average the headings of many neighbors. In small flocks, noise alone can create order, with each bird copying one random neighbor. The authors add a fresh mechanism: flocking by stopping. An individual's pause, cued by a neighbor, helps the whole group align into ordered, shared, lasting group motion in the end.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yogesh Kumar KC, Arshed Nabeel, Srikanth Iyer, Vishwesha Guttal |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 32 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-15362
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Flocking by stopping – a novel mechanism of emergent order in collective movement Yogesh Kumar KC, Arshed Nabeel, Srikanth Iyer, Vishwesha Guttal Abstract Collective movement is observed widely in nature, where individuals interact locally to produce globally ordered, coherent motion. In typical models of collective motion, each individual takes the average direction of multiple neighbors, resulting in ordered movement. In small flocks, noise-induced order can also emerge with individuals copying only a randomly chosen single neighbor at a time. We propose a new model of collective movement, inspired by how real animals move, where individuals can move in two directions or remain stationary. We demonstrate that when individuals interact with a single neighbor through a novel form of halting interaction—where an individual may stop upon encountering an oppositely moving neighbor rather than instantly aligning—persistent collective order can emerge even in large populations. This represents a fundamentally different mechanism from conventional averaging-based or noise-induced ordering. Using deterministic and stochastic mean-field approximations, we characterize the conditions under which such ’flocking by stopping’ behavior can occur, and confirm the mean-field predictions using individual-based simulations. Our results highlight how incorporating a stopped state and halting interactions can generate new routes to order in collective movement. I Introduction Collective movement is a ubiquitous phenomenon in nature, where individuals move together, interacting with one another, resulting in emergent large-scale synchronization and pattern formation. Such emergent collective motion is observed in a wide range of systems across scales, ranging from cells and microorganisms, insects, fish, birds, large mammals, human crowds, etc. 1 ; 14 ; 3 ; 24 ; 9 ; 18 ; 4 . It is also observed in non-biological and engineered systems such as active colloids, Janus particles, microswimmers, etc. 35 ; 29 . As such, understanding the dynamics of collective movement is an active area of research that has attracted researchers across disciplines. In particular, the spontaneous emergence of synchronized motion in a group of distinct individuals has been of special interest. The predominant paradigm in the field is to model the individuals as self propelled particles that align their directions of motion to their neighbors, which can lead to coherent and synchronization of movement across the whole group 33 ; 21 ; 41 ; 10 ; 12 ; 15 ; 38 ; 17 ; 22 . Recently, alternative mechanisms have also been suggested through which collective order can emerge 13 ; 8 . Even in flocking systems with alignment interactions, there are different mechanisms through which ordered motion can arise. Consider the familiar example of the classic Vicsek model, where each individual aligns its direction of motion with all the neighbors within a finite radius. These alignment interactions—when noise fluctuations are low enough—results in highly synchronized movement across the whole group, even for very large group sizes 40 . This emergent ordering can occur even if the individuals interact with as few as two (instead of all) neighbors, chosen either based on spatial proximity or randomly from the whole group 14 ; 11 ; 32 . A fundamentally different mechanism of ordering takes place when individuals interact only with a single neighbor (chosen based on spatial proximity or randomly). In this case, order can still emerge, but only in finite group sizes 6 ; 24 ; 23 . The emergent collective order here is called noise induced order 20 , and represents an entirely new mechanism of ordering, which disappears when the number of individuals grow to the thermodynamic limit. In the real world biological collectives such as animal groups, individuals can move with variable speed and can even occasionally stop 34 ; 5 ; 2 . However, models of collective movement often assume constant-speed motion (but see 31 ; 19 ; 28 ). In this context, we present a simple, one-dimensional model of collective movement, where individuals can move in one of two directions, or remain stationary. In this model, we show that collective order can emerge and persist for large group sizes, even when individuals interact with a single neighbor. This is in contrast with previous (constant speed) models, where the emergent order with single neighbor interactions is noise-induced and disappears when the group size grows 6 ; 24 . This new mechanism for emergent order is a surprising consequence of a new type of interaction which we call halting interactions . Here, an individual can stop moving when encountering a neighbor moving in a different direction, instead of immediately copying its direction. We use mean-field descriptions of the model dynamics in the form of ordinary and stochastic differential equations to characterize conditions in which ordered motion can emerge. The mean field predictions match well with individual-based stochastic simulations of the model dynamics. In summary, our work demonstrates how speed variability can offer novel routes to order in collective movement. II A simple model for variable-speed collective movement Figure 1: A schematic illustration of the model. Left: Each individuals can be in one of three states + (moving clockwise), - (moving counterclockwise), or 0 (stopped). Right: The individuals can switch between these states either spontaneously or by interacting with a random neighbor, through the different types of interactions as shown. In real world animal collectives, individuals typically move with variable speed, and often exhibit stop-and-go movement 28 ; 27 ; 5 ; 2 . However, most models of collective movement ignore this aspect of movement. Inspired by the experiments involving locusts, fish etc. moving in annular arenas 7 ; 26 , where individuals can effectively move only along clockwise and counter-clockwise movement, we present the following simplified model of variable speed: We consider N individuals where each individual can take one of three states; X_{+} (moving clockwise), X_{-} (moving counterclockwise) and X_{0} (stopped). Individuals can change their state of motion either spontaneously, or by interacting with random individual from the group, as described below and summarized in fig. 1 . Our assumption that discrete states can represent movement variables is justified in many experimental contexts where animals perform motion in effective 1-dimensional systems such as an annular arena with relatively thin annual region (e.g. 7 ; 26 ). Spontaneous switching. First, individuals can spontaneously change their movement state to a new state with some specified rate. We assume that spontaneous movement initiations, spontaneous stops and spontaneous direction changes occur at rates s_{M},s_{S} and s_{C} respectively. \displaystyle X_{0} \displaystyle\;\xrightarrow{s_{M}}\;X_{+} (1) \displaystyle X_{0} \displaystyle\;\xrightarrow{s_{M}}\;X_{-} (2) \displaystyle X_{+} \displaystyle\;\xrightarrow{s_{S}}\;X_{0} (3) \displaystyle X_{-} \displaystyle\;\xrightarrow{s_{S}}\;X_{0} (4) \displaystyle X_{+} \displaystyle\;\xrightarrow{s_{C}}\;X_{-} (5) \displaystyle X_{-} \displaystyle\;\xrightarrow{s_{C}}\;X_{+} (6) Copy interactions. Second, an individual can choose a random neighbor from the group and copy its motion state. We assume different rates c_{M},c_{S} and c_{C} for copy events that results in movement initiation, movement stop and direction change, respectively. In the equations below, one may take the first individual as the focal individual and the second as the randomly chosen neighbor from the group. \displaystyle X_{0}+X_{+} \displaystyle\;\xrightarrow{c_{M}}\;X_{+}+X_{+} (7) \displaystyle X_{0}+X_{-} \displaystyle\;\xrightarrow{c_{M}}\;X_{-}+X_{-} (8) \displaystyle X_{+}+X_{0} \displaystyle\;\xrightarrow{c_{S}}\;X_{0}+X_{0} (9) \displaystyle X_{-}+X_{0} \displaystyle\;\xrightarrow{c_{S}}\;X_{0}+X_{0} (10) \displaystyle X_{-}+X_{+} \displaystyle\;\xrightarrow{c_{C}}\;X_{+}+X_{+} (11) \displaystyle X_{+}+X_{-} \displaystyle\;\xrightarrow{c_{C}}\;X_{-}+X_{-} (12) Halting interactions. In the copying interactions described above, individuals switched their directions of motion when they encountered an individual moving in the opposite direction. In such cases, alternatively, the individual may first reduce the