Numerical investigation of the generalized Jang equation coupled to conformal flow of metrics
Hollis Williams · 2026
Read Numerical investigation of the generalized Jang equation coupled to conformal flow of metrics by Hollis Williams (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-15359.txt.
Introduction
Hollis Williams computes with a pair of equations used in a famous unproven claim about black holes. His 2026 arXiv paper deals with the generalized Jang equation, coupled to a conformal flow of metrics. A recent result by Jaracz frames the work.
Jaracz showed that no global solutions meet the conditions needed to prove the Penrose conjecture this way. The proof found a breakdown: the Jang slope fails at finite radius. Williams studies the coupled system numerically. His investigation traces how that breakdown unfolds inside the coupled equations themselves in detail.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Hollis Williams |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 32 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-15359
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Numerical investigation of the generalized Jang equation coupled to conformal flow of metrics Hollis Williams Abstract Abstract: A recent result of Jaracz has established nonexistence of global solutions to the coupled generalized Jang equation and zero divergence system which satisfy the asymptotic conditions needed to prove the Penrose conjecture by identifying a breakdown mechanism for the Jang slope at finite radius. In this work, we investigate whether a similar obstruction arises when the generalized Jang equation is instead coupled to the conformal flow of metrics. Restricting to spherical symmetry and time-symmetric initial data, we formulate a numerically tractable version of the Jang/conformal flow system. Our numerical results show no evidence of a finite radius breakdown analogous to that observed by Jaracz. Instead, the Jang slope remains regular and approaches its limiting value asymptotically. This behavior persists under controlled perturbations of the warping factor, indicating robustness of the observed phenomenon. These findings suggest that coupling to conformal flow of metrics alters the obstruction mechanism present in the Jang/zero divergence system, and hence that this system may still be viable for proving the Penrose conjecture. † † corref: cor1 \cortext [cor1]Corresponding author. Email: [email protected] 1 Introduction 1.1 The Penrose conjecture The Penrose inequality relates the total mass of an asymptotically flat initial data set for the Einstein equations to the area of its outermost apparent horizon penrose . A popular form of the inequality states that M_{\mathrm{ADM}}\geq\sqrt{\frac{A}{16\pi}}, (1) where M_{\mathrm{ADM}} is the ADM mass and A is the area of the outermost minimal surface, with saturation occurring for the Schwarzschild metric. The Penrose conjecture states that equation (1) is true for any asymptotically flat initial data set (M,g,k) satisfying suitable asymptotic boundary conditions and the dominant energy condition (in other words, for any physically reasonable initial data set). A slightly different formulation of the conjecture is known to be true for spherically symmetric data sets (in this version, one considers the outermost future or past apparent horizon) hayward ; bray1 . The conjecture is also known in the important special case of time-symmetric data (M,g) , where M is a Riemannian 3 -manifold. The proofs of this statement both use geometric flows (either inverse mean curvature flow or conformal flow of metrics) huisken ; bray2 . The conjecture remains open in full generality. One of the main challenges is the presence of extrinsic curvature, which prevents a direct reduction to the Riemannian case and complicates the application of methods from geometric analysis. There have also been proofs of extensions of the Penrose inequality to include charge or angular momentum, but these invoke strong geometric assumptions similar to those of the Riemannian Penrose inequality disconzi ; yamada ; weinstein ; jaracz2 . 1.2 The generalized Jang equation The Jang equation was introduced in the 1970s as a potential method for proving the positive energy theorem jang . A full proof of this theorem with the Jang equation was provided by Schoen and Yau shortly afterwards schoen . The overall idea of the Jang equation is to produce a geometric perturbation which is designed to transform a general initial data set into one with improved scalar curvature properties. Given an initial data set (M,g,k) , the Jang perturbation seeks a graph hypersurface whose induced metric captures key features of the original data whilst allowing control of scalar curvature. One can then complete the proof by reducing back to a proof of the positive energy theorem in the case of positive scalar curvature schoen2 . In order to attempt a proof of the Penrose inequality in this approach, it is necessary to generalize the Jang equation bray3 . In the generalized version of Jang, one searches for a hypersurface \Sigma given by a graph t=f(x) in the product space M\times\mathbb{R} , but now the product metric is a warped product metric \overline{g}=-\phi^{2}df^{2}+g , where \phi is a nonnegative function defined on M . The Jang surface \Sigma should satisfy a PDE of the form H_{\Sigma}=\text{Tr}_{\Sigma}K, (2) where H_{\Sigma} is the mean curvature of the hypersurface and \text{Tr}_{\Sigma}K is the trace of the extrinsic curvature extended to the product M\times\mathbb{R} and taken over \Sigma . The extension of k to M\times\mathbb{R} is given by K(\partial_{x^{i}},\partial_{x^{j}})=K(\partial_{x^{j}},\partial_{x^{i}})=k(\partial_{x^{i}},\partial_{x^{j}})\>\>\text{for}\>\>1\leq i,j\leq 3, K(\partial_{x^{i}},\partial_{t})=K(\partial_{t},\partial_{x^{i}})=0\>\>for\>\>1\leq i\leq 3, K(\partial_{t},\partial_{t})=\frac{\phi^{2}g(\nabla f,\nabla\phi)}{\sqrt{1+\phi^{2}|\nabla f|^{2}}}, where x^{i} are local coordinates on M . When k is extended in this way, the generalized Jang equation in local coordinates is \Bigg(g^{ij}-\frac{\phi^{2}f^{i}f^{j}}{1+\phi^{2}|\nabla f|^{2}}\Bigg)\Bigg(\frac{\phi\nabla_{ij}f+\phi_{i}f_{j}+\phi_{j}f_{i}}{\sqrt{1+\phi^{2}|\nabla f|^{2}}}-k_{ij}\Bigg)=0. There are several auxiliary equations which can be coupled to equation (4) to produce systems which can (in theory) be used to prove the Penrose inequality. One of the simplest is the Jang-zero divergence system, where the auxiliary equation is simply \overline{\text{div}}(\phi q)=0 . This system admits solutions when linearized, but it was recently shown by Jaracz that the full system is not solvable even when spherical symmetry is assumed williams2 ; jaracz . It is also possible to produce viable systems by coupling to inverse mean curvature flow or conformal flow of metrics, but the analysis becomes considerably more complicated. 1.3 Jang/conformal flow system In this work, we will consider the latter system. The main idea of this system is to couple the generalized Jang equation to a conformal deformation of the metric. To do this, one considers a one-parameter family of metrics g_{t}=u_{t}^{4}g, where u_{t}>0 evolves by Bray’s conformal flow of metrics. The conformal factor u_{t} satisfies \partial_{t}u_{t}=v_{t}u_{t}, where v_{t} is harmonic with respect to g_{t} : \Delta_{g_{t}}v_{t}=0\quad\text{on }M_{t}. The boundary and asymptotic conditions for v_{t} are v_{t}=0\quad\text{on }\partial M_{t}, v_{t}(x)\to-1\quad\text{as }|x|\to\infty. In the zero scalar curvature formulation of Han and Khuri, the warping factor \phi is determined via a scalar curvature correction han . We introduce a function z_{t} satisfying \Delta_{\bar{g}_{t}}z_{t}-\frac{1}{8}R_{\bar{g}_{t}}z_{t}=0, with asymptotic boundary condition z_{t}\to 1\quad\text{as }|x|\to\infty. In this formulation, the warping factor \phi admits an explicit integral representation along the conformal flow. Specifically, \phi is given by \phi(x)=2\int_{0}^{\infty}\chi_{t}(x)\left(w_{t}^{-}(x)\,z_{t}^{-}(x)+w_{t}^{+}(x)\,z_{t}^{+}(x)\right)u_{t}^{2}(x)\,dt, where \chi_{t} is an indicator function on \Sigma_{t} , u_{t} is the conformal factor evolving under the conformal flow, w_{t}^{\pm} denote the null expansions of the Jang surface, and z_{t}^{\pm} are the scalar curvature correction factors arising from equation (9) on suitable ”mirror slices” of M_{t} defined in han . When an apparent horizon is present, the Jang function f is required to blow up appropriately at \partial M , whereas the induced metric \bar{g}_{t} remains regular. At spatial infinity, the asymptotic boundary conditions are f(x)\to 0,\quad\phi(x)\to 1\quad\text{as }|x|\to\infty. Solutions for have been shown to exist for this system given restrictive assumptions, but a full existence theory is beyond current techniques williams1 . There is also an alternative formulation for the system using spinors, but this runs into further subtleties involving spin geometry witten ; taubes . A key issue with solvability is that the generalized Jang equation is degenerate and may fail to admit global solutions, with breakdown often occurring when the slope of the graph approaches a critical value. Jaracz demonstrated that this degeneracy leads to nonexistence of solutions for the Jang/zero divergence system, even in spherical symmetry jaracz . By identifying a finite radius blow-up mechanism for the Jang slope, that work effectively ruled out this particular formulation as a viable route toward the Penrose inequality. Motivated by this result, it