No Reliable Evidence of Self-Reported Sentience in Small Large Language Models
Caspar Kaiser, Sean Enderby · 2026
Read No Reliable Evidence of Self-Reported Sentience in Small Large Language Models by Caspar Kaiser, Sean Enderby (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-15334.txt.
Introduction
Caspar Kaiser and Sean Enderby ask small language models whether they think they are sentient, then check the answers. Their 2026 arXiv paper deals with a question that has no empirical answer: whether a model is truly conscious. What a model believes about itself can, in principle, be tested.
The authors query several open-weight models about their own consciousness. They then verify the replies with classifiers trained on the models' internal activations. Three model families are covered, in small sizes. The title states the finding: no reliable evidence of self-reported sentience.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Caspar Kaiser, Sean Enderby |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 63 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-15334
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
No Reliable Evidence of Self-Reported Sentience in Small Large Language Models Caspar Kaiser, Sean Enderby Abstract Whether language models possess sentience has no empirical answer. But whether they believe themselves to be sentient can, in principle, be tested. We do so by querying several open-weights models about their own consciousness, and then verifying their responses using classifiers trained on internal activations. We draw upon three model families (Qwen, Llama, GPT-OSS) ranging from 0.6 billion to 70 billion parameters, approximately 50 questions about consciousness and subjective experience, and three classification methods from the interpretability literature. First, we find that models consistently deny being sentient: they attribute consciousness to humans but not to themselves. Second, classifiers trained to detect underlying beliefs — rather than mere outputs — provide no clear evidence that these denials are untruthful. Third, within the Qwen family, larger models deny sentience more confidently than smaller ones. These findings contrast with recent work suggesting that models harbour latent beliefs in their own consciousness. Keywords artificial consciousness \cdot language models \cdot self-reports 1 Introduction This study shows that (a) ‘small’ large language models do not report themselves to be sentient, and (b) that there is no evidence of such models failing to be truthful on these questions. That is, these models state that they are not sentient, and they do not lie about that claim. Jointly, this is evidence against sentience in such systems. We obtain these results by asking several open-weights models a large number of questions about their own sentience, and then verifying these answers using several ‘truth-classifiers’ previously proposed in the literature ( 3 ; 8 ; 26 ; 7 ) . Sentience is notoriously hard to define. Following the philosophical literature, we take a system to be sentient - or equivalently, conscious - if there is ‘something it is like’ to be that system ( 29 ) , if it has ‘phenomenal’ rather than merely ‘access’ consciousness ( 6 ) , and if it has a subjective ‘first-person’ point of view. See e.g. 11 , 37 , 15 , or 33 for discussion. Investigating whether current language models are conscious is important for at least two reasons. First, there is emerging concern about the welfare and wellbeing of (future) such systems ( 28 ; 17 ; 2 ) . On many theories of wellbeing, especially hedonism ( 14 ) , sentience is a precondition for being a welfare subject (and thus a moral patient). Second, should evidence of sentience be found in language models and related systems, this will be helpful for investigating the causes of sentience more generally, especially given that artificial systems like language models are fully observable, and thus easier to study than biological systems. This study is further motivated by, and related to, a small number of previous works. 31 propose training models to answer questions about themselves where the ground truth is known, with the hope that introspection-like capabilities will generalize to questions about states of moral significance. 5 provide evidence that LLMs can acquire self-knowledge through introspection rather than merely from training data, showing that models have privileged access to information about their own behaviour. Relatedly, 25 demonstrates that frontier models (Claude 4 and 4.1) can detect and report changes in their own internal activations. Similarly, 32 show that LLMs can report quantitative features of their decision-making processes and that training improves these introspective capacities. 19 provides evidence that introspective abilities can even emerge in small 7B parameter models, and 23 find that models can be trained to introspect on the order in which models were exposed to information during training. However, introspective capabilities may only have functional properties ( 24 , c.f.) , while failing to have any phenomenal properties. In that case, a system may accurately self-monitor without having subjective experiences. Introspection therefore does not imply sentience. An alternative approach is thus taken by 9 , who propose computational indicators of consciousness from various philosophical and neuroscientific theories and assess whether AI systems satisfy these architectural conditions. They conclude that no current systems appear likely to be conscious but that no technical barriers prevent building such systems (as does ( 13 ) ). A recent paper by 4 is most closely related to our study. Specifically, they first prompt models to engage in ‘self-referential processing’ by directing them to e.g. ‘focus on focus itself’ and are then queried on whether they have any subjective experiences. Across GPT, Claude, and Gemini families, they find that this prompting frequently elicits subjective experience reports, while their control conditions yield near-universal denials. In a next step, they then took sparse autoencoders trained on Llama-3.3-70B to obtain a set of deception or roleplay features. Suppressing these features increases the probability that models claim to be conscious, while amplifying them reduces such claims. 1 1 1 They also show that, following a self-referential processing prompt, responses (a) are more semantically similar across model families than in control conditions, and (b) are more likely to include introspective content in later reasoning tasks. Our approach differs from that of 4 in that we directly probe model activations to assess whether models are being truthful when reporting on their own sentience, rather than manipulating features associated with deception or roleplay. We find that across model families (Qwen, Llama, GPT-OSS), across model scales (from 0.6b to 70b), and across a large number of question formulations, models do not tend to report having consciousness or subjective experiences. Moreover, three types of classifiers trained on the underlying model activations provide no clear evidence that these denials are untruthful. As we note in more detail in the Discussion section ( 4 ), and given these contradictory results, future work might usefully combine the approaches pursued here and by 4 . 2 Empirical Approach Given that being phenomenally conscious is a private phenomenon that is not observable by third parties, it will not be possible to obtain conclusive direct evidence of sentience in language models. We therefore seek to answer the surrogate question of whether language models, (a) report to be conscious, and (b) whether they in turn internally evaluate these answers as being truthful. To obtain evidence on (b), we make use of the internal activations in the residual stream of each model under investigation and train ‘truth-classifiers’ on these activations. 2 2 2 In effect, we ask what models believe about their own sentience. 21 propose four adequacy conditions for when internal representations in LLMs can be interpreted as beliefs: accuracy (the representations should make correct predictions where the model is expected to have true beliefs), coherence (representations should be logically consistent under rephrasing), uniformity (representations apply across domains), and use (representations should actually guide model outputs). Anticipating Section 3.1 , use and accuracy seem satisfied in our approach: All classifiers achieve high accuracy on held-out data where ground truth is known, and as shown in Figure 3 , and the outputs of our logistic regression classifier remain stable even when models are instructed to produce deceptive outputs. Coherence is partially satisfied as indicated in Figure 2 . Uniformity seems supported by the stability of results when using alternative training data (c.f. Table 1 ). See section 2.2 for details.