Pairwise Beats All-at-Once: Behavioral Gains from Sequential Choice Presentation

Dipankar Das · 2026

Read Pairwise Beats All-at-Once: Behavioral Gains from Sequential Choice Presentation by Dipankar Das (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-15332.txt.

Introduction

Dipankar Das argues that shoppers choose better when options arrive two at a time. His 2026 arXiv paper sets out the Sequential Rationality Hypothesis. It says consumers make more utility-maximizing choices in sequential pairwise comparisons than in all-at-once displays.

Pairwise choice costs more mental effort than scanning one big display. Yet today's digital markets pile on reviews, prices, and paid placements. That clutter often leads to inconsistent choices. Sequential presentation, the paper argues, cuts through the clutter. Buyers weigh one clear trade-off at a time and end up closer to their true best pick.

Catalog record

CREATORDipankar Das
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE65 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-15332

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Pairwise Beats All-at-Once: Behavioral Gains from Sequential Choice Presentation Dipankar Das Abstract This paper presents the Sequential Rationality Hypothesis, which argues that consumers are better able to make utility-maximizing decisions when products appear in sequential pairwise comparisons rather than in simultaneous multi-option displays. Although this involves higher cognitive costs than the all-at-once format, the current digital market, with its diverse products listed by review ratings, pricing, and paid products, often creates inconsistent choices. The present work shows that preparing the list sequentially supports more rational choice, as the consumer tries to minimize cognitive costs and may otherwise make an irrational decision. If the decision remains the same on both offers, then that is a consistent preference. The platform uses this approach by reducing cognitive costs while still providing the list in an all-at-once format rather than sequentially. To show how sequential exposure reduces cognitive overload and prevents context-dependent errors, we develop a bounded attention model and extend the monotonic attention rule of the random attention model to theorize the sequential rational hypothesis. Using a theoretical design with common consumer goods, we test these hypotheses. This theoretical model helps policymakers in digital market laws, behavioral economics, marketing, and digital platform design consider how choice architectures may improve consumer choices and encourage rational decision-making. Keywords: Sequential Rationality Hypothesis, Random Attention Model, bounded attention, choice theory, monotonicity, choice architecture, digital markets. 1 Introduction Consumers frequently encounter decision environments in digital markets characterized by high product diversity and digital interfaces where multiple options are presented simultaneously. On the other hand, classical economic models presuppose full rationality and stable preferences, which implies that agents can process and evaluate all alternatives concurrently to select the utility-maximizing option. Empirical evidence consistently reveals that human cognitive capacities are bounded. As established in foundational works by Simon Simon, 1955 , Kahneman Kahneman, 2003 , and Gabaix Gabaix, 2014 , decision-makers often operate under informational and attention constraints, leading to deviations from full rationality. Recent developments in the economics of recommender systems underscore the impact of choice architecture on consumer behavior in digital markets Jannach et al., 2010 ; del Carmen Rodríguez-Hernández et al., 2016 ; De Biasio et al., 2024 . While recommender systems are designed to guide consumers through informational complexity, they often present alternatives simultaneously, which can lead to cognitive overload and a decline in decision quality. Against this backdrop, this paper introduces the Sequential Rationality Hypothesis , which posits that a sequential, pairwise presentation of options can systematically enhance decision quality by aligning the structure of the choice environment with cognitive processing capabilities. Using a simple numerical example, the Sequential Rationality Hypothesis can be explained. Consider a hypothetical consumer choosing among three simple beverages: Coffee ( A ), Tea ( B ), and Juice ( D ). Each option has an associated utility reflecting the consumer’s true preference: Product True Utility Coffee ( A ) u(A)=8 Tea ( B ) u(B)=6 Juice ( D ) u(D)=7 Let the consumer be shown all three products in the standard choice setting, viz. \{A,B,D\} , simultaneously, and is expected to select the most preferred option. Under the full attention model and assuming perfect rationality, the consumer would compare all three options and choose Coffee ( A ), the option that maximizes utility. However, under limited attention, the consumer may only compare a subset, such as Tea ( B ) and Juice ( D ), and inadvertently overlook Coffee. If Juice is chosen based on this partial comparison, the decision is suboptimal: C(A,B,D)=D\quad\text{(irrational choice due to attention omission)} (1) Now consider a sequential choice structure. In Step 1, the consumer has to choose between Coffee ( A ) and Tea ( B ). Since u(A)>u(B) , and the comparison is focused, Coffee is chosen: C(A,B)=A (2) In Step 2, the consumer must choose between the previously selected Coffee ( A ) and Juice ( D ). Again, since u(A)>u(D) , Coffee is chosen: C(C(A,B),D)=A (3) The final choice is Coffee ( A ), the utility-maximizing product. The Sequential Rationality Hypothesis is motivated by the theoretical literature on bounded rationality, list-based choice models, and limited attention frameworks Cattaneo et al., 2020 ; Masatlioglu et al., 2012 ; Rubinstein and Salant, 2006 . Whereas classical revealed preference theory assumes consideration of all alternatives, empirical research shows that attention is often confined to a subset, known as the consideration set Hauser and Wernerfelt, 1990 ; Goeree, 2008 ; Van Nierop et al., 2010 ; Honka et al., 2017 ; Reutskaja et al., 2011 . Rubinstein and Salant Rubinstein and Salant, 2006 provide an axiomatic foundation for choice from lists, emphasizing how order effects shape the construction of preferences. However, such models remain static and do not capture dynamic, sequential attention shifts. Our hypothesis builds upon this gap by introducing a recursive model of binary comparisons under cognitive constraints, establishing conditions under which step-wise exposure enhances utility-maximizing outcomes. The central theoretical insight is that when consumers compare two options at a time, they avoid attention overload, pay cognitive costs, and are more likely to make consistent, rational decisions. Here the cognitive cost is the weighted sum of information process Bettman et al., 1990 ; Dhar et al., 2000 .This has been tested mathematically and has a logical formulation of the theory. This sequential offering acts as a cognitive filter that incrementally preserves the better alternatives, thereby reducing cognitive overload and enhancing decision-making. The sequential offering acts as a cognitive filter that incrementally preserves the better alternatives. Formally, when attention is limited then the following holds. \Pr(C(C(A,B),D)=\arg\max\{u(A),u(B),u(D)\})>\Pr(C(A,B,D)=\arg\max\{u(A),u(B),u(D)\}) (4) The visual presentation of options in digital marketplaces has a significant influence on consumer decisions. Based on the following figure of Amazon’s recommendation interface (Figure 1 ), we explain user behavior through the lens of the Sequential Rationality Hypothesis (SRH) using simple logic. The hypothesis proposes that sequential binary exposure mitigates attention overload and facilitates utility-maximizing decisions under bounded rationality, making us acutely aware of the influence of digital interfaces on consumer behavior. The Amazon recommendation system presents a grid-like layout where alternatives are displayed both horizontally across rows and vertically across scrollable columns. This grid includes advertisements, promotional labels (e.g., "Deal of the Day"), brand tags (e.g., "Amazon’s Choice"), and price discounts, all of which act as cognitive distractions unrelated to intrinsic utility. From a behavioral point of view the following are the beatification may be emerged (i) horizontally aligned options force users to compare several visually similar products simultaneously, (ii) vertically stacked rows necessitate scrolling, introducing temporal fragmentation of attention,(iii) salient design cues (e.g., discount tags, star ratings, number of reviews) divert focus from utility-relevant attributes, (iv) the lack of structured comparison logic increases decision fatigue and lowers the probability of selecting the utility-maximizing option. These factors align with the prediction of bounded attention models, where users fail to process all alternatives fully and are instead influenced by framing and salience Kahneman, 2003 ; Gabaix, 2014 ; Bordalo et al., 2013 . We develop a choice-theoretic model in which bounded attention and cognitive viability thresholds determine the selection path. Through a set of theorems, lemmas, corollaries, and propositions with illustrative counterexamples, we show, for example, that C(C(A,B),D)\neq C(A,B,D) when attention is limited. This divergence departs

Read the complete text