Five-point partial waves, splitting constraints and hidden zeros

Arnab Priya Saha a and, Aninda Sinha a,b · 2026

Read Five-point partial waves, splitting constraints and hidden zeros by Arnab Priya Saha a and, Aninda Sinha a,b (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-15088.txt.

Introduction

Arnab Priya Saha and Aninda Sinha study how five particles scatter, one piece at a time. Their 2026 arXiv paper deals with five-point tree amplitudes, the basic terms in a scattering process. All five external particles are identical scalars.

The team expands the residues of the amplitude in partial waves. They check the build in two ways. One uses massive spinor-helicity building blocks. The other matches the five-point Veneziano amplitude at fixed mass levels. The work also brings in splitting constraints and the hidden zeros of the full five-point scattering amplitude.

Catalog record

CREATORArnab Priya Saha a and, Aninda Sinha a,b
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE109 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-15088

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Five-point partial waves, splitting constraints and hidden zeros Arnab Priya Saha a and, Aninda Sinha a,b Abstract We study the partial-wave expansion of residues of five-point tree-amplitude involving identical scalar particles in the external legs. We check the construction using massive spinor-helicity building blocks and by matching to the tree-level five-point Veneziano amplitude at fixed mass levels. As an application, we express five-point splitting constraints - the reduction of the five-point amplitude to products of four-point amplitudes on special kinematic loci - as linear relations among the five-point partial-wave coefficients. At low mass levels these constraints, together with spin truncation, fix the full five-point partial-wave data in terms of the four-point coefficients and imply simple compatibility conditions; remarkably, imposing two independent splitting loci also forces the residue to vanish on their intersection, making the associated hidden zero manifest in partial-wave space. We also show that once both channels allow spin-2 exchange a genuine kernel can remain, indicating the need for additional higher-point input to achieve complete rigidity. 1 Introduction Recent progress in the modern S-matrix bootstrap has shown that remarkably sharp constraints on low-energy effective interactions can follow from general principles such as analyticity, unitarity, crossing symmetry, and Regge/UV behavior, sometimes even isolating string-like amplitudes as distinguished corners or islands in the space of consistent S-matrices 29 ; 33 ; 23 ; 30 ; 21 . However, most bootstrap technology and most quantitative bounds have so far been developed in the simplest setting of 2\!\to\!2 scattering. This makes it especially timely to systematically extend the program to five-particle (and, more generally, n -particle) amplitudes, where genuinely new physics and new constraints first appear: inelasticity and multi-particle unitarity, a richer web of factorization channels, and kinematic configurations that are invisible at four points. Indeed, recent work has demonstrated that higher-point consistency can feed back nontrivially onto lower-point data—for example, “hidden-zero” and “splitting” conditions 5 on five-point EFT amplitudes can drastically reduce the allowed region for four-point Wilson coefficients and drive the bootstrap toward the open-string beta function 10 . More broadly, mixed-multiplicity positivity constraints (“multipositivity”) provide an infinite family of inequalities that simultaneously constrain residues and EFT coefficients at arbitrary multiplicity, and are strikingly saturated by tree-level open-string amplitudes 22 . Complementing these S-matrix developments, multipoint bootstrap methods on the CFT side—such as positive semi-definite reformulations of six-point crossing—underscore that going beyond four points is both feasible and generically more constraining, e.g. 9 ; 36 ; 3 . Finally, rapid advances in multi-leg amplitude technology and function-space control—including powerful new methods for evaluating and organizing multi-point integrals—make five- and six-particle kinematics increasingly tractable, strengthening the case for a systematic study of higher-point amplitudes and their analytic structures and factorization properties 31 . Historically, extending S-matrix ideas beyond 2\!\to\!2 scattering was viewed as essential but technically formidable. Classic analytic S-matrix treatments already emphasized that multiparticle amplitudes live on a far more intricate multi-sheeted Riemann surface than four-point scattering, with many independent invariants constrained by Gram-determinant relations and with a proliferation of normal and anomalous thresholds 26 . In the late 1960s, five-point amplitudes became a central testing ground: requirement of duality and Regge behavior led to explicit five-point constructions and generalizations of Veneziano/Virasoro-type formulae 43 ; 35 , while multi-Regge theory developed a detailed framework for studying analyticity and factorization of the five-point function 1 ; 46 ; 16 . A major obstruction to a systematic bootstrap at higher multiplicity is that analyticity constraints are no longer captured by a single complex variable: different channel discontinuities can overlap, and consistency requires nontrivial Steinmann relations, which dictate that double discontinuities on overlapping channels vanish, together with generalized optical theorems expressing multiparticle cuts in terms of physical-region amplitudes 40 ; 17 . In practice, these features have made it difficult to write higher-point analogs of the machinery, such as dispersive representations or partial-wave expansions, which are conventionally used to obtain bounds in 2\!\to\!2 scatterings 24 ; 25 ; 42 ; 19 ; 38 . Even setting aside analyticity, the most basic remaining challenge is unitarity: beyond four points, unitarity becomes genuinely nonlinear and couples different multiplicities through phase-space integrals for loops, so imposing it sharply in a bootstrap-friendly way remains difficult. An interesting new route is provided by “hidden zeros”—special kinematic loci where higher-point amplitudes vanish with a factorization-like structure—because these conditions translate nontrivial higher-point consistency into comparatively tractable algebraic constraints that can be fed into EFT/bootstraps, dramatically shrinking allowed regions and isolating string-like solutions 8 ; 10 . The remarkable discovery of “hidden zeroes” in amplitudes 5 begins with the observation that certain color-ordered massless tree-amplitudes vanish on a highly non-generic locus in kinematic space, defined by setting a special set of non-planar Mandelstam invariants to zero. In 5 these zeros are not presented as an accident of Feynman-diagram numerators; rather, they become manifest in the positive geometric description of the amplitudes using canonical forms 4 . Even more striking is what happens near the zero locus: the amplitude exhibits a novel “(2-)split” behavior, simplifying into a nontrivial product of lower-point objects (up to a known kinematic prefactor) without being on an ordinary factorization pole. The same zero locus and splitting structure is shown to extend beyond \mathrm{Tr}(\phi^{3}) to pions (NLSM) and non-supersymmetric gluons, and a unique kinematic shift preserving the zeros relates these theories as different “faces” of a single underlying function; the phenomenon further generalizes to “stringy” \mathrm{Tr}(\phi^{3}) amplitudes 5 . The hidden zeroes and splitting are considered from a bootstrap input point of view with sharp EFT consequences in 10 . Working within the perturbative numerical S -matrix bootstrap for weakly coupled EFTs, this work imposes the hidden-zero conditions and, crucially, the five-point splitting constraints on a systematic EFT ansatz. While the hidden-zero conditions largely fix five-point contact ambiguities, enforcing the splitting relations propagates back to 2\!\to\!2 scattering by generating nonlinear constraints among the four-point Wilson coefficients 10 . When incorporated into positivity-based bootstrap analyses, these higher-point constraints can shrink and deform the allowed regions for the four-point EFT data into smaller non-convex islands, and their numerics indicate that (under assumptions about the absence of single-mass infinite-spin towers at the gap) the string beta function emerges as essentially the unique solution compatible with hidden zeroes plus the five-point splitting constraints. In this paper we develop a convenient partial-wave language for planar-ordered tree-level five-point amplitudes, with {\rm tr}\left(\phi^{3}\right) theory and the tree-level five-point Veneziano amplitude 6 as guiding examples. Despite the central role of partial-wave methods in 2\!\to\!2 bootstrap bounds, an equally practical and widely adopted partial-wave technology for five-point, i.e. 2\rightarrow 3 amplitudes has not been discussed in the modern literature. The reason is partly kinematic and partly analytic: five-point scattering depends on several independent invariants subjected to Gram-determinant constraints, and the amplitude lives on a considerably richer multi-sheeted analytic structure with overlapping discontinuities and multiparticle thresholds, so more than single angular variable are required to describe the five-point kinematic. Higher point parameterization of kinematic variables using little group frames can be found in 41 . As a result, most recent higher-point bootstrap discussions have emphasized on polynomial residue ansätze and consistency conditions (such as hidden zeros and splitting) rather than a systematic harmonic decomposition. We believe that this leaves

Read the complete text