Benchmarking neutrino-nucleus quasielastic scattering model predictions against a missing energy profile obtained using a monoenergetic neutrino beam

J. McKean, L. Munteanu, S. Abe · 2026

Read Benchmarking neutrino-nucleus quasielastic scattering model predictions against a missing energy profile obtained using a monoenergetic neutrino beam by J. McKean, L. Munteanu, S. Abe (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-14831.txt.

Introduction

J. McKean, L. Munteanu, and S. Abe benchmark neutrino scattering models in this 2026 paper. They examine three exclusive nuclear ground state shell models implemented in the NEUT neutrino event generator. They benchmark them against the recent JSNS2 measurement of missing energy, made with a monoenergetic neutrino source. A single-energy beam makes the test unusually clean.

The nature of the measurement allows a detailed investigation of nuclear ground-state modeling using a neutrino source. It gives access to a direct measurement of the neutron spectral function in a carbon-12 nucleus. Readers get a rare, sharp check on the nuclear models inside a major neutrino simulation tool.

Catalog record

CREATORJ. McKean, L. Munteanu, S. Abe
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE35 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-14831

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Benchmarking neutrino-nucleus quasielastic scattering model predictions against a missing energy profile obtained using a monoenergetic neutrino beam J. McKean, L. Munteanu, S. Abe Abstract We examine three exclusive nuclear ground state shell models implemented in the NEUT neutrino event generator and benchmark them against the recent JSNS 2 measurement of missing energy using a monoenergetic neutrino source. The nature of the measurement allows a detailed investigation of nuclear ground-state modeling using a neutrino source, and gives access to a direct measurement of the neutron spectral function in a 12 C nucleus. The NEUT intranuclear cascade and nuclear deexcitation NucDeEx are used to simulate inelastic final-state interactions and nuclear deexcitations respectively. We find that the spectral function (SF) models perform better than relativistic mean field models in modeling both the ground state and the tail of the missing energy distribution when the NEUT cascade and nuclear excitation channels are turned on. We also find that taking into account the missing energy threshold for single nucleon knockout interactions results in all nuclear models being accepted based on the obtained p p -values. I Introduction Precise modeling of neutrino–nucleus interactions is essential for current and future neutrino oscillation experiments, where systematic uncertainties associated with nuclear effects directly impact the interpretation of measured signals 9 . Current and future generation neutrino oscillation experiments heavily rely on Monte Carlo event generators to predict neutrino interactions in the GeV regime. Until recently, neutrino generators mostly relied on inclusive theoretical model implementations, providing differential cross section predictions only as a function of final-state lepton kinematics. Over the last few years, generators have undergone an overhaul that accommodates the implementation of more exclusive models by relying on the factorization approach 30 ; 10 . This has notably allowed for the implementation of shell-based models such as the Benhar Spectral Function (SF) 15 ; 17 ; 12 . Recently, the unfactorized energy-dependent relativistic mean field (ED-RMF) model was implemented into the NEUT generator using a tabulated hadron tensor approach 36 . These models have been benchmarked against exclusive electron scattering measurements, and their validation using exclusive neutrino scattering measurements has recently begun 25 ; 24 ; 23 ; 39 . A major challenge in measuring neutrino scattering cross sections arises from the broadband nature of accelerator neutrino beams. The wide energy spectrum complicates the reconstruction of the incoming neutrino energy and smears out final-state observables, making it difficult to disentangle the modeling of the nuclear ground state from nuclear effects. An exception to this comes from neutrinos produced by kaon decay at rest (K-DAR). In this process, a kaon undergoes a two-body decay producing a neutrino ( K^{+}\rightarrow\mu^{+}\nu_{\mu} ) with a well defined energy of 235.5 MeV, with a branching ratio of 63.6% 28 . Recently, the JSNS 2 collaboration has released its first measurement of the missing energy spectrum using neutrinos from a K-DAR source on a carbon target 35 . This measurement can be used to study the neutron spectral function of carbon, which is a widely used nuclear target in experiments (for example, by experiments such as T2K 1 , MINERvA 8 , and NOvA 14 ). These experiments operate at energies of \approx 1 GeV, so K-DAR neutrinos are comparable to the regions of interest for accelerator-based experiments (such as T2K and NOvA, and in the future, DUNE 7 and Hyper-K 2 ). Moreover, these energies are particularly relevant for testing the approximations on which neutrino interaction generators are built. For example, many generators rely on the plane wave impulse approximation (PWIA), which assumes that the neutrino scatters off a single isolated nucleon and that the outgoing particles propagate as undistorted plane waves, neglecting correlations and interactions with the residual nucleus. The energy region of the K-DAR neutrinos is low enough that the energy transfers involved in charged-current (CC) interactions become sensitive to nuclear medium effects (for example, related to the nuclear ground state, Pauli blocking, or nucleon-nucleon correlations), which provides a unique opportunity to probe them directly. In this work, we focus on benchmarking three exclusive shell-based models implemented in the NEUT event generator 30 (version 6.0.3) against the JSNS 2 measurement of K-DAR neutrinos. We choose to focus on the NEUT event generator because, at the time of writing, it offers the widest choice of exclusive shell-based models within a single generator, allowing us to test the models in a consistent framework. II Interaction Models For neutrinos with an energy of 235.5 MeV, the vast majority of scatters will take place via charged-current quasielastic (CCQE) processes ( \nu_{\mu}n\rightarrow\mu^{-}p ). Multi-nucleon knock-out processes (so-called 2p2h, or npnh, interactions) can happen in this energy regime, but represent a less than 10% contribution to the total cross section. Higher-order processes such as resonant pion production and deep inelastic scatters are negligible at these energies. The following paragraphs describe in detail the CCQE models that we test in this work. For 2p2h interactions, we use the model by Nieves et al. 38 ; 37 ; 27 , which is the default model implemented in NEUT. Resonant pion production is modeled using the Rein-Sehgal model with added lepton mass corrections 41 ; 18 ; 26 . For a full description of the available models in the NEUT event generator, see 30 . NEUT offers several CCQE models. Among them, we chose to focus on two versions of the Benhar SF model, and the ED-RMF model. The SF model provides the two-dimensional probability P(\mathbb{p},\tilde{E}) of removing a proton with momentum \mathbb{p} and removal energy \tilde{E} 15 ; 17 ; 5 . Note that the removal energy is identical to the missing energy discussed here in the absence of final-state interactions (FSI). Recently, a new carbon SF with high removal energy resolution 12 has also been implemented in NEUT. This new SF (denoted as SF ∗ in this work) distinguishes between the ground state and the first and second excited states of {}^{11}\text{B}^{*} (with excitation energies at 2.13 MeV and 5.02 MeV) that were smeared out by coarse binning in the previous SF. Thus, it is expected to provide a more precise description of gamma-ray emissions by the nuclear deexcitation. Since the SF tables are obtained from exclusive electron scattering measurements (e,e^{\prime}p) , they provide only the spectral function for protons. To obtain the neutron spectral function, an additional correction is required. While assuming that the momentum distributions of protons and neutrons in symmetric nuclei are the same, a shift to the removal energy distribution is applied to neutrons, following the discussion in Refs. 13 ; 11 . P_{\text{neutron}}(\mathbb{p},\tilde{E})=P_{\text{proton}}(\mathbb{p},\tilde{E}-\Delta\tilde{E}), (1) where \Delta\tilde{E}=2.76 MeV for the carbon nucleus 22 . This correction takes into account the fact that neutrons are more deeply bound in the nucleus than protons due to the absence of the Coulomb potential. In the case of SF ∗ , this correction approximately reproduces the removal energy corresponding to the first and second discrete excited states of {}^{11}\text{C}^{*} (with excitation energies at 2.00 MeV and 4.80 MeV). The results of applying this correction for both SF and SF ∗ will be discussed in this paper. In the high-removal energy and high-momentum region, the SF and SF* models include a non-negligible contribution from short-range correlations (SRCs). In NEUT, events

Read the complete text