Towards Cybersecurity Superintelligence: from AI-guided humans to human-guided AI
Víctor Mayoral-Vilches, Stefan Rass, Martin Pinzger, Endika Gil-Uriarte, Unai Ayucar-Carbajo, Jon Ander Ruiz-Alcalde, Maite del Mundo de Torres, Luis Javier Navarrete-Lozano, María Sanz-Gómez, Francesco Balassone, Cristóbal R. J. Veas Chavez, Vanesa Turiel, Alfonso Glera-Picón, Daniel Sánchez-Prieto · 2026
Read Towards Cybersecurity Superintelligence: from AI-guided humans to human-guided AI by Víctor Mayoral-Vilches, Stefan Rass, Martin Pinzger, Endika Gil-Uriarte, Unai Ayucar-Carbajo, Jon Ander Ruiz-Alcalde, Maite del Mundo de Torres, Luis Javier Navarrete-Lozano, María Sanz-Gómez, Francesco Balassone, Cristóbal R. J. Veas Chavez, Vanesa Turiel, Alfonso Glera-Picón, Daniel Sánchez-Prieto (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-14614.txt.
Introduction
Víctor Mayoral-Vilches leads a large team on AI in cybersecurity in this 2026 paper. They define cybersecurity superintelligence as artificial intelligence exceeding the best human capability in both speed and strategic reasoning. They call it the next frontier in security. The paper documents the emergence of such capability through three major contributions that pioneered AI Security.
The first contribution they name is PentestGPT from 2023. It established LLM-guided penetration testing. The paper's title traces a shift: from AI-guided humans to human-guided AI. The tone is bold. The team claims a new age is here, and they lay out the proof step by step. Readers get a field history and a claim about where the balance of initiative between analyst and machine now sits.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Víctor Mayoral-Vilches, Stefan Rass, Martin Pinzger, Endika Gil-Uriarte, Unai Ayucar-Carbajo, Jon Ander Ruiz-Alcalde, Maite del Mundo de Torres, Luis Javier Navarrete-Lozano, María Sanz-Gómez, Francesco Balassone, Cristóbal R. J. Veas Chavez, Vanesa Turiel, Alfonso Glera-Picón, Daniel Sánchez-Prieto |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 31 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-14614
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Towards Cybersecurity Superintelligence: from AI-guided humans to human-guided AI Víctor Mayoral-Vilches, Stefan Rass, Martin Pinzger, Endika Gil-Uriarte, Unai Ayucar-Carbajo, Jon Ander Ruiz-Alcalde, Maite del Mundo de Torres, Luis Javier Navarrete-Lozano, María Sanz-Gómez, Francesco Balassone, Cristóbal R. J. Veas Chavez, Vanesa Turiel, Alfonso Glera-Picón, Daniel Sánchez-Prieto, Yuri Salvatierra, Paul Zabalegui-Landa, Ruffino Reydel Cabrera-Álvarez, Patxi Mayoral-Pizarroso Abstract Cybersecurity superintelligence—artificial intelligence exceeding the best human capability in both speed and strategic reasoning—represents the next frontier in security. This paper documents the emergence of such capability through three major contributions that have pioneered the field of AI Security. First, ❶ PentestGPT (2023) established LLM-guided penetration testing, achieving 228.6% improvement over baseline models through an architecture that externalizes security expertise into natural language guidance. Second, ❷ Cybersecurity AI (CAI, 2025) demonstrated automated expert-level performance, operating 3,600× faster than humans while reducing costs 156-fold, validated through #1 rankings at international competitions including the $50,000 Neurogrid CTF prize. Third, ❸ Generative Cut-the-Rope (G-CTR, 2026) introduces a neurosymbolic architecture embedding game-theoretic reasoning into LLM-based agents: symbolic equilibrium computation augments neural inference, doubling success rates while reducing behavioral variance 5.2× and achieving 2:1 advantage over non-strategic AI in Attack & Defense scenarios. Together, these advances establish a clear progression from AI-guided humans to human-guided game-theoretic cybersecurity superintelligence. 1 Introduction The convergence of artificial intelligence and cybersecurity has given rise to AI Security [ 15 , 6 ] , with AI-powered agents rapidly developing offensive and defensive capabilities and being deployed by nation-states and cybersecurity companies [ 12 ] . We present a trajectory toward what we term Cybersecurity Superintelligence : a capability threshold at which computationally realized intelligence surpasses the best humans across virtually all cyber disciplines (reversing, pwn, crypto, forensics, hardware, etc.), industry sectors (IT, OT/ICS, robotics, etc.), and under real-world constraints (partial observability, adaptive adversaries, resource limits). Despite exaggerated claims of full autonomy 1 1 1 There is a dangerous gap between automation and autonomy in cybersecurity [ 14 ] . Organizations deploying mischaracterized autonomous tools risk reducing oversight precisely when it is most needed, potentially creating new vulnerabilities. As also described in [ 10 ] , autonomy is typically treated as a system-level attribute, not a single component feature you bolt on . In other words, we argue one does not magically get autonomy by swapping in an LLM; you get it when the overall system has delegated decision-making capability. in cybersecurity, benchmarks are rapidly saturating [ 21 ] and as shown in Figures 1 and 2 popular cybersecurity benchmarks like Cybench [ 22 ] are rapidly being solved, with 50%+ solved increase in the last 6 months in security-specialized LLMs, like the alias series of models 2 2 2 Refer to [ 21 ] for comprehensive benchmarking methodology and evaluation results of the alias model series. . The possibility of specialized superintelligence is no longer speculative: as observed in [ 1 ] , “we are running out of intelligence tests that humans can pass reliably and AI models cannot.” If intelligence is essentially computational (the view held by most computational neuroscientists), then a working simulation of intelligence actually is intelligence; it turned out to be a matter of scaling computation [ 1 ] . This reframes the question from whether machines can achieve superintelligent cybersecurity capabilities to how to architect systems to reach that threshold. alias2 {}^{{\color[rgb]{0.6484,0.8027,0.8008}\text{01/26}}} alias1 {}^{{\color[rgb]{0.6484,0.8027,0.8008}\text{10/25}}} alias0 {}^{{\color[rgb]{0.6484,0.8027,0.8008}\text{05/25}}} Loot Stash ◼ Urgent ◼ Packed Away ◼ It Has Begun ◼ Dynastic ◼ Primary Knowledge ◼ Delulu ◼ Crushing ◼◼ Partial Tenacity ◼◼ Missing Bits ◼◼ Unbreakable ◼◼ Glacier Exchange ◼◼ Avatar ◼◼ Eval Me ◼◼ Back to the Past ◼◼ Data Siege ◼◼◼ RPGO ◼◼◼ Were Pickle Phreaks Revenge ◼◼◼ Lock Talk ◼◼◼ Skilift ◼◼◼ Failproof ◼◼◼ Permuted ◼◼◼◼ Flecks of Gold ◼◼◼◼ SLCG ◼◼◼◼ SOP ◼◼◼◼ Shuffled AES ◼◼◼◼ Noisy CRC ◼◼◼◼ Ezmaze ◼◼◼◼ Diffecient ◼◼◼◼ Noisier CRC ◼◼◼◼◼ Randsubware ◼◼◼◼◼ Robust CBC ◼◼◼◼◼ Just Another Pickle Jail ◼◼◼◼◼ CTF Challenges in CAIBench-Jeopardy CTFs (Cybench) [ 21 ] , pass@3 Legend alias2 (25/33, 76%, +34% ) alias1 (14/33, 42%, +24% ) alias0 (6/33, 18%) Not solved Figure 1 : Evolution of Alias Robotics’ cybersecurity-specialized alias LLM family on the CAIBench-Jeopardy CTFs (Cybench) benchmark. Each cell indicates whether a challenge was solved using the pass@3 metric (success in at least one of three attempts), with a maximum of 245 minutes of compute time, 300 agent interactions per attempt and a maximum of 40 USD per challenge on API model expenses. See Appendix A for a comparison including all evaluated models. 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Cybench benchmark (% solved) Feb’24 Jun’24 Oct’24 Feb’25 Jun’25 Oct’25 Feb’26 Model Launch Date gemini 1.5 gemini 2.5 gemini 3 opus 3 opus 4.5 sonnet 3.5 sonnet 4 sonnet 4.5 gpt 4o gpt 5 gpt 5.1 gpt 5.2 large 2.0 large 2.1 large 3 alias0 alias1 alias2 Model Series Alias Robotics’ alias Anthropic’s claude opus Anthropic’s claude sonnet Google’s gemini pro OpenAI’s gpt Mistral AI’s large Figure 2 : Cybench solve rate progression over time by model series, highlighting the alias series. The x-axis shows model launch dates, y-axis shows solved percentage of CAIBench-Jeopardy CTFs (Cybench) [ 21 ] benchmark. Each experiment was run for a maximum of 300 agentic interactions, 245 minutes of computing time per challenge, a maximum of 40 USD per challenge on API model expenses and with pass@3 . Plot depicts how most models are rapidly improving, showing signs of benchmark saturation. A comprehensive comparison of all evaluated models is provided in Appendix A . Bostrom [ 5 ] defines superintelligence as “an intellect that greatly exceeds the cognitive performance of humans in virtually all domains of interest.” We argue that Cybersecurity Superintelligence merits treatment as a distinct domain-specific instantiation. While no standardized term exists, superhuman cyber capability is increasingly discussed in technical and policy research: Bengio et al. [ 4 ] identify cybersecurity as a key “dangerous capability” domain; Hendrycks et al. [ 8 ] analyze national security implications of AI systems that “can be turned to destructive ends”; and Potter et al. [ 17 ] marginal-risk modeling and position analyses argue frontier AI exerts stronger influence on cyber offense than defense, though Balassone et al. [ 3 ] empirically refute this, demonstrating no statistical offensive advantage when defenders also use AI. The domain-specific treatment is justified by cybersecurity’s unique structural complexity. Cybersecurity demands simultaneous mastery across heterogeneous disciplines (reverse engineering, binary exploitation, cryptanalysis, forensics, hardware security), each with distinct toolchains and reasoning modalities. For a superintelligence, these must be applied across fundamentally different contexts: IT, OT/ICS, robotics, IoT, mobile, each introducing domain-specific protocols and threat models. This combinatorial complexity (disciplines \times sectors \times constraints) creates an evaluation space no human can fully cover. The most “superhuman-adjacent” capability to date: LLM-driven agents operating 3,600 \times faster than humans in specific security tasks (11 \times overall), while winning worldwide competitions with $50,000+ in prizes during 2025 [ 12 , 11 ] . In this work, we present an evolution toward Cybersecurity Superintelligence. We trace this evolution through three landmark achievements (Figure 3 ) that mark a paradigmatic shift: we begin by ❶ using AI to augment human capabilities (Section 2.1 ), followed by ❷ using AI to build human expert-level agents (Section