European digital identity
Wouter Termont, Esteves Beatriz · 2026
Read European digital identity by Wouter Termont, Esteves Beatriz (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-14503.txt.
Introduction
Wouter Termont and Esteves Beatriz examine European digital identity in this 2026 paper. Recent European efforts center on the EUDI regulation and its OpenID architecture. The authors say these efforts aim high but start from a narrow, ill-defined view of authentication. From a broader, more grounded view of the term, they identify several issues.
The issues sit in the OpenID4VCI and OpenID4VP protocols. They name insecure practices, plus static and subject-bound credential types. A limited query language also restricts the design. The authors say these limits confine the system to classic credential exchange cases, which existing solutions like OpenID Connect already support.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Wouter Termont, Esteves Beatriz |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 105 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-14503
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
European digital identity Thanks: This research was funded by SolidLab Vlaanderen (Flemish Government, EWI and RRF project VV023/10) Wouter Termont, Esteves Beatriz Abstract Recent European efforts around digital identity – the EUDI regulation and its OpenID architecture – aim high, but start from a narrow and ill-defined conceptualization of authentication. Based on a broader, more grounded understanding of the term, in we identify several issues in the design of OpenID4VCI and OpenID4VP: insecure practices, static, and subject-bound credential types, and a limited query language restrict their application to classic scenarios of credential exchange – already supported by existing solutions like OpenID Connect, SIOPv2, OIDC4IDA, and OIDC Claims Aggregation – barring dynamic, asynchronous, or automated use cases. We also debunk OpenID’s ‘paradigm-shifting’ trust-model, which – when compared to existing decentralized alternatives – does not deliver any significant increase in control, privacy, and portability of personal information. Not only the technical choices limit the capabilities of the EUDI framework; also the legislation itself cannot accommodate the promise of self-sovereign identity. In particular, we criticize the introduction of institutionalized trusted lists, and discuss their economical and political risks. Their potential to decline into an exclusory, re-centralized ecosystem endangers the vision of a user-oriented identity management in which individuals are in charge. Instead, the consequences might severely restrict people in what they can do with their personal information, and risk increased linkability and monitoring. In anticipation of revisions to the EUDI regulations, we suggest several technical alternatives that overcome some of the issues with the architecture of OpenID. In particular, OAuth’s UMA extension and its A4DS profile, as well as their integration in GNAP, are worth looking into. Future research into uniform query (meta-)languages is needed to address the heterogeneity of attestations and providers. This research was funded by SolidLab Vlaanderen (Flemish Government, EWI and RRF project VV023/10) Executive summary While offering a plausible architecture for the limited use cases accommodated by EUDI, OpenID’s design does not provide significant technical innovation when compared to existing decentralized alternatives. Based on a narrow intuition of (digital) identity, both the regulations and their architecture limit their possible applications, and miss the opportunity to construct a truly uniform model of authentication on the Web. Aggregating terminology from multiple international legal and technical standards, we define ‘ partial identity ’ as a subset of the measurable characteristics of an entity , and ‘ identity ’ as those subsets that are sufficient to represent the entity and distinguish the entity within a given context – they are pseudonyms , whose anonymity set is a singleton. However, for practically all use cases, it suffices to identify context-dependent roles . Interpreting ‘ identification ’ as the exchange of such attributes as claims about a subject , we characterize the process of ‘ authentication ’ as the verification of their authenticity – their origin and integrity – based on trust in some authority (i.e., the issuer–holder–verifier model). It follows from these definitions that credentials are merely certificates : documents attesting to the truth of certain stated facts . Based on these definitions, we find a mismatch between the ‘paradigm-shifting’ promises of EUDI and OpenID, and the actual capabilities of their combined framework. The OpenID architecture, on the one hand, is • based on a history of software design that disregards best practices in internet security and interoperability; • limited to static credential types, and an inflexible, format-dependent query languages; and • not applicable to dynamic or automated use cases. Furthermore, even within classic scenarios of credential exchange, OpenIDs new trust model fails to deliver the promised benefits; for example, when compared to already existing OIDC-based solutions (SIOPv2, OIDC4IDA, OIDC Claims Aggregation): • OpenID’s wallet offers offline availability , but does not increase portability of personal information in the usual Bring-Your-Own-Identity sense, nor any extra control through informed consent . • Selective disclosure seems like a big step forward in user control over personal data; we’re it not that this form of data minimization predominantly applies to OpenID4VCI- and OpenID4VP-specific scenarios, and a lot less to other decentralized identity models. • Despite the change of interactions between issuer, holder, and verifier, privacy issues merely shift from the identity provider to the wallet provider – or not at all when following all OpenID’s precautions. The EUDI regulations, on the other hand, are far from achieving their promise of self-sovereign identity . Their use of institutionalized trusted lists makes participation in the identity market dependent economical and political incentives . This risks a de facto re-centralization of digital identity that not only weakens the security and neutrality of the Web, but also makes the framework vulnerable to vendor lock-ins , data correlation , and government abuse . In anticipation of regulatory changes, we urge to research alternatives that aim at a broader interpretation of authentication and identity. The sound foundation provided by W3C’s decentralized identifiers (DID) and verifiable credential model (VC) can be complemented by frameworks based directly on OAuth. Ongoing research into the asynchronous and dynamic capabilities of User-Managed Access (UMA), Authorization for Data Spaces (A4DS), and the Grant Negotiation and Authorization Protocol (GNAP) are prime candidates; while future research is still needed into uniform query (meta-)languages, and support for more general attestation documents. Introduction The concept of identity plays a big role in the fields of Data Spaces (DS) and Identity and Access Management (IAM): from the personal information of an individual human being, over the information collected about legal entities, to the processing of any of the former, either through traditional methods or involving artificial intelligence. 1 1 1 Many terms exist that define certain kinds of information about a person. Coming from different backgrounds, and using different terminology, it is often hard to determine how they relate. Most general is probably personal information (PI), which can be any information related to an individual in any way (e.g., one’s favorite color, the number of steps it usually takes one to cross the market square). Personal data (PD), however, as defined in the GDPR [ [ ref-eu:gdpr ] ], is personal information that “is or might be directly or indirectly linked to [the subject] to whom such information relates” [ [ ref-openid:connect ] ], “in particular by reference to an identifier or to one or more factors specific to [their] identity” [ [ ref-eu:gdpr ] , art. 4]. It includes information that might not necessarily identify an individual directly (i.e., on its own), but might nevertheless be indirectly linked to them, when put in context, or when combined with other data. Examples include photographs, location data, and many technical identifiers (e.g., cookies, device identifiers, network addresses). Personally Identifiable Information (PII), a similar term from U.S. legislation, has a roughly equivalent definition, but is typically seen as somewhat narrower than personal data. It includes personal information that can be used to identify the individual to which that information relates [ [ ref-openid:connect ] ; [ ref-cnss:i4009 ] ], either alone (i.e., as a single data point) or “when combined with other information that is linked or linkable to a specific individual” [ [ ref-nist:sp800-63 ] ]. Examples include contact details, account names, identification numbers – but typically not the more technical identifiers, as present in