Fracture initiation in silicate glasses via a universal shear localization mechanism
Matthieu Bourguignon, Gustavo Alberto Rosales-Sosa, Yoshinari Kato, Bruno Bresson, Hikaru Ikeda, Shingo Nakane, Gergely Molnár, Hiroki Yamazaki, Etienne Barthel · 2026
Read Fracture initiation in silicate glasses via a universal shear localization mechanism by Matthieu Bourguignon, Gustavo Alberto Rosales-Sosa, Yoshinari Kato, Bruno Bresson, Hikaru Ikeda, Shingo Nakane, Gergely Molnár, Hiroki Yamazaki, Etienne Barthel (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-14493.txt.
Introduction
Matthieu Bourguignon and a team of seven co-authors study how glass breaks in this 2026 paper. Shear bands lie at the root of fracture initiation in bulk metallic glasses and amorphous polymers. For silicate glasses, past studies stressed a distinct effect: permanent volumetric strain, often called densification. The team's work tests which picture fits silicate glass.
They systematically investigate indentation-induced fracture in two families of aluminoborosilicate glasses. Indentation presses a hard tip into the surface to start cracks in a controlled way. Their title claims a universal shear localization mechanism behind fracture initiation. The tests are hands-on. A hard tip is pressed into real glass, and the cracks are then read up close. Readers get lab evidence that silicate glass may fail more like its metallic cousins than once thought.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Matthieu Bourguignon, Gustavo Alberto Rosales-Sosa, Yoshinari Kato, Bruno Bresson, Hikaru Ikeda, Shingo Nakane, Gergely Molnár, Hiroki Yamazaki, Etienne Barthel |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 34 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-14493
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Fracture initiation in silicate glasses via a universal shear localization mechanism Matthieu Bourguignon, Gustavo Alberto Rosales-Sosa, Yoshinari Kato, Bruno Bresson, Hikaru Ikeda, Shingo Nakane, Gergely Molnár, Hiroki Yamazaki, Etienne Barthel Abstract Shear bands lie at the root of fracture initiation in bulk metallic glasses and amorphous polymers. For silicate glasses, in contrast, studies have largely emphasized permanent volumetric strain, commonly referred to as densification. Here we systematically investigate indentation-induced fracture in two distinct families of aluminoborosilicate glasses. The results demonstrate that plastic shear flow plays a decisive role in governing fracture initiation. In addition, molecular dynamics simulations reveal a pronounced composition dependence of softening associated with plastic shear flow, closely mirroring the experimentally observed propensity for strain localization. We conclude that silicate glasses conform to a universal pattern of rupture initiation governed by localization of shear-deformation, aligning with a broad range of amorphous materials, including bulk metallic glasses and glassy polymers. I Introduction Despite decades of intensive research, a comprehensive understanding of the rupture properties of silicate glasses remains a significant challenge Wondraczek et al. 2022 , constraining mitigation strategies. A range of conceptual frameworks has been advanced, including the tailoring of network connectivity Januchta and Smedskjaer 2019 , the notion of optimal topological rigidity Wondraczek et al. 2011 (often illustrated by highly connected networks such as silicon oxynitrides or carbides Rouxel et al. 2021 ) or, from a quite different perspective, the ideas of nanoscale ductility Wondraczek et al. 2011 or adaptive network structures Januchta et al. 2017 . These approaches however, offer limited predictive capability and have yet to establish clear, quantitative relationships between glass composition, underlying deformation mechanisms, and macroscopic mechanical performance. One of the difficulties is that, in very practical terms, the fracture sensitivity of silicate glasses is usually probed by indention, indeed a technique of choice for characterizing the non-linear deformation, damage and fracture processes in brittle materials Marshall et al. 2015 . In particular, indentation cracking provides a convenient and quantitative measure of crack resistance (CR), the resistance to indentation-induced damage Wada 1974 ; Lawn et al. 1980a . In fact, although CR, defined as the threshold load required to initiate median or radial cracks beneath a Vickers indenter tip, may seem somewhat primitive at first glance, it has proven to be highly discriminating for silicate glasses Kato et al. 2010a . The strain field under the tip is complex, but extensive studies over more than half a century Lawn and Fuller 1975 ; Chiang et al. 1982a ; Davis et al. 2020 ; Rosales-Sosa et al. 2025 have provided a robust foundation for a general understanding of the ensuing damage and fracture processes. Silicate glasses, however, undergo irreversible volumetric deformation, or densification Ernsberger 1968 which reduces indentation-induced stresses and can therefore partially suppress crack initiation and propagation Yoffe 1982 ; Cook 1990 . As a result, over the past decades, considerable effort has been devoted to quantifying the role of densification in decreasing the cracking sensitivity of silicate glasses Rouxel 2015 ; Barlet et al. 2015 . Notably, low atomic packing density and a low Poisson’s ratio, both linked to enhanced densification, have been reported to correlate with improved crack resistance Yoshida 2020 ; Rouxel et al. 2021 . In contrast to this densification-oriented perspective, an alternative framework was developed in the 1980s, highlighting localized shear deformation as the primary mechanism governing fracture initiation. Experimental studies showed that cracks often originate at discrete shear events, referred to as shear faults or slip events, which appear during loading and serve as deformation-induced crack nuclei Hagan 1979 ; Lawn et al. 1983 ; Lathabai et al. 1991 . This line of investigation, however, has received comparatively little attention in recent years, with only one notable exception Gross et al. 2018 . To clarify the relative contributions of the different mechanisms proposed for fracture initiation in silicate glasses in relation to their composition and structure, we conducted a systematic investigation of indentation cracking across two families of glass compositions spanning a broad range of crack resistances. One of these families comprises Ca alumino-boro-silicate glasses: the influence of silicon substitution by boron on crack resistance is well established and has been extensively studied Kato et al. 2010b , although a complete understanding of the mechanisms underlying boron-induced strengthening remains elusive. To broaden the scope of our conclusions, we also examined the effect of network modifier field strength, substituting Mg for Ca, another well-known strategy for drastically improving crack resistance Osada et al. 2020 ; Fry et al. 2023 . Within these compositional ranges, we find compelling evidence that crack resistance correlates strongly with the morphology of shear bands, while exhibiting no significant dependence on Poisson’s ratio or on the densification behavior. This finding demonstrates that, in silicate glasses, the intrinsic resistance to localized shear faulting controls the macroscopic cracking response under sharp-contact loading. Shear flow and the associated material instabilities thus emerge as a unifying paradigm of fracture behavior in amorphous materials, one that silicate glasses, despite their capacity for densification, share with e.g. metallic glasses and glassy polymers. II Results Eighteen glass samples were melted (see Supplemental Material, section S I for more detail on the experimental procedures) with the nominal composition (15-y)\text{CaO}\cdot y\text{MgO}\cdot 15\text{Al}_{2}\text{O}_{3}\cdot x\text{B}_{2}\text{O}_{3}\cdot(70-x)\text{SiO}_{2} (CMABS glasses). The boron content (x) was varied as 0, 5, 15, and 25 mol% (Table S1). For compositions with x = 5 and 15 mol%, CaO was progressively substituted by MgO, with y=0 (CABS), 2.5, 5, 7.5, 10, 12.5 and 15 (MABS) mol% (Table S2). In addition, reference glasses previously reported by Kato et al. Kato et al. 2010b were also prepared for comparison. II.1 General mechanical properties Key mechanical properties were systematically characterized and are presented in Fig. 1 , with numerical values provided in the Supplemental Material, section S I. Young’s modulus E and shear modulus G were measured with the resonance method, hardness H with microindentation under a load of 100 gf. a) b) c) d) e) f) Figure 1: (a-c) single alkaline earth (Ca or Mg) ABS glasses with varying B 2 O 3 content: a) Young’s Modulus E and Poisson’s ratio \nu ; b) micro-indentation Vickers hardness H V ; c) densification (CABS only) at 25 GPa (Multi Anvil Cell) Gomes et al. 2025 - (d-e) mixed alkaline earth ABS glasses (5% or 15% B 2 O 3 ) as a function of Mg vs Ca content: d) Young’s Modulus E and Poisson ratio \nu ; e) micro-indentation Vickers hardness H V - (f) all glass compositions: RID as a function of Poisson ratio including some (LS, SLS, ABS) glasses from Kato et al Kato et al. 2011a and from Barlet et al. Barlet et al. 2015 . Error bars are not shown if smaller than the marker size. Overall, the property evolutions were moderate across the present compositional changes. Incorporating 25 mol% \text{B}_{2}\text{O}_{3} led to a 20% reduction in both Young’s modulus and hardness. Conversely, substituting \text{Mg}^{2+} for \text{Ca}^{2+} resulted in a marginal 5% increase in E and a 10% increase in H . Regarding Poisson’s ratio, the 25 mol% \text{B}_{2}\text{O}_{3} addition caused a 20% increase in the CABS system and a 10% increase for the MABS system, while the \text{Mg}^{2+} for \text{Ca}^{2+}